India's China strategy is a concoction of reserved diplomacy, backed by a vocal army

Asia's Tech News Daily

India’s China strategy is a concoction of reserved diplomacy, backed by a vocal army
© Provided by Firstpost India’s China strategy is a concoction of reserved diplomacy, backed by a vocal army

India’s rising China challenge is now being more openly acknowledged by our armed forces in public. They seem to have acquired more freedom to express themselves on politically sensitive security issues. Our retired military figures have been speaking and writing on such issues freely, but serving top brass have been traditionally publicly discreet on such matters.

The earlier practice of serving military chiefs confining themselves essentially to bread and butter defence and service issues related to equipment, procurement, organisation, manpower, deployments, capacity gaps, modernisation etc., and staying clear of issues with foreign policy sensitivities is being redefined. The armed forces have always complained about not being consulted adequately, much less institutionally, on the strategic national security challenges confronting India.

Their other longstanding grouse has been that India has ignored the importance of military diplomacy as an adjunct to the conduct of foreign policy, unlike in the case of other major powers, especially the US. It is true that the military represents hard power and used with discernment it can give teeth to diplomacy. Our Chief of Defence Staff and service chiefs are lately frequently speaking in various fora on a range of challenges facing India that straddle defence and foreign policy. This is particularly true of our challenges from China and Pakistan.


General Rawat, the Chief of Defence Staff (CDS), has been particularly outspoken on the national security challenges facing India. In a recent public lecture he called China’s ambitions and aspirations to global power an “omnipresent danger” to regional strategic instability and carrying the potential of “threatening India’s territorial integrity and strategic importance”. He noted that China was making huge inroads into South Asia and the Indian Ocean region to strengthen its position as an emerging global power.

Bangladesh and Myanmar, he said, have been the largest recipients of Chinese military aid in the recent past, which he characterised as not being in India’s national interest as these were attempts to encircle us. China had made significant investments in Nepal, Sri Lanka and Maldives to gain a strategic foothold in the region, he added. China’s supply of military hardware to Pakistan and supporting it in international fora was described by him as an anti-India nexus. He believes Pakistan’s continued sponsoring of cross-border terrorism, a vicious anti-India rhetoric on social media, and efforts to create social disharmony within India, makes the trust gap between India and that country “unbridgeable”.

The CDS has been highlighting China’s technological advances in the cyber and space domains as the most worrisome external security challenge, as beyond the military, it includes critical infrastructure as well. For him, procuring advanced surveillance systems that can help India keep an eye on its land borders and oceans is the topmost priority of the armed forces right now. He foresees a durable confrontation with China, as he views the recent incidents on the northern borders along with aggressive posturing remaining a cornerstone of China’s expansionist foreign policy about which India has to be wary.

Without mincing words he has spoken of geo-strategic competition in the Indo-Pacific, including a race for strategic bases in the Indian Ocean region and increasing militarisation of the Belt and Road outposts in the region. This is plain talk which the Chinese would have noted carefully, as we too would have noted equally carefully if the PLA chief had given his assessment publicly on the impact of India’s policies on China’s regional strategic interests.


General Rawat’s assessment of China’s regional threat to India has been commonplace in think tank circles for years. After the Doklam stand-off and the much more serious Chinese military moves in Ladakh which in a breakdown of border protocols resulted in actual loss of lives, the threat from China is being felt by the country much more palpably than in recent times.

Our policy toward China since 1988 has essentially failed. The peace and tranquility agreements, the confidence building measures, several additional border management protocols to prevent any actual clash, a Special Representatives mechanism to resolve the border issue politically, the agreement on parameters and guidelines for a border settlement, allowing bilateral trade ties to grow without making them hostage to border differences, exchange of state visits, numerous bilateral meetings, informal summits—all of this has not only not worked for betterment and stability of our ties, our relations today have deteriorated sharply and the distrust of China has become deeper.

The failed latest round (13th) of military talks points to a hardening of China’s position. The statements issued on both sides, unlike after the previous rounds, not only show an impasse, but also a readiness on both sides to publicly blame each other. This was unusual in the light of a studied optimistic posture maintained after the previous rounds. The prospect of forces on both sides continuing to be deployed at icy heights in Ladakh during the coming winter is now a reality.

The hardening of China’s posture is reflected in setting up additional infrastructure by China for the winter deployment of its forces in Ladakh, the dual purpose border villages set up close to the LAC in the eastern sector and the new border law passed by China to protect its territorial integrity. China has also begun mounting pressure on the eastern front with additional infrastructural activity and reported intrusions (in the central Barahoti sector as well), with India, in turn, increasing its troop and weapon deployments such as the M777 ultra-light howitzers and the 155 mm FH 77 BO2 (Bofors) guns.

The CDS’s bluntness contrasts with a firm but much more diplomatic posture adopted by the External Affairs Minister and studied reticence at the Prime Minister’s level on the China challenge. The strategy seems to be to maintain diplomatic pressure on China, avoid involving directly the highest political authority in the unfolding situation in order to maintain political manoeuvrability at that level, but let the military spell out the reality of the China threat.

It is a good strategy, in that the China challenge is not being glossed over at the military level while keeping the window open at the bilateral political level and preserving the diplomatic suppleness needed for our participation in forums such as BRICS, the SCO, even the RIC, where China is present and is an ostensible partner, even as we strengthen ties with the US, deepen our Quad engagement, pursue maritime security within the framework of the Indo-Pacific based on adherence to international law and respect for sovereignty.

The author is Former Foreign Secretary. He was India’s Ambassador to Turkey, Egypt, France and Russia. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Pyar Chahiye Ya Mutton? Vegetarian Husband Asks Wife to Choose Between Him & Non-Veg Food!

© Ritu Singh | Trending Desk Vegetarian Husband Asks Wife to Choose Between Him & Non-Veg Food Viral News: People on social media have been left in splits after a ... Read more »

Homeless man sentenced to five years in prison for Peach Tree Mall arson

Dec. 4—Yuba County Superior Court Judge Julia Scrogin sentenced a homeless man to five years, eight months in state prison on Monday for the arson of the former Peach Tree ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi to Pele - Who are the all-time highest goalscorers for club and country?

Cristiano Ronaldo achieved a new career milestone on Thursday as he became the first player ever to score 800 career goals with a brace against Arsenal in Manchester United’s 3-2 ... Read more »

Renewable energy to dominate growth in global power capacity through 2026, says IEA

© Somya Lohia Renewable energy to dominate growth in global power capacity through 2026, says IEA Renewable energy is set to account for nearly 95 percent of the increase in ... Read more »

2nd Test: Ajaz Patel revels in heroics on his 'home' turf

© Provided by The Times of India MUMBAI: Out of the 70 overs that New Zealand bowled on Day 1 of the second Test, 29 were bowled by Ajaz Patel. ... Read more »

Pensioners Get More Time to Submit Life Certificate. Know Details

© Provided by News18 Pensioners Get More Time to Submit Life Certificate. Know Details Life Certificate Submission 2021: The central government in a recent notification announced that it has extended ... Read more »

Sutersville man to serve up to 20 years in prison for sexual assaults of 2 children

Dec. 4—A Sutersville man will serve up to an additional 20 years in prison for the rape and sexual assaults of two children. Ronald E. Styche III, 43, pleaded guilty ... Read more »

'Look at bench strength and talent team has got': Zaheer cautions senior India batsman on 'difficult' comeback chance

© Provided by Hindustan Times Zaheer Khan (Getty Images) Former India pacer Zaheer Khan on Friday cautioned senior Indian batsman Ajinkya Rahane on how difficult it has become to get ... Read more »

Explained: App permissions, updated passwords to browsing in private mode, here's how to ensure digital privacy

© Provided by CNBCTV18 As we become more and more dependent on digital technologies and share information on social media, banking websites and all sorts of apps, our privacy is ... Read more »

Willmar man continues to suffer complications from November stabbing

Dec. 4—WILLMAR — A Willmar man is still suffering from an incident when he was stabbed multiple times in his apartment in early November. John Claeys, 26, suffered a hemothorax ... Read more »

Doctor doubles down on fighting for trans rights despite suspension for ‘offensive' tweets

Adrian Harrop, a British doctor, has been suspended after using his Twitter account to send “offensive” tweets to people who opposed trans rights. The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) suspended ... Read more »

Two Seward men charged with illegally dumping oily fluid in Chugach National Forest

Dec. 4—An indictment by a federal grand jury in Anchorage charged two Seward men with dumping more than a dozen 55-gallon drums containing an oily substance into the Chugach National ... Read more »

Funeral next week in San José for YCHS grad Kevin Nishita

Dec. 4—The funeral for Yuba City High School graduate Kevin Nishita, who died from injuries sustained while working as a security guard for a Bay Area TV crew last week, ... Read more »

How to watch the CoD: Mobile World Championship Western Finals 2021

© Provided by Dot Esports The Western Finals of the Call of Duty: Mobile World Championship 2021 will take place on Dec. 4 and 5. Twelve teams from Europe, North ... Read more »

Finland arrests 5 over far-right terror plot

© Provided by Police have arrested 5 over an alleged terror plot Five men suspected of planning a far-right motivated bomb and gun attack have been arrested, Finnish police ... Read more »

Rangnick spoke like a coach worthy of managing United as injury updates ahead of Palace match

Here are your Saturday morning Manchester United headlines on December 4. Rangnick has spoken The wait is finally over. Ralf Rangnick has not only been unveiled as the next Manchester ... Read more »

PH ranks 4th in one-day jabs worldwide

THE Philippines has clinched the fourth spot in the global rankings of nations with the highest daily Covid-19 jab rate, the National Task Force Against Covid-19 (NTF) said on Friday. ... Read more »

Nearly 1,500 unhoused people died on the streets of Los Angeles during the pandemic, according to a new report

© Francine Orr / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images Echo Park Lake Thursday, March 25, 2021 in los Angeles, CA. Francine Orr / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images ... Read more »

'Boris Hasn't Lost Star Quality' - Tories Say After Majority Slashed In By-Election

Prime Minister Boris Johnson earlier this week (Photo: JUSTIN TALLIS via Getty Images) The Conservative Party chairman today insisted Boris Johnson has not lost his “star quality” after their majority ... Read more »

Jets prepping for either Eagles' quarterback amid Jalen Hurts' injury

The Jets entered the weekend unsure of which quarterback they will be facing Sunday at MetLife Stadium. The Eagles labeled starter Jalen Hurts, who suffered a sprained ankle last week ... Read more »

Ruru Madrid, Bianca Umali, paanong break na?!

© Provided by NOEL FERRER Happy Birthday, Ruru Madrid! For me, Ruru remains to be the Kapuso young actor who is my best bet for major stardom. Nagkaroon man ... Read more »

Gilead recalls vials of COVID antiviral drug remdesivir over glass shard contamination

Gilead Sciences Inc. recalled vials of its COVID-19 antiviral drug after finding it was contaminated with glass particles. AP Photo/Eric Risberg, File A pharmaceutical manufacturer recalled thousands of vials of ... Read more »

Zuu and plogging: new fitness trends we'll be embracing in 2022

© Getty Images Home workouts are waning in popularity as the world eases restrictions on movement brought on by the pandemic. Getty A new study by PureGym in the UK ... Read more »

Kad laporan 100 hari: Markah buruk bagi Rina, Siti Zailah

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Rina Harun (kanan) dan Siti Zailah Mohd Yusoff telah menyandang jawatan tertinggi di KPWKM sejak Mac 2020. (Gambar Facebook) PETALING JAYA: Kad laporan 100 ... Read more »

Why do I grind my teeth and clench my jaw? And what can I do about it?

© Getty Images Why do I grind my teeth and clench my jaw? And what can I do about it? Alexander Holden, University of Sydney Dentists have reported a rise ... Read more »

China looks to ease monetary policy to help smaller firms

China will cut the amount of cash banks have to keep in reserve to aid smaller firms, the Premier Li Keqiang said Friday, although he didn’t say when the reduction ... Read more »

'Watered-down hope': Experts wanted more from climate pact

The Associated PressClimate activists hold a demonstration through the venue of the COP26 U.N. Climate Summit in Glasgow, Scotland, Friday, Nov. 12, 2021. Negotiators from almost 200 nations were making ... Read more »

«Es ist immer noch besser, als nichts zu tun»

Die Schulen sind aktuell Corona-Hotspots. Der Bundesrat sieht davon ab, sie zu repetitiven Tests zu verpflichten. Epidemiologin Susi Kriemler hält den Entscheid für falsch. © Bereitgestellt von Tages-Anzeiger Schulen dürfen ... Read more »

More than one million people book booster jab appointment in less than a week

More than one million people have booked an appointment for a booster jab this week after the public were urged to have the shot following the emergence of the Omicron ... Read more »

UK holidays: The staycation destinations that could save you money this Christmas

Christmas is an expensive time of year, with multiple social events and plenty of presents to spend money on. However, for many families or groups of friends, a festive staycation ... Read more »

Kyle Lowry nails six of Heat's 16 triples in win over Pacers

© Provided by By Phillip B. Wilson INDIANAPOLIS — Kyle Lowry scored a season-high 26 points with six 3-pointers and the short-handed Miami Heat beat the Indiana Pacers, 113-104, ... Read more »

Russia planning Ukraine offensive with up to 175,000 troops: report

© Sergey VOLSKIY Ukraine has warned that Russia may be planning a large-scale attack next month Russia is orchestrating a multi-front offensive involving up to 175,000 troops as soon as ... Read more »

Exclusive | IND vs NZ: Women Scorers Team-up For Historic Debut

© Provided by News18 Exclusive | IND vs NZ: Women Scorers Team-up For Historic Debut Making a maiden appearance in any field will leave you with butterflies in your stomach ... Read more »

South Africa hit by fourth COVID-19 wave: What we know about country's surge in cases

© Provided by Firstpost South Africa hit by fourth COVID-19 wave: What we know about country’s surge in cases As some parts of the globe still reel from the Delta ... Read more »

Rise above ‘why should I care' attitude, Amit Shah tells IPS probationers

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Home minister Amit Shah, while interacting with IPS probationary officers here on Friday, appealed to them to rise above the “what ... Read more »

Security Forces Alerted Over Delhi Woman Suspected of Honey-Trapping Officials for Favours, Sensitive Info

© Provided by News18 Security Forces Alerted Over Delhi Woman Suspected of Honey-Trapping Officials for Favours, Sensitive Info Security forces and police in the national capital as well as Jammu ... Read more »

Mahua Moitra says she stands by her tweets on Adani, after Mamata-Adani meeting

© Provided by Hindustan Times Mahua Moitra is a staunch critic of the several Adani dealings and she has not changed her stance following Mamata’s meeting with Gautam Adani, she ... Read more »

Former Andhra Pradesh CM Konijeti Rosaiah dies at 88

Former Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Konijeti Rosaiah died on Saturday. He was 88. Konijeti Rosaiah, who also served as the governor of Tamil Nadu, breathed his last today morning in ... Read more »

Omicron in India: 10 passengers from South Africa go ‘missing' in Karnataka; woman jumps home quarantine in Chandigarh

© Provided by Firstpost Omicron in India: 10 passengers from South Africa go ‘missing’ in Karnataka; woman jumps home quarantine in Chandigarh The Omicron variant, the latest ‘variant of concern’, ... Read more »

Rains lash parts of Odisha, Cyclone Jawad likely to reach near coast around noon on Dec 5 | Pics

The impact of Cyclone Jawad could be felt in Odisha on Saturday morning as rains began to lash parts of the state. The impact of Cyclone Jawad could be felt ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic