How Twitter can fix itself

Twitter, Twitter ceo, Jack Dorsey, Facebook, Parag Agrawal

Twitter has lagged behind its social media peers in recent years, failing to keep pace in new services, acquisitions, user growth and stock price. Consider that its most memorable innovation was doubling the tweet character limit to 280, and that was more than four years ago.

The site has just plodded along, content to be a plaything for corporate public relations, journalists and politicians. It’s not all that popular with regular folks, who instead turn to Facebook, Instagram and YouTube. And for many years that afforded Twitter less scrutiny, until Donald Trump became a Twitter power user.

There has been much discussion recently about Facebook’s polarizing effects and the spread of hate, racism and misinformation on its parent Meta’s platforms, after a whistleblower released a huge cache of internal documents about the company. Much of the same can be found on Twitter; trolls, bigots and outright lies wend their way into Twitter feeds alongside more anodyne fare. It’s just a smaller audience.

The company now has the opportunity to inject some life into what has become a stagnant, albeit highly addictive, service after its co-founder Jack Dorsey said on Monday he would relinquish his role as chief executive and, sometime next year, his board seat. Investors’ hopes for new blood sent the company’s stock soaring briefly, only to fall back to earth after Dorsey revealed his successor is a 10-year veteran of the company, the most recent chief technology officer and a relative unknown. “Twitter probably needs a more dramatic management change than what has been announced,” Mark Mahaney, a longtime tech analyst, said.

Dorsey has split his duties since 2015 between Twitter and the payments company Square (now Block), where he’ll go full time. With the undivided attention of the new chief executive, Parag Agrawal, there are some changes Twitter ought to institute to clean up the service and make it a more robust competitor to Facebook and YouTube, among others.

First, Agrawal must restore trust in the site by better policing misinformation spread by politicians and celebrities. Like Facebook, Twitter has sparingly enforced community standards against its best-known users, despite strong evidence that politicians are more likely to be believed than regular folks — even, or perhaps especially, when they are spouting falsehoods.

For instance, Twitter allowed to stand a September tweet from the musician Nicki Minaj that falsely tied the COVID vaccination to impotence. That tweet garnered tens of thousands of likes. And Twitter was slow to act upon Trump, who freely spread falsehoods about the coronavirus and voting, leading up to the Jan. 6 siege of the Capitol building. Agrawal’s mettle will surely be tested if, as expected, Trump runs again for president.

Second, Agrawal needs to reel in the bots. Twitter is infested with fake accounts and automated trolls that can degrade the experience for earnest users and too often result in bigoted or sexist invective. Tallying them has become a fool’s errand, and users are left wondering whether misinformation or personal attacks are from a reliable source or from a software program.

Anil Dash, chief executive of the programming company Glitch and a tech industry veteran, told me that simply eliminating bots “would get rid of some of the most potentially valuable, useful and fun accounts on the service” — accounts that tweet out a phrase or sentence a day from “Moby Dick,” for instance. He suggested, instead, that Twitter more clearly label the accounts and require their creators to register them with the company.

Labeling works only so well, of course. Too often, labels on misinformation posts contain mealy-mouthed language like “disputed” or “misleading,” or they ineffectually direct users to other sites for more definitive information. By one measure, Twitter’s own data showed that such labels contributed to a decrease in some of the spread of offending tweets of just 29%. A recently announced change calling greater attention to the labels is a step in the right direction. But if Twitter won’t remove outright lies about democracy, climate change or the pandemic, Agrawal can see to it that Twitter’s labels more convincingly dispel those myths.

More human moderation would be a plus, too. Automated systems let too much garbage through. And like its larger competitors, Twitter has too few systems in place to detect violations abroad where less commonly spoken languages dominate, meaning hateful speech can easily slip through. Humans in the loop can also put greater scrutiny on those accounts with the most followers and retweets.

Eric Goldman, a Santa Clara University law professor, suggested to me a more radical approach: banning political accounts. “Every time Twitter tries to fact-check or moderate politicians, it makes another political enemy who becomes hellbent on regulating Twitter out of existence,” Goldman wrote in an email.

A ban seems extreme, as Twitter has proved valuable as a way to communicate directly and promptly with constituents. Still, it’s worth considering Goldman’s suggestion that politicians’ accounts carry identifiers and that they be subject to greater restrictions on whom they can block and what content they can moderate.

Agrawal will need to develop thick skin. His predecessor was hauled before Congress three times in just the past couple of years, where lawmakers alleged he both stifled free speech and allowed far too much speech to remain on Twitter.

The social media experts I reached out to agreed that Twitter needs to institute paid subscription services that are more comprehensive than its recently introduced $3-per-month Blue service, which gives users access to features like recalling errant tweets and seeing some news articles ad-free. This would serve to limit Twitter’s need to collect as much personal data as it does to feed its advertising business, but also open up opportunities for creative new ways to use the service, such as exclusive content.

In his resignation letter, Dorsey said he wished for Twitter to be the most transparent company in the world — that should include working closely with researchers and admitting mistakes. In that spirit, Twitter should also carry through on Dorsey’s promise to Congress in March to give users greater transparency and control over how the company uses algorithms. If Agrawal doesn’t do it, Congress may force the matter.

There are other things Twitter can do. Kate Starbird, a professor of human-computer interaction at the University of Washington, suggested the company invest in media literacy campaigns so that users can better interpret the tweets they see. And Nate Persily, a professor at Stanford Law School, proposed that Twitter establish independent boards to set standards for global elections and for oversight of the company’s algorithms.

Twitter can be fun, surprising, funny, irreverent and germane. There is simply no better place to rapidly find the day’s news and to fire off ephemeral comments on global events. Here’s hoping the new chief can make it a far less toxic place, too.

And for Pete’s sake, Agrawal, please give us an edit button.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Those who forced exodus have fled: Amit Shah in Kairana

Union home minister Amit Shah kickstarted his Uttar Pradesh election campaign with a door-to-door campaign in Kairana district where the alleged “exodus” of Hindu families during the previous Akhilesh Yadav-led ... Read more »

EC allows rallies with up to 500 people for phase 1, 2

The Election Commission has allowed campaign relaxations in assembly constituencies that will go to polls in the first two phases even as it extended the ban on physical rallies and ... Read more »

Beyond-Covid-19: S Jaishankar dials 24 ministers in 19 days

The government has given new momentum to its post Covid-19 diplomacy at the outset of 2022, expanding bilateral agenda beyond the pandemic-related cooperation and putting meat into traditional areas of ... Read more »

Negredo y Ledesma levantan al Cádiz

© Juan Carlos Cárdenas (EFE) El centrocampista del Cádiz Salvador Sánchez celebra su gol contra el Levante. Una dentellada letal del tiburón Álvaro Negredo, un chispazo de Salvi y los ... Read more »

Delhi, Berlin need Russia against China, says German Navy Chief

Germany, which has a long history of cooperation with Russia, has signalled a pragmatic approach to end tensions in Europe. Its navy chief said during his recent visit to India ... Read more »

Skandal w Anglii. Reprezentant Polski trafiony butelką w głowę

© James Gill – Danehouse / Getty Images Piłkarze Aston Villi W sobotę Everton grał z Aston Villą w meczu angielskiej Premier League. Podczas spotkania doszło do sporego skandalu. Butelką ... Read more »

Man City vs Arsenal - WSL: TV channel, live stream, team news & prediction

Manchester City host Arsenal in the pick of the WSL fixtures this weekend. © Provided by 90min Man City & Arsenal meet in the WSL on Sunday | Catherine Ivill/GettyImages ... Read more »

Mohamed Salah & Sadio Mane to face off in final stage of World Cup qualifying

Liverpool duo Mohamed Salah and Sadio Mane will square off in the final round of CAF World Cup qualification when Egypt and Senegal meet in a two-legged tie for a ... Read more »

Ships with liquefied gas change course: imports doubled

Liquefied gas has therefore become an alternative for Europe for gas from our own soil or via the pipelines. For years, that subterfuge was not really necessary. “The Gate terminal ... Read more »

Covid: Delhi records 45 deaths, highest since June 5; 11,486 cases

Delhi on Saturday recorded 45 deaths due to COVID-19, the highest since June 5, and 11,486 fresh cases with a positivity rate of 16.36 per cent, according to data shared ... Read more »

Davis claims promoter hasn't paid him for comeback fight

In November UFC veteran Marcus Davis returned to MMA action after a seven lay-off. His return was a triumphant one as he submitted Stephen Stengel by first round triangle choke. ... Read more »

COVID-19 update | Maharashtra records 46,393 cases, 48 deaths

Representative image Maharashtra on Saturday recorded 46,393 new coronavirus cases including 416 Omicron infections and 48 pandemic-related deaths, the health department said. The daily new cases came down by more ... Read more »

High fertilizer prices could mean smaller crops for farmers

COLUMBUS, Miss. — Farmers across Mississippi are having to adjust to a steep rise in the price of fertilizer. The Mississippi State Extension Service recently released a study about how ... Read more »

Why you might be leasing not buying your next couch

shironosov | iStock | Getty Images Before eventually moving to California, the grandson of one of interior designer Phyllis Harbinger's wealthy clients who had just graduated from college opted to ... Read more »

Kerala govt asks private hospitals to set aside 50 per cent beds for COVID patients

Amid surging coronavirus cases in Kerala, the health department on Saturday instructed private hospitals in the state to set aside 50 per cent of beds for COVID-19 patients. The department ... Read more »

Fan arrested for throwing missile during Everton vs Aston Villa

Police have arrested a fan at Goodison Park for throwing a missile onto the pitch during Aston Villa‘s Premier League victory over Everton on Saturday. © Provided by 90min Lucas ... Read more »

Behind GM, Ford's aggressive new electric vehicle strategy is old-time financing: Cash

The cab to a Ford all-electric F-150 Lightning truck prototype is seen on an automated guided vehicle (AGV) at the Rouge Electric Vehicle Center in Dearborn, Michigan, September 16, 2021.Rebecca ... Read more »

ECI extends ban on physical rallies, road shows in poll bound states till January 31

(Representative image) Amid the rising COVID-19 cases in the country, the Election Commission of India on January 22 extended the ban on physical rallies and roadshows till January 31, 2022. ... Read more »

End odd-even system for markets in Delhi , relax COVID curbs: Traders' body

A prominent organisation of traders on Saturday demanded that the Kejriwal government allow the opening of markets on all days of the week and relax COVID-19 restrictions. Confederation of All ... Read more »

Un ciclista muere al ser arrollado por cuatro vehículos en una autopista de Mallorca

© Europa press Control de la Guardia Civil en Mallorca, en una imagen de archivo. GUARDIA CIVIL (Foto de ARCHIVO) 01/1/1970 Un ciclista de 27 años de edad ha fallecido ... Read more »

Exclusive: SEBI pulls up PTC India Financial, says no board meeting till corporate governance issue addressed

Securities and Exchange Board of India has pulled up PTC India Financial Services (PFS), asking the company not to hold a board meeting until the corporate governance issues are addressed ... Read more »

Nikt nie gra tak jak on. SofM znowu zaskoczył wszystkich

© Riot Games SofM Pana z obrazka nikomu przedstawiać nie trzeba. SofM stał się popularny także wśród europejskiej społeczności podczas Worldsów 2020, kiedy to wraz z Suning niespodziewanie doszedł aż ... Read more »

Lata Mangeshkar's health shows signs of improvement

Legendary singer Lata Mangeshkar‘s health is showing signs of improvement, her team has confirmed. “Heartfelt request for the disturbing speculation to stop. Update from Dr Pratit Samdani, Breach Candy Hospital. ... Read more »

Cuba relaxes COVID requirements for Russian tourists arriving in groups

Cuba’s embassy in Moscow told that the entry regulations had been relaxed for Russian travelers due to an improving epidemiological situation in the country Read more »

Sibir nuclear-powered icebreaker arrives at homeport of Murmansk from Baltic Shipyard

In Murmansk, the Sibir will start operating along the Northern Sea Route Read more »

Bitcoin pyramid schemes wreak havoc on Brazil's 'New Egypt'

CABO FRIO, Brazil — In April, Brazil’s federal police stormed the helipad of a boutique seaside hotel in Rio de Janeiro state, where they busted two men and a woman ... Read more »

End of tech party hits wealth Jeff Bezos hard: $25 billion up in smoke

The rapidly deteriorating mood is particularly noticeable on the Nasdaq, where many tech giants are listed. From its peak in November last year, the technology stock market has already fallen ... Read more »

La UE tiene listas sanciones a gran escala por si Rusia ataca Ucrania

© SERGEI SUPINSKY (AFP) La madre de un soldado ucranio recordaba a su hijo, el viernes en un memorial del conflicto en Kiev. La Unión Europea ha negociado en secreto ... Read more »

'Bulli Bai' App case: Delhi Court rejects anticipatory bail to Vishal, says it's direct onslaught upon dignity, modesty of woman

The Patiala House Court’s Session Court on Saturday rejected the anticipatory bail petition of Vishal Sudhir Kumar Jha in relation to the ‘Bulli Bai’ app case and said that the ... Read more »

‘An optimistic trend': Covid cases are falling, but U.S. isn't out of the woods yet

Case counts have a long way down to go, meaning many more infections are expected in the coming weeks. Read more »

Diese klassischen Auto-Aktien überflügelten den «Highflyer» Tesla

Auch wenn Tesla als Highflyer unter den Auto-Titeln gilt: 2021 haben Anleger mit Titeln vieler traditioneller Autobauer besser verdient. Im vergangenen Oktober war es erstmals so weit: Der Elektroautopionier Tesla hatte an ... Read more »

ICICI puts up all round show to clock record profit in Q3

ICICI Bank‘s net profit increased 25% year-on-year to a record Rs 6194 crore in the quarter ended December 2021 on the back of strong growth in loans and fee income ... Read more »

Kerala logs 45,136 new COVID-19 cases

Kerala continued to record steep rise in COVID-19 cases with 45,136 new positive cases being reported on Saturday, taking the tally to 55,74,702. Kerala had on Friday logged 41,668 fresh ... Read more »

Ministop joins French fry war in Japan with larger Bucket Potato as McDonald's reel from potato shortage

Ministop’s Bucket |Potato Ministop has joined the French fries war in Japan by offering its Bucket Potato, which has three times the amount of their X Fried Potatoes for 641 ... Read more »

German government: natural gas is an interim solution in the energy transition

Photo: ANP The use of natural gas is necessary as an interim solution for the energy transition. The German government wrote this in a letter to the European Commission. Berlin ... Read more »

8 Features of The Best Forex Trading Platforms

Retail trading is a robust industry. Around the world, millions of people buy and sell currencies online, and the term “Forex” is now associated with broad portfolios comprising currencies, stocks, ... Read more »

Shell looks at sustainable projects in France with €4 billion in its pocket

According to Van Beurden, Shell is looking at possible investments in French offshore wind farms, charging stations for electric cars and the production of hydrogen and biofuel for aircraft. France ... Read more »

The 21-year-old College Cuber makes $8,000 mosaics of sports stars using cubes

Dylan Sadiq, known as “The College Cuber” charges $8,000 for his mosaics made of cubes. Pro teams including the NBA's Detroit Pistons have purchased the artwork.Courtesy: Dylan Sadiq | The ... Read more »

Watford ready to part ways with Claudio Ranieri

Claudio Ranieri will be relieved of his duties as Watford manager this weekend following his side’s disastrous 3-0 home defeat to struggling Norwich City on Friday. © Provided by 90min ... Read more »

Central Vista Avenue is ready with new effect, says Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri

Union Minister of Housing and Urban Affairs, Hardeep Singh Puri, on Saturday, said that Central Vista Avenue is completely ready with its new effect. Talking to ANI at Central Vista ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic