If confirmed, tubes in 890-million-year-old rock may be the oldest animal fossils

oldest known fossils of animals, extreme burst, too much further back in time, more recent research, Jake Buehler

Pale, wormlike tubes in 890-million-year old rock may be ancient sea sponges, a new study concludes. If confirmed, that controversial claim would push back the origin of the earliest sponges by about 350 million years and make the tiny squiggles the oldest known fossils of animals, by far.

Crucially, these fossils would imply that animals emerged in environmental conditions previously thought unworkable for animal life, geologist Elizabeth Turner reports July 28 in Nature.

Early in Earth’s history, the ocean mostly lacked oxygen. It wasn’t until a large pulse of the gas to the atmosphere about 800 million to 540 million years ago, known as the Neoproterozoic Oxidation Event, brought atmospheric oxygen levels to within 10 to 50 percent of modern levels, boosting the amount of oxygen in surface ocean waters (SN: 12/11/19). “But sponges are different from other animals,” says Turner, of Laurentian University in Sudbury, Canada. “Some sponges in the modern world and in the rock record are known to be tolerant of comparatively low oxygen relative to modern ocean levels.”

Until now, the earliest, unambiguous fossils of sponges date to about 540 million years ago to the beginning of the Cambrian Period, when an extreme burst in the evolution of animal diversity took place (SN: 7/29/13). Some other animals are known from just a bit earlier, but go too much further back in time and identities become less clear (SN: 3/9/15). Based on genetic data and their relative simplicity, sponges are generally thought to have been the earliest form of animal life.

But some scientists aren’t convinced that the newly described tubes are sponge fossils. “Organisms from anywhere on the tree of life can make wiggly, little [branching and rejoining] structures,” says Jonathan Antcliffe, a paleobiologist at the University of Lausanne in Switzerland. The fossils lack features such as mineralized skeletal parts called spicules that would identify the creatures as sponges, he says.

What’s more, the finding “doesn’t fit with everything we know about the whole [ocean] ecosystem” in regards to nutrient, biomineral and oxygen availability before the Cambrian Period, Antcliffe says. “Everything we know about the Earth’s oceans in this interval of time tells us that animals originated around 540 [to] 550 million years ago. It’s a legion of evidence, and to overturn such an enormously strong paradigm, you need more than ‘might be a sponge.’”

Turner first found the network of tubes in 1992 in rocks from the ancient Little Dal cyanobacteria reef in Canada’s Mackenzie Mountains. “I found this thing that was totally out of place,” she says. “It was much more complex in terms of its structure than anything that could be made by cyanobacteria.”

oldest known fossils of animals, extreme burst, too much further back in time, more recent research, Jake Buehler

This microscope image shows the pale, wormlike tubes of putative fossils of ancient sea sponges, found in 890-million-year old rock. E.C. Turner/Nature 2021

oldest known fossils of animals, extreme burst, too much further back in time, more recent research, Jake Buehler

This microscope image shows the pale, wormlike tubes of putative fossils of ancient sea sponges, found in 890-million-year old rock. E.C. Turner/Nature 2021

She would have reported the curious squiggles then, but without much else to tie them to sponges besides a general resemblance, Turner moved on. But after more recent research showed that sponges could be preserved in rock similarly to the Little Dal’s pallid wiggles, she returned to her find.

Turner argues that many modern sponges don’t have spicules and that the newly described fossils may be similar. And she suggests that sponges predating the Neoproterozoic Oxidation Event may have scraped out an existence in “oxygen oases” along microbial reefs, living in holes and reef flanks and not competing with cyanobacteria for space.

It’s possible that early sponges emerged much earlier than the rest of animal life and remained in a kind of “evolutionary stasis” in low-oxygen conditions, she says, with the evolution of later, more complex animals having to wait until the gas became more abundant.

Scientists have known about odd types of fossils in the Little Dal reef for a while, says James Schiffbauer, a paleobiologist at the University of Missouri in Columbia who wasn’t involved in the research. And “we’ve expected from molecular clocks that sponges should be present earlier in the Neoproterozoic [Era],” he adds, referring to genetic analyses that estimate that sponges evolved well before the Cambrian Period. “It has just been a matter of finding them if they were indeed preserved.”

Future research could help confirm the fossils’ identity. Turner plans to work more with the ancient tubes, adding that more answers may come from looking in the right places. “We need to be looking for similar material with a really open mind in rocks of similar age, and we need to be looking for more complex animal evidence in them as well,” rather than just simpler organisms like microbes.

Questions or comments on this article? E-mail us at feedback@sciencenews.org

Citations

E.C. Turner. Possible poriferan body fossils in early Neoproterozoic microbial reefs. Nature. Published online July 28, 2021. doi: 10.1038/s41586-021-03773-z.

F. Neuweiler et al. Degradative calcification of a modern siliceous sponge from the Great Bahama Bank, The Bahamas: A guide for interpretation of ancient sponge-bearing limestones. Journal of Sedimentary Research. June 2007. Vol 77. Number 7. p. 552–563. doi: 10.2110/jsr.2007.058

About Jake Buehler

Jake Buehler is a freelance science writer, covering natural history, wildlife conservation and Earth’s splendid biodiversity, from salamanders to sequoias. He has a master’s degree in zoology from the University of Hawaii at Manoa.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Language level for inburgering exam goes up in 2022

Photo: Pixabay With an increase in the language requirements for the integration exams imminent, smart candidates are signing up for a new self-access course with InburgeringOnline.nl to prepare for their ... Read more »

How to hold on to post-lockdown joy - practise gratitude

Feeling thankful for the little pleasures in our lives can add up to make us happier people overall. CALIFORNIA (NYTIMES) – When pandemic rules began to loosen earlier this year, ... Read more »

Emmys avoid record-low TV audience for first time in 6 years

7.4 million viewers tuned in to the awards show on Sept 19, 2021. LOS ANGELES (NYTIMES) – For the first time in six years, the Emmys did not set or ... Read more »

Chinese version of TikTok limits kids under 14 to 40 minutes per day

People walk past a logo of Bytedance, the China-based company which owns the short video app TikTok, or Douyin, at its office in Beijing on July 7, 2020. (Reuters photo) ... Read more »

SAC show explores our inner thoughts

SAC Gallery invites us to witness artworks that remind us to take care of our thoughts and feelings towards the stimuli around us during “Art Cart 04: Handle With Care”, ... Read more »

An all-too-familiar sight While a repeat of the 2011 floods is unlikely, heavy rains pose a threat to rice cultivation and will not mitigate drought next year

Locals brave the flood that recently hit the Bang Bo district of Samut Prakan province. Photos: Somchai Poomlard Torrential rain has recently left many areas underwater. Last month, it caused ... Read more »

Chinese artist presents 'Control' at Tang gallery

Tang Contemporary Art presents “Control”, a new solo exhibition by young Chinese artist Li Erpeng who uses realist brushwork to depict an abstract spiritual world, until Oct 31. On display ... Read more »

Google Arts & Culture shines the spotlight on late princess

The Ball. photos courtesy of Marsi Foundation Some 100 paintings by the late HSH Princess Marsi Sukhumbhand Paribatra are among the works of many great artists of the world that ... Read more »

Vaccinated Travel Lane scheme may be expanded soon; 1 Covid-19 case found among 900 visitors

A passenger of Singapore Airlines flight SQ325, the first flight ferrying travellers from Germany under the quarantine-free scheme, at Changi Airport on Sept 8, 2021. SINGAPORE – Vaccinated travellers from ... Read more »

First S'pore leisure tour group to leave for Germany on Sept 22 under Vaccinated Travel Lane scheme

Mr Reuben Lim (left), who will be part of the leisure group tour, speaking with tour manager Gary Teo. SINGAPORE – The weekend after news of the vaccinated travel lane ... Read more »

Chef Gaggan Anand to hold two-month pop-up at Mandala Club from November

The Gaggan Anand Residency at Mandala Club runs from Nov 3 to Jan 6 next year. SINGAPORE – After the recent conclusion of the Mirazur residency at the members-only Mandala ... Read more »

Thumb-sized bat on cusp of world record flight taken down by Russian house cat

Going for the gold can often end in heart-breaking defeat, as one intrepid bat learned last week when a Russian house cat mortally wounded it and left it for dead ... Read more »

Blackpink's Lisa, actor Justin Theroux start Instagram accounts for their pets

SEOUL/LOS ANGELES – It’s raining cats and dogs on Instagram. Blackpink’s Lisa has started an Instagram dedicated to her furry family of five cats (Leo, Luca, Lily, Louis and Lego) ... Read more »

The Crown and Ted Lasso win big at the Emmys, helped by comfort viewing trend

Shows with escapist content, like The Crown and Ted Lasso, went home with the most awards in the major categories. SINGAPORE – At the 73rd Primetime Emmy Awards, streaming service ... Read more »

From vagina pants to Máxima's wedding dress: new exhibition pays tribute to Amsterdam fashion 

Photographs at Maison Amsterdam illustrate the catwalk that is Amsterdam’s streets. Credit: Nederlands Fotomuseum / © Ed van der Elsken Queen Máxima’s silk wedding gown and the sensational ‘vagina pants’ ... Read more »

The Crown's Emma Corrin is fine with not playing Diana to the end

Playing a bona fide icon has afforded Emma Corrin plenty of attention. NEW YORK (NYTIMES) – Fans of Netflix’s The Crown awaited Season 4 with particular interest – it would ... Read more »

Emmy winners in key categories

“The Crown” and “The Queen’s Gambit” were the top winners at the Emmys. LOS ANGELES: Here is a list of the winners in key categories for the 73rd Emmy Awards, ... Read more »

Netflix dominates Emmys with Crown sweep and Queen's Gambit win

LOS ANGELES (AFP) – The Crown swept the drama awards at the Emmys on Sunday (Sept 19) to finally coronate Netflix with a top prize on television’s biggest night, as ... Read more »

Emmys: Ted Lasso, The Crown, Queen's Gambit win top Awards

LOS ANGELES (REUTERS) – Drama The Crown and comedy Ted Lasso won the top prizes at television’s Emmy awards on Sunday (Sept 19), while The Queen’s Gambit was named best limited series. The best ... Read more »

73rd Emmy Awards: Best and worst looks as the stars returned to the red carpet

SINGAPORE – After a red carpet-deprived Emmy Awards last year, the 73rd Primetime Emmy Awards returned with fanfare and in-real-life glamour on Monday (Sept 20), celebrating the best of television ... Read more »

Emmys: Big wins for Olivia Colman, Kate Winslet

LOS ANGELES (REUTERS, AFP) – Olivia Colman and Josh O’Connor won the top television Emmy awards for drama actors on Sunday (Sept 19), on a banner night for British talent, ... Read more »

Bill Bensley's art up for auction again

Church Of The Immaculate Conception, Chanthaburi. photos courtesy of River City Bangkok After the success of his first online art auction for charity three months ago, Bill Bensley is once ... Read more »

Emmys: Heart-warming Ted Lasso kicks off awards with double win

LOS ANGELES (REUTERS) – Ted Lasso actors clinched two early Emmy Awards on Sunday (Sept 19), setting the stage for multiple potential wins for the warm-hearted comedy about a struggling ... Read more »

Elton John delays European tour until 2023 due to hip pain

Elton John (Reuters photo) Elton John has delayed his European “Farewell Yellow Brick Road” tour until 2023 due to hip problems. The 74-year-old British singer said he had been advised ... Read more »

Emmys: Billy Porter and stars of The Crown hit red carpet

Pose star Billy Porter (left) and British actor Josh O’Connor. LOS ANGELES (REUTERS) – Pose star Billy Porter and British actor Josh O’Connor were among the early arrivals in Los ... Read more »

In-person Emmys open with musical number

Cedric the Entertainer attends the 73rd Primetime Emmy Awards in Los Angeles, California, on Sept 19, 2021. LOS ANGELES (AFP) – Comedian Cedric the Entertainer opened the 73rd Emmy Awards, ... Read more »

Less comedy, more dhamma

Phra Maha Praiwan Worawano (left) Phra Maha Sompong Talaputto (right) A couple of weeks ago, two well-known monks — Phra Maha Sompong Talaputto and Phra Maha Praiwan Worawano — held ... Read more »

All in the family For some of his charges on Thailand's Olympic champion taekwondo team, federation president Pimol Srivikorn is known as 'dad No.2'

President of Thailand’s national taekwondo association Pimol Srivikorn, with gold medalist Panipak ‘Tennis’ Wongpattanakit. Thailand’s national Taekwondo association While having deep pockets and managerial skills are an integral part of ... Read more »

Helping teens through the tough times Teenage author and mental health advocate says empathy is key to supporting struggling young people

Prachaya Sirimahaariyapoya, 15, deputy of the Children and Youth Council in Bangkok and an author. Photos: Prachaya Sirimahaariyapoya When Prachaya Sirimahaariyapoya was eight years old, she noticed that one of ... Read more »

Get the most out of your staycation at Singapore's first garden-in-a-hotel

The lush green canopy peeks up along the Skybridge, flanked by pavilions that allude to bird nests ensconced in the treetops. PHOTO: PARKROYAL COLLECTION MARINA BAY Having completed the final ... Read more »

Comedian Chris Rock has a breakthrough case of Covid-19

He also urged his 5.2 million Twitter followers to get the vaccine. LOS ANGELES – Comedian Chris Rock, who was vaccinated earlier this year, has revealed that he has tested ... Read more »

McDonald's to continue running Ridout Tea Garden outlet in Queensway after winning tender

The tender for the 57,453.9 sq ft site was awarded to Hanbaobao, Singapore licensee of McDonald’s. SINGAPORE – Happy meals will still be a treat for fans of McDonald’s outlet ... Read more »

Analysing the 'wellness-industrial complex' an episode at a time

On the podcast Maintenance Phase, Ms Aubrey Gordon explores what they call the “wellness-industrial complex”. NEW YORK (NYTIMES) – Ms Aubrey Gordon collects vintage diet books. She has amassed almost ... Read more »

Life Weekend Picks Podcast: Dune is an admirable introduction into its sprawling, sandy universe

Stills from the film Dune starring Chang Chen. Life Weekend Picks Ep 138: Dune is an admirable introduction into its sprawling, sandy universe 7:41 mins Synopsis: Every Thursday, The Straits ... Read more »

Branagh's 'Belfast' boosts Oscars hopes with Toronto prize

Kenneth Branagh’s deeply personal dramedy “Belfast” captures the late-1960s outbreak of Northern Ireland’s violent “Troubles” from the perspective of Buddy, a nine-year-old boy OTTAWA: “Belfast,” Kenneth Branagh's black-and-white homage to ... Read more »

In-person Emmys return as Netflix eyes TV's top prize with 'The Crown'

Leading streamer Netflix has never won best drama at the Emmys — nor best comedy, nor best limited series. LOS ANGELES: Television's top stars will gather in person for the ... Read more »

Expelling the family pest, killer 'mouse', brave canal hug

Don't bag that head A bag of coconut coir helped lead police to the alleged killers of an ex-soldier shot three times and dumped by the side of a gravel ... Read more »

National Cheeseburger Day 2021: McDonald's, Burger King, Wendy's offer deals and free food Saturday

Get a 50 cent double cheeseburger at McDonald’s Saturday for National Cheeseburger Day with the app. At Burger King, get a free cheeseburger with a $1 or more purchase through ... Read more »

Restaurant etiquette debate: Should you add a tip when you order takeout food?

Leaving a gratuity at an American restaurant was all but mandatory before the coronavirus pandemic. But as COVID-19 lingers, customers have discovered a new requirement: tipping on takeout orders – ... Read more »

The Bodyguard set to get a Hollywood remake

Whitney Houston in 2009. (Reuters photo) The Bodyguard, a 1992 movie that launched the acting career of the late Whitney Houston and featured her most famous hit, is getting a ... Read more »