India plan for tighter e-commerce rules faces internal government dissent

#E-commerce, #Economy, #Finance Ministry, #India

5) Spinny | Sector: E-commerce | Founded in: 2015 | Total Funding Received: $230 million

India’s plan to tighten rules on its fast-growing e-commerce market has run into internal government dissent, memos reviewed by Reuters show, with the Ministry of Finance describing some proposals as “excessive” and “without economic rationale”.

The memos offer a rare glimpse of high-stakes policy-making governing a market already featuring global retail heavyweights from Amazon to Walmart, plus domestic players like Reliance Industries and Tata Group. The sector is forecast by Grant Thornton to be worth $188 billion by 2025.

It’s not clear how the objections from the finance ministry – a dozen in total – will ultimately be reflected in the proposed rule changes, first floated in June. But watchers of the influential government arm say its complaints won’t fall on deaf ears in the upper echelons of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s administration.

“The ministry of finance raising such concerns would likely spur a rethink of the policy,” said Suhaan Mukerji, managing partner at India’s PLR Chambers, a law firm that specialises in public policy issues.

India in June shocked the e-commerce world with proposals from its consumer affairs ministry that sought to limit ‘flash sales’, rein in a push to promote private-label brands push and raise scrutiny of relationships between online marketplace operators and their vendors. There is not yet a formal implementation timeline for the new rules.

Though the rules were announced after complaints from brick-and-mortar retailers about alleged unfair practices of foreign companies, they also drew protest from Tata Group, with more than $100 billion in revenue, which is planning an e-commerce expansion.

But the finance ministry, the ministry of corporate affairs and the federal think-tank NITI Aayog – an active player in policy-making – have all raised objections in memos reviewed by Reuters, saying the proposals go far beyond their stated aim of protecting consumers and also lack regulatory clarity.

An Aug. 31 memo from the Finance Ministry’s Department of Economic Affairs said the rules appeared “excessive” and would hit a sector that could boost job creation as well as tax revenue.

“The proposed amendments are likely to have significant implications/restrictions on a sunrise sector and ’ease of doing business’,” said the three-page memo. “Care needs to be taken to ensure that the proposed measures remain ‘light-touch regulations’.”

The ministry did not respond to Reuters’ requests for comment.

‘UNPREDICTABILITY’ IN POLICY-MAKING

Voicing its own objections on July 6, NITI Aayog’s vice chairman, Rajiv Kumar, wrote to Piyush Goyal, who is minister for commerce as well as consumer affairs minister, saying the rules could hit small businesses.

“Moreover, they send the message of unpredictability and in-consistency in our policy-making,” Kumar wrote in the letter, a copy of which was reviewed by Reuters.

Minister Goyal and NITI Aayog’s Kumar did not respond to Reuters requests for comment.

The consumer affairs ministry, which drafted the rules, also did not respond. Its secretary, Leena Nandan, this month told Indian media that ”wide and varied diverse views” had been expressed on the proposed new rules by stakeholders, but that there was no timeline for any announcement on their implementation.

The arguments put forth by the finance ministry and NITI Aayog are in line with concerns raised by sector operators, and even the U.S. government. They say New Delhi has in recent years changed e-commerce policies too often and taken a hard-line regulatory approach that especially hurts American players.

But Indian consumer affairs minister Goyal and brick-and-mortar retailers disagree, and have repeatedly said big U.S. firms have bypassed Indian laws and their practices hurt small retailers.

The consumer affairs ministry said the new rules were aimed to “further strengthen the regulatory framework” and were issued after complaints of “widespread cheating and unfair trade practices being observed in the e-commerce ecosystem.”

FLASH SALES, REGULATORY OVERLAP

But the proposals have met with resistance in more than one ministry.

In a July 22 memo, the corporate affairs ministry objected to one proposed clause to be enshrined in new rules that says e-commerce firms should not abuse their dominant position in India. The ministry said the provision was “unnecessary and superfluous”, and that the subject was best handled by India’s antitrust watchdog.

“It is undesirable to introduce a mini-competition law regime in the consumer” rules, said the memo. The corporate affairs ministry did not respond to Reuters requests for comment.

The finance ministry has taken a much harder stance on the proposals and raised a total of 12 objections.

Among them, it said, a proposal that makes online shopping websites liable for its sellers’ mistakes would be a “huge dampener” and could force companies ”to revisit their basic business models”.

It also lodged a protest against the banning of flash sales, which see deep discounts on offer on websites like Amazon and are popular during festive seasons.

“This is a normal trade practice. The proposed restriction … seems without economic rationale,” the ministry wrote.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Power consumption up 3% at 57.22 billion units in October 1-15

(Representative image) India’s power consumption grew 3.35 percent in the first half of October to 57.22 billion units (BU), showing recovery amid coal shortage at electricity generation plants, according to ... Read more »

Uttarakhand news: Stay on high alert for heavy rainfall, CM Pushkar Singh Dhami directs police, SDRF

Uttarakhand is likely to witness heavy rainfall in the coming days. [Representative image] Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami, on October 17, inquired about the situation in the state due ... Read more »

Talks between Pakistan, IMF for release of $1 billion loan tranche remains inconclusive: Report

Representational Image The fresh rounds of talks between Pakistan and the International Monetary Fund for the release of USD 1 billion loan tranche and a good economic certificate to the nation have remained inconclusive, ... Read more »

Netflix estimates Squid Game will be worth almost $1.2 billion to company

Squid Game stands out both for its popularity, and its relatively low cost. LOS ANGELES (BLOOMBERG) – Netflix estimates that its latest megahit, “Squid Game,” will create almost US$900 million ... Read more »

‘Residential revolt' in Rotterdam: ‘They do not take us into account'

Opponents of the current housing policy are gathering in Rotterdam today to protest. They call it a ‘residential stand’. As with the housing protest in Amsterdam last month, people from ... Read more »

Rainfall increases woes of cyclone-ravaged farmers in West Bengal

Women farmers work in a paddy field. (Representative image: Reuters) For months after the saline water from the rivers had gushed into fields in coastal districts of West Bengal due ... Read more »

Long COVID may not be as fatal as acute COVID-19 but can worsen existing ailments, say experts

Representative image Long-Covid may not be as fatal and hard-hitting as acute COVID-19 and mostly improve over time but it can worsen existing ailments such as diabetes and kidney diseases, ... Read more »

Sri Lanka seeks $500 mn loan from India for fuel purchase

Sri Lanka has sought a USD 500 million credit line from India to pay for its crude oil purchases amid a severe foreign exchange crisis in the island nation. The ... Read more »

Air India privatisation saga: 'Time we stopped paying Rs 20 crore/day of taxpayers money to keep it flying'

Air India | Representative image Two aborted missions, three different ministers, multiple rule changes, and two decades later, Indian taxpayers will no longer have to pay Rs 20 crore per day to ... Read more »

Kerala landslide toll rises to eight as search for those missing on

Rescue workers search for the bodies of missing persons after a landslide, triggered by heavy rains and floods, at Nenmara in Palakkad, Kerala. (Image: PTI) The death toll from heavy rains and ... Read more »

Sri Lanka seeks $500 million loan from India for fuel purchase

Representative image Sri Lanka has sought a USD 500 million credit line from India to pay for its crude oil purchases amid a severe foreign exchange crisis in the island nation. The move came ... Read more »

Power Global to invest $25 million to set up battery infrastructure facility in India over next 2-3 years

Representative image US-based clean energy and mobility products start-up Power Global plans to invest around USD 25 million (around Rs 185 crore) to set up a lithium-ion battery manufacturing unit ... Read more »

Take COVID-19 vaccine & get a chance to win a TV set, mobile phone

Representative image. People in Manipur’s Imphal West district will get a chance to win a television set, mobile phone, or blankets if they take the COVID-19 vaccine in the mega vaccination camp ... Read more »

Is this China's ‘Great Resignation'? Freelancers find both hope and uncertainty in bid to escape 9-to-5 grind

With China’s working environment becoming increasingly stressful and competitive, Zheng Lizhu’s career ambitions as a designer shifted dramatically earlier this year. “The competition and anxiety in the design industry made ... Read more »

Over 4 crore unorganised workers registered on e-Shram portal

The Ministry of Labour and Employment on Sunday said the number registrations has crossed 4-crore mark on e-Shram portal in less than two months of its launch. According to a ... Read more »

India's coal import drops in August despite higher fuel demand from power sector

Coal India’s coal import registered a decline of 2.7 percent to 15.22 million tonnes (MT) in August this year amid the country’s power plants grappling with fuel shortages. The country ... Read more »

Govt to decide tax cut on petrol after reviewing the state's economy: Karnataka CM Basavaraj Bommai

Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai (File image) Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai on Sunday said that the government will decide on reducing the petrol price by effecting a tax cut, after reviewing ... Read more »

Gold ETFs attract Rs 446 crore in September; inflow may continue in coming months on festive season demand

Gold exchange-traded funds (ETFs) attracted Rs 446 crore in September and inflow may continue in coming months due to strong demand on the back of festival season in the country. ... Read more »

FPIs turn net sellers in capital markets in October so far, pull out net Rs 1,472 crore

Kerala had set up India’s first lottery department in 1967. Foreign portfolio investors (FPI) have turned net sellers in the capital markets in October so far, reversing the trend of ... Read more »

Coronavirus Update | India logs 14,146 fresh COVID-19 cases, 144 new deaths

Since the beginning of the country’s vaccination drive, 69.26 crore people have received at least one dose of Covid-19 vaccine, and 27.88 crore are fully vaccinated. (Representative image) India recorded ... Read more »

With current reset in global supply chain, opportunities galore in India for investors and industry stakeholders: Nirmala Sitharaman

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitaraman. Opportunities are galore in India for all investors and industry stakeholders with the current reset in the global supply chain and clear headed and committed leadership ... Read more »

Indian economy is bouncing back strongly: MoS for External Affairs V Muraleedharan

Representational image. Muraleedharan said the Narendra Modi government has undertaken “far-reaching” structural reforms, making use of the mantra of ‘Reform, Perform and Transform’. “These reforms range from digital transactions to ... Read more »

Procurement of expensive aircraft parts to be done after approval of senior official: Air India

Air India | Representative image New aircraft parts worth more than Rs 10 lakhs and non-aircraft parts worth more than Rs 5 lakh will now be procured only after the ... Read more »

Moneycontrol Area Watch | Jewar Airport brings tailwinds to projects along Yamuna Expressway

Buddh International Circuit (above) brought the Yamuna Expressway in the limelight, and now the proposed Jewar Airport is giving the area a leg-up. Buddh International Circuit – India’s first and ... Read more »

Effects of China's regulatory onslaught felt in Hong Kong as large IPOs fall by the wayside

Hong Kong’s primary-listing market is going through a dry patch in what is normally the busiest time of the year. Several potential billion-dollar initial public offerings ranging from supermarket owner ... Read more »

Petrol, diesel prices hiked by 35 paise; petrol at Rs 105 in Delhi, Rs 111 in Mumbai

Fuel prices in India rose by 35 paise, on Sunday, taking prices in Delhi to Rs 105.84 per litre and Rs 94.57 per litre for petrol and diesel, respectively. Prices ... Read more »

Expect 8-12% market returns in next one year: Ajay Kejriwal of Choice Broking

Ajay Kejriwal, President at Choice Broking feels that Infosys (the growth leader in the sector) and TCS (a sector leader) will continue to attract investors’ interest, mainly on the back ... Read more »

Incessant rains lash Kerala; 'Red Alert' in 5 districts

Monsoon Heavy rains lashed Kerala, especially the south and central regions on Saturday, causing water-logging in several areas and leaving many rivers in spate, as the weathermen sounded ‘red alert’ ... Read more »

Cryptocurrency Prices Today on October 17: Polkadot plunges over 3%

Cryptocurrency (Representative image) Cryptocurrency prices continue to be in mostly in red on October 17. The global cryptocurrency market cap is Rs 185.34 lakh crores, a 0.36 percent decrease over ... Read more »

I insisted that Uddhav Thackeray become CM of Maharashtra after MVA was formed: Sharad Pawar's snipe at Devendra Fadnavis

File image NCP president Sharad Pawar said he had insisted that Uddhav Thackeray become chief minister of Maharashtra after Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) was formed two years ago, hours after ... Read more »

World Bank president David Malpass congratulates India on successful COVID-19 vaccination campaign

World Bank President David Malpass (Image: Reuters) World Bank president David Malpass on Saturday congratulated India on a successful vaccination campaign against the Covid-19 pandemic as he met finance minister ... Read more »

IMD issues yellow alert for thunderstorms, lightning for parts of Madhya Pradesh

(AP Photo/Rajanish Kakade) The India Meteorological Department (IMD) issued a yellow alert for thunderstorms alongside lightning in four divisions and as many districts of Madhya Pradesh. The alert. which is ... Read more »

Why independent floors are staging a comeback this festive season

Builder floors are also gaining popularity because they combine the benefits of traditional apartments and villas. With one flat typically constructed on a single floor, occupying families have more space ... Read more »

Gati Shakti, digitisation, 'Make in India' discussed as Nirmala Sitharaman meets top CEOs in New York

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitaraman. The discussions that took place between Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman and the world’s leading business officers at the Big Apple in New York heavily emphasized on India’s ... Read more »

97.62 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses administered in India: Govt

Shots developed by Pfizer and Moderna were the first mRNA COVID-19 vaccines to be rolled out in the world. (Representative image) The cumulative number of COVID-19 vaccine doses administered in ... Read more »

Congress slams 'catastrophic mishandling' of economy; says every aspect of democracy 'diminished'

19 Opposition parties including Congress will jointly launch a protest against the Centre (File image: PTI) The Congress hit out at the Centre over what it said was ”catastrophic mishandling” of the economy and also alleged ... Read more »

Delhi's air quality slips to ‘very poor' category; stubble burning contributes 14% to polluted air

India’s capital New Delhi ranks first with 1,826.6 cameras per square mile. CM Arvind Kejriwal tweeted that “Feel proud to say that Delhi beats cities like Shanghai, NY n London ... Read more »

SIA sees moderate uptick in September passenger traffic on VTL tailwind

The group’s total passenger traffic rose by 4.4 per cent in September. SINGAPORE (THE BUSINESS TIMES) – The vaccinated travel lane (VTL) arrangement has helped lift demand for Singapore Airlines ... Read more »

"Democracy survived" Capitol riot because of police: Joe Biden

Joe Biden addressing UN General Assembly (Image: Twitter/@ANI) Framed by the Capitol, President Joe Biden paid tribute Saturday to fallen law enforcement officers and honored those who fought off the Jan. 6 ... Read more »

Lottery Sambad Result October 17: 'Dear Bangasree Ichamati' lottery winners to be announced at 4 pm

Results of the West Bengal State Lottery Sambad ‘Dear Bangasree Ichamati’ are announced every Sunday at 4 pm. Lottery Sambad Result: The West Bengal State Lottery Department to announce the results of its ... Read more »