How times change: the Turnbulls face off against an old friend, seeking millions

The Turnbull family and Sydney fund manager Russel Pillemer are facing off in the NSW Supreme Court — but it is not the first time those names have appeared on a witness list. 

© Provided by Crikey

Crikey readers with long memories will recall that Malcolm Turnbull and Pillemer were both up before the HIH royal commission in 2003, giving evidence about their dealings with Rodney Adler and FAI Insurances. Suffice to say, the noble profession of investment banking did not cover itself in glory.  

This current court action dates back to the relationship the two forged while working together at Goldman Sachs Australia. After leaving the bank — where they advised Adler and FAI — they started up boutique funds management business Pengana Capital Group in 2003. But when Turnbull went into politics in 2004, it became an issue — for any politician, the potential conflicts of interest in running an investment business are too problematic.

The evidence from this case is that in 2008 he lent the shares to Pillemer and eventually sold them to him in 2017 for $6.1 million.  

© Provided by Crikey

Triple A credit rating endorses economic leadership of … Malcolm Turnbull

In November 2015, two months after Turnbull became prime minister, he transferred the loan to the plaintiff in this matter, Maurtray Pty Ltd, a company owned and operated by the two Turnbull children: Alex and Daisy. 

Alex Turnbull gave evidence yesterday that at the time of the share sale, Pillemer hadn’t told him that Pengana was about to merge with investment house Hunter Hall. This “misleading and deceptive conduct” could have increased the value of the Turnbull family’s stake in Pengana by millions, he claims. Maurtray is suing Pillemer for damages of up to $12 million. 

Alex Turnbull was giving evidence from Singapore. He denied he changed his evidence on the instruction of his father and that he ­deliberately tried to conceal his ­father’s stake in Pengana while he was PM. 

How times change. Back in the late ’90s, everything was smooth sailing between Turnbull Sr and Pillemer. 

‘Business opportunities’

The former PM told the HIH royal commission that Pillemer spoke to him in 1997: “My recollection is that Mr Pillemer said to me he thought there could be some business opportunities in and around FAI and did I know [chief executive] Mr [Rodney] Adler, and I said I did, and he said: ‘Well, why don’t we go and have a chat to him?’ So we did. That’s what investment bankers do.”

Turnbull recalled that he had probably first met the Adler through business in the late 1980s. HIH launched a $300 million takeover bid for FAI in September 1998, and the FAI board retained Goldman Sachs for financial advice.

It was a long and sorry saga, but HIH eventually went under with total losses of $5.3 billion, earning the title of the largest corporate collapse in Australia’s history. 

Pengana Capital earned a profit of $8.7 million last financial year. The last annual report records $2.34 million paid for “aggregate compensation” to directors and key management, with Pillemer earning $636,293.

Bird of prey

Pengana is the name of an ancient bird of prey, with special ankle joints that enabled it to bend its feet in all directions. The group’s website says: “This made it an expert hunter, with a significant competitive advantage. It not only had the ability to identify its prey from a long distance, but also to use its flexible joints to reach into hard to access places, giving it the ability to extract prey unavailable to its competitors.” 

Are the Turnbulls more agile than an ancient bird of prey? The case continues, with Alex Turnbull still in the witness box this morning.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Condoleezza Rice spars with The View host while discussing Capitol riot

© Provided by Washington Examiner Condoleezza Rice won’t be interrupted. The former secretary of state appeared Wednesday on The View as a guest host, but it didn’t take long for ... Read more »

What time is Dune released on HBO Max today?

What time is Dune streaming on HBO Max today? Denis Villeneuve’s sci-fi epic has been brought forward by a day to match its release date in theaters – so Dune ... Read more »

Kengo Kuma to add contemporary entrance to gothic cathedral in Angers

Japanese studio Kengo Kuma and Associates has unveiled plans for a contemporary entrance gallery to protect the sculptural doorway at Angers Cathedral, France. © Provided by Dezeen Angers Cathedral entrance ... Read more »

Boris Johnson's government accused of being 'willfully negligent' as UK Covid cases mount

Britain’s doctors’ union has accused Boris Johnson’s government of being “willfully negligent” in its handling of the latest wave of the Covid-19 pandemic, as ministers refuse to introduce mitigation measures ... Read more »

Tata Motors DVR share price rises 10% after Rakesh Jhunjhunwala raises stake

© Rakesh Patil Tata Motors DVR share price rises 10% after Rakesh Jhunjhunwala raises stake Tata Motors DVR share price rose 10 percent on October 21 to close at Rs ... Read more »

YouTube aims to reduce borderline content views from recommendations to below 0.5%

© Provided by Business Today YouTube aims to reduce borderline content views from recommendations to below 0.5%  The consumption of borderline content that comes from YouTube’s recommendations is significantly below ... Read more »

TMC plans mass outreach programme before Tripura municipal polls

The Tripura unit of the Trinamool Congress is gearing up with a mass outreach programme ahead of the municipal elections in the state. The outreach programme comes almost a year ... Read more »

Bangladesh, Fabindia episodes show Hindus are easy targets; they need to learn to defend themselves

© Provided by Firstpost Bangladesh, Fabindia episodes show Hindus are easy targets; they need to learn to defend themselves There is no doubt in my mind that the Narendra Modi-led ... Read more »

PBB vice-president hints at impending polls in Sarawak

© Provided by MalaysiaNow Sarawak Parti Pesaka Bumiputera Bersatu (PBB) vice-president Abdul Karim Rahman Hamzah today said the overdue election in the state might be called by the end of ... Read more »

Floods force evacuations in Larut, Matang and Selama

© Provided by New Straits Times IPOH: Heavy rain since yesterday triggered floods in the Larut, Matang and Selama districts, forcing 57 people to evacuate their homes as of 3pm ... Read more »

Small-scale tuna fishermen in Luzon obtain international sustainability certification

© Provided by BusinessWorld By Patricia Mirasol The Philippine Tuna Handline Partnership (PTHP) is the first group of small-scale fishers and tuna processors in the Philippines to earn a Marine ... Read more »

Turkey's Erdogan blasts ambassadors' call for philanthropist's release

© Reuters/PRESIDENTIAL PRESS OFFICE Turkish President Erdogan speaks during a news conference in Ankara ISTANBUL (Reuters) – President Tayyip Erdogan slammed ambassadors of 10 countries, including the United States, Germany ... Read more »

Hospitality trade fears going under if UK imposes new Covid ‘plan B'

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Charles Stirling/Alamy Pubs, bars, restaurants and hotels would be driven under if the government imposes “plan B” restrictions to curb the rise in Covid-19 ... Read more »

Sainsbury's shoppers gobsmacked after price glitch lists kettles and toasters for 0p

A price glitch on the Sainsbury’s website saw the supermarket list several kitchen appliances for free. Items that were spotted selling for 0p online included the Cookworks Brushed New 2 ... Read more »

FIFA 22 RTTK: Road To The Knockouts Upgrades, How To Obtain And All You Need To Know

© GiveMeSport FIFA 22 RTTK Upgrade Opportunities FIFA 22 and its Road To The Knockout promo continues as the 2021/22 campaign passes the halfway stage in the respective European Group ... Read more »

KKM lanjut pemberian dos penggalak kepada penerima Sinovac

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Khairy Jamaluddin berkata, dos penggalak secara heterologous akan diberikan kepada individu berumur 60 tahun ke atas berdasarkan saranan WHO. KUALA LUMPUR: Kementerian Kesihatan (KKM) ... Read more »

UK's Shell Energy to take on customers of failed supplies GOTO Energy

© Reuters/Toby Melville FILE PHOTO: A Shell petrol station in London (Reuters) – Britain’s energy market regulator Ofgem said on Thursday it has appointed Royal Dutch Shell’s power retail business ... Read more »

New power line to electrify important ferry routes in Northern Norway

The Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Directorate (NVE) approved the power line in Hamarøy Municipality, which will enable the electrification of the ferries from Bognes – the only ferry connection ... Read more »

OMG! You Can Now Get Birthday Cake Flavoured Baileys

Baileys has to be one of the most delicious drinks out there. It’s creamy, boozy and indulgent. And that’s just the original flavour. Don’t get us started on all the ... Read more »

How does Formula 1 move cars between races?

It’s one of the biggest logistical challenges in sport, but how do Formula 1 teams move hundreds of tons of equipment across the world, from week to week? © AFP ... Read more »

Baby girl, 16 months, 'murdered' by mother and partner who 'stamped on her'

Star Hobson, 16 months, suffered catastrophic injuries and died in hospital. (GoFundMe) A 16-month-old baby girl was stamped on by her mother and her bouncer partner who then tried to ... Read more »

Springfield man granted probation on abuse of girlfriend's son

Oct. 21—MOUNT VERNON, Mo. — A 30-year-old Springfield man was assessed a suspended imposition of sentence and probation when he pleaded guilty this month to physical abuse of his Mount ... Read more »

The Best Men's Winter Coats, Because It's Big Coat Season

© Getty Images The chill is on its way. Prepare in style © Getty Images winter coats Each year, sensationalist headlines doth appear: “the coldest WINTER in 30 YEARS” and ... Read more »

Bosses tell Boris Johnson: Act now to avoid tougher Covid restrictions

© PA Wire Prime Minister’s Questions Business chiefs have urged Boris Johnson to reimpose some Covid restrictions such as mandatory masks on the Tube — warning that “indecision is our ... Read more »

Matsuyama shines on home soil at Zozo

© Associated Press Hideki Matsuyama is one off the lead after a 64 Hideki Matsuyama was energised by the support from his home fans as he enjoyed another excellent start ... Read more »

Dream.risk.sing review – women's stories told in idiosyncratic song

The Oxford lieder festival has grown since its 2002 inception, with 100-plus events this year: ample room for big names singing the famous song cycles, and a heartening amount of ... Read more »

Not just NatWest: Compliance guru on why money laundering is rampant in the City

© Provided by City AM Over the past few decades, money laundering has become an increasingly prevalent issue. Financial institutions are constantly looking for new ways to fight money launderers, and several anti-money laundering ... Read more »

Jake Paul to train with former Tyson Fury opponent for fight with brother Tommy

Jake Paul has drafted in former cruiserweight world champion Steve Cunningham to help with his preparations for his bout with Tommy Fury. Paul will face Fury, who is the younger ... Read more »

Lorry plunges into Bristol harbour

© LBC / Twitter A lorry has plunged into Bristol harbour – LBC / Twitter A lorry has plunged into Bristol Harbour, with images showing the vehicle nearly upright as ... Read more »

Bill Clinton ‘touched by outpouring of support' as he continues recovery

Former US president Bill Clinton has released a video saying he is on the road to recovery after being admitted to hospital in California for six days to treat an ... Read more »

Billie Eilish Debuts Fragrance In Body Inspired Bottle

© Provided by Lehren Billie Eilish Debuts Fragrance In Body Inspired Bottle The pop star Billie Eilish recently announced that she is set to release her first fragrance, Eilish, calling ... Read more »

Astro talk: 3 Zodiac signs that are secretive

There’s a difference between being private and secretive. While it is good to keep certain things private, what is not is to be secretive all the time. Since this can ... Read more »

Keith Sequeira Shares How Couple Counselling Helped Reignite The Spark In His Marriage

The pandemic has been tough for everyone, especially for couples who are cooped up in their homes for almost two years now. People are struggling to keep up the romance ... Read more »

Amazon has launched a week of early Christmas present deal sales

AMAZON has launched a week of early Christmas present deals and you can get up to 50% off gadgets, beauty products and toys. The online retail giant has launched a ... Read more »

6 long weekends in 2022 after Muis revised Hari Raya dates

SINGAPORE — Mark your calendar for another long weekend in 2022. The changes in the 2022 public holidays calendar come after Singapore Islamic authority Muis revised the two Hari Raya ... Read more »

Southwest Airlines posts smaller loss on strong travel demand

© Reuters/JOE SKIPPER A Southwest Airlines jet sits at a gate at Orlando International Airport in Orlando (Reuters) – Southwest Airlines Co posted a smaller third-quarter loss on Thursday as ... Read more »

Kanton Bern will mit Steuergesetzrevision Solaranlagen fördern

Der Kanton Bern will im Rahmen der Steuergesetzrevision 2024 die Solarkraft fördern. Auf eine allgemeine Steuersenkung verzichtet er. © Foto: Keystone Neu sollen Photovoltaik- und Solarthermieanlagen den Eigenmietwert nicht mehr ... Read more »

Pantech's 2Q net profit rises 42.76% to RM15m, declares one sen dividend

© Provided by The Edge KUALA LUMPUR (Oct 21): Pantech Group Holdings Bhd’s net profit rose 42.76% to RM15.31 million for the second quarter ended Aug 31, 2021 (2QFY22), from ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic