How 'mix and match' COVID-19 booster shots work, and why we're using them

Asia's Tech News Daily

Chanei Henry, senior research coordinator of molecular virology and microbiology at Baylor College of Medicine, prepares a COVID-19 booster shot during a mix-and-match trial. Baylor College of Medicine

  • Fully vaccinated Americans will soon be offered extra doses of different COVID-19 vaccines.

  • This is known as a “mix and match” booster shot strategy.

  • Here's what we know about the benefits of mix and match booster shots so far.

Americans will soon be able to get so-called “mix and match” boosters – an extra COVID-19 shot that's different to the vaccine they originally received.

On Wednesday evening, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) authorized mix-and-match booster shots for people in the US who originally got Johnson & Johnson's single dose vaccine, and for older adults and vulnerable people who had Moderna's vaccine.

Pending a final green light from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), eligible Americans vaccinated with Pfizer and Moderna's vaccines will soon be able to get a shot of any FDA-authorized vaccine booster after six months. People who got J&J's vaccine will be able to have one after two months.

This followed an influential US trial that suggested boosting with different vaccines was safe and effective.

Before, only immunocompromised patients, as well as vulnerable populations and older adults who'd had Pfizer vaccines, were eligible for boosters.

Mix-and-match boosters haven't been extensively tested in the real world – but there are lots of reasons why they're a good idea, experts say.

The reasons for the decision

In theory, different vaccines can stimulate the immune system in different ways, so giving people mix-and-match booster shots could produce a better immune response than an extra dose of the same vaccine.

“You'll reach a part of the immune system not reached as well by the initial vaccine,” Dr. Robert Atmar, one of the principal investigators of the ongoing mix-and-match booster trial at Baylor College of Medicine, told Insider of the idea.

Some vaccines may be better at producing an antibody response, for example, while others might be better at stimulating white-blood cells called T cells and B cells to protect us.

But this was “really a theoretical potential benefit” that's largely been seen “in the test tube,” he said.

The main reason the US is allowing mixing and matching is, for now, practical rather than scientific. It's “really a public health question, in terms of ease of administration and distribution,” Atmar said.

Some vaccines are simply more readily available than others – not every pharmacy or doctor's office carries all three vaccine brands.

Mix and match will help if one manufacturer has a problem, Pedro Piedra, professor of molecular virology, microbiology, and pediatrics at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, told National Geographic.

The data on mix-and-match booster shots

In the UK, adults over 50 or at risk of severe COVID-19 have been able to get a mix-and-match booster since September 14. This decision was mostly based on early data from an ongoing UK-based trial, COV-Boost, which is not publicly available.

The National Institute for Health Research, which funded the study, said at the time that the trial showed mixed booster doses of COVID-19 vaccines given to fully vaccinated people provided a “substantial increase in vaccine-induced immune responses.”

The preference is for Brits to get Pfizer, regardless of what vaccine they had before, but a half-dose of Moderna is also available.

The US published its first landmark booster trial on October 13, which showed giving people who'd received J&J's one-shot vaccine a separate dose of any FDA-approved vaccine boosted their antibodies, without any serious side effects.

In the trial, a second dose of J&J's shot boosted people's antibodies four fold, while switching to a shot of Pfizer or Moderna boosted antibodies 35 and 75 fold, respectively. This could suggest mixing and matching provided more protection – but antibodies aren't a perfect measure of overall immune protection.

“The study really was not designed” for direct comparisons, Atmar said. Regardless of what a person received originally, getting one of the three booster shots “led to good antibody responses,” he said.

Real-world results aren't yet known

But it's unclear what the true effect of mixing and matching will be because real-world data is scarce.

Dan Barouch, director of the Center for Virology and Vaccine Research at Boston's Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, told National Geographic that every combination should be specifically studied for safety and immune response. Even vaccines that use the same technology aren't identical, which could affect how a mix and match booster dose works, he said.

For example, Moderna and Pfizer's vaccines both use a genetic code to teach the body to make part of the virus to trigger an immune response, but they vary in multiple ways including dose, dosing interval, and the genetic sequence they use.

Atmar agrees you'd test all combinations “in a perfect world,” but that it wasn't “feasible” in the US to, for example, study “boosters in persons who had gotten AstraZeneca, or who had gotten the Chinese vaccine, or the Sputnik vaccine.”

Mix-and-match alone can't end pandemic

At the least, mixing and matching gives us options. In places where the same brand of booster isn't available, people can just take what's on offer.

But no matter how effective they are, the extra protection won't be enough to end the pandemic, vaccine experts say.

“The effect of a booster is much less than the effect of vaccinating unvaccinated individuals – and that means both here and abroad,” Dr. Eric Rubin, who sits on the independent vaccine advisory committee to the FDA, said last week.

“If we're going to get out of this thing, we have to be vaccinating the unvaccinated,” he said.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Ted Cruz and Donald Trump Jr. taunt the WHO for skipping 'Xi' to name the new coronavirus variant 'Omicron'

Texas Senator Ted Cruz (L), Donald Trump Jr. (R).Tom Williams-Pool/Getty Images (L), Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images (R) The WHO skipped two letters of the Greek alphabet to name the new coronavirus ... Read more »

The James Webb space telescope: in search of the secrets of the Milky Way

Photograph: Dotted Zebra/Alamy Billions of dollars over budget and years late, the most expensive, complex telescope to be sent into space will launch next month. What will it learn? In ... Read more »

Notorious Pegasus spyware faces its day of reckoning

Photograph: Amir Levy/Getty Images The infamous hacking tool is now at the centre of international lawsuits thanks to a courageous research lab If you were compiling a list of the ... Read more »

Best Black Friday laptop deals 2021: Offers on Microsoft, HP, Apple Macbooks and more

(Black Friday) When it comes to bagging a serious bargain, there’s really no better time than Black Friday. The annual sales event is one of the biggest days in the ... Read more »

COPY OF 15 Bose Black Friday deals not to miss — save up to $100

We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. It’s a Bose bonanza! Score speakers, headphones, earbuds and more at ... Read more »

Archaeologists unearth 800-year-old mummy in Peru

A 600-year-old mummy was found in the Mangomarca archaeological site, east of Lima, last year (AFP via Getty Images) Archaeologists have found a mummy estimated to be at least 800 ... Read more »

Pfizer said an updated version of its COVID-19 vaccine will be 'ready in 100 days' if the new Omicron variant is resistant to its current vaccine

© Bryan Woolston/Reuters A healthcare worker holds a vial of the Pfizer coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccine at The University of Louisville Hospital in Louisville, Kentucky, U.S., December 14, 2020. Bryan ... Read more »

If a new vaccine is needed for the omicron variant, how long will it take to arrive?

<a href="/tag/covid-variant“>Covid variant illustration The world has limited vaccine manufacturing capacity and its factories are currently running flat out producing vaccines for existing variants of the coronavirus. It raises the ... Read more »

Four more countries added to red list after Omicron variant found in the UK

(AFP via Getty Images) Four more countries have been added to the red list after a new Covid-19 variant was detected in the UK for the first time. Angola, Mozambique, ... Read more »

SpaceX's Starlink has no licence to operate in India and the public should steer clear until it does, say lawmakers

© Joan Cros/NurPhoto via Getty Images Starlink has begun taking pre-bookings for the service in India, according to government officials. Joan Cros/NurPhoto via Getty Images The Indian government has said ... Read more »

COVID-19: New coronavirus variant may not change anything about the pandemic

The emergence of a new coronavirus variant with significant mutations to the spike protein may change nothing about the pandemic. The jump in cases in the Gauteng province of South ... Read more »

‘I don't believe it': Anger as Nadine Dorries dismisses MP's allegation of groping by Boris Johnson's father

Nadine Dorries says she does not believe a fellow Conservative MP’s allegation that she was groped by Boris Johnson’s father, sparking anger. Caroline Nokes has accused Stanley Johnson of smacking ... Read more »

The Omicron variant carries a number of genetic mutations that might cause it to spread quickly, even among vaccinated people: report

A healthcare worker collects a swab from Bronwen Cook for a PCR test against the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) before traveling to London, at O.R. Tambo International Airport in Johannesburg, South ... Read more »

Moderna plans to produce a booster vaccine shot specifically for the new coronavirus variant Omicron

© KAZUHIRO NOGI/AFP via Getty Images Moderna has outlined its strategy to address the new coronavirus variant Omicron. KAZUHIRO NOGI/AFP via Getty Images Moderna has outlined its strategy to address ... Read more »

There's an easy way to tax billionaires that would actually work

© Provided by Business Insider Elon Musk recently sold some of his Tesla shares after discussing wealth taxation on Twitter. Picture Alliance/Getty Images The ultra-wealthy avoid paying taxes by using ... Read more »

CCTV shows fierce gun battle between two gangs which left man, 22, dead

CCTV of the shootout in Lozells, Birmingham. (SWNS) Shocking CCTV shows the moment two rival gangs had a gun battle in broad daylight which left a man dead. Naasir Francis, ... Read more »

Así trabajan los laboratorios en una vacuna contra la variante Ómicron: Pfizer, Moderna, AstraZeneca...

© Proporcionado por AS Así trabajan los laboratorios en una respuesta a Ómicron: Pfizer, Moderna, AstraZeneca, Janssen… La variante del SARS-CoV-2 surgida en Sudáfrica y que se ha denominado como ... Read more »

Oxford jab scientist optimistic over vaccines' effectiveness on Omicron variant

A scientist behind the Oxford jab has expressed optimism that existing vaccines will be effective against the new Omicron variant and said it is “extremely unlikely” it will cause a ... Read more »

United and Delta say they aren't cutting flights to South Africa as new travel restrictions throw a wrench in the recovery of international travel

© Provided by Business Insider United Airlines and Delta Air Lines both fly to South Africa. vaalaa / United Airlines and Delta Air Lines are the only two US ... Read more »

The US is getting another startup airline, California-based Airbahn

© Provided by Business Insider Airbahn first Airbus A320. Airbahn California-based startup Airbahn received its first Airbus A320 aircraft on Wednesday. The company has teased its launch on social media ... Read more »

Pfizer-BioNTech, Moderna y J&J pasan a la acción: prueban sus vacunas frente a la variante ómicron y revelarán los resultados en las próximas semanas

© Redacción Sanitarios preparan vacunas contra el coronavirus Pfizer-BioNTech, Moderna y J&J pasan a la acción: prueban sus vacunas frente a la variante ómicron y revelarán los resultados en las ... Read more »

A man on a lockdown stroll across English farmland discovered an 'extraordinary' Roman villa with epic Trojan War mosaic

Aerial view of the excavations of a large Roman mosaic in Rutland, England.Historic England Archive A man taking a lockdown walk on his father's farm stumbled across a rare Roman ... Read more »

Amazon Shoppers Love This Easy-to-Install Video Doorbell — and It's 30% Off Right Now

ring doorbell Amazon If you're looking for an easier way to monitor your front door and manage visitors in order to feel safer and more comfortable at home, a video ... Read more »

BioNTech says it will know in 2 weeks whether the COVID-19 vaccine it developed with Pfizer works against the new variant rapidly spreading in southern Africa

BioNTech said it’s testing the COVID-19 vaccine it developed with Pfizer against the new variant that appears to have emerged in southern Africa.Peter Kovalev/TASS/Getty Images BioNTech is testing its COVID ... Read more »

Sheridan Smith ‘upset' after ‘not being treated with kindness' on Jonathan Ross Show

Sheridan Smith has reportedly had a backstage row after growing “upset” during her time on The Jonathan Ross Show. The actor and singer, 40, will appear on Saturday’s episode of ... Read more »

Louise Redknapp enjoys wild night out with her 'boys' after ex Jamie welcomes son

Louise Redknapp let her hair down on Friday night to enjoy an evening of music with her “boys” following her ex-husband Jamie Redknapp welcoming a baby with his new wife. ... Read more »

A rare manuscript featuring Albert Einstein's early calculations for his theory of relativity sold for $13 million

A manuscript showing early calculations of Albert Einstein‘s theory of general relativity at Christie’s auction house in Paris.Alain Jocard/Getty Images A rare manuscript with notes made by Albert Einstein was ... Read more »

Small Business Saturday is vital to entrepreneurs — especially this year. Here's how business owners can get the most out of the holiday.

© Peathegee Inc/Getty Images Here are five ways small businesses can prepare for Small Business Saturday this year. Peathegee Inc/Getty Images This year’s Small Business Saturday is the most important ... Read more »

The market's Black Friday freakout about the new variant shows how a reactionary Wall Street rules American life and politics

© Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images Stocks plummeted on Friday as investors braced for the Omicron variant fueling a new round of lockdowns. In one day, the market challenged ... Read more »

I'm a Celebrity chaos as ITV show hit by ‘security breach' amid fears more stars will quit

The latest series of I’m a Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here! has been hit by chaos in recent days. This year’s crop of stars entered the compound, which was ... Read more »

Omicron variant ‘extremely unlikely' to trigger major new Covid wave in UK, saysvaccine expert

Watch: New Omicron strain of Covid deemed ‘variant of concern’ by WHO A vaccine expert says it is “extremely unlikely” that the new Omicron variant will trigger a major new ... Read more »

Chair of South African Medical Association says Omicron cases are mild so far, but it's too soon to the determine risk of severe disease

© Michele Spatari/AFP/Getty Images Doctors Without Borders nurse Bhelekazi Mdlalose performs a COVID-19 test on a health worker at the Vlakfontein Clinic in Johannesburg, South Africa on May 13, 2020. ... Read more »

People are confusing Jennifer Lawrence for another star in new photoshoot

The Oscar winning star is back to promote her new movie, Don’t Look Up (Reuters) A list actor Jennifer Lawrence is back in the spotlight after almost three years. She ... Read more »

A NASA astronaut who took part in the first all-female spacewalk describes what it was like wearing an oversized 1970s spacesuit in zero gravity

Astronaut Jessica Meir.Photo by Andrei Shelepin\TASS via Getty Images Astronaut Dr Jessica Meir described the challenges of wearing a spacesuit from the 1970s in 2019. It's “incredibly cumbersome,” and “pressurized,” ... Read more »

In a crypto crash, the coins with the best real use cases and loyal followings will survive the best, according to FTX's Sam Bankman-Fried

© FTX Sam Bankman-Fried cofounded FTX in 2019 and is its CEO. FTX In a bear market, look for cryptos with big real use cases and a loyal fan base, ... Read more »

Stock Market Tumbles On New Covid Variant; Pfizer Breaks Out, Ovintiv Dives, Li Auto On Tap

Stock Market Tumbles On New Covid Variant; Pfizer Breaks Out, Ovintiv Dives, Li Auto On Tap Read more »

Omicron: UK braces for expected arrival of new Covid variant

Watch: Is Omicron a serious worry or an evolutionary dead end? The UK is bracing for the arrival of the potentially more dangerous and transmissible new Covid variant, as Europe ... Read more »

How Britain could learn from Australia's mistakes in dealing with migrant boats

Photograph: BASARNAS/AFP/Getty Images Analysis: Australia knows the horror of deaths at sea – and that turn-backs and offshore processing have huge human costs The prime ministerial language is starkly reminiscent. ... Read more »

Fans react to Naughty Boy earning all the stars in I'm a Celebrity task

Fans react to Naughty Boy earning all the stars in I’m a Celebrity task Fans have been reacting to how successful producer Naughty Boy was in tonight’s (26 November) I’m ... Read more »

Ridley Scott is wrong to blame millennials for his box-office bomb – but he's right to be angry

Adam Scott and Matt Damon star as two duelling noble-men in Ridley Scott’s biggest box-office flop yet (20th Century Fox) Maybe we, as a culture, don’t deserve good things. For ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic