How uncertainty can impair our ability to make rational decisions – new research

When times are uncertain, we can fail to be flexible. jefftakespics2/Shutterstock

We make decisions every day, many of which are so straightforward that we hardly notice we are making them. But we tend to struggle when faced with decisions that have uncertain outcomes, such as during the pandemic. Cognitive scientists have long been interested in understanding how people make such uncertain decisions. Now our new research, published in the journal JAMA Network Open, gives a clue.

Scientists typically test decision-making under uncertainty using “probabilistic tasks”, in which study participants can choose from two or more options, each with a specific probability of providing a reward (usually points or money). This could be a game, for example, in which you have to choose between a picture of an apple or a banana on a computer screen. The apple might be programmed to give you points 80% of the time while the banana will do so 20% of the time, but during the game the probabilities can change. You would not be aware of the probabilities at any given time, however – leading to uncertainty. Your task would be to find out which option is more rewarding.

Humans generally use two decision-making strategies when faced with uncertainty: exploitation and exploration. Exploitation involves frequently choosing options that are familiar and provide a higher certainty of reward. Exploration involves trying out choices that are unfamiliar. In an uncertain and changing environment, it is thought that the best strategy is to flexibly alternate between exploration and exploitation.

Whether people explore or exploit depends on the situation at hand. When under time pressure, people are more likely to repeat old choices and explore less.

Obsessive-compulsive disorder

A common symptom of many psychiatric disorders is difficulty in coping with uncertainty. People suffering from obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), in particular, feel incredibly uncertain about their thoughts, feelings and actions, and may feel anxious. They may feel doubtful over whether they counted the number of tiles accurately, or whether they scrubbed their hands thoroughly enough.

In our study, we demonstrate that people with OCD struggle to make decisions when they are uncertain. We asked 50 teenagers with OCD and 53 teenagers without OCD to complete a probabilistic task, in which the probabilities associated with each option would reverse halfway through the task (for example the apple picture would go from giving a reward 80% of the time to 20% of the time). The ideal strategy would be to exploit the more rewarding choice early on (apple), but then engage in exploration (pick banana) once you’ve noticed a shift in how often points are offered.

Teenagers with OCD did not do this, however. Across the task, they displayed a great deal of exploration of choices. They showed a tendency to switch choices and select the less rewarding choice more often than teenagers without OCD. Fascinatingly, when teenagers with OCD performed another task which was not probabilistic and didn’t trigger uncertainty, they showed no problems with decision-making.

Uncertainty caused by the probabilistic task may have caused teenagers with OCD to doubt their decisions and feel the need to “check” the less rewarding choice frequently. This exploration could be a strategy for them to try to seek out information until they feel certain. Intolerance of uncertainty is a plausible reason for why people with OCD feel compelled to check items like locks, stoves and switches in daily life.

The results also suggest that many people may start to explore in this way if they are feeling uncertain enough.

Pandemic uncertainty

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused a great deal of uncertainty for everyone, which in turn seems to have increased our tendency for exploration in the form of information-seeking. A study has shown that perceived uncertainty has led to people seeking more information about COVID via social networking apps and online news media.

On the one hand, this has led to more preventative actions, such as increased hand washing and mask wearing, which can reduce uncertainty and keep people safe. On the other hand, this information-seeking may not be entirely beneficial. A recent study has shown that since the onset of the pandemic, otherwise healthy people are reporting more obsessive-compulsive symptoms, such as constantly checking for new information to reduce feelings of pandemic-induced uncertainty.

Stress from exploration can change the brain. Semnic

Excessive information-seeking during this period can lead to high levels of stress. We know from previous research that it can eventually lead to burnout and avoidance of information altogether, leaving people less informed about government guidelines, safety measures and COVID-19 treatment advances.

Persistent stress from overexposure to distressing news may also cause changes in key brain areas such as the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and hippocampus, which are responsible for memory and cognition. This can in turn result in reduced rational decision-making, leading us to rely more on emotions. This could make us susceptible to believing misinformation and engaging in irrational behaviours, such as hoarding toilet paper.

Luckily, there are ways to combat pandemic uncertainty by trusting some of the information you’ve already gathered and that seems consistent over time, such as the benefits of masks and vaccines. If you are finding it difficult to cope without frequently checking the news and social media for reassurance, experts recommend setting a timer on social media use, logging out of accounts temporarily, and seeking out more positive, non-pandemic related content online.

There are even evidence-based methods to improving your decision-making under uncertainty, including playing games designed to train your brain, getting good sleep and nutrition, and having social support.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Barbara Jacquelyn Sahakian consults for Cambridge Cognition. Dr Sahakian’s research is funded by the Wellcome Trust, the Lundbeck Foundation and the Leverhulme Trust and is conducted within the NIHR MedTech and in vitro diagnostic Cooperative (MIC) and the NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centre (BRC) Mental Health and Neurodegeneration Themes.

Aleya Aziz Marzuki received funding as a research assistant and PhD student from a Wellcome Trust Grant awarded to Professor Trevor Robbins (104631/Z/14/Z/) and was the recipient of a grant from the G C Grindley Fund.

News Related


This Top-Rated Gadget Makes Lifting the Lid off Pickle Jars, Bottles, and More So Much Easier

It’s a scenario most of us have dealt with before: You go to open a jar and it just won’t give. You hunch over, lean into your table or countertop ... Read more »

Mouni Roy adorably smiles at her 'everything' Suraj Nambiar in THIS new happy photo

© Provided by Pinkvilla The bride to be Mouni Roy is on cloud nine as she is going to tie the knot with her love of life Suraj Nambiar. The ... Read more »

Happy Birthday Bobby Deol: From Animal to Aashram 2, upcoming projects of the actor that won't disappoint

© Provided by Pinkvilla Tinsel town has an amazing set of artists, who are known throughout the for their incessant efforts in creating masterpieces. One of the influencers in the ... Read more »

Ayushmann Khurrana begins filming ‘An Action Hero', shares glimpses; Fans say 'Nice place'

Ayushmann Khurrana is one such actor who has often grabbed the limelight for the kind of films he has chosen. He has never failed to impress us by going offbeat ... Read more »

Happy Birthday Shehnaaz Gill: 5 life lessons from Punjab's Katrina Kaif that prove why she's queen of hearts

Shehnaaz Gill – the name doesn’t need an introduction. The Punjabi actress, who has made her acting debut with Punjabi film Sat Shri Akaal England, became a household name when ... Read more »

Aufträge im Wert von 35 Mio.: Stadler Rail wehrt sich gegen Vergabe in der Ukraine

Der Thurgauer Schienenfahrzeughersteller Stadler Rail reicht bei der ukranischen Wettbewerbsbehörde Beschwerde ein. Der Vorwurf: Ungerechte Auftragsvergabe eines Grossauftrags über 35 Millionen Franken. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Stadler Rail wehrt sich ... Read more »

General Motors to add 8,000 technical workers this year

The Associated PressFILE – This Oct. 16, 2019, file photo shows a sign at a General Motors facility in Langhorne, Pa. General Motors says, Wednesday, Jan. 26, 2022, it wants ... Read more »

Prince Andrew comes out fighting: Royal files legal papers DENYING all of Virginia Roberts' sex abuse allegations, demands a jury trial and claims Ghislaine Maxwell was NOT his 'close friend' as he faces epic US court battle

BREAKING: Royal files legal papers denying all of Virginia Roberts allegationsPrince Andrew also claimed Ghislaine Maxwell was not a 'close friend' in papersThe Royal's legal team has requested that he be granted a trial by jury Duke of York's official rebuttal of the claims comes after a motion to have the case dismissed on a legal technicality in January was deniedMORE TO FOLLOW  Read more »

Video: 'I am NOT Che Diaz!' OITNB star Lea DeLaria issues cheeky 'public service announcement' after fans compared her to nonbinary character from And Just Like That...

Read more »

A huge LEAP closer to limb regeneration: Scientists regrow a frog's lost leg using a five-drug cocktail - and want to test the technique on mammals next

Scientists performed growth experiments on African clawed frogs missing limbsThey used a five-drug cocktail applied in a silicone wearable attached to woundsOver the course of 18 months, frogs had 'almost fully functional' limbs restoredMethod marks a milestone in the ultimate goal of limb regeneration for humans  Read more »

Bassetlaw council won't allow binmen to collect overflowing bins in case the lid flips open in the wind and slams them in the face

Bassetlaw District Council is taking a more 'proactive' approach to bin collectionResidents will not have bins collected if the lid isn't fully shut under new policy A council spokesman said that overloaded bins can pose a safety risk to workersThe new approach will see red stickers put on the side of bins with raised lids  Read more »

Vets reveal the dog breeds most affected by 'cherry eye' – with flat-faced pups including Neapolitan mastiffs, English bulldogs and American cocker spaniels up to 34 TIMES more likely to suffer the uncomfortable condition

Cherry eye is a condition that results in a large pink mass in the dog's eyeIt can cause discomfort and lead to complications including ulcerationResearchers studied health records of more than 900,000 dogs in the UKFlat-faced dogs were found to be at the highest risk of cherry eyeGerman Shepheds and West Highland White Terriers were at the lowest risk Read more »

Bowl Bread Is Martha Stewart's Family Favorite Winter Baking Recipe

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission. From sourdough to banana bread, there have been a ... Read more »

The Book of Boba Fett episode 5 was the ‘best' of the season – but fans are conflicted

© Disney Plus book of boba fett The latest episode of The Book of Boba Fett has left fans conflicted. Disney Plus’s Star Wars spin-off series focuses on the former ... Read more »

BlendJet Just Released a Line Of Creamy Lattes That Can Be Made in Seconds

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission. The first thing we start thinking about when we ... Read more »

Stephen Breyer to retire as Biden urged to fulfill promise to nominate Black woman – live

LIVE – Updated at 19:00 Biden promised on campaign trail to select Black woman fill any US supreme court vacancy – follow the latest.   19:00 Joanna Walters Hillary Clinton ... Read more »

CP NewsAlert: Four people found dead at home in Richmond, B.C.

RICHMOND, B.C. — Police say four people were found dead at a home in Richmond, B.C., in what they describe as a targeted shooting. © Provided by The Canadian Press ... Read more »

We Found a Dupe For the Internet-Famous Theragun Massage Tool & It's $100 Less

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission. So you know that massage gun that’s been all ... Read more »

Netherlands unveils 'world's-largest' canal lock

© Provided by DW The lock connects the North Sea with the port of Amsterdam Dutch King Willen-Alexander on Wednesday opened what authorities say is the world’s largest canal lock. ... Read more »

Troubled Waters: Killing the will of the villagers next to Lake St Lucia

KwaNibela residents rely on the fish and reeds they harvest within the protected iSimangaliso Wetland Park. But authorities consider this poaching, threatening the community’s lives and livelihoods. © Copyright (c) ... Read more »

Don't overdose on supplements. They can impact your organs

Immunity supplements are taken with the notion that they help in preventing infections and keeping diseases at bay naturally. However, there is no evidence to support it. With repeated Covid-19 ... Read more »

Video: Euphoria's Eric Dane highlights chiseled chest in a gray t-shirt paired with charcoal jeans while grocery shopping in Beverly Hills

Read more »

India seeks justice for Pakistan Army's 1971 genocide and 26/11 at UNSC

India sought justice for 1971 genocide and 26/11, during the first UNSC open debate this year, while slamming state actors for backing terrorism. It condemned resurgence of armed conflicts that ... Read more »

Priyanka accuses cops of vandalising hostel

Congress general secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra has accused the Uttar Pradesh Police of assaulting students and vandalising their hostel in Prayagraj for allegedly protesting against unemployment in the city. Sharing ... Read more »

Bentley Commits to Five New EVs by 2030, Including a New Model in 2025

Bentley follows through on previously announced plans to go electric by saying it will launch its first all-electric model in 2025. The statement today is in line with a commitment ... Read more »

Mo Salah shows nerves of steel to score winning AFCON penalty after Bailly miss

© GiveMeSport p1fqbqdimt18os1ljrbgi1ddq1030d.jpg Mo Salah was the hero as Egypt progressed to the quarter-finals of the 2021 Africa Cup of Nations against the Ivory Coast on Wednesday. While the regulation ... Read more »

Why fitness trackers are doing more harm than good

Are fitness trackers causing more harm than good? Doctors warn it’s possible. Your smartwatch might have it all, but when it comes to your overall health, it might be taking ... Read more »

Disney pulls U-turn on Snow White And The Seven Dwarfs remake after Peter Dinklage fury

DISNEY has hit back at claims its planned remake of Snow White is offensive to dwarfs. The storm raged after Game of Thrones actor Peter Dinklage described the live action ... Read more »

Barty bats, Usyk chills and Maguire tees off – Wednesday's sporting social

© Provided by The Independent Ashleigh Barty, Oleksandr Usyk and Harry Maguire (Steven Paston/Richard Sellers/Martin Rickett/PA) – Sports stars and clubs across the world continue to provide an insight into ... Read more »

Uttarakhand poll: Congress fields Harish Rawat from Lalkuwa, Mahendra Pal to contest from Ramnagar

Uttarakhand Congress released a fresh list of 10 candidates on Wednesday. The list includes the name of former chief minister Harish Rawat, who was earlier given ticket from the Ramnagar ... Read more »

Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson is primed to become Biden's first Supreme Court pick as Justice Stephen Breyer retires

© Kevin Lamarque-Pool/Getty Images Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson is primed to become Biden’s first Supreme Court pick as Justice Stephen Breyer retires Justice Stephen Breyer announced on Wednesday his plans ... Read more »

Stephen Breyer: Supreme Court justice plans to retire

Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer plans to retire, setting up a seismic confirmation battle at the start of a midterm election year as President Joe Biden tries to find his ... Read more »

FIFA 22 TOTW 19: New Team of the Week cards for FUT out now

© GETTY EA fifa 22 totw 19 FIFA 22 TOTW 19 has launched today, with the new FUT cards available in packs right now. The highest rated card available with ... Read more »

Ellis Simms: January signing tells Hearts fans what to expect from new striker

© Ellis Simms posing with the Hearts scarf after completing his move. Picture: Hearts TV The Everton youngster completed his loan move to Tynecastle earlier on Wednesday and goes straight ... Read more »

Ivory Coast 0-0 Egypt (4-5 pens): Mo Salah wins shootout after Eric Bailly sees penalty saved

© AP mosalah.jpg Mo Salah scored the winning penalty as Egypt beat Ivory Coast 5-4 in the shootout to reach the Africa Cup of Nations quarter-finals. A match with plenty ... Read more »

Soccer-Substitute keeper Abo Gabal the shootout hero as Egypt advance

© Reuters/MOHAMED ABD EL GHANY Africa Cup of Nations – Round of 16 – Ivory Coast v Egypt (Reuters) – Egypt booked a quarter-final place at the Africa Cup of ... Read more »

Irish youngster James Abankwah completes transfer to Serie A side Udinese

ST PATRICK’S ATHLETIC have confirmed the sale of promising centre-back James Abankwah to Italian club Udinese. Abankwah, who turned 18 earlier this month, has signed a deal with the Serie ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo's girlfriend Georgina Rodriguez admits adapting to life with him was hard

Georgina Rodriguez has admitted it was hard adapting to life after meeting Manchester United icon Cristiano Ronaldo. The couple have been together since 2016, with the Spanish model giving birth ... Read more »

The Early Front-Runner for Breyer's Seat

© Kevin Lamarque / Getty Like an air-horn blast at summer camp, the news of 83-year-old United States Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer’s imminent retirement is calling Democrats to attention. ... Read more »

US sends firm response to Russia's Ukraine demands

© Reuters Mr Blinken said the US was “prepared either way” The United States has issued its formal response to Russia’s demands over the crisis on the Ukraine border. Secretary ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic