IPO investing: How to read key metrics, spot red flags in a draft prospectus

IPO investing: How to read key metrics, spot red flags in a draft prospectus
© Provided by CNBCTV18

Remember the days when we wrote exams on paper sheets, there was a generally accepted norm to score well. Write more pages, take extra sheets. Regardless of the content, the first impression on the examiner would be — this student has put in the effort and knows quite a bit. If you can’t answer the specifics, more words and pages could help. In a cumbersome process of examining papers and teacher fatigue, somehow it worked.

The DRHPs for IPOs are no different. Although the information needed to value a company can be summarised in 10 pages, what we get is 600 pages of the dump. You are the examiner here. Good luck!

If you’ve found yourself in this situation after downloading the recent DRHPs, let’s examine some critical pointers to look for before you decide to buy that IPO. This is in no way a comprehensive list but gives you broad pointers to explore. The first pages to search are the balance sheet, income statement and cash flow statement. These are mostly one after the other.

  1. Sales growth-consistency and quality: Most IPOs of new-age companies love to quote rising sales. In absence of profits, this is the only metric they want to be valued for. The story however is far from simple. Many recent companies have tried various diversifications and folded many failed initiatives. In many cases, they have acquired companies just to buy topline. One should explore the products and subsidiaries that contribute to sales growth and has that been consistent? In many cases, we see that while the overall number is growing, there is no specific product line that is gaining leadership on the ground. In many cases, there is other income that inflates the sales. Not the growth you’re looking for.
  2. Market Leadership/dominance and market potential: The second area to explore is overall market potential and the company’s share of that market. Don’t get carried away by the future market size projections. Most of the reports quoted there are created just for IPO purposes. Try searching for the growth and market size for the last decade vs the future. India wasn’t that bad in the past 10 years too and it is unlikely to change drastically in the next decade. The truth will be somewhere in-between. If the market grows by 10 percent, a company can’t grow at 25 percent plus unless it is grabbing share from existing players. Sounds easier than it is.
  3. Gross margin and Unit economics: This question touches the heart of valuation i.e. earnings. Ultimately you buy a stock for its profits or potential to earn profits. Examine gross margins and promotional spends. Notice the co-relation between promotional spends and sales. Do the gross margins justify that the company has a strong moat in the market of is it just selling because of heavy promotions. Remember, the Indian consumer is very sensitive to price. If a company is paying its way to market share, there will always be some new player who will take that market away. Recall what happened in telecom when Jio arrived.
  4. Apply basic financial sense: Look at comparable companies in the market. Every company claims there is no competition for them, but there always is. Regardless of online or brick-and-mortar debates, look at the core product the company sells. Amazon is basically delivering the same products that you used to buy in the market, only cheaper. Most of the new-age companies are selling the same products cheaper and in a convenient way, nothing more. But the incumbents will not sit and twiddle their thumbs. In most cases, the competition bounces back and fast. In many cases like banking, it is very difficult to sell products online especially on large amounts and that’s where the profits are. Each industry is different and the growth trajectory for any company can’t be a straight line. If a company claims to grow at 30 percent each YoY for the next decade, it can’t be true for most. Things will change. The competition will emerge. Don’t price abnormal growth numbers in your models.
  5. Finally, look at the current investors and sellers: They say, before you buy anything, look at the seller. It is hard to get a good bargain if people who’re selling are bigger and smarter players than you. Even on a used car, you always ask who owned it earlier and why are they selling. IPOs are no different. IPOs sold by private equity players haven’t done good for retail investors in most cases internationally. Remember — Everything is good at a price. Not beyond!

ALSO READ | RateGain Travel Technologies IPO to open today: Key things to know

While it may be hard for retail investors to explore fine print and accounting changes in annexures, I’m sure the above pointers will address broad valuations parameters for most IPOs. And if the answers to the above are not very clear in the DRHP, think for a moment — Why has the company filled so many pages? Don’t reward a thick answer sheet.

If you don’t understand what you buy, you’re just buying another Tulip flower hoping that someone else will pay even more for that. It works for a while until it doesn’t.

The author is Managing Partner Ansid Capital, a limited partnership hedge fund. He tweets at @anuragsingh_as and is an ardent follower of the value investing school. Views expressed are personal

News Related


Leader Kloten stoppt den Lauf von La Chaux-de-Fonds

© KEYSTONE/ENNIO LEANZA Kloten und Olten ziehen an der Ranglistenspitze der Swiss League weiterhin einsam ihre Kreise. Die beiden Aufstiegsaspiranten kommen am Freitag zu einem weiteren Heimsieg. Drei Tage nach ... Read more »

Report: Kings no longer pursuing Sixers star Ben Simmons in a trade

© Provided by Sixers Wire The Philadelphia 76ers are still in pursuit of trying to move star guard Ben Simmons who is obviously not going to throw in a Sixers ... Read more »

