Insulate Britain: blocking roads will alienate some people – but it's still likely to be effective

Insulate Britain is a campaign group urging government action on greenhouse gas emissions and fuel poverty in the country’s housing stock. Their methods have recently landed them in the news, as activists blocked parts of the M25 – the motorway surrounding London – by sitting on slip roads and in the carriageway until their removal by police.

The long delays their protests caused drew outrage from motorists and much of the media that reported it. So what is the purpose of this kind of disruption, made popular in recent years by Extinction Rebellion (XR)?

The American sociologist Charles Tilly argued that all protest actions were what he called WUNC displays: shows of worthiness, unity, numbers and commitment. The goal was not to stop or make something happen directly, but to demonstrate the strength and appeal and values of the protesters, so that both those in power and the general public would listen to their message.

Direct action groups tend to be slightly different from traditional social movements: their actions typically carry higher risks, and they tend to have fewer organisational resources. While they are very committed, being “respectable” isn’t necessarily so important, and the actions are typically carried out by relatively small numbers of people. Creating disruption helps make up for these shortcomings.

Novelty and attention

Protest is the language of people denied access to power – it is designed to draw attention, to be seen and heard. It is much more likely for protesters to achieve something if they inconvenience others in the process, rather than (as more established groups tend to do) leading a march or a demo. Many activists in Britain drew that lesson from the massive anti-Iraq war protests of 2003, which mobilised so many people and yet achieved little.

Recently, researchers have shown this to be true by comparing various kinds of protest over the past decade. Strikes, sit-ins, occupations and blockades have proven more likely to achieve some degree of success than less disruptive protests such as marches, demos or petitions.

One reason for the efficiency of disruption is that it is much more likely to provide press coverage, particularly when it is novel. It’s instructive to compare the Insulate Britain protests with the recent Extinction Rebellion protests. In April 2019, XR were able to garner widespread media and political attention by occupying central London for nearly two weeks. Since then however, doing the same thing has brought diminishing returns: the police are better prepared, the actions are less disruptive, they mobilise fewer people, and the media has turned elsewhere.

Yet people stopping traffic on the M25 has attracted attention. And the small group of activists have managed to get their demands – insulate all social housing by 2025 and all homes by 2030 – printed in national newspapers. Their clear demands are an evolution of XR’s preference for leaving details of what policies are needed to tackle climate change to a future citizens’ assembly.

A nationwide retrofit and insulation campaign could slash emissions and fuel poverty. Irin-k/Shutterstock

Is annoying people worthwhile?

Critics say that blocking roads hurts vulnerable people. In this case, talk radio hosts highlighted delays to one girl’s taxi journey to her special needs school. In the case of anti-fracking activists who blocked the A583 in Lancashire in July 2017, the trial judge argued that the inconvenience caused – the police had to set up a contraflow – justified sending three of them to jail on a public nuisance charge.

But as any motorist can tell you, these things happen every day. If you drive a car to work, you’ll know how often you are delayed, by accidents, roadworks, sheer weight of traffic.

Other critics will point to the confused logic of blocking roads for the cause of insulating homes. There is, indeed, little connection between the two, unlike activists occupying the Science Museum to protest Shell’s sponsorship of its climate change exhibition, or blockades of fracking sites. But then again, there isn’t much of a direct connection between marching through London and demanding that British forces don’t invade Iraq, either.

Where groups engage in more indirect forms of disruption, it’s necessary to do more behind the scenes for the protest to make sense, including making the link explicit for onlookers. Insulate Britain held banners with their name and logo – a quick search on the web takes you to a website outlining what the group wants. It is, in other words, all about the target audience, the public, which activists reach through the media. Nothing will be achieved there and then. Britain’s homes will not be insulated as a result of this particular protest.

Read more: Five numbers that lay bare the mammoth effort needed to insulate Britain's homes

Of course, disruptive protest annoys people, and protesters sometimes lose support because of this. YouGov measured public support for XR recently and found that nearly half of those polled have a negative opinion of the group. But broad popularity isn’t all that relevant. Direct action groups aren’t running for elections. They don’t need to be supported by a majority. At least 73% of those polled had heard of XR – more than Momentum (33%), Stonewall (50%), ActionAid (60%), or the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (64%).

What Insulate Britain want is to highlight political inertia and force the government to take action. And it is unlikely that people will be against insulating homes just because they get annoyed at protesters. An estimated four million UK households currently live in fuel poverty. Insulating homes is an essential part of lowering Britain’s emissions – and saving British households a lot of money. So, while Insulate Britain may well not be popular, their strategy appears to be to take the hit among some groups who might be irked by their methods in order to get home insulation in the news and up the government’s agenda.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Oscar Berglund is a member of the Labour Party.

Graeme Hayes is a member of the Labour Party.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Covid: Vaccine passport scheme enforceable by law in Scotland

Scots will need to show an app with a QR Code to enter large events (PA) Enforcement of the Scottish Government’s Covid vaccine passport scheme came into effect on Monday ... Read more »

Hydrogen-powered Ineos Grenadier concept to use Hyundai fuel cell tech

A hydrogen-powered concept of the new Ineos Grenadier is set to use fuel cell technology from Hyundai. The move has come through a memorandum of understanding signed between the two ... Read more »

Still using BIOS? It's time to switch to UEFI — here's how on Windows 10.

© Provided by Windows Central UEFI makes your device more secure and faster than the legacy BIOS, and in this guide, we show you how to switch. If you plan ... Read more »

Facebook denies failings on hate speech removal

© Getty Images Facebook has denied allegations that its algorithms only remove a small number of posts containing hate speech. The company uses automated systems, alongside other methods, to identify ... Read more »

Sir David Amess' family visit scene of his stabbing

The widow of Sir David Amess, Julia, was accompanied by family members outside Belfairs Methodist Church, Leigh-on-Sea on Monday morning. Wiping tears from her eyes, she read messages on flowers ... Read more »

Batman is dead and the Court of Owls is here: Gotham Knights story trailer arrives

At this year’s DC Fandome, DC Comics unveiled its upcoming film and game trailers, besides giving fans a peek into the other new projects the company is working on. One ... Read more »

IKEA is working on a Spotify-enabled speaker that doubles as a lamp

Ikea may soon release a new Bluetooth “Vappeby” speaker with a couple of interesting twists, according to an FCC filing spotted by The Verge. It also functions as a lamp, ... Read more »

The best fitness tracker 2021: watches to help you keep healthier habits

A fitness tracker will help you develop healthier habits by giving you gentle encouragement to take a few extra steps, go for a run, take the stairs rather than the ... Read more »

The best running headphones 2021: high quality audio that'll go the distance

The best running headphones should help boost your performance and keep your mind occupied while you run. They also need to stay in place above no matter how vigorous your ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 Classic India review

The Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 Classic is the elder sibling of the Samsung Galaxy Watch 4. The Classic version is more premium while also being bigger and bulkier than the ... Read more »

Look like your favorite Metal Gear Solid character, Cool Glassesman, with these Hideo Kojima shades

Legendary video game designer Hideo Kojima has collaborated with French eyewear specialist Jean-François Rey to produce a limited-edition quartet of shades, specs, and a 3D-printed mask. The capsule collection is ... Read more »

Apple just took a huge step forward in smartphone sales

Early demand for the iPhone 13 saw Apple regain second place in the global smartphone market, however the ongoing shortage of components is finally having an impact on sales. According ... Read more »

The Morning After: Apple's Mac and Google's Pixel events, previewed

Apple’s second fall product event kicks off later today at 1 PM ET. We’ve laid out what to expect, but it’s not the only big tech event week. Spare a ... Read more »

What are hypersonic missiles? China's new weapons explained after nuclear-capable missile test alarms US

China’s advanced military capabilities took the US by surprise after it was revealed the Asian superpower reportedly tested a nuclear-capable hypersonic missile that circled around the earth before speeding towards ... Read more »

Facebook is hiring 10,000 new workers to help build the metaverse

Facebook is looking to hire some 10,000 new employees to help it build its own “metaverse”. While the “metaverse” itself does seem to be the upcoming trend across the globe ... Read more »

Foxconn unveils its first three electric vehicle prototypes

Taiwan‘s Foxconn unveiled its first three electric vehicle prototypes on Monday, underscoring ambitious plans to diversify away from its role of building consumer electronics for Apple Inc and other tech ... Read more »

40% users blame manufacturers for security of their IoT devices: Report

New Delhi: As internet of things (IoT) smart devices pick up adoption in our daily lives, new research said on Monday that 40 per cent of users think that manufacturers ... Read more »

Samsung's next flagship phones, Galaxy S22, S22+, display sizes leaked

As Samsung is gearing up for its Galaxy Unpacked Part 2 event on October 20, rumours around the company’s upcoming lineup are also heating up. While the company hasn’t provided ... Read more »

Canon in legal trouble for disabling scanning feature in ‘all-in-one' printers when ink is low

When you purchase an ‘all-in-one’ printer you expect the scanning functionality to work even if the printer is running low on ink. However, Canon is accused of disabling the scanning ... Read more »

Microsoft fixes this issue with latest Windows 11 beta update

Microsoft has rolled out a new Windows 11 build 22000.282 to Windows Insider users in Beta and Preview channels. The build has reportedly resolved the widespread Windows 11 bug in ... Read more »

Tagg launches Verve Plus smartwatch at Rs 1,899

Domestic electronics brand Tagg has launched the Verve Plus smartwatch at a price point of Rs 1,899. The smartwatch comes in three colour variants — Silver, Black, and Golden — ... Read more »

Tips on holiday shopping via Amazon: Talking Tech podcast

Hit play on the player above to hear the podcast and follow along with the transcript below. This transcript was automatically generated, and then edited for clarity in its current ... Read more »

New MacBook Pro models could have M1 Pro and M1 Max chips (not M1X)

Apple’s purported new MacBook Pros (theoretically 14-inch and 16-inch models) could arrive later today not toting the M1X chip, but rather they might be built around CPUs with different names: ... Read more »

No 10 denies Boris and Carrie Johnson broke lockdown rules by having friend stay at Christmas

(Anadolu Agency via Getty Images) Downing Street has denied Boris Johnson and his wife Carrie broke lockdown rules to have a close friend stay over during the Christmas period as ... Read more »

Teenager arrested after death of 14-year-old found at railway station

A teenager has been arrested in connection with the death of a 14-year-old boy. Justin McLaughlin was found seriously injured at High Street railway station in Glasgow at around 3.45pm ... Read more »

West Virginia Leads U.S. in Flood Risk, Adding to Manchin's Climate Dilemma

Mary Anne and Bob Marner in their basement of their Morgantown, W.Va. home on Oct. 5, 2021, which flooded twice recently, sending raw sewage into their house both times. (Erin ... Read more »

French drug firm Valneva reports positive results from its Covid trial

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo French drug firm Valneva today reported successful results from its Covid vaccine trial — a month after the UK cancelled its contract for ... Read more »

SK E&S funds W500b won for US affiliate to invest in US energy firm

A logo of SK E&SSK E&S Co., the natural gas provider under SK Group, said Monday it will invest some 500 billion won ($421 million) in its US affiliate, SK ... Read more »

UK needs to double daily installations of chargers to meet EV demand

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo Britain needs to increase its installation of public charge points from 27 per day to 50 if it is to meet electric ... Read more »

Fox Weather rolls out Oct. 25, and you can pre-register starting Monday

Most of the time when we check out the weather app on our phones, it’s to find a forecast for today, or tomorrow, or maybe even a week or two ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy Watch4 Smartwatch review: A sleek watch loaded with features

Looking for more of the best deals, latest celebrity news and hottest trends? Sign up for Yahoo Lifestyle Canada’s newsletter! I tried the Samsung Galaxy Watch4 Smartwatch: here’s what I ... Read more »

China denied a report that it tested a nuclear-capable hypersonic missile, saying it was just a space vehicle

Military vehicles carrying hypersonic missiles DF-17 in Tiananmen Square, Beijing. Thomas Peter/Reuters The Financial Times reported that China tested a nuclear-capable hypersonic missile in August. The FT reported that US ... Read more »

NBA picks Kuaishou as short-video content partner in latest attempt by sport to move on from China PR debacle

The National Basketball Association (NBA) has signed up short video platform operator Kuaishou Technology as a content partner in China, one of the sport’s biggest markets outside the US, in ... Read more »

Foxconn's 3 EV prototypes are here — and damn, their range is loooong

Remember Foxconn, Apple’s iPhone assembler? The Taiwanese company is now officially expanding its business areas and joining the EV game. At the Hon Hai Tech Day (HHTD21) on Monday, Foxconn ... Read more »

Apple is hosting an event where it could unveil a new MacBook Pro

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Apple could unveil a new version of its MacBook Pro laptop at an event tonight, alongside the long-awaited AirPods 3 wireless earphones, reports ... Read more »

Walmart Black Friday sale starts now - more deals coming throughout November

Not only has Walmart kicked off its Black Friday sale early today with hundreds of sales on everything from cheap laptops to vacuum cleaners, but the retailer has also unveiled ... Read more »

This super-fast e-bike can hit up to 31mph – but there's a caveat

Dutch e-bike company VanMoof has announced an e-bike that can hit a top speed of up to 31mph – in theory, at last. The VanMoof V is intended to replace ... Read more »

6 made-in-S'pore games: From grappling with zoo ethics to being a sci-fi Chinatown detective

(Clockwise from top left) Eye Of The Storm. Let’s Build A Zoo, Assassin’s Creed Valhalla: The Siege Of Paris, and The Signal State. SINGAPORE – Here are six games launched ... Read more »

Fix for AMD performance bug on Windows 11 in testing with Insiders

© Provided by Windows Central AMD Ryzen 9 5950X Microsoft appears close to fixing the L3 caching issue affecting Windows 11 PCs with AMD Ryzen processors. What you need to ... Read more »

Nintendo's pricing for Switch Online Expansion Pack leave fans fuming

Nintendo has priced the Expansion Pack for $49.99 per year Nintendo isn’t exactly known for its technological smarts. The Nintendo Switch is great, but is yards behind the competition when ... Read more »