Indiana doctor breaks down at medical board hearing as she is punished for speaking publicly about 10-year-old's abortion in 'brazen pursuit of her own agenda' but is allowed to keep license

Dr Caitlin Bernard performed an abortion in Indiana on a 10-year-old girl from Ohio who had been raped, but could not get an abortion in her own stateThe case became an immediate flashpoint in the battle over Roe v Wade, which was repealed on June 24, 2022On Thursday, an Indiana medical board fined Bernard $3,000 for speaking about the case: she insisted she did not release any identifying details

An Indiana doctor has been fined $3,000 after she performed an abortion on a 10-year-old Ohio girl who had been raped and was unable to obtain the procedure in her own state, thanks to the repealing of Roe v. Wade.

Dr Caitlin Bernard was fined not for the procedure itself, but for publicly talking about it – with the state’s Republican deputy attorney general accusing her of being ‘brazen in pursuit of (her) own agenda’.

The case became a flashpoint following the June 24, 2022 decision by the Supreme Court to revoke the 50-year-old law.

Ohio’s near-total abortion ban immediately went into effect: It banned all abortions after the sixth week of pregnancy, before most people even know they are pregnant.

Abortion is legal in Indiana, up until 21 weeks and six days. An Indiana law that completely banned abortion in Indiana went into effect on September 15 but is being challenged in the courts, and it is currently not in effect.

Bernard on Thursday broke down in tears as she was told that she would not lose her medical license – something the Republican attorney general had sought.

Dr Caitlin Bernard on Thursday was fined $3,000 for performing the abortion on the 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio, and then talking publicly about it

Dr Caitlin Bernard on Thursday was fined $3,000 for performing the abortion on the 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio, and then talking publicly about it

But the state Medical Licensing Board voted that she did not abide by privacy laws by telling a newspaper reporter about the girl’s treatment.

The board, however, rejected accusations from Indiana’s Republican attorney general that Bernard violated state law by not reporting the child abuse to Indiana authorities.

Board members chose to fine Bernard $3,000 for the violations, turning down a request from the attorney general’s office to suspend Bernard’s license.

Bernard has consistently defended her actions, and she told the board on Thursday that she followed Indiana’s reporting requirements and hospital policy by notifying hospital social workers about the child abuse – and that the girl’s rape was already being investigated by Ohio authorities.

Bernard’s lawyers also said that she did not release any identifying information about the girl that would break privacy laws.

The Indianapolis Star cited the girl’s case in a July 1 article that sparked a national political uproar in the weeks after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade last summer.

Some news outlets and Republican politicians falsely suggested Bernard fabricated the story, until a 27-year-old man was charged with the rape in Columbus, Ohio.

During an event at the White House, President Joe Biden nearly shouted his outrage over the case.

Bernard, left, sits between attorneys John Hoover and Alice Morical on Thursday before a hearing in front of the state medical board in Indianapolis

Bernard, left, sits between attorneys John Hoover and Alice Morical on Thursday before a hearing in front of the state medical board in Indianapolis

Board President Dr. John Strobel said he believed Bernard went too far in telling a reporter about the girl’s pending abortion, and that physicians need to be careful about observing patient privacy.

‘I don’t think she expected this to go viral,’ Strobel said of Bernard.

‘I don’t think she expected this attention to be brought to this patient. It did. It happened.’

Bernard’s lawyer Alice Morical told the board on Thursday that the doctor reported child abuse of patients many times a year and that a hospital social worker had confirmed with Ohio child protection staffers that it was safe for the girl to leave with her mother.

‘Dr Bernard could not have anticipated the atypical and intense scrutiny that this story received,’ Morical said.

‘She did not expect that politicians would say that she made the story up.’

Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita’s complaint asked the licensing board to impose ‘appropriate disciplinary action’, but did not specify a requested penalty.

Amid the wave of attention to the girl’s case last summer, Rokita, who is stridently anti-abortion, told Fox News he would investigate Bernard’s actions and called her an ‘abortion activist acting as a doctor.’

Deputy Attorney General Cory Voight argued on Thursday that the board needed to address what he called an ‘egregious violation’ of patient privacy and Bernard’s failure to notify Indiana’s Department of Child Services and police about the rape.

‘There’s been no case like this before the board,’ Voight said.

‘No physician has been as brazen in pursuit of their own agenda.’

Voight asked Bernard why she discussed the Ohio girl’s case with the newspaper reporter and later in other news media interviews rather than using a hypothetical situation.

‘I think that it’s incredibly important for people to understand the real-world impacts of the laws of this country about abortion,’ Bernard said.

‘I think it’s important for people to know what patients will have to go through because of legislation that is being passed, and a hypothetical does not make that impact.’

During Thursday’s hearing, Rokita’s office kept up a running commentary on its official Twitter account, with one post saying: ‘When Bernard talked about the high priority she puts on legislation and speaking to the public, she did so at the expense of her own patient.

‘This shows where her priorities are as an activist rather than a doctor.’

Bernard objected to Voight saying her choice to publicly discuss the case led to the misconduct allegations.

‘I think if the attorney general, Todd Rokita, had not chosen to make this his political stunt we wouldn’t be here today,’ Bernard said.

Lawyers for the attorney general’s office repeatedly raised questions about whether the policy of Bernard’s employer, Indiana University Health, to report suspected child abuse to authorities in the state where the abuse occurred complied with Indiana law.

Officials of IU Health, which is the state’s largest hospital system, testified that the Indiana Department of Child Services has never objected before to the hospital policy.

The Indiana board – with five doctors and one attorney present who were appointed or reappointed by Republican Governor Eric Holcomb – had wide latitude under state law allowing it to issue reprimand letters or suspend, revoke or place on probation a doctor’s license.

Ohio’s law imposing a near-ban on abortion was in effect for about two months, before being put on hold as a lawsuit against it plays out.

Indiana’s Republican-dominated Legislature approved a statewide abortion ban weeks after the Ohio girl’s case drew attention, but abortions have continued to be permitted in the state while awaiting an Indiana Supreme Court decision on the ban’s constitutionality.

Bernard unsuccessfully tried to block Rokita’s investigation last fall, although an Indianapolis judge wrote that Rokita made ‘clearly unlawful breaches’ of state confidentiality laws with his public comments about investigating the doctor before filing the medical licensing complaint against her.

News Related


Mar-a-Lago employee 'FLOODED room with video surveillance logs when they drained the swimming pool': New twist in Trump classified documents saga - as his lawyers hold crunch talks with Department of Justice

Unclear if the room was intentionally flooded or if it was a mistake Prosecutors are investigating whether there was any attempt by Donald Trump or his associates to obstruct the Justice Department's investigationTrump's lawyers met with DoJ officials on Monday about the case  Read more »

Supermodel vs nepo baby! Heidi Klum, 50, covers her modesty with a feather boa as she and daughter Leni, 19, grace competing covers of Super Magazine

Heidi Klum and her daughter Leni wowed as they graced competing covers of Super Magazine this week. The America’s Got Talent judge, who just celebrated her 50th birthday,  looked stunning ... Read more »

'If it wasn't for them, we wouldn't be here': Formerly conjoined twins, 19, reunite with the medical staff who separated them in life-saving surgery nearly two decades ago

Erin and Jade Buckles, from Virginia, were born connected from chest to navelThey underwent successful surgery at the Children's National Hospital in 2004The sisters have reunited with the doctors who gave them a new lease of life Read more »

Damar Hamlin should be the Madden 24 cover star, according to Robert Griffin III, amid reports his Buffalo Bills teammate Josh Allen will front the EA Sports game

Allen is said to be dating singer Hailee Steinfeld after splitting with ex, BrittanyHamlin resumed football-related activities when re-joining Bills practice in May provides all the latest international sports news Read more »

Woman, 34, who posted a selfie on Twitter and asked if 'any celebrities wanted to DATE HER' because she was 'bored, tipsy, and frustrated' during pandemic ends up MARRYING a stranger who replied

Jill Sennett, from Buffalo, shared the social media post during the pandemicThe 34-year-old was met with a lighthearted response from Casey SerranoThe couple have tied the knot on the 'third anniversary' of their fateful meeting  Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Transgender inmate's mom denies claims transition is a SCAM to get into women's prison as ex-wife slams $495K DoC lawsuit and opens up about being married to the 'extremely masculine' felon with enormous rap sheet

Minnesota's DOC agreed to settle Christina Lusk’s case after housing her in a male facility where she says other prisoners verbally and sexually abused herHer ex-wife, who she was married to for three years, told that the transition is 'a scam' for Lusk to get moneyBut her mother, Patricia Lombard, claims that isn't the case - as Lusk has gender identity struggles for the past 15 years   Read more »

Mother and daughter are accused of killing and dismembering 71-year-old grandmother with chainsaw before burning her remains on a grill: Cops noticed smell of decomposing body during welfare check

Candace Craig, 44, is accused of killing her mother Margaret Craig, 71, on May 23, following an altercationShe allegedly had her daughter Salia Hardy, 19, help to dispose of the remainsMargaret Craig, 71, was allegedly dismembered with a chainsaw and her remains burned on a grill at their home in Landover, Maryland Read more »

Young, wild and free: Wolverine spotted in California for only second time in last 100 years

Young, wild and free: Wolverine spotted in California for only second time in last 100 years A wolverine was spotted three times last month in the eastern Sierra Nevada, a ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Fully three quarters of voters say climate activists who vandalize artworks should face charges, poll shows as DC gallery duo face jail for Degas paint attack

Voters overwhelmingly want activist art vandals to face charges and even jail Comes after first major US artwork attack on a beloved statue in Washington  The activists, Declare Emergency, are planning more publicity stunts in summerRead our exclusive about European activists bringing chaos to the US in August    Read more »

Police release dramatic dashcam footage of high speed chase with 10-year-old who had stolen his mom's SUV to visit her in Detroit

The child, who has not been identified, can be seen opening the door before the end of the video. He then ran into the woods before eventually being caught The 10-year-old is facing counts of unlawfully driving, fourth-degree fleeing and eluding police, and assaulting, resisting, or obstructing police Read more »

Friends of Cameron Robbins and partygoers on booze cruise are slammed for shouting 'bye bye' at high school baseball star before he jumped in Caribbean Sea and vanished

Video shows Cameron Robbins, 18, in the water after he jumped from the party boat on May 24 during a graduation trip with his friends and fellow graduatesA male is heard shouting 'bye bye' to the teen, which has received swift backlash online as many slammed the partygoers for not helping RobbinsSocial media users have since taken aim at the remarks, posting videos asking how Robbins' so-called friends and fellow graduates could be so callous  Read more »

Teresa Giudice's daughter Milania and Melissa Gorga's girl Antonia look gorgeous as they head to prom... amid RHONJ feud

Antonia Gorga and Milania Giudice looked gorgeous as they headed off to prom over the weekend. The teens – who are cousins and the daughters of feuding Real Housewives of ... Read more »

Republican Chris Sununu is OUT for 2024: New Hampshire says he WON'T run for president, Trump has no chance of beating Biden and other GOP contenders are auditioning to be VP

The sitting governor said the stakes were 'too high' Said he can be more effective working against Trump as governorN.J. Gov. Chris Christie is expected to announce his run here Tuesday  Read more »

ESPN is 'preparing for raft of on-air layoffs with Suzy Kolber and Steve Young among those at risk' - as network prepares for arrival of $85m host Pat McAfee

ESPN - owned by Disney - previously slashed 7,000 jobs to save $5.5bn in costs ESPN gave Pat McAfee an eight-figure annual contract after hiring him in May provides all the latest international sports news  Read more »

Democrats defend 80-year-old Biden's age as 'wisdom' as president prepares to get back on stage this week after fall at Air Force Academy

Rep. Jamie Raskin calls Joe Biden a 'wise man'Robert F. Kennedy Jr said it's not about age but about mental fitnessDefense comes as Biden prepares to hit the road, going to North Carolina Friday  Read more »

La La Anthony showcases her incredible figure in neon yellow and white bodycon dress as she arrives to Today Show studios in NYC

La La Anthony looked incredible as she arrived to the Today Show studios in New York City on Monday morning. The star, 40, showcased her incredible hourglass figure in a ... Read more »

Kyrie Irving 'has contacted LeBron James in a bid to lure him to Dallas this offseason' - as Lakers star, 38, continues to weigh up his future

In Cleveland six years ago, Irving demanded a trade to escape James's shadow Dallas missed the playoffs while LeBron led the Lakers to a conference final provides all the latest international sports news  Read more »

Pregnant RHOBH star Diana Jenkins puts her massive LA home on the market for $20.5M... as she awaits birth of her second child with fiance Asher Monroe

Diana Jenkins of Real Housewives of Beverly Hills fame has put her Los Angeles home on the market for $20.5 million, ahead of the birth of her fourth child. The ... Read more »

Super Bowl champions Kansas City Chiefs arrive at the White House to visit President Biden as Patrick Mahomes and Co. don smart suits to celebrate their victory over the Eagles

Kansas City Chiefs visited President Biden Monday to celebrate Super Bowl win It is tradition for the Super Bowl champions to go to the White House after glory provides all the latest international sports news  Read more »

Lionel Messi will make a decision on his future in just HOURS after Barcelona were unable to make his father a concrete offer in a meeting on Monday, with Al Hilal and Inter Miami also in for the Argentine legend

Lionel Messi's father Jorge met with Barcelona president Joan Laporta It's believed Barcelona were unable to make a proper offer for their former star Saudi side Al-Hilal and Inter Miami are both also interested in the 35-year-old  Read more »

Christian Pulisic, Gio Reyna, Weston McKennie and Co turn their attention to the USMNT as America's top stars arrive in LA to begin prep for Nations League semi-final against Mexico

The USMNT has a great chance to make a second straight Nations League final Mexico has only won a single game since the World Cup while drawing twice provides all the latest international sports news  Read more »

My Daily Horoscope: What does June 6 2023 hold for MY star sign? Oscar Cainer tells all...

Calls cost 80p per minute plus your phone company’s access charge. To report a phone line problem, call 0800 138 9789. Go to and join the 5 Star Service for personalised messages, audio, video, discounts on full readings, and more!  Read more »

401(K) balances have INCREASED this year with the average pot now $108,200 - here's what each generation has in their retirement fund

Experts said increased employer contributions pushed up 401(K) balancesFidelity Investments found the average 401(K) balance is now $108,200 READ MORE:  America’s great retirement divide: Meet the fat cat CEOs who are on track to earn more PER MONTH in retirement than their average worker makes in a year Read more »

Aaron Rodgers wows in Jets practice as he gets down to work after enjoying Broadway show and Taylor Swift concert in his first weeks in New York

Rodgers played in scrimmage, Monday, after tweaking his calf in practice in May The 39-year-old quarterback revealed himself to be a massive T-Swift fan once provides all the latest international sports news  Read more »

Robert Downey Jr. revived his career and became a bigger star than ever with Iron Man — but he almost played a radically different Marvel character

Despite his long list of roles in modern classics — potentially including Christopher Nolan’s upcoming Oppenheimer — Robert Downey Jr. is best known for a single role: Iron Man. The 58-year-old ... Read more »

3 children remain hospitalized following shooting in Texas suburb: Police

3 children remain hospitalized following shooting in Texas suburb: Police The “horrific” shooting left one adult dead and four others injured on Sunday. ByPeter Charalambous June 5, 2023, 3:34 PM ... Read more »

Teens, aged 16, 17 and 18, accused of brutal killing of beloved swan mom Fay in New York town and then eating the bird were REFUGEES from Myanmar

Eman Hussan, 18,  and his two accomplices were charged with felony grand larceny and criminal mischiefThe three criminals are refugees from Myanmar and attend high school in near Syracuse, New YorkThe teens risk deportation if found guilty of killings Fay, the popular swan Read more »

It's 2016 all over again: Trump critics fear he will storm the Republican primary field if new candidates join and don't 'get out of the way' if they plummeting in the polls

Republican lawmakers, politicians and strategists are worried Trump could sweep the 2024 primaries if other candidates don't get out of the wayTexas Sen. John Cornyn expressed concern over 'a replay of 2016' There are already nine GOP candidate in the 2024 primary race – and Trump's top competitor is Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis Read more »

Twitter failed to pick up on 40 child porn images that had already been flagged as harmful over two-month period, Stanford research group claims

The Stanford Internet Observatory analyzed 100,000 tweets over two monthsThey claim to have found 40 images that all appear on PhotoDNA - a database that identifies harmful content  Read more »

REVEALED: How Binance founder Changpeng Zhao went from working in Canadian McDonald's flipping burgers to running a crypto empire with a net worth of $10.5billion

 Changpeng Zhao was born in Jiangsu, China, where he lived until the age of 12 in the late 1980s when his family moved to Vancouver, Canada READ MORE: The SEC sues Binance - the world's largest cryptocurrency exchange  Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự