How to deal with Suez contractual claims

After the Suez Canal incident last month causing wide disruption to global trade, attention has been turned to the legal implications surrounding the issue. Tony Nguyen,  founder and senior partner of legal consultancy firm EPLegal, discusses the varying laws and contracts that could come into play.

Ever Given, Suez Canal, Ever Given, Suez Canal
Tony Nguyen, founder and senior partner of legal consultancy firm EPLegal

The Ever Given container ship, wedged in the Suez Canal for almost one week before it was finally freed from the shoreline, had an adverse impact on about 12 per cent of global trade. Around one million barrels of oil and roughly 8 per cent of liquefied natural gas passes through the canal each day, and it was estimated by Lloyd’s List that the crisis cost $400 million per hour in delayed goods. It was also projected that the canal’s revenues were taking a $14-15 million hit for each day of the blockage.

This was not the first time the Suez Canal was blocked, causing huge damages to one of the world’s most vital shipping routes. The closing of the Suez Canal for five months in November 1956 due to war triggered a number of British and American decisions involving claims of frustration of contract.

In 1967, the canal turned into a battleground between Israel and Egypt during national conflicts and was blocked for eight years. In three other circumstances (2004, 2006, and 2017) a large tanker and two cargo/container vessels got lodged in the waterway and caused the canal to be blocked for respectively three days, eight hours, and three hours.

All these accidents would invite a wave of claims due to the delays or cancellation of shipments via the canal. These claims generally arise between the buyers and sellers of goods being transported; the contract of carriage between the charterers and the ship owners/carriers; and parties in service and construction contracts utilising goods being transported. Would these claims be easily rejected by the fact that the accidents are by nature force majeure (FM) events and the parties in breach should be exempted from liability?

We can analyse the legal issue in the context of (i) English laws, being the most frequently applied laws to international trade contracts, (ii) the UN Convention on the Contracts for International Sales of Goods (CISG) – the substantive provisions applied to the buyers and sellers of goods which have their places of business in member states, and (iii) Vietnamese laws. The common element in these three jurisdictions is that they all require the event to be ‘unexpected’ to the party in breach. It is without doubt that the Suez events are qualified for this condition. But there are other conditions to be met.

English laws

Under English law, contractual performance will be excused due to unexpected circumstances only if they fall within the doctrine of frustration; or where the parties agree otherwise (most likely a ‘FM clause’) in their contract. The test of frustration is a very high threshold: it only applies where the events make the performance of the contract impossible, illegal, or radically different from that originally envisioned by the parties.

In the first Suez event waive of cases, the buyer and seller disputed over the alleged breach of failure to ship the goods via Suez Canal under a sales contract which applied Form No.38 of the Incorporated Oil Seed Association Forms of Contract.

It was found that closure of the canal increased the length of the voyage necessary for delivery from 2,300 to 10,500 miles (to go through the alternative Cape of Good Hope). The cost of shipment was raised from about £6 ($8.2) per tonne to between £27-29 ($37-39.8) per tonne.

The court held that “in the present case an unexpected event occurred, namely, the closure of the Suez Canal, and no doubt it may be said to have involved both inconvenience and material loss. But I am not satisfied that there was also such a change in the significance of the obligation as would call the principle of frustration into play.”

Thus, the fact that the alternative route for shipment of goods via Cape of Good Hope would incur huge additional costs to the obligor will not excuse them from liability. Similar results are expected for a contract of carriage between a charterer and a carrier, except that if the contract specifies that cargo should be shipped via the Suez, then the blockage would have frustrated the contract.


Article 79.1 of the CISG provides a more specific description of the conditions for an “impediment” which stop a party from performing a contract: “A party is not liable for a failure to perform any of his obligations if he proves that the failure was due to an impediment beyond his control and that he could not reasonably be expected to have taken the impediment into account at the time of the conclusion of the contract or to have avoided or overcome it or its consequences.”

According to Professor John Honnold, the term “impediment” must be interpreted to read that the event actually prevents performance. This also implies that an event that makes performance commercially impracticable does not satisfy the test.

The other conditions of an “impediment” under the CISG are (i) beyond a party’s control; (ii) the affected party could not reasonably anticipate the impediment at the time of signing the contract; and (iii) the affected party could not reasonably avoid or overcome it or its consequences. “Reasonably” means what a normal person in such circumstances knew or should have known at the time of signing the contract.

In addition, the affected party must inform the other party of the impediment and its effect on his ability to perform within a reasonable time, otherwise he will be held liable for damages resulting from such non-receipt (Article 79.4).

Putting the Suez events in context, it seems that a seller or carrier would face the same problem if he tries to avoid liability based on Article 79 of the CISG. It is theoretically possible (though commercially impractical) to have shipments via alternative routes and the very first condition of impediment is not met.

Notably, the affected party may seek to amend the contract using another doctrine under the CISG and the UNIDROIT (International Institute for the Unification of Private Law) Principles: hardship. It has been widely established by the academics that Article 79 of the CISG applies to hardship situations, and the UNIDROIT Principles may be applied to fill in the gap of Article 79 while determining the consequence of hardship.

Accordingly, if a hardship situation is established under Article 79, the affected party may request renegotiation of prices and/or terms (but he may not withhold performance). Upon failure to reach agreement within a reasonable time, either party may resort to the court, who will then terminate, or adapt the contract with a view to restoring its equilibrium.

Vietnamese laws

Vietnam has recognised FM since 1995 and the definition of FM is currently stipulated in the Civil Code 2015. Accordingly, an event is an FM if it satisfies the following three conditions: being objective; being unforeseeable; and cannot be overcome despite taking all necessary and possible measures.

The last condition means that the event must be an impediment that could not be overcome despite the affected party’s attempt to implement all solutions. The Suez events therefore shall not give rise to an exemption of the obligor despite the impact of these events.

In terms of hardship, Article 420.1 of the Civil Code 2015 renders the concept of “a fundamental change in circumstance” to describe hardship, and provides a solution to hardship situations which is similar to the UNIDROIT Principles.

Given the situation of the recent Suez Canal incident, applying English laws, the CISG, or Vietnamese laws will result in the same consequence: contractual claims against the party affected by the blockage will likely succeed. However, the party in breach may declare a hardship situation in a timely manner and request renegotiation of the contract prices and/or other terms with a view to restore the economic balance of the contract.

News Related


The PAN Group to press on with Bibica and VFC acquisitions

The PAN Group rush in acquiring Bibica and VFC The PAN Group announced these goals on the occasion of publishing the group’s financial statement for the first quarter this year. However, the company… Read more »

Trademark trickery blurs rice status

ST25 was voted World’s Best Rice at the award ceremony of the same name in 2019, Photo: Le Toan It is currently not possible to determine whether the United States Patent and Trademark… Read more »

Questions over air titans’ funding plans

Airlines are looking at new ways to raise funds after a terrible situation for aviation in 2020 According to Pham The Anh, chief economist at the Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research,… Read more »

Beer battle ahead shakes up goals

Beer battle ahead shakes up goals. Source: Although domestic brewers have been faced with social restrictions during the pandemic and stricter regulations on road traffic to keep beer lovers safer, this year’s… Read more »

Pandemic fluctuations persist in Vietnamese labour market

High determination and great efforts to fulfil the dual goal of containing the spread of the pandemic and promoting economic growth have somewhat improved the bleak domestic labour and employment situation. However, the… Read more »

Collective wage talks key to aiding growth

Collective wage talks key to aiding growth The Vietnam General Confederation of Labour (VGCL) has raised two proposals related to minimum wage for workers. What is the role of grassroots trade unions in… Read more »

Vingroup steps up overseas investment to realise global ambitions

Vingroup soaring overseas investment Vietnam’s overseas investment in the first four months of the year has increased sharply thanks to the expansion of Vingroup to markets like France, the Netherlands, Canada, Singapore, Germany,… Read more »

M&A expected to soar in second half

News of a couple of big M&A deals are warming up the market During the pandemic, investment into M&A reduced significantly, while newly-registered and additional investment decreased by a smaller rate, with occasional rises.… Read more »

Export-import turnover hits 10-year record

Export-import activities have been thriving in the first four months of the year Domestic businesses exported $25.76 billion worth of goods and services, up 12.8 per cent on-year and accounting for 24.8 per… Read more »

PDP8 expected to be tabled for government approval in June

The draft Power Development Plan 8 will have to undergo one more round of tweaks At the meeting between ministries and relevant authorities, which was hosted by Le Van Thanh, Deputy Prime Minister… Read more »

Nestlé, Formosa, and four others expand investment in Dong Nai

The Formosa Industries Corporation project is the first Taiwanese project at Nhon Trach 3 Industrial Zone (IZ) of Dong Nai province. Formosa has increased capital by $12.7 million to roughly $1.64 billion. Nestlé… Read more »

Ninh Binh proposes to build airport and remove thermal power plant

Ninh Binh has proposed building an airport and removing a thermal power plant In a report submitted to the prime minister, the province requested adding its own airport to the national airport planning in… Read more »

Vietravel suffers more than $3 million in losses over first quarter

Vietravel keeps ailing from COVID-19 Vietnam Travel and Marketing Transport JSC (Vietravel) has just published its financial report for the first quarter of 2021,showing a 65 per cent drop in revenue on-year to… Read more »

It’s never too late to optimise M&A value

Le Khanh Lam, tax partner at RSM Vietnam Organisations have the best intentions and normally develop a global strategy when approaching a merger or acquisition (M&A). Short cuts, limited resources and potential missteps… Read more »

Qualcomm contributing to domestic IP awareness

Qualcomm’s Thieu Phuong Nam explains why IPs are crucial for startups Nothing underlines this better than the amendments to the Law on Intellectual Property, which are set to be presented at the National… Read more »

Indian coronavirus strain found in Vietnam

Vietnam’s Ministry of Health (MoH) said on April 30 that four Indian experts and a Vietnamese man working at a hotel where they were quarantined have been infected with the Indian variant of… Read more »

BASF makes strong start to 2021

BASF was able to carry over the tailwinds from the strong fourth quarter of 2020 into the first quarter of 2021 “BASF had a strong start to the year 2021. We were able… Read more »

Vietnamese Plywood Branch wants to recheck the export of veneer products

Many local exporters specialised in veneer products have been suspected of falsifying prices to reduce export tax. According to the document, the branch has received plenty of feedback about massive export volumes of… Read more »

Vietnam gov’t encourages foreign investment into banking sector

The Vietnamese government encourages foreign investment into local credit institutions in a bid to enhance efficiency and safety of the banking sector.  Deputy Prime Minister Pham Binh Minh (r) and SMFG’s General Manager… Read more »

Foreign partners help to lay foundations for Vietnam’s rise

Industry insiders advise a shift from wooing foreign direct investment in high numbers towards higher quality, photo Le Toan Pham Minh Chinh Prime Minister Ministries, agencies, and localities are required to implement in… Read more »

Experts suggest issuing gov’t bonds on international capital market

The issuance of government bonds in international capital market is an option to mobilize funds for socio-economic investment projects in the coming time.  Since 2005 to date, Vietnam has issued government bonds in… Read more »

Phu Yen emerges as attractive market for tourism and property investment

The central province of Phu Yen is emerging as an attractive market for real estate investment, especially in large-scale hospitality projects.   Two luxury resort complexes of Xuan Dai Bay and Crystal Holidays Marina… Read more »

Cooperation crucial to build competent auto industry

Local automobile businesses are dependent on major foreign car manufacturers and their core technologies, a sticking point for true progress, photo Le Toan Vietnam has received praise for its control of the pandemic,… Read more »

Stock market has been ‘out of position’?

The market liquidity suddenly went down, the VN-Index still recorded increasing sessions but the “bounce” was getting worse. This seems to be a reflection of investors’ expectations that are not as much as… Read more »

New feed groups attempt to outmuscle top performers

Feed group sales are rising, but the competition is fierce with more farms outsourcing for husbandry companies. Photo: Le Toan As the largest animal feed production country in Southeast Asia, the sector in… Read more »

GDVC licenses Hateco Group’s customs clearance site for post and courier items

From April 29, the customs clearance site of Hateco Group (operated by Hateco Fulfillment) is allowed to receive post and courier items. They will be transported independently from international land border gates, international… Read more »

Actual FDI to Vietnam rises nearly 7% in four-month period

Disbursement of foreign direct investment (FDI) to Vietnam rose by 6.8% year-on-year in the first four months of this year to US$5.5 billion, a report of the Foreign Investment Agency (FIA) under the… Read more »

Chinese growth offering regional food for thought

Global economic performance post-pandemic will, for better or worse, be affected by the success or otherwise of China. Photo: Le Toan Ballooning exports have helped China’s GDP grow a record 18.3 per cent… Read more »

New wave of high-tech ventures await entry

Director general of the Ministry of Planning and Investment’s (MPI) Foreign Investment Agency (FIA) Do Nhat Hoang confirmed that the number of South Korean investors setting eyes on Vietnam has been increasing, even… Read more »

Crafting specific measures to ensure top-quality growth

Jonathan Ostry, deputy director of the International Monetary Fund’s Asia and Pacific Department The Vietnamese economy grew 2.91 per cent in 2020 and 4.48 per cent in the first quarter of 2021. How… Read more »

DDCI complements PCI findings to improve business environment

Dr. Le Duy Binh, managing director of management consultants Economica Vietnam The PCI is fairly popular in Vietnam as a means of assessing innovation and competitiveness among localities. Why is an additional DDCI… Read more »

Dragon Capital-related fund prepares to ‘pour’ over VND 1,000 billion into Vietnam’s stock market through VFMVSF

At the end of the first quarter, VFMVFS had 24 stocks, of which HPG was the largest share with 12.52%. Vietnam DC25 is holding 83.42 million VFMVSF fund certificates. Vietnam DC25 Ltd., a… Read more »

Stock judgment April 29: Hope is only rekindled

Final structure date for domestic ETFs (Neutral) Vn-Index is forecasted to struggle with fluctuations in the next session. The index might challenge resistant level of 1.235-1.248 points. Tomorrow, investment funds according to the… Read more »

Many large stocks increased strongly, VN-Index increased nearly 9 points

15:00 At the end of the session, the demand increased again and helped pull many key stocks to increase, so the indices also extended the green color. In which, VPB increased 3.4%, VRE… Read more »

Digital transformation of technology stocks

Digital transformation will boost the growth of the information technology industry in the period 2021-2025, along with the growth of the broadband segment will open up investment opportunities in this group of stocks.… Read more »

SABECO tries its best to usher a brighter 2021 despite challenges ahead

SABECO tries its best to usher a brighter 2021 despite challenges ahead Vietnam’s biggest brewer has set a target revenue of VND 33.49 trillion ($1.33 billion) and net profits of VND5.2 trillion ($208… Read more »

Amazon announced to strengthen collaboration with iDEA

The two parties will jointly support Vietnamese sellers with cross-border e-commerce workshops and training series, aiming to provide them with skills and knowledge to capture global opportunities of transforming online. Simultaneously, Amazon Global… Read more »

Local steelmakers red hot on investment

Vietnam’s steel industry is now ranked in the top 15 biggest worldwide, photo Le Toan In particular, locally-invested steelmaker Hoa Phat Group surpassed Taiwan’s Hung Nghiep Formosa Ha Tinh to become Vietnam’s largest… Read more »

Uphill prospects in M&A activity through to 2022

Uphill prospects in M&A activity through to 2022 According to partner from Mazars Jack Nguyen, mergers and acquisitions (M&A) will be active for the remainder of 2021 as the Vietnamese market prepares itself… Read more »

The keys to M&A attraction

Pham Duy Khuong Managing director ASL LAW Besides, it is also one of the countries that have been able to control the COVID-19 epidemic, creating a safer environment for foreign investors. This encourages… Read more »

Index results spark reforms in Vietnamese metropolises

While some provinces have become shining examples in Vietnam’s PCI, its metropolises are lagging behind. Photo: Le Toan According to the Korea Chamber of Business in Vietnam (KorCham), Hanoi is planning to organise… Read more »

New General Director takes the lead of Shinhan Finance

Having been working for Shinhan Card (Korea), the parent company of Shinhan Vietnam Finance Company (Shinhan Finance), for more than 26 years, Oh Taejoon has a wealth of experience in risk management, business… Read more »

ADB forcasts Vietnam’s economic growth to rebound to 6.7 per cent this year

ADB highlighted bright prospects for the Vietnamese economy  “Stagnant domestic consumption and weak external demand caused by the COVID-19 pandemic slowed down Vietnam’s economy last year, but the growth momentum remains strong this… Read more »

Japfa inaugurates pig farm with 10,000 sows in Binh Phuoc province

The launching ceremony of Japfa Vietnam’s pig farm with 10,000 sows in Binh Phuoc  The 22-hectare farm is aimed to supply breeding piglets of the best quality for the domestic market and for… Read more »

Creaking infrastructure bites into rail network’s potential

There are complexities in funnelling through funding in a timely manner so that the railway sector can modernise itself Leaders of Petrolimex Hanoi – a unit of Vietnam National Petroleum Group (Petrolimex) –… Read more »

Safety on the line for railway system in stagnation crisis

Vu Anh Minh, chairman of Vietnam Railways There are different ideas in Vietnam about how much state funding should be allocated for railway maintenance this year, which is causing difficulties for the industry… Read more »

Foreign companies ramp up investment in tyre production

Foreign investors are increasing tyre production capacity in Vietnam  Kumho Tire, one of the world’s leading tyre manufacturers, has today that they will be investing $305 million to expand upon their Vietnam tyre plant… Read more »

UNDP urges better business practices

Businesses in Vietnam need to go beyond the bare minimum laid out in regulations. Photo: Shutterstock At last week’s launch of a study on corporate awareness and implementation of responsible business practices (RBP)… Read more »

Indian investors seek investment opportunities in Vietnam

Indian authorities and businesses wish to have a greater presence in Vietnam by cooperating with local enterprises in the southern Vietnam in diverse aspects such as agriculture, industry, machinery and equipment, healthcare, education,… Read more »

Risks at the fore in global wood trade

The wood industry has to take into account developments in US-China trade as well as South Korean anti-dumping probes. Photo: Le Toan “The Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development has received documents from… Read more »