In Texas Senate hearing, education savings accounts raise questions about accountability and impact on public schools

In Texas Senate hearing, education savings accounts raise questions about accountability and impact on public schools

Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.

Texas senators on Wednesday held their first meeting to discuss education savings accounts — one of Gov. Greg Abbott’s top causes this legislative session — giving a glimpse at the support behind the program and the questions it faces about how it works, who it benefits and its broader impact on the public education system.

“We will see a strengthening of the parochial private schools and we will see a weakening of the public schools,” said Gary Bledsoe, president of the Texas NAACP, who testified against the bill proposing such accounts.

More than 380 supporters and opponents attended the Senate Committee on Education meeting and signed up to testify on Senate Bill 8, authored by state Sen. Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, which would create a program similar to vouchers that would let parents who opt out of the public education system use taxpayer money to pay for their children’s private schooling.

Senators will most likely vote in the next committee meeting whether the bill goes before the full Senate. The next meeting doesn’t yet have a date set.

[What you need to know about education savings accounts, the voucher-like program championed by Gov. Greg Abbott]

Through the program, also a priority for Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, the state would deposit up to $8,000 per student into these accounts to be used on private school tuition, tutors, uniforms and other approved educational expenses.

Religious organizations have been big advocates for education savings accounts and voucher-like programs in other parts of the country.

Bishop Michael Olson of the Catholic Diocese of Fort Worth said Creighton’s bill would empower parents to choose other educational options and said legislators should consider adding provisions that prioritize benefiting low-income families.

“Parental choice programs provide hope for the thousands of families who need better access to personalized educational options and are currently denied access to their tax dollars for exercising this natural right,” he said.

Supporters have framed education savings accounts as a tool to give parents more choices when deciding how and where to educate their children. But similar programs have faced staunch opposition from Democrats and rural Republicans, who worry using state money to pay for private schooling will result in less funding for public schools in areas with fewer education options.

“There’s no offense meant towards our public schools,” Creighton said. “We’re talking about our Texas parents, our moms and dads and their kids and the expectations for them.”

A University of Texas at Austin survey, released earlier this month, found that 46% of voters supported education savings accounts, while 41% opposed them. But it showed that the issue was not a high priority for voters as those surveyed felt that school safety, teacher compensation and curriculum are more important.

When introducing SB 8 to the committee, Creighton said that education savings accounts would not affect the state’s public education budget. He said funding for the program would come from the state’s general revenue fund rather than the Foundation School Program, which is the primary source of state funding for Texas school districts.

But public school leaders have expressed concerns that the savings account program would worsen the enrollment declines they’ve had in recent years — and in Texas, where school districts receive state dollars based on student attendance, that would mean less funding.

Senators intend to allocate about half a billion dollars to the savings account program, estimating that about 60,000 students will use it in the first two years.

SB 8 offers a kind of concession for school districts in rural areas: Any school district with fewer than 20,000 students that loses kids to the savings account program would continue to receive funding for those children for the first two years.

Sen. José Menéndez, D-San Antonio, questioned whether the program would actually provide more educational options for all parents, noting that $8,000 may not be enough to cover the extra costs that may come with private schooling.

“If they can’t pay for the whole tuition and they can’t pay for the books and can’t pay for the uniforms and can’t pay for transportation or the meal plan, how does this provide all parents freedom?” Menéndez asked Creighton.

Creighton responded that the average private school tuition in Texas is slightly less than $10,000 a school year and that plenty of schools charge well under that amount.

Sen. Morgan LaMantia, D-South Padre Island, said she hopes the state has a plan to prevent low-tuition private schools from jacking prices up to collect every cent parents will get from their education savings account.

On the other hand, Sen. Drew Springer, R-Muenster, was upset that Creighton’s bill would not allow parents with children currently enrolled in private schools to enroll in the program.

“I want to make sure that we do right by those parents,” he said.

The committee also discussed three other proposals to create an education savings account program that have been filed in the Senate. Those versions would allow any child to use the program, but only Creighton’s proposal was designated as a priority bill for this legislative session.

Creighton said his bill does not allow parents already in private schools to apply for an education savings account to prioritize state funding and make sure it benefits applicants from public schools that have received a grade of C, D or F in the state’s accountability rating system, which is largely based on students’ test scores.

“We have to start somewhere and there is a scarcity of dollars,” he said.

Another concern was how the state will prevent program participants from misusing the funds they receive from the state.

Creighton said the state comptroller would have jurisdiction over the accounts, and a third-party vendor would distribute the funds directly to private schools and education services providers that have been approved by the Texas Education Agency.

Creighton added that the comptroller will conduct account audits to prevent fraud.

Sen. Paul Bettencourt, R-Houston, who filed similar legislation to create education savings accounts, said his version of the program would allow a third party to audit accounts and notify the comptroller of any violations.

“We’re not playing around with the public’s money,” he said. “If you can’t keep it straight, don’t get into this program.”

How private schools use state funds they receive from parents is a different matter.

Whether the state should oversee how students are performing academically at private schools receiving taxpayer money has been a big question at the center of the debate over education savings accounts. In most cases, states that adopt voucher-like programs do not have any jurisdiction to monitor private schools like they do with their public counterparts.

Creighton made it clear that his bill would not require any state testing for private schools.

Proponents of the bill argue that parents will ultimately act as the highest level of accountability as they can choose to leave the schools.

“Private schools will set their criteria, and parents will make the decision on whether or not that criteria is fair,” Creighton said.

Chloe Sikes, deputy director of policy at the Intercultural Development Research Association, said she worries that private schools will receive taxpayer funds but won’t be held financially or educationally accountable.

“There are some random audits but no academic accountability about students’ outcomes, their performance and how they do later in life,” she said.

Creighton’s education savings account bill also includes a provision that would restrict how gender and sexual orientation is taught in public schools.

During the hearing Wednesday, Creighton introduced a new provision for SB 8 that significantly restricts classroom instruction and school activities about gender identity and sexual orientation in all public and charter schools. A previous version of the bill would have allowed such lessons or programming if presented in a manner that is developmentally or age-appropriate.

Menéndez questioned if the bill’s language would suppress a student’s free speech. Creighton said this is not imposing any ideas on students, rather making sure that these conversations on such topics take place at home.

“It’s not about the students expressing their opinions or certain thoughts,” he said. “It’s about teaching instruction.”

Disclosure: Curri and University of Texas at Austin have been financial supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in the Tribune’s journalism. Find a complete list of them here.

We can’t wait to welcome you Sept. 21-23 to the 2023 Texas Tribune Festival, our multiday celebration of big, bold ideas about politics, public policy and the day’s news — all taking place just steps away from the Texas Capitol. When tickets go on sale in May, Tribune members will save big. Donate to join or renew today.

News Related


Who wins the real North-South war? As a new study says Greggs and Pret A Manger represent the true social divide in Britain we dive into the pasties and sausage rolls to find which is tastiest - and best value for money

Forget politics, the weather or how you pronounce ‘scone’ . . . the true North-South divide, it seems, is found in what you eat for lunch. If you’re partial to ... Read more »

Dangerous dog that mauled grandmother to death as she lay on sun lounger in her garden has been put down

The dog, which is understood to be a banned breed, was 'euthanised yesterday' The lady - who was in her 70s - was declared dead at the scene in WarwickshireMan and a woman arrested on suspicion of possession of a banned breed of dog Read more »

Prince Harry stayed at Frogmore Cottage during short visit to UK — and didn’t see family

Prince Harry reportedly stayed at the Frogmore Cottage, where King Charles evicted him from earlier this year, during his latest trip to the UK. Shutterstock Prince Harry reportedly stayed at ... Read more »

4 children lost for weeks in Colombian jungle after plane crash found alive

Four children from an Indigenous community in Colombia were found alive in the country’s south on Friday more than five weeks after the plane they were travelling in crashed in ... Read more »

4 children lost for 40 days after a plane crash are found alive in Colombian jungle

In this photo released by Colombia’s Armed Forces Press Office, a soldier stands in front of the wreckage of a Cessna C206, May 18, 2023, that crashed in the jungle ... Read more »

‘Interact with culture’: 2nd annual Indigenous artisan market kicks off in New Westminster

Shop First Nations and the Arts Council of New Westminster are kicking off their second collaborative New West Craft Indigenous Market on Saturday, with more vendors, food trucks and performers ... Read more »

BBC broadcaster Amol Rajan apologizes for using slur — about seaweed — on air

Conservationist Chris Packham said using the term seaweed puts the marine algae at an “immediate disadvantage.” Getty Images/iStockphoto He needs some kelp. A BBC anchor profusely apologized after an environmentalist ... Read more »

4 kids lost in the jungle for 40 days after a plane crash found alive in Colombia

Colombian President Gustavo Petro said Friday that authorities found alive four children who survived a small plane crash 40 days ago. AP Colombian President Gustavo Petro said Friday that authorities ... Read more »

Couple helps save fellow passenger during Southwest flight

Couple helps save fellow passenger during Southwest flight Emily Raines and Daniel Shifflett said a passenger had stopped breathing. ByYi-Jin Yu June 9, 2023, 12:43 PM For one Maryland couple, ... Read more »

Trill Burgers: I tried out Bun B’s restaurant

“A creation so perfect in its simplicity, I was at a loss for how it could be improved upon.” Read more »

PHOTOS: Texas looks sleek, spacious on this modern estate with water views

Home is on the market for $2.9M Read more »

Netflix subscriptions jump, password crackdown pays off

Netflix said over 100M accessing the service using borrowed passwords Read more »

4 Indigenous children lost in jungle for 40 days after plane crash are found alive in Colombia

4 Indigenous children lost in jungle for 40 days after plane crash are found alive in Colombia Colombian authorities have found alive four Indigenous children who survived a small plane ... Read more »

Colombian president says 4 children lost in the jungle were found alive after surviving a plane crash 40 days ago

Colombian president says 4 children lost in the jungle were found alive after surviving a plane crash 40 days ago Colombian president says 4 children lost in the jungle were ... Read more »

Trump-appointed judge assigned to documents case

Aileen Cannon, the Florida judge initially assigned to oversee Donald Trump's classified documents case, made headlines when she decided in favour of the former US president at a pivotal stage ... Read more »

Ahsoka: Heir To The Empire Is A Pivotal Star Wars Story (Despite Not Being Canon)

Streaming Disney + Lucasfilm/Disney+ Joining the vastly-expanding Disney+ “Star Wars” library next is “Ahsoka,” with Rosario Dawson once again playing the popular Togruta Force-user. While it’s great to see the ... Read more »

How Wes Anderson Fought Asteroid City's R-Rating And Won

Movies Comedy Focus Features/YouTube Despite a moment of full nudity, Wes Anderson’s latest film, “Asteroid City,” will hit theaters with a PG-13 rating from the Motion Picture Association. The film, ... Read more »

The Hunger Games: Jennifer Lawrence Is Open To Picking Up Katniss Everdeen's Bow Again

News Movie News Lionsgate While her Oscar-nominated turn in “Winter’s Bone” was what first put Jennifer Lawrence on the map, it was undoubtedly her role as Katniss Everdeen in the ... Read more »

Kathleen Folbigg: Daughters may have died due to 'incredibly rare' genetic mutation as imprisoned mum pardoned

Kathleen Folbigg was convicted of the murder of daughters Sarah and Laura and son Patrick, and the manslaughter of another son, Caleb. Twenty years on, a professor has named the "rare" condition that her daughters had. Read more »

Asia Markets to Fall as Wall Street's Rally Takes a Breather; Australia Central Bank Decision Ahead

This is CNBC’s live blog covering Asia-Pacific markets. Asia-Pacific markets fell, tracking similar moves on Wall Street after the S&P 500 erased earlier gains that brought the benchmark index to ... Read more »

How Across The Spider-Verse Changed Marvel's Spider-Punk Forever

Movies Animation Sony Pictures/YouTube Five years ago, “Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse” blew the minds of viewers everywhere with its boldly shocking plot twists and the cool new characters that it ... Read more »

Who Voices Clark Kent In My Adventures With Superman?

Television Cartoons Adult Swim/YouTube A new trailer has just been released for the upcoming Adult Swim animated series, “My Adventures with Superman.” The series, which will premiere on July 6, ... Read more »

You Probably Haven't Heard About Miyazaki's Final Studio Ghibli Film - Here's Why

Movies Animation Studio Ghibli Few names in animation are as widely respected as Hayao Miyazaki. The prolific writer, director, and animator has been behind some of the most iconic and ... Read more »

US House panel investigates ties between US Interior secretary, environmentalists

US House panel investigates ties between US Interior secretary, environmentalists Members of the U.S. House Committee on Natural Resources have launched an investigation into ties between Interior Secretary Deb Haaland ... Read more »

After 6 women found dead, Portland officials warn against serial killer speculation

After 6 women found dead, Portland officials warn against serial killer speculation Six women under the age of 40 have been found dead over the last three months. ByPeter Charalambous ... Read more »

Approval for Idaho phosphate mine reversed after judge rules US didn't assess prairie bird impact

Approval for Idaho phosphate mine reversed after judge rules US didn't assess prairie bird impact A federal judge has yanked the U.S. government's approval for a phosphate mining project in ... Read more »

Oregon is invested in Fox Corp. and is investigating its board over bogus election fraud claims

Oregon is invested in Fox Corp. and is investigating its board over bogus election fraud claims Oregon’s attorney general has announced she has begun investigating the board of directors of ... Read more »

Who Plays Antoinette In The Rookie: Feds?

Television TV Dramas ABC/Raymond Liu Led by Emmy nominee Niecy Nash as Simone Clark, “The Rookie: Feds” features an impressive cast of proven players like Britt Robertson from “Tomorrowland” and ... Read more »

Michael Block comes up short in U.S. Open qualifying bid

Michael Block comes up short in U.S. Open qualifying bid news services June 5, 2023, 8:09 PM Michael Block, the teaching pro who finished tied for 15th at last ... Read more »

Canadian province of Quebec looks for international support to fight wildfires

Canadian province of Quebec looks for international support to fight wildfires Quebec is looking internationally for support as it struggles to battle more than 160 forest fires and federal officials ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự