Illinois Democrats' Gerrymandering Is a Partisan Disgrace

Days ago, Stacey Abrams spoke to a crowded ballroom at a Chicago Foundation for Women event. “When you break democracy for anyone, you break it for everyone,” she said.

© rruntsch/Getty Images Illinois State Capitol in Springfield

The irony was palpable. Abrams spoke of the Prairie State as a place where voting rights are upheld and elections are fairly handled. And policymakers here can claim some of the strongest voting-access laws in the country.

But in reality, representative government in Illinois is broken.

Though the state’s nearly 13 million residents can cast a ballot easily enough, manipulation of electoral maps by a Democratic Party obsessed with maintaining its stranglehold on power deprives them of meaningful choice on those ballots. When maps are rigged, it deters challengers and leaves more incumbents uncontested. That, in turn, discourages voters from turning out — and means that even when they do, the outcome is a foregone conclusion.

When campaigning for governor, J. B. Pritzker promised that if elected, he’d put an end to this state of affairs. He pledged to veto any plan drawn up by lawmakers and political-party leaders rather than an independent redistricting commission. Yet in June, he signed into law maps drawn by Democrats in the state legislature without any Republican participation. And three weeks ago, after those maps were challenged in court and it became apparent that they wouldn’t pass constitutional muster, the legislature approved revisions to them, which Pritzker is expected to sign off on soon.

The redistricting process has provoked criticism from an unusually broad array of advocacy groups. The objections of the state GOP were, of course, to be expected. But one of the lawsuits against the legislature was filed by the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund, which claims that the lawmaker-drawn maps would weaken the influence of Latino voters. And North Lawndale Alliance co-founder Valerie Leonard similarly complained to NPR that the legislature’s plan “dilutes Black voting power to the hilt.”

All of this controversy could have been avoided if the legislature had amended the state constitution to take redistricting out of the hands of lawmakers and put it in the hands of an independent redistricting commission, as 15 other states around the country have done. But instead, a state that touts strong ballot-access laws gave its voters fewer choices to make at the polls. The new legislative maps pit incumbents from the minority party against one another while raising the odds that incumbents in the majority will face little or no meaningful opposition when they seek to retain their seats.

According to the Illinois State Board of Elections, about half of all statehouse races were uncontested between 2012 and 2020, while the old maps remained in effect. That meant that nearly 5 million voting-age residents lived in districts which gave them no choice at the polls. And research from the Illinois Policy Institute shows voter participation to be seven percentage points lower on average when only one candidate is on the ballot. Because low voter participation tends to be most common in low-income areas, this means that the interests and policy preferences of low-income residents — those who depend on public services the most — are particularly ill-served by Illinois Democrats’ partisan gerrymandering. To take just one example, from fiscal year 2000 to fiscal year 2021, state spending on pensions for government workers skyrocketed by 533 percent, while spending on a range of core government services such as public-health and anti-poverty programs dropped by 14 percent.

In Illinois as everywhere else, the purpose of gerrymandering is to establish an unfair political advantage for one party by manipulating the boundaries of electoral districts. Through such manipulation, the democratic process is upended to allow politicians to pick their voters, rather than the other way around. This is a serious problem, because the efficacy of representative government rests on accountability: The people have to be able to fire their leaders when they see fit.

And in Illinois, so long as Democrats control the redistricting process, that kind of accountability won’t be in the cards.

More on National Review

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Emma Raducanu beats Ana Bogdan to reach Transylvania Open quarter-finals

The US Open champion, who is playing in the homeland of her father Ian for the first time, told local fans she was “proud to be Romanian” before the start ... Read more »

Jason Momoa tests positive for COVID-19 during filming of ‘Aquaman 2'

“Aquaman” star Jason Momoa has tested positive for COVD-19 while filming the latest installment of the franchise in the United Kingdom, according to a report. Momoa, 42, has been self-isolating ... Read more »

2022 Mercedes-AMG SL gets a major makeover to take on the Porsche 911

The seventh-generation SL has arrived to prove once and for all that the V8-powered roadster isn’t dead. Making this point required undergoing a significant transformation: the SL now comes from ... Read more »

Fishing rights row explained: France issue warning but what happens next?

After the UK and Jersey’s decision last month to reject dozens of licences for French boats to fish their waters, France has now issued an ultimatum. The country has warned ... Read more »

Mark Messier not a fan of Rangers' controversial captain decision

Mark Messier would like to see a captain. One, that is. Not six. Speaking on The Post’s “Up in the Blue Seats” podcast, the Rangers legend said that he believes ... Read more »

Blackmore on board as Gold Cup hero heads classy quintet at Down Royal

© Dan Sheridan INPHO Rachael Blackmore on Minella Indo at Cheltenham in 2019. GOLD CUP HERO Minella Indo will face King George winner Frodon and the improving Galvin in a ... Read more »

Nigel Pearson delivers Nathan Baker injury update ahead of club's clash with Barnsley

© Provided by Football League World Nathan Baker Bristol City are set to be without Nathan Baker for this weekend’s clash with Barnsley as the defender has yet to make ... Read more »

Stolen car was dragging owner as it crashed into another stolen car, Nashville cops say

An odd chain reaction of crime erupted this week in Nashville when the owner of a stolen vehicle was dragged across a parking lot and then assaulted after the accused ... Read more »

Sanofi exec: new COVID-19 shot will cost less than 10 euros

FILE PHOTO: A researcher works in an industrial development laboratory at the vaccine unit of French drugmaker Sanofi‘s Pasteur plant in Marcy-l’Etoile, near Lyon, France (Reuters) – The COVID-19 vaccine ... Read more »

Politics Is Becoming Toxic: How Not To 'Unfriend' Family And Friends

Copywriter Camille (not her real name) splashed her Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram with shades of pink to drum up support for Vice President Leni Robredo’s presidential bid. She unfriended “apologists” ... Read more »

'Supply chain bottlenecks and rising energy prices' are main threat to recovery, warns Lagarde

© DPA PA Images European Central Bank HQ in Frankfurt THE EUROPEAN CENTRAL Bank (ECB) has decided to keep its pandemic stimulus efforts unchanged even as consumer prices spike and ... Read more »

New price emerges as Villa target eyed in club-record Newcastle deal

Aston Villa summer target James Ward-Prowse is the latest player being pursued by Newcastle United as the newly-affluent Magpies look to seriously strengthen their midfield options. © PA Images Ben ... Read more »

Tom Holland Reveals How He Helped With Marvel And Sony's Spider-Man Deal

Cubankite/Shutterstock When Spider-Man officially joined the Marvel Cinematic Universe with 2016’s “Captain America: Civil War,” fans were overjoyed. Though we had already seen plenty of iterations of the iconic web-slinger on the big ... Read more »

The Manner sister and Duchess Rutland take the lead as

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The Manners sisters led the glamour as society beauties turned out in force for a jewellery brand party in London last night.  Lady ... Read more »

A New Trailer For Thriller Series Yellowjackets Ramps Up The Intensity

Paul Sarkis/Showtime Showtime has a not unwelcome habit of producing compelling dramas that grab your attention and won’t let go. From “Dexter” and “Homeland” to “Billions” and “Penny Dreadful,” the ... Read more »

Papua New Guinea's fragile health system pushed to the brink as Covid infections ‘skyrocket'

Health workers – in a country that only had seven doctors per 10,000 people pre-pandemic – are struggling to cope with a surge in cases – Tom Maguire/Results UK Papua ... Read more »

Victorian government urged to drop deep clean mandates as businesses fork out thousands

Photograph: Darrian Traynor/Getty Images Victorian businesses are handing over thousands of dollars for Covid-related deep cleans that infectious disease experts now say are unnecessary. The Victorian government has been urged ... Read more »

Interest rates 'ticking time bomb' warning as Britons face £510 mortgage payment increase

© Getty Andrew Bailey Describing the current situation as “a ticking mortgage timebomb” the leader of the Liberal Democrats Sir Ed Davey cited figures from the Office for Budgetary Responsibility’s ... Read more »

'Perfect for this Celtic squad', 'Outstanding' - Many Hoops fans blown away by 'revelation'

© Provided by This is Futbol Joe Hart Celtic fans have been reacting to the performance of Joe Hart during their game against Hibs in the Scottish Premiership. Ange Postecoglou’s ... Read more »

Apple AirPods tips and tricks: How to get the most out of Apple's wireless earphones

© Provided by Pocket-lint Apple AirPods tips and tricks How to get the most out of Apples wireless earphones image 1 (Pocket-lint) – Apple’s AirPods are like Marmite: you’ll either love ... Read more »

Publikationsverbot bleibt vorläufig bestehen

Ein geplantes Buch über die Zuger Landammannfeier darf vorderhand nicht veröffentlicht werden. © Foto: Urs Flueeler (Keystone) Hat einen Entscheid des Zuger Obergerichts weitergezogen: Jolanda Spiess-Hegglin. Die Tamedia-Journalistin Michèle Binswanger ... Read more »

Coronavirus: Singapore sees record 5,324 cases in ‘unusual surge'; Japan approves vaccine boosters for all eligible

Singapore has registered a total of 184,419 infections since the start of the pandemic. Photo: Reuters Singapore on Wednesday logged a record 5,324 new Covid-19 cases and 10 more deaths ... Read more »

Disguised Lewis Hamilton shocks kids and delivers inspiring message on Mercedes tour

© UBS F1 Hamilton in disguise to surprise children – UBS F1 Lewis Hamilton dressed up in disguise to surprise three schoolchildren on a tour of the Mercedes factory. Dressed ... Read more »

Una Healy receives rave reviews for Six O'Clock show presenting role

© Provided by As she fills in for Karen Koster on this week’s Six O’Clock Show, Una Healy has received rave reviews for her presenting stint with some fans ... Read more »

Leicester vs Arsenal: Prediction, kick off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h results

© ES Composite PLLeicesterArsenal2122.jpg A resurgent Arsenal travel to Leicester on Saturday lunchtime, buoyed by a recent run of good form that has seen Mikel Arteta’s side go unbeaten in ... Read more »

Suncor doubles dividend, boosts stock buyback as oil rally gains steam

© Jason Franson/The Canadian Press Suncor slashed its dividend in half in the early days of the pandemic. After slashing its dividend in half at the start of the pandemic, ... Read more »

Nick Chubb hopes he'll be back in Browns lineup this week

© Provided by NBC Sports Browns right tackle Jack Conklin declared himself ready to return to the lineup after missing the team’s last two games, but another player who has ... Read more »

Shopify CFO sees e-commerce return to normal levels as firm reports Q3 revenue up

Shopify Inc. is starting to see the intense levels of online sales companies garnered during the COVID-19 pandemic ease. © Provided by The Canadian Press “As the world begins to ... Read more »

Exploring Switzerland: Lucerne, Interlaken and Geneva

© Motivate Publishing Geneva aerial view Switzerland On the eve of schools and colleges closing for the summer vacation earlier this year, there was reason to cheer among avid travellers. ... Read more »

US stocks rise as investors weigh strong earnings against slower economic growth

© Johannes Eisele/Getty Images Johannes Eisele/Getty Images US stocks rose as investors weighed strong third-quarter earnings against slower economic growth. GDP expanded by 2% in the third quarter, down from ... Read more »

Boy, 14, caught with loaded gun at his Brooklyn high school

A 14-year-old boy was caught carrying a loaded gun into his Brooklyn public high school Thursday morning, police said. School safety officers assigned to Automotive High School on Bedford Ave. ... Read more »

Tesco website and app down again as shoppers unable to place or change orders

Tesco’s website and app have crashed for the second time in a week – leaving customers unable to place or change orders. It comes just days after the supermarket experienced ... Read more »

Police aided illegal marijuana operation in Maine, feds say

Two sheriff's deputies accepted new cars and an ownership stake in an operation that illegally sold more than $13 million in pot grown for the state’s medical marijuana program, <a ... Read more »

Biden pitches $1.75T plan at Capitol, trying to unite Dems

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden traveled to Capitol Hill early Thursday to make the case to House Democrats for a dramatically scaled-back domestic policy package, $1.75 trillion of social ... Read more »

Paroled 'Starved Rock Killer' wins OK for evidence tests

CHICAGO (AP) — A man freed from prison last year after serving nearly 60 years in the slaying of one of three suburban Chicago women found bludgeoned to death in ... Read more »

'Terrible', 'So bad' - Many RFC fans blast 'anonymous' man who had fewer touches than McLaughlin

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Kemar Roofe Rangers Many Glasgow Rangers fans have been left blasting the display of Kemar Roofe in their 2-2 draw at home to Aberdeen in ... Read more »

Former school safety officer charged with murder in death of unarmed 18-year-old

A former school safety officer in Long Beach, Calif. has been charged with murder in connection to the death of an unarmed 18-year-old student. © Getty Images Former school safety ... Read more »

Moscow is going on its strictest lockdown yet as Russian COVID-19 deaths reach record highs

© Provided by Business Insider Russian President Vladimir Putin Mikhail Svetlov/Getty Images Russia has been in a COVID-19 lockdown for nine days as case numbers rise in the country. Only ... Read more »

Quartararo has brought "positivity" to Yamaha MotoGP team

Quartararo secured his first MotoGP title at the Emilia Romagna Grand Prix at Misano, after championship rival Francesco Bagnaia’s crash from the lead made it mathematically impossible for the Ducati ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic