Independent Directors | We need less confusion, more relaxation of norms

#Business, #company board, #independent directors, #markets, #opinion, #SEBI

On August 19, the Ministry of Corporate Affairs gave some relief to aspiring independent directors . Certain further categories of people have been exempted from passing an online proficiency test on their knowledge of board governance, accounting, etc. People who have worked at very senior level with government or regulators, or have long standing as professionals such as chartered accountants, lawyers, etc., are now not required to pass this test. But the way the scheme has been drafted leaves much to be desired.

Independent directors are rightly seen as pillars of good corporate governance, as they have no axe to grind. They have to pass through multiple hoops of disqualifications and come out unscathed. Now, a company board must typically consist of one-third to half of independent directors. Where do companies find them? The reality is that, too often, the promoters/management find people who may be favourably disposed to them.

Nevertheless, the law provided an option to find them from a databank maintained by the Indian Institute of Corporate Affairs. People desiring to become independent directors could submit their profile to this databank.

How does one ensure that such candidates are well equipped to be part of a board of directors which has to operate in a complex maze of company and securities laws? For this, those who wish to become independent directors must familiarise themselves on subjects such as corporate/securities laws, accounting, etc., and pass a relatively rigorous online proficiency test, scoring at least 50 percent in aggregate. Though well intended, the scheme has been poorly framed, and repeatedly amended leaving companies and directors in a quandary.

Initially, maintaining a databank of such candidates and selecting therefrom was kept as optional. But then, in a subordinate law, a requirement was made that each person seeking appointment as an independent director should mandatorily get their details in the databank. So an optional convenience became a mandatory irritant.

An aspiring independent director is required to pay a fee (Rs 5,000 to Rs 25,000) for inclusion of their name. While this charge might help in maintaining the databank, it hardly benefits independent directors because more often than not companies appoint independent directors based on references, or on their reputation.

Then comes the requirement to pass the online proficiency test in subjects that are relevant to functioning as part of the board. The topics are well framed and relevant. Directors come from diverse backgrounds and knowledge of board procedures and relevant laws can help them assimilate into a corporate board easily. That said, the problems are aplenty.

The rules say that a candidate should pass the test within two years from inclusion of their name in the databank. Thus, the connection is made not to when they become an independent director, but when they include their name in the databank. A person thus can become a director and function for two years without passing the test. This defeats the purpose of the test. The requirement ought to be that they pass the test before being appointed an independent director.

Curiously, only independent directors are required to pass this test, other directors can function on the board without this certification.

What happens if an independent director does not pass this test within two years? Should they step down from the board? Can the independent director continue, albeit by paying a penalty? Is it mandatory that the company remove an independent director who has not passed this test? There are no clear answers, and this lack of clarity confounds those who comply with the law and is used by those who want to escape compliance.

Several categories of persons are exempted from taking such tests, and rightly so. Those with an experience for at least three years as directors or key managerial personnel of listed companies and other large entities, those who have acted at senior levels in government departments, those who have worked at senior levels in regulators such as Sebi, RBI, etc., and, advocates and chartered accountants/company secretaries/cost accountants with 10 years of practice are exempted.

Another area of concern is that directors are not mandated to be up to date. Directors are not required to update themselves or take a refresher test from time to time. For example, Sebi regulations require investment advisers to obtain fresh certifications from time to time. Similarly, at a time when laws are constantly being amended, directors also must be required to keep their eye on the ball.

The remuneration for independent directors is capped at a low figure that hardly does justice to their seniority, for the time they are expected to spend, and on the multi-fold obligations placed on them. To add to the complexity, Sebi and the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) both have partially overlapping but effectively duplicate provisions relating to independent directors and related subjects.

The law on this subject needs to be rewritten from scratch. Currently, it appears that the rules surrounding independent directors are a product of isolated silos in bureaucracy, and is a nightmare to grasp it. Ideally, Sebi should be given exclusive jurisdiction on this subject, since it has the expertise, extensive experience, and it irons out creases of ambiguities and loopholes faster and more responsively than the MCA.

Jayant Thakur is a chartered accountant.

Views are personal and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Elon Musk joins VW executive conference as ‘surprise guest'

Elon Musk made a surprise appearance at a Volkswagen AG conference, addressing 200 executives of one of his biggest competitors about the German company’s pivot to electric vehicles, his management ... Read more »

Azerbaijan recovers from economic impacts of pandemic - President Aliyev

According to Azerbaijani President, the economy has grown by some five percent, the non-oil sector of industry has grown by 20% Read more »

‘There is a storm', great demand for everything that reduces gas bills

“We often get people who want us to insulate their house before Christmas, but that usually just doesn’t work.” In addition, it is difficult to attract more people due to ... Read more »

Sailing amusement palace is not what it used to be

The port of Rotterdam overtakes a new cruise ship as if there had never been a corona crisis. The fire boats spray meters high columns of water. Passing ships sound ... Read more »

FNV: ‘Discount on municipal tax for more people'

The social minimum is the minimum amount a person needs to live on. According to FNV, these people should also be able to make use of facilities such as special ... Read more »

End Clothing lines up former Gucci chief to fashion growth spurt

Patrizio di Marco is to become chairman of End Clothing, which was set up by two British university graduates and sold to Carlyle this year for £750m, Sky News learns. Read more »

Korean central bank: no crisis by Evergrande

Evergrande is the second largest property developer in China. That is why there are fears in the financial markets of a possible domino effect if the company were to fall. ... Read more »

AirLuxxis expects 30-40 departures a day going forward; moving to leasing model: CEO

Representative Image Private air charter services provider AirLuxxis might see 30-40 departures per day as it partly moves from the non-ownership of aircraft to leasing model amid the pandemic-triggered booming ... Read more »

VLCC Health Care raises Rs 37 crore from foreign entity

Representative image. VLCC Health Care Ltd, which is set to come out with an initial share sale, has raised nearly Rs 37 crore by selling shares to a foreign entity. ... Read more »

Imagine Meats to bolster product range, aims to expand presence in 25-30 cities by FY22-end

Picture Courtesy: Wikimedia Commons Imagine Meats, a food venture by Bollywood couple Genelia and Riteish Deshmukh, is working on expanding its range of plant-based meats suited for Indian taste buds ... Read more »

Independent financial adviser in favour of ESR-Reit, ARA Logos merger

SINGAPORE (THE BUSINESS TIMES) – The independent financial adviser to Hong Kong-listed ESR Cayman’s independent board committee and independent shareholders has recommended that shareholders vote in favour of the proposed ... Read more »

BCCI invites application for coaching staff of Indian men's cricket team and NCA

Ravi Shastri’s contract will run out after the T20 World Cup in the United Arab Emirates in November 2021. The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) on October ... Read more »

Top 10 most valued companies by market capitalization

10 | Kotak Mahindra Bank’s valuation rose by Rs 15,944.02 crore to Rs 3,99,810.31 crore. 9 | The market valuation of State Bank of India zoomed Rs 29,272.73 crore to ... Read more »

The courts have a new chance to block Texas's abortion law. They must take it

Photograph: Tom Brenner/Reuters Sadly, predictably and appallingly, on October 14, a three judge panel of the US court of appeals for the fifth circuit has allowed Texas’s “Bounty-Hunter” anti-abortion law ... Read more »

Income Tax Department raids on digital marketing, waste management biz groups across states

IT Department (Representative image: Shutterstock) The income tax department on October 17 informed that it initiated search and seizure operations in two groups based in several states on October 12. ... Read more »

Pollution increasing in Delhi due to stubble burning in neighbouring states: Arvind Kejriwal

The decision was taken at a meeting held to review the national capital’s drainage master plan. The meeting was chaired by Kejriwal, according to the Chief Minister’s Office (CMO). As ... Read more »

Leisure Hotels Group to add 6 properties by 2022-end

Limit yourself to two or three materials, to achieve a clean, minimalist look. (Photo Credit: Ksaraah – Taliesyn © Harshan Thomson) Hospitality firm Leisure Hotels Group is looking to add six properties ... Read more »

Delhi govt's push for pollution certificate for vehicles ahead of winter

Motor Vehicle Act Mandating the Pollution Under Control Certificate (PUCC) for vehicles because of rising pollution levels in winter, the Delhi Transport Department has requested motorists to show the document to its teams ... Read more »

Extraditan a EU a testaferro de Nicolás Maduro

© Excélsior Venezuela calificó de ilegal la extradición de Alex Saab, por no concluir el proceso judicial. Fotos: Especiales CIUDAD DE MÉXICO. El empresario colombiano Alex Saab, acusado de corrupción ... Read more »

Alan Navarro busca dar un mensaje positivo

© Excélsior Meet me on the Bleachers es su EP como solista que ya se escuentra en plataformas digitales. Foto: Cortesía Universal Music CIUDAD DE MÉXICO. El pesimismo se hace ... Read more »

Priyanka Gandhi will be face of Congress' election campaign in Uttar Pradesh: P L Punia

Priyanka Gandhi Vadra releases statement on her arrest in Sitapur, Uttar Pradesh. Priyanka Gandhi Vadra will be the face of the Congress’ election campaign in Uttar Pradesh, party’s newly-appointed campaign committee chief P L Punia said ... Read more »

Apple offers 20% bonus in India for adding money to Apple ID

As the tech giant is asking developers to promote payments using the Apple ID balance, Apple is now giving a 20 percent bonus to Indian users who add funds to ... Read more »

Atlanta lo grita; vencen a los Dodgers

CIUDAD DE MÉXICO. © Ozzie Albies realizó la jugada clave para los Bravos. Foto: Reuters Austin Riley conectó un hit al jardín izquierdo y los Bravos ganaron el juego ... Read more »

Centralcon's Sha Tin project sees sales pick up as smaller flats attract price-sensitive end users rather than investors

Sales picked up on day two of a residential project launch in Sha Tin as the developer allocated smaller flats that tend to appeal to genuine end users, who are ... Read more »

Bank of India cuts home, vehicle loan rates

Representative Image. State-run Bank of India on Sunday announced a cut in its interest rates on home and vehicle loans by 35 basis point and 50 basis points, respectively. With ... Read more »

Dixon Tech plans to export 5G millimetre phone to US, jack up production capacity

Dixon Technologies (India) | In the last 6 days, the stock has risen 23 percent to Rs 17342.55, as on February 8 from Rs 14129.90 as on January 29, 2021. Domestic electronics manufacturing firm Dixon ... Read more »

Digit Insurance eyes Rs 6,500 crore in premia sales by October 2022

Kerala had set up India’s first lottery department in 1967. Fairfax-promoted Digit Insurance is confident of taking its premia sales to over Rs 6,500 crore when it completes five years ... Read more »

Mcap of eight of top-10 most valued firms jump over Rs 1.52 lakh crore; HDFC Bank biggest gainer

Eight of the top-10 most valued companies together added Rs 1,52,355.03 crore in market valuation last week, with HDFC Bank and State Bank of India emerging as the biggest gainers. ... Read more »

All you need to know about front-running in crypto trading

Back in the day, when trading on the stock exchanges was a chaotic affair, with transactions taking place between pieces of paper and hoarse screams, a particular intra-day trading tactic, ... Read more »

Route Mobile shareholders approve raising Rs 2,000 crore via securities

Route Mobile | The stock gained 86 percent to Rs 651.10 as against the issue price of Rs 350 as on September 21, 2020. Enterprise communication service provider Route Mobile has received shareholders approval to raise ... Read more »

Jyotiraditya Scindia flags off SpiceJet's Delhi-Tirupati flight

Cargo operations have come to SpiceJet’s rescue, so to say, with Q1-FY22 seeing the cargo arm reporting a net profit of Rs 30 crore. (Representative Image) Civil Aviation Minister Jyotiraditya ... Read more »

Salman Khan launches Chingari's first ever crypto-token $GARI

File image (Image: Reuters) Making his way further into the NFT and cryptocurrency space, Bollywood megastar Salman Khan recently unveiled $GARI, the first-ever crypto-token launched by micro-content, short video application ... Read more »

Finance Ministry to seek Cabinet nod for setting up company to monetise land assets of privatisation-bound CPSEs

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitaraman. The finance ministry will soon move the Cabinet to seek approval for setting up a company for transfer and subsequent monetisation of land and non-core assets of privatisation-bound ... Read more »

Domestic sponge iron sector might report negative growth due to coal crisis: Industry body SIMA

Waste generated by a power plant. The river also faces a menace of fly ash. Photo by Rahul Singh The domestic sponge iron industry might report a negative growth in ... Read more »

Pakistan blacklists Chinese company for submitting fake documents in tendering process: Report

Representational Image Pakistan has blacklisted a Chinese firm and barred it from participating in any government tender for a month over the allegations of submitting forged documents during the bidding of a ... Read more »

China surprises US with hypersonic missile test

China tested a nuclear-capable hypersonic missile in August, showing a capability that caught U.S. intelligence by surprise, the Financial Times reported, citing five unnamed sources. The report late on Saturday ... Read more »

RBI's growth estimate ‘exaggerated' as it fails to reflect state of informal sector: Montek Singh Ahluwalia

Montek Singh Ahluwalia (REUTERS/B Mathur) Montek Singh Ahluwalia who was the Deputy Chairman of the erstwhile Planning Commission of India during 2004-2014 said that the economy is recovering but the ... Read more »

Subscriber additions to drive Reliance Jio's Q2 show; tariff hikes to aid Bharti Airtel, Vodafone Idea: Analysts

The cashback will be credited to the Jio account soon after the recharge is complete. (Image: Moneycontrol) The second quarter of the fiscal is likely to be a ”healthy quarter” ... Read more »

Delhi Metro launches free WiFi services at Yellow Line metro stations

Representative image Commuters of the Delhi Metro can now access the internet using free high-speed WiFi at all its Yellow Line stations, as the DMRC launched the facility on Sunday. ... Read more »

Max group firm MaxVIL plans to expand realty business; looks to add at least 2 projects in FY22

Real Estate Bullish on the Indian real estate market, Max group firm Max Ventures and Industries Ltd (MaxVIL) is looking to acquire at least two land parcels, outright or through joint ventures, in Delhi-NCR this fiscal ... Read more »