Please! Make me a Pokéshi Doll! request guide – Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by GamePur There are numerous requests for you to complete in Pokémon Legends: Arceus. These differ from traditional quests because these allow you to complete specific tasks for ... Read more »

Giant red king crabs from Russia which can grow to 6ft are invading Britain

GIANT red king crabs from Russia are invading Britain — spreading fear and joy among fishermen. The species, which can grow close to 6ft across and weigh up to 28lb, ... Read more »

How to get a Sun Stone in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by GamePur Sun Stones in Pokémon Legends: Arceus are mainly needed to evolve Pokémon such as Petilil into Hisuian Lilligant. As veterans may expect, all Sun Stones can ... Read more »

Covid-19: Boosters will be untimely now, says expert

© Provided by The Times of India PUNE: Epidemiologist Dr JP Mulayil, member of the National Technical Advisory Group on Immunisation in India (NTAGI), on Tuesday said booster dose against ... Read more »

Ben Simmons trade rumors: Kings pull out of trade talks with 76ers, per report

© Provided by CBS Sports Though there have been reports suggesting that the Philadelphia 76ers would prefer to wait until the offseason to trade disgruntled All-Star guard Ben Simmons, that ... Read more »

Can you dodge in the water in Pokémon Legends: Arceus?

© Provided by GamePur The exploration possibilities in Pokémon Legends: Arceus is a complete first for the series. While the Wild Area in Pokémon Sword and Shield offered wide swaths ... Read more »

A Ben Simmons Trade Just Got a Lot Harder for the Philadelphia 76ers

© Provided by The Big Lead Atlanta Hawks v Philadelphia 76ers – Game Seven | Tim Nwachukwu/GettyImages The Sacramento Kings have officially dropped out of the chase for Ben Simmons. ... Read more »

Andrew Wiggins shows NBA All-Star voting is still completely broken

© Provided by Fansided The fact that Rudy Gobert got more media votes, more player votes and a higher player rank than Andrew Wiggins proves that NBA All-Star voting is ... Read more »

Why a rich Gujarati family paid $100,000 for illegal journey to US? Police seek answers

© Provided by The Times of India WASHINGTON: Law enforcement authorities in Canada are seeking information from the public about how an Indian family of four from Gujarat, who froze ... Read more »

PC gaming hardware and accessories revenue up 25 percent in US in 2021

© Provided by Dot Esports Marketing research services company NPD Group is reporting a 25-percent increase in sales related to PC gaming hardware and accessories in the U.S. in 2021, ... Read more »

These might be the worst NBA All-Star jerseys to date

The NBA dropped the ball this year with the new All-Star game jerseys. Official images of the 2022 NBA All-Star Game jerseys pic.twitter.com/hpx669WPN9 — Ben Axelrod (@BenAxelrod) January 28, 2022 ... Read more »

Matt Turner to Arsenal transfer: USA boss' comments music to the ears of Mikel Arteta

© Provided by Mirror Arsenal are close to completing a £5.8million deal for goalkeeper Matt Turner. The 27-year-old American is not a household name in England but has a fine ... Read more »

Ukraine's President Zelenskyy walks fine line between downplaying war threat and appealing for help

Despite Russian forces massed near its border, critics say Ukraine's leader is more worried that talk of invasion will hurt its economy Read more »

Our Peter Seabrook is honoured by top gardening bosses – with a garden dedicated to his memory

GREEN shoots are showing in a scheme to create a memorial to honour The Sun’s legendary gardening guru Peter Seabrook. During the pandemic, our much-loved and greatly missed colleague, who ... Read more »

Inside the luxury life of Gunther IV – a pampered German shepherd who inherited a £280million fortune

WHILST most of us humans can only dream of having £280million given to us, life is pretty sweet for this pup. Gunther IV, a German shepherd inherited his vast wealth ... Read more »

Here's how to make the viral Starbucks brown sugar shaken espresso at home with just a few ingredients you can buy online

Prices are accurate at the time of publication. When you buy through our links, Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more. © Provided by INSIDER Kenedee Fowler/Insider I’ve mastered ... Read more »

Iqaluit lifts precautionary boil-water advisory, bypass system still being used

IQALUIT, Nunavut — Nunavut’s Health Department has lifted a precautionary boil-water advisory for the city of Iqaluit. © Provided by The Canadian Press The capital’s 8,000 people had been under ... Read more »

MétisMétis National Council takes former president, Manitoba Métis to court

The Métis National Council has filed a lawsuit against its former president and the Manitoba Métis Federation alleging financial irregularities and questionable contracts.  © Provided by The Canadian Press President ... Read more »

Texas makes 247Sports' list of teams that can crash the college football playoffs in 2022

© Provided by Longhorns Wire The cycle seems to be repeating itself already, and spring camp hasn’t even begun. For the past decade, a hype surrounding Texas’ football team develops ... Read more »

Joe Burrow Sends Clear Message Before AFC Title Game

© Provided by The Spun Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow points at his helmet with both hands before snapping the ball. Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow is more than ready for ... Read more »

Kellen Moore may get playcalling help, according to Cowboys owner Jerry Jones

© File photo Aug 21, 2021; Arlington, Texas, USA; Dallas Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy (left) talks with offensive coordinator Kellen Moore in the second quarter against the Houston Texans ... Read more »

Rob Gronkowski (well, his uniform) goes to the Hall of Fame

© Provided by Buccaneers Wire .@RobGronkowski’s uniform (jersey, pants, gloves) he wore during Week 18 when he surpassed HOF TE Tony Gonzalez for the most 100-yard receiving games by a ... Read more »

Ranking the all-time leading passers in LSU football history

© Provided by LSU Tigers Wire MORE: Opinion: Brian Kelly has dismissed any concerns about ‘culture and fit’ Five-star defender Jayden Wayne has LSU among top schools LSU’s defense struggles ... Read more »

Chiefs' Darrel Williams, Tyrann Mathieu questionable vs. Bengals

© Katie Stratman-USA TODAY Sports Darrel Williams was inactive against the Bills and was limited to one carry in the Chiefs’ wild-card round win over the Pittsburgh Steelers. The Kansas ... Read more »

Cree author Shayla Raine credits her community and family for her success

(ANNews) – Shayla Raine has created a powerful Cree poetry book called The Way Creator Sees You which is a long, free verse poem about a Plains Cree boy named ... Read more »

Report: Josh McCown finalist for Texans head coach

© Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports Josh McCown (18) Josh McCown has no experience coaching at either the NFL or collegiate level, but the former quarterback reportedly has a real shot ... Read more »

PFF ranks Jaguars' 2021 draft class near the bottom of the NFL

© Provided by Jaguars Wire The 2021 NFL draft will likely always be remembered by Jaguars fans as the class that featured first overall pick quarterback Trevor Lawrence. The Clemson ... Read more »

Steelers have interviewed 2 candidates to succeed Kevin Colbert as GM

© Provided by Fansided The Pittsburgh Steelers have already interviewed two internal candidates to replace Kevin Colbert once he steps down as general manager after the 2022 NFL Draft: Omar Khan and Brandon Hunt. Pittsburgh Steelers ... Read more »

What An Aaron Rodgers Trade Would Look Like

© Provided by The Spun Aaron Rodgers walks off the field on Saturday night. Heading into the 2022 offseason, Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers has made it very clear ... Read more »

Vikings to interview Giants DC Patrick Graham

© Chris Pedota, NorthJersey.com / USA TODAY NETWORK Patrick Graham Despite the Giants’ late-season nosedive, their defensive coordinator will meet with another team about its top coaching job. The Vikings ... Read more »

Rams Get Major Boost Before NFC Title Game vs. 49ers

© Provided by The Spun Rams head coach Sean McVay and defensive coordinator Raheem Morris stand side-by-side on the sidelines. The Los Angeles Rams are getting healthy at the right ... Read more »

LSU vs TCU Prediction, College Basketball Game Preview

© Provided by College Football News LSU vs TCU prediction, college basketball game preview, how to watch: Saturday, January 29 LSU vs TCU How To Watch Date: Saturday, January 29 ... Read more »

Minister optimistic P.E.I. potato shipments to Puerto Rico could resume soon

FREDERICTON — The federal agriculture minister is optimistic the United States could approve the resumption of shipments of Prince Edward Island potatoes to the key market of Puerto Rico within ... Read more »

The Signs of Caregiver Burnout Experts Say You Shouldn't Ignore

If you’re a caregiver, you might feel strange letting yourself focus on your life and how hard this job might be on you—but it’s crucial you do, not just for ... Read more »

Schweizerinnen so gut wie noch nie: Naomi Osaka stürzt in der Weltrangliste 71 Plätze ab

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Naomi Osaka stürzt in der Weltrangliste 71 Plätze ab Sportlich waren die Australian Open für Naomi Osaka (24) eine kurze Geschichte. In der 3. Runde musste ... Read more »

Star linebacker Simoni Lawrence returning to Hamilton for ninth season

HAMILTON — The Hamilton Tiger-Cats have re-signed star linebacker Simoni Lawrence. © Provided by The Canadian Press The 32-year-old was the East Division’s nominee for the 2021 CFL outstanding defensive ... Read more »

LOOK: Texas' pitching staff headlines Baseball America's February cover

© File photo Jun 22, 2021; Omaha, Nebraska, USA; Texas Longhorns pitcher Tanner Witt (11) throws against the Tennessee Volunteers at TD Ameritrade Park. Mandatory Credit: Bruce Thorson-USA TODAY Sports ... Read more »

US stocks end volatile week slightly higher after earnings beat from Apple helps investors overcome Fed fears

© Andrew Kelly/Reuters A trader works on the trading floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in Manhattan, New York City, U.S., December 28, 2021. Andrew Kelly/Reuters US stocks ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic