Inside Dr. Oz's Shameless Flip-Flop on Abortion

Photo Illustration by Kelly Caminero/The Daily Beast/Getty

When the Supreme Court heard arguments last week for a case that could upend abortion rights nationwide, Mehmet Oz—the TV doctor and accused “quack” turned Republican candidate for Senate in Pennsylvania—suggested he was at peace that the Supreme Court could overturn Roe v. Wade.

But only two years earlier, Oz characterized efforts to overturn Roe as a misleading and possibly conspiratorial crusade. Not only was Oz supportive of abortion rights, he seemed puzzled that people would spend time fighting abortion rights—going so far as to say that, as a physician, he was “really worried” about the anti-abortion movement and that eliminating Roe would have negative effects on women’s health.

“It’s, as a doctor—just putting my doctor hat on—it’s a big-time concern,” Oz said in the 2019 interview, which aired on the Breakfast Club radio show. “Because I went to medical school in Philadelphia, and I saw women who had coat-hanger events. And I mean really traumatic events that happened when they were younger, before Roe v. Wade. And many of them were harmed for life.”

Oz conceded that abortion “is a hard issue for everybody,” and he said that, on “a personal level,” he disliked abortion and would not want anyone in his family to have one. But he took a common pro-choice position in 2019 that his belief should not be forced onto others. He would not want to “interfere with everyone else’s stuff,” he said, “because it’s hard enough to get into life as it is.”

Oz’s defense of abortion wasn’t just a passing question. He held forth for seven minutes in this 2019 interview about the practice and was highly critical of anti-abortion advocates who argue that life begins at conception. His tone throughout the entire segment on abortion was one of concern that legislators might be passing abortion restrictions, and he seemed to endorse viability—generally thought of as about 24 weeks—as a popular limit for abortion.

“Just being logical about it,” he said, “if you think that the moment of conception you’ve got a life, then why would you even wait six weeks? Right, then an in vitro fertilized egg is still a life.”

Oz also questioned why restricting abortion access was so important to some people.

“There’s so much we gotta do already to take care of each other. To start picking fights on this—I always wonder about it,” he said. “It happens periodically. There are these moral issues that almost on purpose are inflamed.”

And yet, despite his full-throated support for abortion access in 2019, Oz said last week during an interview on WGAL in Lancaster that he was “OK with the Supreme Court making the right decision” on Roe, “based on what they think the Constitution says.”

Earlier that day, the high court heard arguments regarding a challenge to Mississippi’s prohibitive abortion law, with conservative justices signaling they were prepared to scrap Roe entirely.

But in the discussion with the Breakfast Club—hosted by rapper and political pundit “Charlamagne tha God”—Oz devoted several minutes to explaining why the resurgent anti-abortion movement concerned him as a physician, and why Roe was valuable and should not be overturned.

When The Daily Beast called Dr. Oz for comment, he picked up his phone and immediately ended the call. He then did not reply to a text message asking about his remarks in the abortion discussion.

But asked in 2019 about prohibitive laws like the near-total ban Alabama Republican Gov. Kay Ivey had signed earlier that month—a so-called “heartbeat” bill which outlawed abortion in almost every instance starting six weeks after conception—Oz denounced the idea as dangerous, unfair to women, and premised on misleading information.

At one point in the conversation, Oz, who has been vocal about his own Christian faith, also questioned why anti-abortion advocates cared so much in the first place.

“Is this really the way they want to spend their time?” he wondered. “There’s so much we gotta fix in the world.”

While the physician and herbal weight-loss supplement salesman acknowledged that true believers “gotta be heard,” he said “that doesn’t mean that’s what the rule of the land is.”

“If people thought about it and logically work through it, most Americans sort of already agree on what the right answer is”—a position that appears directly at odds with the conservative majority on the Court.

Asked by tha God whether he thought prohibitive anti-abortion laws were “healthy,” Oz replied, “I’m really worried about it,” and invoked his professional experience.

“I’ve taken care of a lot of women who had issues around childbirth. The problem with the [Alabama] law as it stands now—and I think the law was really only passed to generate a Supreme Court challenge—but most women don’t know they’re pregnant,” he said, taking specific aim at the bad-faith effort to overturn Roe. “It’s two weeks past your last period when you have to decide by,” Oz explained, referencing the six-week line.

Oz, who rose to fame in the 2000s as a regular guest on Oprah Winfrey’s daytime television show, claimed he had guests on his own show “all the time” who did not know they were pregnant even “when they’re delivering.”

“So you’re asking women to decide almost instantaneously if they’re pregnant or not,” Oz said. “And it’s also banned in cases of incest and rape. So I don’t quite get it as a doctor.”

He then went to lengths to dismantle the spurious six-week “heartbeat” talking point.

“There are electrical exchanges at six weeks, but the heart’s not beating,” Oz said.

“If you’re going to define life by a beating heart, then make it a beating heart, not little electrical exchanges in the cell that no one would hear or think about as a heart,” he continued. To do otherwise, he said, misleads the average person into “envisioning a little acorn heart beating in there, and that’s not what’s going on at six weeks.”

The Mississippi law currently before the court is not as extreme as Alabama’s 2019 bill, banning abortions after 15 weeks, not six. But hours ahead of Oz’s interview, the conservative justices signaled they were open to a broad ruling that would legalize six-week bans.

Chief Justice John Roberts was the lone conservative to raise the question of a narrow decision, saying, “The thing that is at issue before us today is 15 weeks.” But Roberts would need to pick off at least two other conservatives, and none appeared eager to join him.

One of those justices, Samuel Alito, mused that “the only real options we have” are to uphold or overturn Roe.

And while Oz now seems fine with a conservative majority overturning Roe, as he faces a GOP primary field of anti-abortion Republicans, Oz was explicitly concerned by that prospect in 2019, and suggested abortion bans could result in a “big sucking sound of businesses leaving” states.

When Breakfast Club co-host Angela Yee expressed concern that if Roe were overturned, abortions would continue, but “in a dangerous way and it could actually kill you,” Oz backed that up with his own medical experience.

The abortion discussion was only one part of a wide-ranging interview on the Breakfast Club. Dr. Oz and the hosts also covered why it’s unsanitary to wash chicken before cooking it (“you spray the salmonella all over the kitchen”), why Americans should consume less meat (“what’s destroying our economy in many ways is the way we eat so much meat”), the medical promise of hallucinogenic drugs (“I don’t have a problem that I think it would help”), environmentally friendly wet wipe alternatives (“I take toilet paper; I spit on it, to moisten it, or use the sink”) and how liberals and conservatives are different “partly for genetic reasons.”

“Liberals primarily view freedom and the right to do what’s important to them as their primary drivers. Conservatives tend to use other factors in addition. For example, you don’t want people pissing in your neighborhood—that’s much more important to conservatives,” Oz explained.

An acclaimed thoracic surgeon and director of integrated medicine at one of the top med schools in the country, Oz long ago morphed into a controversial public figure straddling the worlds of health, media, and politics. He leveraged Oprah’s imprimatur into a multimillion-dollar celebrity doctor brand, racking up accusations of “quackery” along the way—promoting false theories about genetically modified foods and hawking “sham” weight-loss supplements, for which he at one point answered to Congress.

Dr. Oz watches as Oprah Winfrey shaves off the moustache of television personality Dr. Phil in 2010. Lucas Jackson/Reuters

As the coronavirus pandemic descended last spring, Oz—a regular on Fox News—caught the attention of then-President Donald Trump, who wanted to connect with Oz after watching him speak positively about the unproven COVID treatment hydroxychloroquine.

In an interview two months before the 2016 election, Oz briefly quizzed then-candidate Trump on women’s reproductive health, touching first on birth control and following up with a fleeting discussion about abortion.

“What is your stand on abortion today?” Oz asked.

“I am pro-life,” Trump replied.

Oz had no other follow-ups.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Kao the Kangaroo gets a reboot, two decades after the original

© Image: Tate Multimedia Kao the Kangaroo screenshot Born in the era of animal-based platformers and continuing in the era of remakes, Kao the Kangaroo is back. Beginning more than ... Read more »

Jon Watts reveals 'therapy session' with Spider-Man stars

© Bang Showbiz Jon Watts recalls Spider-Man ‘therapy session’ Jon Watts held a “therapy session” with the key cast members of ‘Spider-Man: No Way Home’. The 40-year-old filmmaker helmed the ... Read more »

Link's Breath of the Wild archery skills are sorely lacking, according to one expert

© Provided by GamesRadar Nintendo Direct Link from The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild apparently isn’t very good with a bow and arrow according to an archery expert.  ... Read more »

NHL 22's huge update today adds national teams — women included

© Image: EA Vancouver/Electronic Arts As hockey fans well know, the United States-Canada rivalry, in the Olympics anyway, has been a rather one-sided affair. Three wins, three draws for the ... Read more »

Horizon Forbidden West Reusing Animations Isn't A New Phenomenon (And It's Not Bad, Either)

© Screenshot: Guerrilla Games / Kotaku A screenshot from Horizon Forbidden West’s January 19 story trailer depicting protagonist Aloy looking at a skyscraper-sized machine in the distance. Just because minor ... Read more »

Why everyone is playing Yu-Gi-Oh! out of nowhere

© Image: Konami Digital Entertainment Looking for another way to relive that ’90s and early 2000s nostalgia? You’re in luck — Konami recently released a new free-to-play Yu-Gi-Oh! game called ... Read more »

Riot Games wants you to know Valorant's Killjoy does not enjoy NFTs

© Image: Riot Games Valorant, the competitive shooter from Riot Games, stars a cast of near future heroes and mercenaries with unique skillsets and personalities. One of these characters, Killjoy, ... Read more »

Hitman 3 Had A Bad Steam Launch, So Everyone Gets An Upgrade

© Screenshot: IO Interactive Agent 47 pours a glass of Argentinian Malbec in a brick-lined winery in Hitman 3. The news here isn’t that IO Interactive—which has historically been reticent ... Read more »

YouTuber Hit With Ungodly Number Of Anime Copyright Strikes Gets A Win For Everyone

© Screenshot: Totally Not Mark Mark Fitzpatrick sits in front of bookselves filled with manga and delivers news about his copyright battle with Toei from his gamer chair. In a ... Read more »

Hyper Scape will shut down on April 28, Ubisoft announces

© Image: Ubisoft Montreal Ubisoft has announced that development on Hyper Scape will come to an end. In a short blog post addressed to the community, the company wrote that ... Read more »

Destiny 2 will get less tedious in The Witch Queen

© Image: Bungie Destiny 2 is a game all about grind, and it does it well. But even the great grindy games can become tedious, and Destiny is no exception. ... Read more »

A Senator's Wife Was Nearly Denied A Life-Saving Abortion & That's Why He's Committed to Reproductive Rights

As pro-choice activists grow more and more concerned over the fate of Roe v. Wade in the coming weeks, and having just celebrated an uncertain 49th anniversary of the landmark ... Read more »

'Licorice Pizza,' West Side Story,' 'Dune' score top guild nominations, clarifying Oscar race

Hopes that a few of last year’s biggest box-office hits, “Spider-Man: No Way Home” and “No Time to Die,” might join the best picture Oscar race were dealt a blow ... Read more »

JoAnna Garcia Swisher Says Her ‘Sweet Magnolias' Co-Stars Became Her Support System Following The Death Of Her Mother

JoAnna Garcia Swisher is grateful for her “Sweet Magnolias” family. Back in May, the actress posted a photo of herself with co-stars while filming season two of the Netflix series, ... Read more »

Dolly Parton On 55 Years Of Happy Marriage: ‘Nobody Wants To Make Out With A Slouch'

Dolly Parton shares her recipe for more than five decades of marriage with Carl Thomas Dean. Parton and Dean have been together for 55 years. The country superstar’s secret to ... Read more »

Who is Lykke Li? Everything to know about the singer and actor rumoured to be dating Brad Pitt

© Getty Images lykke-li.jpg Lykke Li is rumoured to be dating Brad Pitt, leaving fans wondering who the Swedish singer is and how the celebrity pair may have met. Rumours ... Read more »

Fatboy Slim on performing in Belfast, fatherhood, and why lockdown rekindled his love for gigs

Legendary dance artist Fatboy Slim has opened up about his excitement at returning to Belfast this March, as well as sharing how he kept his sanity during lockdown, and what ... Read more »

The Beatles final rooftop performance's audio beautifully remastered for release this week

When Then Beatles gave their iconic rooftop performance, the band hadn’t performed live together in three years. Taking place on January 30, 1969, the legendary show would also be their ... Read more »

Kanye West fans make same prediction about new album Donda 2 following release date announcement

Kanye West fans are making several predictions about the rapper’s newly-announced album. On Thursday (27 January), it was revealed that his 11th studio album will be released in February. The ... Read more »

Donald Trump Jr leads conservatives celebrating Neil Young's Spotify purge over Joe Rogan clash

Many conservatives, including Donald Trump Jr, have been celebrating Spotify’s removal of Neil Young’s music this week. The folk musician, best known for songs like “Heart of Gold” and “Old ... Read more »

Why Kristen Bell's Signature 'Gossip Girl' Voiceover Was Almost Cut From the Show

The one and only source into the scandalous lives of Manhattan’s elite almost never came to be, as in Kristen Bell almost got the ax as the voiceover for Gossip Girl because — get ... Read more »

Music giants face investigation into ‘excessive power' claims

© Provided by The Telegraph Music giants face investigation into ‘excessive power’ claims Record labels and music streaming giants will be investigated by the competition watchdog to determine if they ... Read more »

Hundreds of pupils missing out on music tuition in Dumfries and Galloway due to tutor shortages

Teachers’ union EIS this week insisted that there are “nowhere near enough” music tutors in Dumfries and Galloway. This comes after it was revealed that 411 pupils are on a ... Read more »

Music quiz: Test you knowledge with these 30 questions and answers

Like most people you probably have a favourite song and a favourite artist or band. But how much do you really know about the music you love? We’ve set up ... Read more »

How to listen to Neil Young's music now it's been removed from Spotify

Neil Young fans have been left wondering how they can listen to his music after its removal from Spotify. The 76-year-old’s music has been removed from Spotify after he protested ... Read more »

Prince Andrew's ‘humiliation' could be made public – even if he settles out of court

© Steve Parsons/Pool Photo via AP, File Prince Andrew, the Duke of York – Steve Parsons/Pool Photo via AP, File The Duke of York’s deposition could be made public even ... Read more »

Nightmare neighbour harassed disabled man by attacking Ring doorbell camera

A nightmare neighbour terrorised a wheelchair-bound man by playing “thumping” music – and then took a hammer and screwdriver to his Ring doorbell. Stephen Groves was due to appear at ... Read more »

John Legend joins thousands spamming Virginia tip line for parents who oppose critical race theory

© screengrab Activist Olivia Juliana calls on her followers to flood a tip-line created by Republican Governor Glenn Youngkin and used by Virginians to report teachers who act “objectionably.” – ... Read more »

Taiko no Tatsujin is out today on Xbox Game Pass - but PC version hit with launch issues

© BANDAI NAMCO taiko no tatsujin arrives on xbox game pass today Taiko no Tatsujin The Drum Master has launched on Xbox Game Pass today. The long running and beloved ... Read more »

Tom Holland says Benedict Cumberbatch's performance in 'The Power of the Dog' was so convincing that he 'hated' him

© Provided by INSIDER On the left: Tom Holland at the premiere of “Spider-Man: No Way Home” in December 2021. On the right: Benedict Cumberbatch in “The Power of the ... Read more »

UK festival line-ups 2022: The best tickets to buy now, from Camp Bestival to Parklife

© Press image GreenManFestival1509 There were times when it didn’t look like it would happen, but the UK’s festival summer finally arrived in 2021 — and what a blast it ... Read more »

Scenes from the Kalevala review – the Finnish epic poem that inspired a nation's composers

The Kalevala, the Finnish epic poem describing the creation of the world and the journeys and adventures of the people of the land of Kalevala, first appeared in print in ... Read more »

Kendrick Lamar and Eminem fans predict Super Bowl LVI will be ‘best ever'

Ahead of next month’s Super Bowl, fans of Kendrick Lamar and Eminem have predicted that this year’s halftime show will be the best ever. The rappers are featured as headline ... Read more »

UK watchdog to study music streaming amid claims of raw deal for artists and fans

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Anadolu Agency/Getty Images The UK’s competition watchdog has launched an in-depth study into the booming music streaming market, to assess whether the big record ... Read more »

My transgender reforms do not threaten women's rights, says Nicola Sturgeon

© Drew Angerer/Getty Images Transgender rights – Drew Angerer/Getty Images Nicola Sturgeon has dismissed claims from the UK’s equalities watchdog that her planned overhaul of gender laws threatens the rights ... Read more »

Eric Dane Addresses Those Fan Theories About Grey's Anatomy and Euphoria

We hate to burst your bubble but Eric Dane says that young Cal’s love interest is not Derek Shepherd. In the latest episode of Euphoria, which aired Sunday, Jan. 24, ... Read more »

Why Tom Holland, Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire Had "Therapy Session" Before Filming Spider-Man

Spider-Men, unite! That was exactly what happened both on and off-screen for Tom Holland and Spider-Man alums Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire in the making of the latest installment of ... Read more »

Man Arrested Outside of Taylor Swift's NYC Apartment After Trying to Gain Access

A man has been arrested following an incident on the street of Taylor Swift‘s New York City apartment building. According to the New York Police Department, witnesses called New York’s ... Read more »

Mark Wahlberg Jokes He Doesn't Want to Upset Wife for 'Not Wearing a Shirt' as He Flexes Muscles

© Provided by People Mark Walhberg/Instagram Mark Wahlberg Mark Wahlberg is continuing to hit the gym! The Uncharted actor, 50, showed off his killer physique on Instagram Thursday, posting a ... Read more »

Sundance Embraces Elevated Nonfiction Fare as Oscar Voters Expand Definition of Excellence in Filmmaking

© Courtesy: Cinetic Media In the streaming age, documentary filmmakers, once the long-suffering artists working in obscurity to finish self-funded passion projects, have become rock stars. Deep-pocketed platforms like Netflix ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic