Investigation into infamous bread price-fixing scheme isn't finished, competition watchdog says

Asia's Tech News Daily

Investigation into infamous bread price-fixing scheme isn't finished, competition watchdog says
© Provided by Financial Post The Competition Bureau started its inquiry in 2017 because investigators believed Canadian food companies had conspired together to control the price of commercial bread products since 2001.

The case against a group of grocery chains and commercial bakeries that allegedly fixed the price of bread in Canada for at least 14 years hasn’t resulted in any charges yet, but the federal competition watchdog said it’s still an active investigation.

The Competition Bureau started its inquiry in 2017, executing search warrants on some of the most powerful food companies in Canada because investigators believed they had conspired together to control the price of commercial bread products since 2001.

“I understand that people think it should go faster, but these investigations are often complicated and require a fair bit of work,” bureau commissioner Matthew Boswell said. “What I can tell you is our investigation in that matter is proceeding.”

Loblaw Cos. Ltd. — Canada’s largest grocery chain — tipped off the bureau to what the grocer described as an “industry-wide price-fixing arrangement” on commercial bread products. Loblaw also offered customers a $25 gift card for its role in the saga, a heavily publicized act that led many to believe the case was over.

In its search warrant applications, the bureau outlined that it believed two commercial bakeries, Canada Bread Co. and Weston Foods Canada Inc., conspired with major grocers Loblaw, Sobeys Inc., Metro Inc., Walmart Canada Corp. and Giant Tiger Stores Ltd. on the alleged price-fixing scheme.

“It looks like Canada has dropped the ball,” said Ambarish Chandra, a professor at the University of Toronto who focuses on competition and public policy. “No one’s paid a fine. No one’s gone to jail. It’s crazy.”

One of the main ways that investigators learn about cartels is through so-called immunity and leniency programs, where one of the conspirators comes forward to confess.

“You come in and spill your guts, and you help the government go after the other guys and in exchange, you get immunity,” said Michael Laskey, a partner in the competition group at law firm Stikeman Elliott LLP in Toronto.

The bureau granted immunity in the bread-fixing case to both Loblaw and Weston Foods, which up until recently were both controlled by George Weston Ltd. This week, George Weston announced a $1.2-billion deal to sell the Weston Foods bakery businesses to FGF Brands Inc.

The bureau’s investigation into the other companies could end one of two ways. Either investigators conclude “there was no wrongdoing by other grocery stores and drop their investigation or they could bring criminal charges,” Laskey said. “But there’s been no obvious movement by the bureau at all.”

Investigation into infamous bread price-fixing scheme isn't finished, competition watchdog says
© Peter J. Thompson/National Post files The bureau granted immunity in the bread-fixing case to both Loblaw and Weston Foods.

Laskey said it’s normal for these types of investigations to move slowly, because the prospect of laying criminal charges means the bureau has to be “quite careful” about its approach and in gathering evidence.

A spokesperson for Sobeys’ parent Empire Co. Ltd. said the company has seen “absolutely no indication” that Sobeys broke competition law.

“It is unfortunate that our brand has been painted with the same brush as others,” Jacquelin Weatherbee said in an email. “This process has moved very slowly and we hope to see meaningful progress towards a resolution.”

Both Metro and Giant Tiger also said in statements to the Financial Post that they do not believe they broke the law. Walmart and Canada Bread declined to comment. Loblaw also did not respond to a request for comment.

If the bureau believes it has sufficient evidence of a criminal offence, it refers the matter to federal prosecutors. A spokesperson said confidentiality rules prohibit the bureau from commenting on whether anything has been referred to prosecutors, but confirmed that “at this time” no charges have been laid.

“Speaking generally, I can tell you that our criminal conspiracy investigations are often quite complex,” Boswell said in an interview.

His predecessor, John Pecman, wrote in 2018 that “it’s important to get it right, because price fixing is notoriously difficult” to prove in court.

Investigation into infamous bread price-fixing scheme isn't finished, competition watchdog says
© James Park for Postmedia files Competition Bureau commissioner Matthew Boswell.

“These cartels typically involve secret deals between schemers who are careful to cover their tracks. Neatly written agreements between competitors rarely exist. Emails get deleted, and meetings to collude on price happen in obscure places.”

Pecman at the time said it may take time to get to a point where cartel cases can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, but “the bureau gets results.”

Gary Sands, vice-president of the Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers, said the investigation’s pace is further “validation” that the heavily consolidated food retail sector needs a code of conduct.

The industry has been debating the development of universal rules of engagement for the sector and the need to rein in bully tactics from some of the dominant players.

  • Competition Bureau gets a budget boost, but is it enough to make companies think twice?
  • Competition Bureau backs review of antitrust laws amid scrutiny of grocers
  • ‘Gap in legislation’: Stronger law needed to launch wage-fixing probe into grocers’ behaviour
  • Bread price-fixing scandal may have originated with PowerPoint presentation: court documents

Sands said a code of conduct would provide a much-needed way to resolve disputes faster.

“Seeking a remedy under the Competition Act, and waiting four or five years for whatever the outcome may be, is just not realistic,” he said.

Financial Post

• Email: | Twitter: jakeedmiston

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Coronavirus: Expert warns one in three colds are linked to the disease

Scientists and experts have been working tirelessly to track and understand the new starting that has mutated from the original coronavirus called Omicron. Brits are buckling up for their second ... Read more »

Switzerland Approves Assisted ‘Suicide Capsule'

Exit International Switzerland has just legalized a new way to die by assisted suicide. The country’s medical review board has just given authorization for use of the Sarco Suicide Pod, ... Read more »

Keith Hill reveals Scunthorpe's ‘mind bomb' preparation for Stevenage game

© Provided by Football League World General view during the match Scunthorpe United manager Keith Hill has used a break in fixtures to ready his players for Tuesday’s visit to ... Read more »

UN delays action on Myanmar and Afghanistan's bid for seats

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — The U.N. General Assembly approved a resolution Monday delaying action on requests by Myanmar’s military junta and Afghanistan’s Taliban rulers to take their countries’ seats at ... Read more »

This HUGE Cadbury Layers Of Joy Chocolate Trifle Is A Perfect Alternative To Christmas Pudding

It’s fair to say, not everyone is bananas for Christmas puddings, Christmas cakes or even mince pies. Now, we love them here at Delish, but we get it – some ... Read more »

How Is Hyundai's Hydrogen Car Bet Working Out?

© InsideEVs Hyundai NEXO in UK Hyundai called Tesla’s EVs “toys” years ago. Now, the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y are dominating. For a time, there’s was quite a ... Read more »

Chris Noth didn't know Willie Garson was ill

© Bang Showbiz Chris Noth didn’t know Willie Garson was ill Chris Noth “didn’t know” Willie Garson was ill before he died. The 67-year-old actor wishes he’d spent more time ... Read more »

Jussie Smollett defense could rest today with or without his testimony

CHICAGO — Jussie Smollett’s attorneys are expected to continue presenting their case to jurors Monday morning on what might be the final day of the “Empire” actor’s trial. And as ... Read more »

Dangerous liaisons? How dating apps use/misuse your data

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Bumble IPO: Dating app aims for nearly $6 billion valuation in US Dating apps have become popular platform with the younger set to meet potential romantic ... Read more »

Binance revives plans for a UK launch after winning over the financial regulators that banned it

© Andrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty Images Binance CEO, Changpeng Zhao. Andrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty Images Binance plans to launch its UK arm in the next six to 18 months, CEO ... Read more »

The SPAC backing Trump's new media venture is under investigation by federal regulators

© Shannon Stapleton/Reuters Former US President Donald Trump looks on during his first post-presidency campaign rally at the Lorain County Fairgrounds in Wellington, Ohio, U.S., June 26, 2021. Shannon Stapleton/Reuters ... Read more »

Narendra Modi-Vladimir Putin meet in Delhi: 7 things they discussed

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, hosted Russian President Vladimir Putin at the 21st India-Russia in Delhi’s Hyderabad House. They talked about various topics ... Read more »

Most Bought smallcase for November 2021

© Sounak Mukherjee Most Bought smallcase for November 2021 The year 2021 is slowly drawing to an end. With approximately 20 days or more for 2021 to wrap up, we ... Read more »

Aishwarya Rai To Star Next In An Indo-American Movie

© Provided by Lehren Aishwarya Rai To Star Next In An Indo-American Movie Aishwarya Rai Bachchan, who was last seen in ‘Fanney Khan’ has recently signed a movie called “The ... Read more »

Who is Sukesh Chandrasekhar? The Millionaire Conman Whose Cosy Pics With Jacqueline Fernandez Went Viral

© Provided by News18 Who is Sukesh Chandrasekhar? The Millionaire Conman Whose Cosy Pics With Jacqueline Fernandez Went Viral Bollywood actress Jacqueline Fernandez has once again been summoned by the ... Read more »

How e-commerce firms are gearing up to tackle the Omicron threat

© Provided by Business Today How e-commerce firms are gearing up to tackle the Omicron threat At a time when the cases of the new Omicron variant are rising in ... Read more »

Freida Pinto thinks Hollywood is 'easier' for people of colour now

© Bang Showbiz Freida Pinto reflects on Hollywood diversity Freida Pinto thinks it would have been “easier” for her to be successful if she was starting her career now. The ... Read more »

Rocky Aur Rani Ki Prem Kahani: Karan Johar and Alia Bhatt head back home as they wrap Delhi schedule in style

Karan Johar created a massive buzz when he announced his next directorial as Rocky Aur Rani Ki Prem Kahani. The ace filmmaker will be working on Ranveer Singh and Alia ... Read more »

Jay Bhanushali on mid way eviction from Bigg Boss 15 & his game: I clearly regret doing this season

© Provided by Pinkvilla Jay Bhanushali was one of the contestants of the reality show Bigg Boss 15 and the actor was highly appreciated for his game. He was evicted ... Read more »

IndiGo parent company calls EGM on December 30

© Provided by CNBCTV18 IndiGo airline’s holding company InterGlobe Aviation on Monday scheduled an extraordinary general meeting (EGM) on December 30. Interglobe sent a notice to its shareholders in this ... Read more »

Jake Paul's brutal response to Tommy Fury pulling out of grudge fight

Jake Paul has slammed Tommy Fury as the “biggest b**** in boxing” for pulling out of their scheduled fight just days out from the event. The YouTube star would have ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15: Differences created between Rakhi Sawant & Ritesh due to Devoleena Bhattacharjee

© Provided by Pinkvilla In the recent episode of the show Bigg Boss 15, there were several wildcard entries in the house. It was seen in the recent promo of ... Read more »

New contract rules unveiled by government after fury over Covid ‘VIP lane' scandal

© PA Communities secretary Michael Gove came under close scrutiny over Covid contracts – PA Boris Johnson’s government has unveiled a series of changes to public procurement rules in a ... Read more »

Tom Holland to play Fred Astaire in upcoming biopic

© Provided by Cover Media Tom Holland Tom Holland is gearing up to play legendary dancer/actor Fred Astaire in an upcoming biopic. In a GQ profile published in November, Spider-Man: ... Read more »

New book claims Pakistan's captain Asif Iqbal had offered to fix Test against India in 1980

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: A new book by veteran sportswriter Pradeep Magazine alleges that former Pakistan captain Asif Iqbal, whose name came up repeatedly in connection with ... Read more »

Nottingham NHS trust pays £2.8m settlement to parents of baby who was stillborn after maternity ward failings

A couple whose child was stillborn after maternity staff made more than a dozen errors have received a £2.8m settlement, thought to be the largest payout of its kind. Sarah ... Read more »

EU sources say no immediate plan for easing Omicron travel curbs on southern Africa

© Reuters/SUMAYA HISHAM FILE PHOTO: International check-in counters stand empty at O.R. Tambo International Airport after several airlines stopped flying out of South Africa because of the spread of the ... Read more »

OPINION - Drug raids might grab headlines but people need help, not coercion

© PA Archive A former Government adviser has said drug laws should be changed (PA) – PA Archive The government has chosen to focus early attention on its new 10-year ... Read more »

I worked at Disney World for 2 years. Here are 10 things I always do at the parks every winter.

© Provided by INSIDER I worked at Disney World for two years. Kayleigh Price I worked at Disney World for 2 years, and I love visiting the parks during the ... Read more »

Assam CM Himanta Biswa Sarma presents financial aid to 1,105 ex-NDFB rebels

Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma asked former militants of National Democratic Front of Boroland (NDFB)who returned to the main stream to use the agriculture equipment as their weapons to ... Read more »

Covid fears split UK as furious debate erupts over Christmas parties ‘Use common sense!'

In a poll of 2,559 Express readers, 50 percent of voters said they would still go to Christmas parties despite fears around the Omicron spread, whilst 46 percent said they ... Read more »

SC suggests mediation to Lalit Modi and his mother for resolving property dispute in family

The Supreme Court Monday suggested mediation to Lalit Modi and his mother Bina Modi, wife of late industrialist K K Modi, to resolve the long pending property dispute in the ... Read more »

Jharkhand CM Hemant Soren inaugurates 4 pvt textile units; hands over job letters to 2,000

Efforts are on to revive the pandemic-hit economy of the state and create jobs by bringing investments here, Jharkhand Chief Minister Hemant Soren said on Monday while inaugurating four textile ... Read more »

Plane flown almost empty to deliver newly required Covid tests

Environmental campaigners have condemned Britain’s biggest holiday company for flying an almost empty plane over 2,750 miles on a round-trip from Birmingham to Finnish Lapland. © Tui UK Dashing to ... Read more »

Families could miss out on thousands via unclaimed inheritance - are you due windfall?

A huge 7,090 estates remain unclaimed, figures obtained from the UK Government’s treasury solicitor shows. The median amount of inheritance received by individuals is £11,000, data from the Office for ... Read more »

Trump media venture unveils forecasts, regulatory inquiries

FILE – In this July 24, 2021, file photo former President Donald Trump smiles as he pauses while speaking to supporters at a Turning Point Action gathering in Phoenix. Trump’s ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity viewers convinced campmates are breaking the rules by wearing make-up – but did you spot it?

I'M a Celebrity viewers are convinced some of the campmates are breaking the rules – by wearing make-up. Fans have flocked to Twitter to share their thoughts, with Frankie Bridge ... Read more »

The staggering amount women need to save to match men's retirement funds exposed

Pension provider Scottish Widows has said women need to nearly double how much they save for later life every month to bridge the ludicrous savings gap. The report found women ... Read more »

School officials could be charged in deadly Michigan shooting: prosecutor

Michigan school officials could still be charged for ignoring multiple red flags ahead of the deadly mass shooting at Oxford High School, the local prosecutor warned in a new interview. ... Read more »

Supreme Court pulls up Railways for not protecting its property & acting against encroachers

The Supreme Court Monday pulled up the Railways for not acting against encroachers on its land in Gujarat, where a railway line is scheduled to come up, and said they ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic