I'm a medical doctor but I oppose Covid vaccine mandates like the one that affected Kyrie Irving. This is why

Asia's Tech News Daily

Basketball player KyrieIrving made the news recently when he was not allowed to play in New York because of the state’s vaccine mandate.

I’m a medical doctor but I oppose Covid vaccine mandates like the one that affected Kyrie Irving. This is why
© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

Virus Outbreak Slovenia

– Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

Like most medical doctors, I am obviously pro-vaccine. I promote its use, its effectiveness and the benefits it has brought to humanity; for instance, the eradication of smallpox (not a small feat). I am not, however, in favor of vaccine mandates for the general public. I am also not in favor of the public shaming of people who chose not to get vaccinated: I don’t think it is effective and I also believe it is absolutely unethical to taunt and harass people who have different views about what goes into their body.

One of the maxims of medicine is “primun non nocere”, a phrase attributed to Hippocrates (the father of medicine). It means that any medical act must be accompanied by a prior reflection on whether the benefit of the treatment (in this case a vaccine) is greater than the damage it can cause. For all the skeptics out there, I am not about to say that vaccines do harm and should be carefully considered. Quite the opposite: the vaccines we have available today, including the Covid vaccines, are completely beneficial and the damage is insignificant. Nevertheless, in medicine, we are taught to have respect for the will and freedom of the patient. That means we must also respect the decisions that they make about their body, however unpopular they may be.

An example. I am a urologist, and recently treated a patient who was 75 years old, who needed to be hospitalized before and after surgery. There was a risk that he could acquire Covid during that time because he was not vaccinated. I explained the reasons why he should get vaccinated, but he continued to refuse. His daughters, who were in consultation with him, wanted to force him to do it. I had to explain that neither they, nor I, could require that he get vaccinated, nor submit him to any other medical treatment against his will. As his doctor, I am the guarantor of his healthcare decisions.

During the pandemic, I have not tired of repeating to my patients over and over again about how much better off they would be if they got the vaccine. I have also publicly written about itsbenefits (direct and tangential), and the drawbacks of not getting vaccinated. Having been on the front line in the fight against Covid, I have personally witnessed, and grieved, the consequences of not getting vaccinated. I watched people my age — doctors my age — die alone and on a ventilator before there was a vaccine available.

Yet we must be consistent. Forcing someone to be vaccinated or applying coercive measures to do so is equivalent to wanting to sterilize someone against their will, while arguing that they are unable to decide for themselves. All this boils down to the fundamental right to freely decide one’s own care, which is a fundamental human right.

My recommendation for anyone struggling with a loved one who won’t get the jab? Be empathetic, listen to their concerns, and base your arguments on science. However, if they persist in their refusal, it is their right to do so. And it is my job, as a doctor, to guarantee that right.

Dr Marcos Del Rosario-Santiago is a urologist in the Mexican Navy, and a writer on medical science and ethics

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Giants report card: This is getting ridiculous

Grading the Giants’ 20-9 loss to the Dolphins on at Hard Rock Stadium on Sunday. Offense This has gone from bad to worse to ridiculous. No touchdowns, 250 total yards. ... Read more »

Verstappen given 10-second penalty for causing Hamilton clash in Saudi Arabian GP

© Simon Galloway / Motorsport Images Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing RB16B, battles with Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes W12 Verstappen and Hamilton were involved in a number of incidents through Sunday’s ... Read more »

Lucid's Short-Term Victories Must Lead To Long-Term Success

© InsideEVs Production Lucid Air Highway and City Streets Drive (source: EV Nomads – Branden & Kalie) The startup has gotten over the major challenge of reaching production, but many ... Read more »

Bosses are so desperate for staff they are offering free flights to Australia - as dishwashers are offered $90 an hour

Hotel executives are willing to offer New Zealand hospitality workers free flightsEmirates One&Only Wolgan Valley scouting trained staff from NZ's North IslandThe five-star hotel said it is considering paying for its workers to cross the ditch Comes after top Sydney eatery said it was paying its dishwashers $90 an hour Australia's stream of working holiday visa holders was abruptly cut off by Covid Read more »

Howe-ay the lads! Newcastle may still have their doubters but - after their first win of the season - new boss Eddie has brought a feel-good factor back to St James' Park that has been missing for years

The team started the season dismally, picking up three points from eight games Steve Bruce subsequently left the club and has been succeeded by Eddie HoweHowe has seen his side take seven points from his first four games at the helm Newcastle got their first win of the season on Saturday, beating Burnley 1-0  Read more »

Video: Alex Pike reveals why her relationship with Nathan Buckley is completely different to her first marriage - as they prepare to celebrate their one-year anniversary

Read more »

Neal Maupay's late, late shows are extending Brighton's revelatory start and turning the 'wasteful' striker into a fan favourite after 98th minute leveller at Southampton

Brighton held Southampton at St Mary's in a 1-1 draw on Saturday afternoon Neal Maupay fired in the 98th minute to rescue the point for the visitors The forward is making a habit of coming up with crucial late goals He faces much criticism but Maupay is becoming an Amex favourite   Read more »

Wild moment enraged truckie smashes a car's window with a baseball bat during road rage fight

Truck driver armed with baseball bat bashes car window in shocking road rageTruck driver's lane was ending and needed to merge, according to onlookersFootage of the extraordinary confrontation in Sydney has gone viral onlineDo you know more? Email tips@dailymail.com Read more »

Collin Morikawa BLOWS chance to become World No 1 by giving up five-shot lead at the Hero World Challenge... as Viktor Hovland wins a thrilling final round at Albany

Collin Morikawa threw away a five-shot lead at the Hero World ChallengeMorikawa also blew the chance to overtake John Rahm as the world No 1 golferViktor Hovland emerged victorious from an extraordinary final round at Albany Read more »

CHRIS FOY: Referee Luke Pearce's 'zero-tolerance' approach to back-chat could be the benchmark, Irish are the great entertainers and Covid ordeals could have sizeable consequences

Respect in rugby is under threat but Luke Pearce's firm approach works wonders London Irish's swashbuckling style of play should see them get more supporters Covid-19 ordeals endured by Cardiff and Munster could have deep ramifications Read more »

Video: Arlene Phillips is the FIRST campmate to be eliminated from I'm a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here!

Read more »

Anthony Yarde roars back with brutal revenge demolition of Lyndon Arthur to set up a likely light-heavyweight world title bout against the winner of Callum Johnson and Joe Smith Jr

Anthony Yarde has dynamited himself into a world title light-heavyweight fightThe Brit avenged his meek loss to Lyndon Arthur with a brutal four-round victory The grudge rematch provoked ugly brawls between rival fans in the Copper Box Read more »

Britain in line to host one of the Davis Cup finals groups next year after being given a wildcard into the event along with Serbia... with Abu Dhabi also set to stage matches in 2022

Britain is set to host one of the four Davis Cup finals groups next calendar year  Leon Smith's Britain and Serbia have been given two free passes to the last 16The Lawn Tennis Association tried to push Glasgow as a host city for the eventThe closing stages of the event are expected to switch to the lucrative Abu Dhabi Read more »

The one lesson I've learned from life: Comedian Katy Brand says putting things off is a recipe for stress

Katy Brand, 42, who lives in London, is best known for her show on ITVComedian admits she was a terrible procrastinator when younger She has become more measured about how she works since getting older Read more »

Video: I'm A Celebrity 2021: Arlene Phillips, 78, is the FIRST campmate to be eliminated - after making history as show's oldest ever contestant 

Read more »

IAN LADYMAN: Carlton Cole deserves a second shot after his 'Holocaust' radio blunder... the former striker's regret was genuine but the language used in dressing rooms must change

Carlton Cole inexplicably used the word 'Holocaust' on live radio last weekendHe was covering Manchester City's match against West Ham for BBC 5 Live 'Football speak' is often crude and hasn't grown like other parts of the gameEveryone deserves a second chance and I have a feeling that Cole will take his Read more »

Ham, lechon prices up as Christmas nears

soh-2 Prices of Christmas staples ham and lechon have shot up, due to high demand amid the holiday season and the impact of the African swine fever on the sector. ... Read more »

Darren Gough takes huge pay cut to leave talkSPORT and become Yorkshire director of cricket

Former Yorkshire cricket captain Darren Gough looks set to enjoy a surprise return to the county as their new director of cricket, marking his first role at the club since ... Read more »

Toni Kroos: A Master of Ball Progression

© Photo by Gonzalo Arroyo Moreno/Getty Images “Real Madrid’s games always run on Kroos’ rhythm” – Casemiro. Toni Kroos, Real Madrid’s midfield general, has played and won a lot with ... Read more »

Ethan Crumbley's parents ‘were helped after Oxford High shooting by artist who let them hide in his studio'

THE parents of alleged Oxford high school shooter Ethan Crumbley were helped by a Detroit artist who reportedly let them hide in his studio's basement after they were charged with ... Read more »

Omicron means it's time to switch to N95 masks

Omicron means it’s time to switch to N95 masks The omicron variant is spreading fast. According to the World Health Organization, at least 38 countries, on six continents, have confirmed ... Read more »

Vicky Kaushal & Katrina Kaif's wedding: Jewel Gamadia & Yasmin Karachiwala invited: Report

© Provided by Pinkvilla Finally, Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif’s royal wedding is just upon us. The couple is also starting their legendary wedding shenanigans from tomorrow (7 December) at ... Read more »

Inside story of Marcel Brands exit and who controls transfers now after Everton power struggle

Marcel Brands has carried the can for not only his mistakes, but other people’s too. Let’s get that straight. The director of football had to accept some of the responsibility, ... Read more »

The costs of Biden's war on oil include higher gas prices

President Joe Biden speaks on the economy during an event at the South Court Auditorium at Eisenhower Executive Office Building on November 23, 2021 in Washington, DC. Alex Wong/Getty Images ... Read more »

Tom Holland and Zendaya joke about height difference

© Provided by Cover Media Tom Holland Tom Holland and Zendaya have joked about how their height difference altered a stunt on Spider-Man: No Way Home. The real-life couple made ... Read more »

RUTH SUNDERLAND: LV's alarm call for mutuals

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo Britain’s mutual building societies, insurance companies and co-operatives were once a potent force. A product of the Victorian era’s reforming zeal, they ... Read more »

Expats working in three countries may not be eligible for state pension from next year

Due to Brexit, workers who live in the EU, EEA, or Switzerland will have to recalculate the amount of “qualifying years” they have endured to see if they meet the ... Read more »

Liam Scales stakes his Celtic claim as debut goal has Irish rising star dreaming of regular place

Liam Scales admitted his phone was red hot after opening his Celtic account – but he’s hoping to get the call from Ange Postecoglou for Thursday. The former Shamrock Rovers ... Read more »

Keir Starmer says anti-vaxxers must 'think again' as NHS resources drained by unjabbed

Keir Starmer has urged anti-vaxxers and jab sceptics to “think again” as he prepares to get his booster vaccine. The Labour leader, who is due to have his third dose ... Read more »

Gambit top EMEA Pro League despite Alliance victory

© Provided by Dot Esports The final day of the first split’s regular season took place with concurrently running lobbies, so no teams would be handed an unfair advantage with ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb's Arlene Phillips becomes first campmate to be eliminated from ITV's 2021 series

I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! has seen its first contestant, Arlene Phillips, eliminated from Gwrych Castle. The 78 year old, whose daughters recently said they weren’t “embarrassed” ... Read more »

How to unlock the Tropical Soda Islands and what it does in Cookie Run Kingdom

© Provided by GamePur In Cookie Run Kingdom, there’s a very helpful mode called Tropical Soda Islands. This mode can earn you a steady stream of items. However, it isn’t ... Read more »

Patrick Vieira outlines Ralf Rangnick impact during Manchester United victory

Patrick Vieira has revealed that the appointment of Ralf Rangnick had a major impact on how Crystal Palace approached their Premier League game with Manchester United. Having finally been granted ... Read more »

Speaker voices ‘deep concern' at reports of drug-taking in Parliament

Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle is to raise reports of drug misuse in Parliament with the police “as a priority”. © House of Commons Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle has ... Read more »

Overwatch fan creates Workshop mode to visualize the range of every ability

© Provided by Dot Esports Every Overwatch player has uttered the words, “there’s no way I was in range of that.” One fan decided enough was enough, so they went ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta to show no mercy on under-fire Rafa Benitez and former club Everton

Mikel Arteta admits he can show no mercy towards under-fire Rafa Benitez – but insists he has the quality and experience to turn things around. Arteta had six years at ... Read more »

A restaurant dedicated to Brussels sprouts is opening next week in London

© Provided by Metro The controversial vegetable is getting a makeover by tastecard this Christmas. (Photo: tastecard) Christmas is a time of celebration and eating, but sometimes we don’t quite ... Read more »

Quebec introduces $52 million in new funding to tackle gun violence and crime

MONTREAL — Quebec announced $52 million in new funding geared towards the province’s youth on Sunday in a bid to stem a rising tide of gun violence and crime.  © ... Read more »

Victoria's Secret model Kelly Gale shows of phenomenal figure in orange bikini

KELLY Gale goes down a storm in a tropical bikini shoot. The Victoria’s Secret model and actress, 26, also put on a showstopping look for her boyfriend’s birthday last week. ... Read more »

Anne Frank memorial: Vandals defaced tunnels near Idaho site with anti-Semitic graffiti

As millions of Jewish people across the country celebrate Hanukkah, police say vandals painted anti-Semitic messages and symbols in tunnels near Idaho’s Anne Frank Human Rights Memorial on Friday. © ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic