How to prevent accidental wars? Strongmen Putin, Xi, Modi are risk-takers, can be triggers

How to prevent accidental wars? Strongmen Putin, Xi, Modi are risk-takers, can be triggers
© Provided by The Print

The virtual meeting on 15 November between Presidents Joe Biden of the US and Xi Jinping of China could hopefully be the forerunner to a dialogue process that was so far missing in action. The relationship had turned openly hostile, and the drift towards armed conflict due to misjudgement and miscommunication needed repair. Some political and military leaders had been warning of the risk of an accidental war—a possibility that could have driven both leaders to acknowledge the danger.

Violence, hatred, enmity: trinity of war

A mere understanding of the nature of the beast that resides surreptitiously in incidents between adversarial military entities is necessary but insufficient to prevent them. Prevention demands political rationale to prevail over the forces that pull in the direction of escalation. Prussian theorist Carl von Clausewitz’s theory of escalation in the form of a ‘trinity’ of forces, which prevails in nations that interact with each other, is probably an explanation that has stood the test of time.

According to the ‘trinity’ theory, the prime escalatory force originates as a result of primordial violence unleashed by hatred and hostility between societies of the belligerents. The second force is of the play of chance and probability resulting in uncertainty and the near impossibility of forecasting action-reaction produced by adversarial military forces in contact. This is also accentuated by misperceptions, miscommunications, and misjudgements and described as the ‘fog of war.’

The main characteristic of this force is that it could acquire a logic of its own, be beyond human control, and may unpredictably act to strengthen escalation. The third force is political rationality that resides in the decision-making of the leadership. This is the force that can contain escalation through decisions that are driven by caution. But the overall danger is that this force could uncontrollably be overwhelmed by both or either of the other two forces.

Also read: US must not be too hard on India over Modi-Putin summit. For its own good

A danger that was wavered

In India, a terrorist attack—especially on a religious symbol— can lead to primordial violence through the unleashing of the forces of hatred and hostility. The call for revenge would be irresistible for the political leadership. Military forces applied in retaliation would get into an action-reaction scenario, which acquires its own military logic that is unbridled by political rationale. The post-Balakote dog fight that resulted in the play of chance and the loss of aircraft and capture of an Indian pilot could have escalated. But political rationale on both sides prevailed with possibly a little help from the US.

‘Accidental wars’ world over

The terrorist attack scenario described above has deliberate initiation of violence as the detonator. In an accidental war, the detonator is an accident. During the Cold War, technical glitches in the early warning radars that were deployed to watch for missiles could have resulted in nuclear exchanges. Each time, the play of chance and probability saved the day.

The scale and pace of the current unbridled global arms race, which now also includes space and cyberspace, is coupled with deployments of technological products that promise to exploit the vulnerabilities of the adversaries and are supposedly able to triumph in militant engagements. China in particular is engaged in frantic moves at military modernisation that have been driven by Xi Jingping, who never fails to remind his domestic audience of the need for military power to defend its interests.

In Asia, adversarial military forces of China and the US, Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) are interfacing in the air, sea, space, and cyberspace. Chinese forces are also in close contact with Ladakh and other places on the India-China border. A similar interface is prevailing in Europe between Russia, the US and the European Union. The military buildup and growing tensions in the Donbass region of Ukraine are of particular concern. The interface is mostly aimed to strengthen territorial or maritime claims and is carried out without any mutual understanding of the rules of the road.

The situation is layered with leaders who rely on their ‘strongman’ image and have a greater proclivity to undertake risks. Such risk-taking behaviour could be the detonators for accidental war. During the Biden-Xi virtual dialogue, there was more than a hint that some level of talks on strategic stability would commence. There is some hope that China, the US, and other actors could evolve confidence-building measures that will be directed to prevent accidental wars. An improved geopolitical ambience can realise that possibility. The dangers of inaction are obvious to all. Only the political will of the parties concerned can overcome the obstacles to reach an understanding.

Also read: China’s military hardware export to Pakistan will affect security dynamics, says Navy chief

India has measures in place, but obstacles are huge

Unlike the confrontation of China and Russia with the US and other nations, the situations on the India-China and the India-Pakistan borders have confidence-building measures in place that are specifically aimed to prevent military flare-ups. These are also buttressed by channels of communications at several levels between political, military, and diplomatic leaders. With Pakistan, these channels also include Track II talks. Some intelligence sources even give them credit for facilitating the reassertion of the India-Pakistan ceasefire in February 2020.

However, in the arena of global politics, India is still not in any camp but is in many issue-based tents. This was reflected in the stances it took at the United Nations forums on climate change and the Treaty on space. Its membership of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), the RIC (Russia-India-China) Forum, BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa), and the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (QUAD) is also indicative. Can India’s political and diplomatic capital be deployed at the global level to usher in a return to politics that is based on dialogue? Will such an attempt be a non-starter due to the poor state of India-China relations? The obstacles seem huge. That is why India with a self-image of Vishwaguru, or world teacher, should give it a try.

Also read: Onus not on India to be friendly and keep peace with China, says former envoy Bambawale

Will leaders prevent a war that nobody wants?

A deadly cocktail of deepened geopolitical competition bordering on confrontation, an unbridled arms race, and greater risk-taking proclivity of leaders can prove to be the catalysts for initiating a war that nobody wants. The hotspots are well known and are begging for political interventions by the parties concerned. Whether Biden, Xi, Putin, and other middle-power leaders like Narendra Modi—who are all entangled in amassing power domestically—can make a difference, only time can tell.

Lt Gen (Dr) Prakash Menon (retd.) is Director, Strategic Studies Programme, Takshashila Institution; former Military Adviser, National Security Council Secretariat. He tweets @prakashmenon51. Views are personal.

(Edited by Humra Laeeq)

News Related


Sektor pelancongan mungkin dilonggarkan lagi jika 'booster' selesai, berikut 9 info ringkas mengenainya

PEMBERIAN suntikan dos penggalak sedang rancak berjalan di seluruh negara. Sehingga 24 Januari, 10,906,259 individu telah menerima suntikan berkenaan di seluruh negara yang melibatkan sebanyak 33.4 peratus populasi keseluruhan. Pemberian ... Read more »

LOOK: Thebe Magugu hangs out with Kanye West at Schiaparelli fashion show

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Thebe Magugu is a gone boy. The multi-award-winning designer who won the LVHM Prize 2019 is not just a success but has been embraced ... Read more »

Black artists highlight how the trauma of empire still echoes in Britain

In April 1819 a French slave ship called “Le Rodeur” departed West Africa for the Caribbean. On board were 22 crew, and around 160 enslaved Africans. In the cramped conditions ... Read more »

FCB-Cabral mit Fiorentina einig – Millionen-Deal soll Weg frei machen

Diashow ein Abschied: Arthur Cabral wird den FC Basel wohl verlassen. Der Topscorer der laufenden Super-League-Saison steht vor einem Wechsel zu Fiorentina. In Florenz soll Cabral den abwandernden Dusan Vlahovic ... Read more »

Perkara buruk bakal berlaku, kata Kit Siang selepas penurunan indeks rasuah

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman berkata, kejatuhan lima anak tangga dalam CPI 2021 memalukan, manakala Faiz Fadzil mendakwa ia menunjukkan prinsip Islam mencegah rasuah ... Read more »

Maida Vale: Tributes paid to woman killed as family say ‘she didn't deserve to die'

The devastated family of a mother-of-two stabbed to death before a motorist mowed down her attacker in west London said on Tuesday: “She didn’t deserve to die.” The driver, 26, ... Read more »

Londoner Polizei leitet Ermittlungen zu Downing-Street-Partys ein

Eine Reihe von Festivitäten an der Londoner Downing Street wird von der Polizei untersucht. Das verschärft die Krise von Boris Johnsons Regierung. © Foto: Andy Rain (Keystone/21. Januar 2022) Die ... Read more »

Happy Birthday Cheteshwar Pujara: Wishes pour in from cricket fraternity as batter turns 34

© Provided by Firstpost Happy Birthday Cheteshwar Pujara: Wishes pour in from cricket fraternity as batter turns 34 Indian batsman Cheteshwar Pujara turns 34 today (25 January). The Test cricketer’s ... Read more »

City's Alvarez talks progressing well over £17m deal

© Associated Press Manchester City are in talks to sign 21-year-old River Plate striker Julian Alvarez Manchester City’s talks to sign River Plate striker Julian Alvarez are progressing well, with ... Read more »

Ikea to open new London store next month

© PA Wire A new Ikea store will open in Hammersmith, west London, next month as the company increases its presence on the high street.(Andrew Matthews/PA) – PA Wire Ikea ... Read more »

AC Milan and Inter Milan Will Have A New Pitch Ready For The Derby After Poor State

© Photo by Francesco Scaccianoce/LiveMedia/NurPhoto via Getty Images La Gazzetta dello Sport spoke to the pitch manager of the San Siro, Giovanni Castelli regarding the condition of the ground. AC ... Read more »

Sensex, Nifty snap 5-day losing run as investors buy the dip

NEW DELHI: Benchmark indices bounced back on Tuesday after five consecutive days of fall as investors preferred to buy stocks at low levels. However, weak global cues kept gains in ... Read more »

Sue Gray's inquiry into No 10 parties to continue despite police investigation

© The Independent breaking-news.png Sue Gray’s inquiry into No 10 parties will carry on, despite the police announcing its own probe into the scandal – amid suggestions it would be ... Read more »

AO 2022: Kyrgios accidentally hits kid in the crowd, makes up with classy gesture

© Provided by The Indian Express Nick Kyrgios handed over a racket as a sympathetic gift for accidentally hitting a young fan and the umpire left her chair to check ... Read more »

Paramedics forced to apologise to patients for waiting before giving care

© PA Wire Ambulances parked outside the Royal London Hospital in December (PA) – PA Wire Paramedics are being forced to apologise to patients for delays as soon as they ... Read more »

EC ban on physical electioneering affects campaign material business

Ban on physical electioneering for the assembly polls amid a spurt in Covid cases has taken a toll on the shops selling publicity material with people in the business complaining ... Read more »

P283 million Army facility to rise in Fort Bonifacio

MANILA, Philippines — A state-of-the-art facility amounting to P283.4 million will be constructed for two units of the Philippine Army at Fort Bonifacio in Taguig, the Bases Conversion and Development ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin's lawyers appeal to have lawsuit over shooting on Rust film set thrown out

Alec Baldwin’s lawyers have appealed for a lawsuit brought against the actor over the fatal shooting on the set of his film, Rust, to be thrown out. © Sky News ... Read more »

Stones thrown in Hebron, near Cave of the Patriarchs

© (photo credit: JPOST STAFF) Breaking news Stones were thrown in Hebron near the Cave of the Patriarchs on Tuesday, Magen David Adom (MDA) announced.  MDA medics and paramedics provided ... Read more »

Happy birthday Xavi, the magician who once destroyed Real Madrid with FOUR assists

© GiveMeSport Xavi Barcelona icon Xavier Hernandez, or as most football fans will fondly remember him, Xavi, turns 42 years old today. Whilst the Spaniard has now retired and moved ... Read more »

Holly Willoughby expected negative reactions to wellness site Wylde Moon

© Provided by Cover Media Holly Willoughby Holly Willoughby expected some pushback from critics when she launched her wellness website Wylde Moon last year. The Dancing on Ice and This ... Read more »

World Bank blames Lebanon's rulers for economic meltdown

The Associated PressAnti-government protesters hold flares as they chant slogans to denounce the country’s deteriorating economic and financial conditions, in front of the Central Bank in Beirut, Lebanon, Sunday, Jan. ... Read more »

Why pet owners in Hong Kong are hiring private planes for their pets

“Private jet for your pet” is the kind of phrase you might expect to hear from a movie star or media mogul. © L’VOYAGE Olga Radlynska says her company has ... Read more »

City officials thrilled by return of spectators to Cape Town Met this weekend

The Cape Town Met returns on Saturday 29 January with the theme “Glam Garden” The Cape Met is one of the Mother City’s most celebrated and prestigious social events Artists ... Read more »

Istanbul airport stays shut as snow pummels Mediterranean

© Yasin AKGUL Monday’s blizzard in Istanbul shut the main airport and left much of the city at a standstill Europe’s busiest airport in Istanbul delayed its reopening on Tuesday ... Read more »

Labour inspectors turn attention to COVID impact on WC hospitality sector

© Kevin Brandt/Eyewitness News. Department of Employment and Labour inspectors are conducting “mega blitz inspections” targeting the hospitality sector in the Western Cape. CAPE TOWN – COVID-19’s impact on the ... Read more »

Marvel actor Vachik Mangassarian dies of Covid complications aged 78

Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D actor Vachik Mangassarian has died of Covid complications at the age of 78. He was best known for starring as Qasim Zaghlul in the Marvel Cinematic ... Read more »

All Refiner recipes in No Man's Sky

© Provided by GamePur Refining minerals and resources is a core part of No Man’s Sky. You’ll need to refine all sorts of items to create others so you can ... Read more »

Dublin actor who was struck by lightning premieres live show to audience in New York

David Gilna, a playwright and actor from Swords in north county Dublin, impressed audiences and critics in the Big Apple with the world premiere of his very own show A ... Read more »

Huge WhatsApp update coming that you shouldn't ignore – how to use it

WHATSAPP has come up with a new way to keep hackers out of your chats amid a raft of scams. A growing number of users have lost their account or ... Read more »

Iliad launches fixed line offer in Italy at 15.99 euros/mth for existing clients

© Reuters/STEFANO RELLANDINI FILE PHOTO: A guest speaks on a mobile phone as she arrives for the French telecoms operator Iliad’s media conference in Milan MILAN (Reuters) – France’s Iliad ... Read more »

Marks and Spencer spark debate as shoppers label new £45 dress 'really poor'

Recently high street brand Marks and Spencer has become quite the hot topic after launching their new spring collection. From selling a very close replica of Kate Middleton’s £390 iconic ... Read more »

Xbox series X stock news - live: EE and Argos restocks continue into 25 January

LIVE – Updated at 09:49 Update: The Xbox series X bundle is still available in some Argos stores and for EE customers. Read on for more details. The Xbox series X ... Read more »

Collin Morikawa has a lot to work on ahead of Dubai Desert Classic

Open champion Collin Morikawa has hit the reset button on his game as he bids to get back to winning ways in Dubai Morikawa could have become world number one ... Read more »

'To not utilize big opportunity shows he needs to increase his maturity level': Kaneria calls out reckless India batter

© Provided by Hindustan Times ‘To not utilize big opportunity shows he needs to increase his maturity level’: Danish Kaneria calls out reckless India batter Rishabh Pant (REUTERS) India’s 3-0 ... Read more »

JSE set for rebound after Monday's global selloff

© Provided by Business Live The JSE was firmer on Tuesday morning, on track to reverse Monday losses that saw the local bourse drop the most since the Covid-19 pandemic ... Read more »

A Las Vegas Casino is offering interns $15 an hour, free accommodation, and the chance to work on the gaming floor

© Station Casinos Interns will be given the chance to work on a Las Vegas gaming floor at some of Station’s casinos. Station Casinos Station Casinos is giving interns the ... Read more »

Cressida Dick confirms Met police will investigate Downing Street parties – live updates

LIVE – Updated at 10:22 Latest updates: commissioner tells MPs allegations over lockdown parties will be investigated. 10:22 Q: Is the alleged party at CCHQ included? Dick says there have ... Read more »

9 mistakes job seekers made on their résumés in 2021 – and how to avoid them

© Provided by INSIDER One small mistake on your resume could sink your job application. damircudic/Getty Images Bad spelling and unexplained career gaps were among the most common mistakes on ... Read more »

Maruti Suzuki Q3 Results | Standalone Profit falls 48%, revenue stays flat at Rs 23,246 crore

© Sunil Matkar Maruti Suzuki Q3 Results | Standalone Profit falls 48%, revenue stays flat at Rs 23,246 crore The country’s largest car maker Maruti Suzuki India Limited on January 25 ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic