In corporations' race to go carbon neutral, forest credits explode in popularity

Asia's Tech News Daily

This article was produced in partnership with the Pulitzer Center’s Rainforest Investigations Network.

In the forests of Guatemala, China and Scotland, oil giant Royal Dutch Shell is planting tens of thousands of trees that suck greenhouse gas out of the air, allowing customers who buy its fuel to claim their driving is carbon-neutral — at least on paper.

In Brazil, Amazon is paying to help small-scale farmers restore degraded lands in the tropical rainforest that shares the company’s name.

And in Asia, Delta Air Lines is spending $30 million to offset pollution from its jets, by protecting half a million acres in an Indonesian peat swamp forest and a Cambodian wildlife sanctuary.

Image: Brazil Amazon forest (Evaristo Sa / AFP via Getty Images file)

With each investment, the corporations rack up “credits” for the forests they save or restore, tokens representing a set amount of carbon dioxide ostensibly kept out of the atmosphere by storing it safely in the trees.

Demand for forest credits is set to explode in the coming years, as image-conscious corporations race to go “net zero.” That has climate finance consultants and environmental groups sounding the alarm about a system they say doesn’t deliver anywhere near the carbon reductions promised, but offers companies a convenient way to avoid the tougher work of actually cutting emissions.

“It is the next big thing in greenwashing — and we must not be fooled,” the group Greenpeace recently declared on its blog.

On its face, the exchange seems like a win-win: Huge sums of money are funneled into environmental projects, mostly in poor countries with less ability to do large-scale forest protection on their own. Companies courting climate-minded investors can say they’re zeroing out their carbon footprints, by offsetting whatever emissions they can’t eliminate from their own operations with CO2 reductions elsewhere on the planet.

Yet the system, part of what’s known as the “voluntary carbon market,” is awash with challenges, fuzzy math and tough-to-prove claims.

Much of the time, credits are banked for existing forests that are already trapping carbon dioxide, public data from carbon registries show, on the speculative assumption that they would otherwise be cut down. In some cases, forests that generated credits bought by Microsoft and other big players have burned down in wildfires, releasing their carbon dioxide stores into the air.

Exponential growth

In recent years, a long list of Fortune 500 companies has begun purchasing credits from forest projects, according to an NBC News review of SEC filings and corporations’ Environmental, Social, and Corporate Governance” disclosures.

The market for the credits is now estimated in the hundreds of millions of dollars, a number growing year upon year as a cottage industry for selling, trading and authenticating forest credits has taken shape.

The growth may soon be exponential. Mark Carney, the former Bank of England governor and U.N. climate finance envoy, has predicted the carbon offset market could soon reach $100 billion a year, although some of those credits may come from carbon capture and other measures rather than forests.

The market is also set to get a major boost from agreements reached in November at the COP26 U.N. climate summit in Glasgow, Scotland, where more than 100 world leaders promised to end and reverse deforestation by the end of this decade. At that same summit, leaders also reached a major agreement setting global rules for carbon markets, a move likely to bring even more major players into the game.

Yet a key concern is that big polluters, rather than actually cutting their emissions from energy and fossil fuels, will opt for the easier, often cheaper route of paying to zero them out, said Thiago Chagas, a legal consultant at Climate Focus, a nonprofit think tank that advises governments and businesses on climate policy, who has studied the quality of a U.N.-backed brand of credits known as REDD+.

“The greenwashing aspect is that companies simply offset a large majority of their emissions, and then come out and say they’re carbon neutral,” Thiago told NBC News. “That’s something that we should not be allowing at this point anymore. … They need to do their homework, they need to reduce their own emissions internally.”

Not all forest credits are built the same.

There are multiple, competing “certification” standards, and a dizzying array of organizations or companies that act as middlemen, authenticating supposed greenhouse gas reductions and connecting credit buyers and sellers. Measuring activity on the ground in far-flung rainforests can be incredibly difficult.

“There’s a whole verification process that involves a third-party auditor, but there are strange things about it,” said Dan Nepstad, an ecologist and president of the Earth Innovation Institute. “It’s the carbon project developer that hires the auditors. So the auditors are working for the company that would benefit really from a good result.”

That means that for companies to know the credits they’re buying are legitimate, it’s up to them to do their own due diligence, Nepstad said.

Delta’s projects in Indonesia’s Rimba Raya Biodiversity Reserve and Cambodia’s Keo Seima Wildlife Sanctuary funnel funds to local and indigenous communities to run forest conservation programs. The company says that in 2020 those projects yielded 13 million metric tons of CO2 reductions, helping the company meet its goal to become “the first carbon-neutral airline globally.”

“All of Delta’s offset projects are independently audited against leading, third-party standards,” the airline said. Delta says it’s also invested in wetland restoration as part of a $1 billion commitment to mitigating its emissions.

Still, there’s no single, universally recognized methodology for counting how much carbon any given project keeps out of the atmosphere.

If a company, for example, pays landowners not to cut down a forest they didn’t plan to cut down anyway, there’s no real savings for the planet — a problem known as “additionality.” Projects are supposed to be measured against a “baseline” of what would most likely have occurred if the payments never occurred. But those baselines are often inflated, experts said.

Britaldo Soares-Filho, a professor of cartography and geosciences at Brazil’s Federal University of Minas Gerais, said that makes forest “preservation” projects far more risky than, say, planting new trees where there previously were none.

“Restoration projects are something that you really can measure. You start from zero, and then you can measure, over time, the amount of carbon fixed in the trees and the soil. It’s closer to reality,” Soares-Filho said. “The thing is, when you say, ‘I’m protecting this area that might be deforested in the future,’ now you are speculating.”

There’s also the “leakage” issue — when a company pays landowners not to cut down Forest A, but they cut down Forest B instead. And the “permanence” problem — when a carbon-trapping forest is kept intact one year thanks to purchased credits, but is cut down the year after.

One model, a start-up credit marketplace called NCX, offers individual landowners a chance to generate and get paid for credits for postponing tree harvesting on their property for one year at a time, rather than the traditional standard of 100 years. If the landowners cut all the trees down the next year, they’ve already gotten paid.

But Zack Parisa, the company’s CEO and founder, argued that since carbon dioxide remains in the atmosphere for a long time, trapping more and more heat, even delaying release of carbon into the air for a year has value. He said that’s especially true since scientists say this is the pivotal decade for humanity to avert the worst effects of global warming.

“When that’s the case, landowners don’t have to engage in these multi-generational contracts that are subject to natural disturbances, fires, hurricanes,” Parisa said. “You can bring a lot more participation to the table, a lot more scale immediately, right now, in this critical decade.”

In the meantime, the forest credit market is creating a pathway for a massive infusion of corporate cash into ecological projects that might otherwise go unfunded: Dense forest restoration in India, agroforestry in Peru, and forestland preservation in Pennsylvania’s Hawk Mountain wild bird sanctuary.

Nepstad, of the Earth Innovation Institute, said the forest credits market is at a crossroads as it transitions to a larger scale in which states and provinces are taking a larger role.

“The bottom line is that these are programs that are starved of finance,” Nepstad said. “The world has been so focused on making sure that funds are not flowing if there’s not just incredibly risk-free emissions reductions behind them, instead of saying, let’s just get the money flowing, and make sure there’s some pretty rigorous credibility measures in place.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Starwatch: full moon to pass through three constellations

chart This week, the full moon will cruise through three zodiacal constellations. First Gemini, the twins; then Cancer, the crab; and finally Leo, the lion. The chart shows the view ... Read more »

Dak Prescott on Cowboys fans throwing debris as refs raced to tunnel: 'Credit to them'

Dallas Cowboys fans were seething on Sunday. Apparently, so was Dak Prescott. After a chaotic playoff game ended in disappointment for Cowboys fans, some of them rained down debris on ... Read more »

Djokovic banned from Australia for three years, federal government confirms

Novak Djokovic will be banned from Australia for three years after the world number one's visa cancellation was upheld, the federal government has confirmed. The 20-time Grand Slam winner failed ... Read more »

Jalen Reagor's brutal day a painful reminder to Eagles fans he's not Justin Jefferson

Jalen Reagor wasn't the reason the Philadelphia Eagles lost to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Sunday. But he didn't help. In a game where pretty much everything that could go ... Read more »

Jordan Cashmyer, '16 and Pregnant' Alum, Dies at 26

Jordan Cashmyer, a woman who was featured on MTV’s “16 and Pregnant” in 2014, died in Maryland on Sunday. She was 26 years old. News of Cashmyer’s death was shared ... Read more »

Self-isolation law set to be scrapped in favour of move towards ‘learning to live with Covid'

People would no longer be legally bound to self-isolate after catching coronavirus – Rasid Necati Aslim/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images People will no longer be legally bound to self-isolate when ... Read more »

A 61-year-old man was arrested and charged with murder after turning himself in to police for pushing an Asian woman in front of an oncoming subway train, authorities said

Times Square 42 St subway underground station in NYC with an old vintage inscription mosaic sign on the wall from tiles with symbols in terra cotta.Nicolas Economou/NurPhoto via Getty Images ... Read more »

Trump claims he couldn't have lost the 2020 presidential election because his Arizona rally boasted thousands of attendees and 'had cars that stretch out for 25 miles'

Former President Donald Trump reacts to the crowd prior to speaking at a “Save America” rally in Florence, Ariz., on January 15, 2022.AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin Former President Trump on ... Read more »

'Keep doors and windows locked', locals told after deadly attack on elderly couple

Freda Walker, 86, is killed and her husband, Kenneth, 88, left with ‘horrific injuries‘ in shocking incident at their Derbyshire home Residents in a Derbyshire town have been told to ... Read more »

A 74-year-old woman was exonerated of the rape and murder of her niece after spending 27 years in prison

A cell in the new HMP Bronzefield (women’s prison) in Ashford Middlesex, England.Tim Ockenden – PA Images/PA Images via Getty Images Joyce Watkins was exonerated after a wrongful conviction led ... Read more »

Giant crocodile found under floorboards of primary school classroom goes on display

The remains of a saltwater crocodile found underneath a classroom at a Welsh Primary School have gone on display after being restored. (Rhondda Cynon Taf Council) A 120-year-old crocodile found ... Read more »

Carol Vorderman looks incredible in curve-hugging activewear on Portuguese health retreat

Carol Vorderman set pulses racing on Sunday as she posed in activewear ahead of a long day of hiking on her luxe Portuguese health retreat. SEE: Carol Vorderman's grand home ... Read more »

Dozens of people flee in panic after hearing a "gunshot" in a UK McDonald's

Shocking footage shows dozens of people fleeing in panic after hearing a “gunshot” in a packed McDonald’s in Manchester. Video shows a huge 30-people brawl break out at the restaurant ... Read more »

‘Such a mess': Andy Murray and tennis world react to Djokovic's deportation

Photograph: Loren Elliott/Reuters Most players have avoided addressing case on social media Murray: ‘I respect Novak, I don’t like that he is in this situation’ The tennis world reacted with ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic deported: tennis star leaves Australia after losing visa case - latest updates

Djokovic says he is 'extremely disappointed' at decision World No 1 to leave Australia on flight at 11.30am GMT on Sunday ​Novak Djokovic has been deported from Australia after federal ... Read more »

British girl, 5, dies in horror ski slope accident in French Alps

The girl died in the ski resort of Flaine (pictured) (Pixabay ) A 5-year-old British girl has been killed in a tragic accident on a ski slope in the French ... Read more »

Amanda Holden enlists vacuum cleaner and thigh-high black boots for 'epic' garage singing session

Amanda Holden channelled her inner pop star to wind down at home this weekend. (Getty Images) Possibly as part of a commendable effort to lift people's January spirits, Amanda Holden ... Read more »

Covid tests for fully vaccinated travellers ‘to be scrapped this month'

Travel bosses will welcome the new changes (AFP via Getty Images) Vaccinated travellers will be able to go on holiday without taking <a href="/tag/covid-tests“>Covid tests on their return to the ... Read more »

Tony Blair Refuses To Call For Boris Johnson To Resign Over Partygate

Boris Johnson and Tony Blair at the Cenotaph in Whitehall, on November 14, 2021. (Photo: TOBY MELVILLE via Getty Images) Sir Tony Blair has refused to call for Boris Johnson ... Read more »

‘Stop lying to us': John Bishop calls Boris Johnson a ‘p***k' over No 10 parties

John Bishop has called Boris Johnson a “p***k” for breaking Covid-19 rules to attend a party at the height of lockdown. The prime minister is facing pressure to resign after ... Read more »

Ominous supercell storm captured over Texas in mesmerizing time-lapse

Mesmerising time-lapse footage has been captured of an ominous supercell storm cloud. Meteorology student Isaac Schluesche captured the images while storm chasing near the town of Earth, Texas. Isaac, of ... Read more »

Prince Andrew accused of ‘victim blaming' over sexual abuse case legal tactics

Prince Andrew has been accused of “victim blaming” by women’s rights groups and legal experts after demanding to see Virginia Roberts Giuffre’s mental health records and suggesting she has “false ... Read more »

'They killed a beautiful sportsman and his career': How the world reacted to Novak Djokovic's deportation

‘They killed a beautiful sportsman and his career’: How the world reacted to Novak Djokovic‘s deportation – EPA Novak Djokovic has lost his appeal against deportation in Australia after a ... Read more »

Kanye West attends daughter Chicago's birthday after claiming Kim Kardashian ‘wouldn't share' address

Kanye West attended his daughter Chicago’s fourth birthday party after claiming Kim Kardashian “wouldn’t share” the address. Chicago is the second youngest of four of the children West shares with ... Read more »

Australia has decided to 'let Covid rip.' Is that a good idea?

In just over a month,  the country’s Covid cases have sharply risen from around 1,000 a day to more than 100,000 a day — but its deaths remain low. Read more »

Tsunami from Tonga volcano eruption leaves trail of flood damage

Waves rush over island country while tidal surges are felt by small Pacific neighbours plus New Zealand, Australia, US and Japan Tsunami waves caused by an undersea volcano have flooded ... Read more »

Downing Street parties: Boris Johnson faces further calls to resign over partygate as reports claim 'mass clearout' of Number 10 team

A sixth Conservative MP is calling for the prime minister to quit over the ever-growing list of alleged lockdown-breaking parties in Downing Street, as Boris Johnson is reportedly preparing to strike back ... Read more »

Nets worry after Durant exits early due to left knee sprain

All-Star Kevin Durant has been forced out of Saturday's Brooklyn Nets game against the New Orleans Pelicans due to a left knee sprain. Durant is expected to undergo an MRI ... Read more »

Bengals end 32-year playoff drought, beat Raiders with dramatic defensive stand

The streak is over. The Cincinnati Bengals beat the Las Vegas Raiders 26-19 in Saturday's wild-card matchup, earning their first postseason victory since 1991 and ending an eight-game playoff losing ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic says Australia's immigration minister failed to ask him his views on vaccination

Photograph: Loren Elliott/Reuters Djokovic’s lawyers dispute that the Serbian tennis player is an anti-vaxxer as federal court hearing on his last-ditch bid to avoid deportation begins Get our free news ... Read more »

Sir Michael Caine Changes His Name To Michael Caine Because Of Isis

(Photo: Daniel Leal-Olivas/PA Wire) Article originally published 21/07/2016: due to a technical issue this article may have resurfaced for some readers, and the original publish date may not have been ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu and Rafael Nadal lead player backlash against Novak Djokovic

Emma Raducan Australian Open – AP The Australian Open can get along perfectly well without Novak Djokovic, said the 20-time major champion Rafael Nadal, on a day when the world’s ... Read more »

Prince Harry seeks judicial review after Home Office bans him from paying for police protection for Archie and Lilibet in UK

Prince Harry has filed a claim for a judicial review over a Home Office decision to not to allow him to privately pay for police protection for himself and his ... Read more »

Carrie Johnson pictured breaking Covid rules hugging friend at West End club

Carrie Johnson with her friend, Anna Pinder Carrie Johnson, the Prime Minister's wife, was photographed breaking Covid-19 social distancing rules days after the public was warned that it was “critical” ... Read more »

Vulnerable woman starved to death in NHS hospital following ‘unacceptable' failures

Jennifer Lewis died in July 2017 from the effects of malnutrition while she was an inpatient at the Bracton Hospital (Angela Lewis) “Unacceptable” failures by a mental health hospital to ... Read more »

Celine Dion inundated with prayers after agonizing health update

Celine Dion delivered upsetting news to fans on Saturday when she shared a health update. The star – who was forced to postpone her Las Vegas residency in October due ... Read more »

Tess Daly melts hearts with emotional tribute to Claudia Winkleman

Tess Daly paid a sweet tribute to her friend and co-worker Claudia Winkleman on Saturday in honour of her 50th birthday. MORE: Tess Daly and Claudia Winkleman's post-Strictly Come Dancing ... Read more »

Jeremy Corbyn Supporters Enjoy Clean Sweep In Election To Labour's Ruling Body

(Photo: Rob Stothard via Getty Images) The left-wing takeover of the Labour Party continued as allies of Jeremy Corbyn seized more control of its ruling body. Six Labour members backed ... Read more »

Amanda Holden sparks fan frenzy in thigh-high boots and sparkly bodysuit

Amanda Holden caused mass hysteria among her followers when she shared a jaw-dropping video of herself wearing very little on Saturday morning. MORE: Amanda Holden looks flawless in gorgeous must-see ... Read more »

Amanda Holden is the ultimate Charlie's Angel in slinky bodycon jumpsuit

Another day at the office means another seriously chic outfit for Amanda Holden! Putting a retro spin on her latest workwear look, the radio star headed to Global Studios in ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic