How nuclear power could help rising power bills and climate change

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo

Australia’s embrace of nuclear-powered submarines begs the question: isn’t it time the country dropped its opposition to atomic energy?

Nuclear power has effectively been banned in Australia since 1998 under Commonwealth legislation, including the enrichment of uranium, the element needed to produce nuclear energy in reactors.

But the decision to develop nuclear-powered submarines in Australia as part of an upgraded defence capability, announced on Thursday morning by Prime Minister Scott Morrison, shapes as a turning point for the place of atomic energy in our energy mix.

Australia’s aim to preferably achieve zero carbon emissions by 2050, without firm detail as yet on how it will achieve the target, is another motivation to change our attitude to nuclear power. 

While nuclear power plants are expensive to build and the disposal of the radioactive waste they generate is controversial, nuclear energy has the potential to significantly reduce power bills for Australians and accelerate our emissions reductions as we phase out legacy fuels like coal. 

( ( (

For a start, nuclear power is recognised as a clean, zero emissions energy source.  

The Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) in the US claims the country avoided 476 metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions in 2019 as a result of its use of nuclear energy in the grid, or the equivalent of removing 100 million cars from the road.  

‘If you want a proven way to get low carbon then nuclear energy has already proven itself,’ nuclear power campaigner Rob Parker told Daily Mail Australia in June.

‘No nation anywhere has achieved ultra low carbon by relying on wind and solar alone.’ 

Of course, the nuclear option still needs to overcome a PR problem with Aussies. 

Incidents at reactors such as Three-Mile Island (1979), Chernobyl (1986) and Fukushima (2011) often overshadow the benefits and long-term stability of the technology in many other places. 

But among industrialised nations, Australia is a laggard when it comes to atomic energy.

Nationals Leader Barnaby Joyce, a prominent supporter of Australia developing a nuclear industry, has previously described the nation as ‘living in a cave’ when it comes to the nuclear issue and has called for a repeal of laws blocking its introduction.   

‘I believe we should have nuclear power… and if people want zero emissions – well, this, this is it,’ Mr Joyce said in June.

‘I mean, you have your wind, you can have your solar, but if you want baseline, deliverable, 24/7 zero-emission power, then nuclear does it.’  

© Provided by Daily Mail (
© Provided by Daily Mail (

In 31 countries around the world, more than 450 nuclear power plants are connected to the grid. 


Video: Steven Marshall responds to plans to build nuclear-powered submarines in SA (ABC NEWS)

France counts on nuclear power for 75 percent of its electricity, and earns three billion Euros a year as a net exporter to other European nations because of its low cost of generation.

The French made the decision to embrace nuclear technology way back in the 1970s, after the OPEC oil crisis.

The US, Russia, China, the UK and Canada all include nuclear power in their energy mix, some of their reactors powered by uranium from Australia. 

Australia is home to a third of the world’s uranium, producing about 10 per cent of the world’s exports worth over $730million a year.

HOW NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS WORK 

1. Producing electricity from nuclear energy first requires splitting atoms to release the energy.

2. Nuclear reactors fuelled by uranium pellets produce atom-splitting nuclear fission.

3. As they split, atoms release particles which cause other atoms to split, causing a chain reaction. 

4. The chain reaction creates heat that warms a cooling agent such as water or liquid metal.

5. Steam is produced that powers turbines which feed energy to generators that produce electricity. 

The recurring sticking points in the development of a domestic nuclear industry are cost and bipartisan political support.

Nuclear power plants are widely recognised as expensive to build, but cheap to run. A large nuclear power plant costs in the vicinity of $40billion to construct. 

Options more suitable for Australia’s smaller population may lay in new-generation Small Modular Reactors (SMRs), or by following the example of the larger one-gigawatt plant with four reactors built by Korean company KEPCO at Barakah in the United Arab Emirates.

SMRs generating up to 300 megawatts of power are cheaper and quicker to build, helping nuclear compete with more economical renewables such as solar and wind. 

They can also be built underground and cooled with air rather than water, enhancing safety in their operation. 

SMRs also ‘load follow’, meaning the reactor adjusts output based on demand. 

But the technology remains under development, with its use of new materials, innovative safety features and advanced construction techniques yet to be approved by most international regulators.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has previously said development of a nuclear industry in Australia would require bipartisan political support, but the Labor Party remains opposed to enrichment and processing of uranium for use in a domestic reactor.

Of the three conditions under which Labor said it would support the new tripartite agreement on nuclear-powered submarines, the first was ‘that there be no requirement of a domestic civil nuclear industry’, ALP leader Anthony Albanese said on Thursday. 

© Provided by Daily Mail (
© Provided by Daily Mail (

What affect would adding nuclear power to our energy mix have on a bread-and-butter issue for millions of Australians: electricity bills?

Australia’s household electricity costs have gone from one of the cheapest in the OECD to one of the most expensive. The nominal price of electricity for Australian households rose from around $44 per megawatt hour in 1978 to around $332 per megawatt hour in 2018. 

An eFuture study by the CSIRO in 2012 estimated the inclusion of nuclear power in our energy mix could cut wholesale electricity prices by as much as 34-37 percent. 

The report also showed that incorporating nuclear into our energy mix from 2025 so that it provided around 55 percent of our electricity from 2040, would save Australia $130 billion in greenhouse gas abatement and $18 billion in health cost savings.

Australia has now conducted numerous inquiries into the possibility of a domestic nuclear industry, from the Switkowski Report in 2006 to South Australia’s Nuclear Fuel Cycle Royal Commission in 2016.

The ‘Not without your approval: a way forward for nuclear technology in Australia’ report by the Australian Parliament in 2019 re-emphasised the benefits of nuclear technology for climate change, energy reliability, and cheaper power for households and business. 

‘Australia should be strategic in its consideration of nuclear energy. This requires us to think about the next 50 years rather than the next five and also how we might enter the nuclear energy industry by learning from other countries while building our own sovereign capability,’ the report stated. 

While an increasing number of MPs at both Federal and state level are pushing for Australia to consider the ‘nuclear option’, others say the business case has not been made and community opposition remains too great.  

‘The greatest risk to it is public perception, not cost. …A major public awareness program will be the deciding factor to enable the successful introduction of nuclear energy into Australia,’ one submission to the parliamentary report noted. 

Mr Joyce believes Australians’ need for cheaper, more reliable power will overcome widespread opposition to the technology, going so far as to suggest free power for towns willing to host a reactor. 

‘You just have to come up with the right policy settings and they will accept it … People will think with their wallets,’ he said in 2019.

‘If you can see the reactor [from your house], your power is for free,’ he suggested. ‘If you are within 50 kilometres of a reactor, you get power for half price.’

But at the current rate of debate and discussion, the nuclear submarines to be built in Adelaide will be with us well before nuclear power is a part of our electricity grid.

THE CASE FOR AND AGAINST NUCLEAR POWER 

 FOR 

* Clean energy: Relative to coal and natural gas, nuclear is a zero-to-low emissions energy source that could more rapidly reduce our reliance on carbon, improving our emissions outlook in relation to the 2050 Paris Agreement target 

* Cheap, reliable power: As coal becomes uneconomic and older coal-fired power stations are decommissioned, Australia’s need for cheaper, reliable power grows. Nuclear power could complement renewable sources such as wind and solar, while avoiding any variability in supply associated with those technologies (the ‘when the wind doesn’t blow and the sun doesn’t shine’ argument)  

 * Long lifespan: Some plants are forecast to last 100 years, offsetting high initial construction costs. By contrast, replacement of renewables such as solar panels and wind turbines needs to occur every 10-20 years. 

* Advances in tech: New generation reactors such as Small Modular Reactors are designed to be smaller, safer, more efficient and quicker to construct.

AGAINST 

* Expense:  Many inquiries into the possibility of nuclear power in Australia have concluded that the business case is not made out. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) has previously estimated the cost of nuclear energy creation at an exorbitant $16,000 per kilowatt.

* Time lag: Most experts agree that even if Australia agreed to develop nuclear power, our first reactor would be another decade away from concept to construction and commissioning.

* Waste: New technology may see nuclear waste stored before it is reprocessed into new forms of fuel. Until that time, burying it within a geological deposit remains the most likely option for an Australian facility. Waste from Sydney’s Lucas Heights reactor, a facility producing medical isotopes, is currently transported to France and then returned as a by-product which is stored in cement canisters at the facility. 

 * Accidents: Incidents at nuclear power plants such as Chernobyl in 1986 and Fukushima in 2011 remain bad ads for nuclear energy, but as Barry Brook, an Australian environmental scientist who supports the development of nuclear power in Australia points out, ‘It’s not possible to design [a nuclear power plat] that’s risk-free… but that’s true of any sort of energy source or indeed, any large infrastructure we require.’

 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Here's everything Apple announced at its fall Mac event

On Monday, Apple held its second and likely last hardware event of the fall. “Unleashed” saw the company spend about an hour talking about updates to its Mac and Music ... Read more »

36 lakh, highest ever, to take CBSE Boards from Nov 16

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: The highest ever total of 36 lakh candidates, 4 lakh more than last year, have registered for the CBSE Board exams ... Read more »

Judge agrees to delay sentencing of former Gaetz associate as cooperation continues

A federal judge in Central Florida has granted a request from attorneys representing Joel Greenberg, the former tax collector of Seminole County, to delay his sentencing after prosecutors said Greenberg ... Read more »

UK Covid cases reach 50,000 in one day as No 10 warns of ‘challenging' winter

Downing Street has warned of “challenging” months ahead as UK coronavirus cases reached their highest level since mid-July. © Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Guy Bell/Rex/Shutterstock The reported number of ... Read more »

Hear AirPods, iMac as instruments in Start Up, a song made from Apple sounds

From iPods to Bono to GarageBand, Apple has long entwined itself with the music world. The company kicked off its Mac-focused “Unleashed” event on Monday with a creative homage to all ... Read more »

New Greens senator Dorinda Cox becomes fifth Indigenous woman in parliament — and she wants to be a 'beacon' for others

© Provided by ABC NEWS Dorinda Cox is the first Indigenous woman to serve as a senator for WA.  (Supplied) Disillusioned and burnt out at just 25, Dorinda Cox faxed off ... Read more »

Woman accused of trying to set fire at Jewish school arrested in New York City

A woman accused of attempting to set a New York City Jewish school on fire was arrested and charged on Sunday with reckless endangerment, a hate crime and attempted arson. ... Read more »

The Republican Party no longer has room for a Colin Powell Republican

When Colin Powell announced that he would not run for president in 1996, he also made a promise. © Brooks Kraft/Corbis/getty Images Secretary of State Colin Powell stands with President ... Read more »

NASA eyes solar array glitch on new Lucy asteroid spacecraft

© Provided by Space Lucy’s solar panels unfurled during spacecraft work before launch. Lucy will become the solar-powered spacecraft to venture the farthest from the sun. A new NASA spacecraft ... Read more »

Al Jazeera Digital wins Online Journalism Award

© Provided by Al Jazeera The series is hosted by veteran Al Jazeera journalist Malika Bilal [Al Jazeera] In a year marked by ongoing pandemic disruptions, Al Jazeera Digital’s news ... Read more »

Citi ThankYou Rewards adds its first hotel transfer partner

© Provided by The Points Guy MSN has partnered with The Points Guy for our coverage of credit card products. MSN and The Points Guy may receive a commission from ... Read more »

These Hallmark Christmas Suites Will Make You Feel Like You're in a Romantic Holiday Movie

© Provided by Travel + Leisure Courtesy of Club Wyndham Nashville Hallmark Channel holiday movies during its “Countdown to Christmas” have long been one of the coziest holiday traditions while ... Read more »

Lebanon Hezbollah chief declares militant group has 100,000 'trained' fighters

© Ramzi Haidar, AFP The head of Lebanon’s Hezbollah said Monday that his Iran-backed movement had 100,000 “trained” and “armed” fighters at its disposal, speaking after deadly violence in Beirut ... Read more »

MPs sit shoulder to shoulder at emotional service for Sir David Amess

Boris Johnson bowed his head as MPs from all parties sat shoulder to shoulder at an emotional church service for Sir David Amess. The Prime Minister sat beside his political ... Read more »

Spanish PM calls for king to be stripped of immunity

© Provided by The Telegraph Juan Carlos Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez said the monarch should be stripped of immunity from criminal prosecution in the wake of a series of ... Read more »

Lawyers defending war vets arrested for hostage drama oppose case extension

© Pool/Jacques Nelles. Accused military veterans in connection of the hostage situation with cabinet ministers at Pretoria Magistrates Court in Kgosi Mampuru II correctional services on 18 October 2021. JOHANNESBURG ... Read more »

Decision to increase gap between 2 Covid doses not political or due to shortage: Dr Bharti Pawar

© Provided by Hindustan Times The decision to increase or decrease the gap between two doses is based purely on scientific evidence and not political considerations or shortage of vaccines, ... Read more »

MEC Mamabolo: Govt, taxi associations need to resolve issues over routes

© Gauteng Health. FILE: Gauteng Transport MEC Jacob Mamabolo on a walkabout at Noord taxi rank on Tuesday, 22 June 2021. JOHANNESBURG – Gauteng Roads and Transport MEC Jacob Mamabolo ... Read more »

US can't defend against new Chinese hypersonic missiles, official warns

Visual China Group – Yan Zehua/Visual China Group America cannot defend against hypersonic missiles, a senior official warned, after China allegedly tested new weaponry in an accelerating global arms race. ... Read more »

Everything you need to know about macOS Monterey: Release date, new features, supported devices

© Provided by The Indian Express Apple announced macOS Monterey back in June this year alongside iOS 15, iPadOS 15 and watchOS 8. While Apple’s other software fronts have received ... Read more »

How Scott Disick helped stars align for Kourtney Kardashian, Travis Barker

Hot couple Kourtney Kardashian and Travis Barker got engaged over the weekend — but how did her ex, Scott Disick, help align the astrological stars for her? Getty Images “Forever” ... Read more »

Red Sox vs. Astros prediction: Fade this pitcher in ALCS Game 3

Ready for another edition of “Who Said It?”… “I don’t want to be hearing boos. I understand they have a right to be upset. At the same time I don’t ... Read more »

Loud explosion damages house in Ayr

An explosion at a house in Ayr has caused severe damage, with the blast being heard for miles around. Emergency services responded to calls to the residential Kincaidston area on ... Read more »

High oil prices to hurt world economic recovery: India to OPEC

© Provided by Zee Business India, the world’s third-largest energy consumer, has told Saudi Arabia and other OPEC nations that high oil prices will hurt the nascent economic recovery the ... Read more »

Princess Charlotte to be ‘richest young royal with net worth of £3.6billion'

© PA Media Princess Charlotte 6th birthday Princess Charlotte is set to become the richest young royal with an estimated net worth of £3.6billion, a new study revealed. It will ... Read more »

Scotland explosion: Rescue services called to house in Ayr after reports of huge blast

Emergency services are responding after an explosion at a house in Ayr. © Independent Breaking News Images on social media showed debris scattered on the street in the Kincaidston area. ... Read more »

BSP sees no rate adjustments this year

© Provided by BusinessWorld Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) Governor Benjamin E. Diokno said that moving too early on rate hikes may hurt the economy’s recovery, which is just starting ... Read more »

'Leadership is solving problems': General Colin Powell's rules for leadership and more

Colin Powell, whose decades-long career repeatedly made history and who was for years one of the Republican Party’s elder statesmen, often discussed his leadership philosophy, famously saying: “Leadership is solving ... Read more »

Pentagon chief to hold military talks in Georgia on first stop of Black Sea visit

US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin landed in Georgia Monday on the first leg of a visit to three allies on the Black Sea, aiming to deliver a message of support ... Read more »

Hazratganj lit up to dazzle, courtesy LMC

© Provided by Hindustan Times Hazratganj market in Lucknow has been decked up with colourful lights for the festive season. (HT Photo) The market of Hazratganj has been decked with colourful ... Read more »

1 killed in gunfight between two NSCN factions in Nagaland

© Provided by Hindustan Times It was learnt that since both groups are currently in a ceasefire agreement with the government of India. (Getty Images/iStockphoto) One person was killed in ... Read more »

Tony Fernandes reveals message Nahki Wells sent to him following QPR v Bristol City in September

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Coventry City v Bristol City Nahki Wells has scored goals at most clubs he has been at in the EFL, and his ... Read more »

State IG launches investigations into end of Afghanistan operations

The State Department’s inspector general is launching a series of investigations into the end of the Biden administration’s diplomatic operations in Afghanistan, according to State Department and congressional officials, as ... Read more »

Details of alleged Google-Facebook collusion must be made public, judge orders

Details in a lawsuit Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton (right) filed against Google have been kept secret — until now. Getty Images Details of alleged collusion between Google and Facebook ... Read more »

Energy chief offers to help 20 energy companies on brink of oblivion

Ecotricity’s founder, Dale Vince, wrote to the energy firms after the forced market exit of CNG, who they all use to ship their gas. In a letter to GoodEnergy, Mr ... Read more »

Melbourne 'fruit nerd' launches Great Backyard Fruit Salvage to save loquats from rot

© Provided by ABC NEWS Melbourne fruiterer Thanh Truong wants to salvage the loquats in your backyard. (Supplied: Thanh Truong) A Melbourne fruiterer has launched the Great Backyard Fruit Salvage to ... Read more »

De Blasio defends having cops chauffeur job applicant from Gracie Mansion

Mayor Bill de Blasio claimed Monday that directing his NYPD security detail to shuttle someone from a job interview at his official residence to “where they were staying” was “in ... Read more »

‘The Haunting' Warzone Halloween Trailer Revealed

We’ve provided a full recap of the latest Halloween event trailer for Call of Duty (COD): Warzone. What’s your favorite place to drop? Warzone players got an ear full of ... Read more »

Atlanta beats NYC, Boston to autumn temperature milestone

Atlanta’s temperature plummeted into the 40s early on Sunday morning — a mark that New York City did not reach until a day later when Central Park hit a low ... Read more »

Michael J. Fox ‘Won't Stop' Fighting To Find A Cure For Parkinson's

Michael J. Fox is doing everything he can to end the devastation of Parkinson’s disease. © Photo: ETIENNE LAURENT/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock Michael J. Fox Speaking with Variety, the actor is looking ahead to ... Read more »