How long will travel restrictions last, and other omicron question that need answers

Asia's Tech News Daily

Renewed travel curbs have been the response to the spread of a new heavily mutated virus, causing some travellers to take extra precautions – MOHD RASFAN/AFP

Travel restrictions are back. After months of loosening our shackles, permitting a slow but steady recovery for an industry that employs tens of millions of people around the world, the red list is back and testing requirements have been tightened.

Given that we don’t yet know whether the omicron variant is more transmissible than delta, whether it is more dangerous (early evidence suggests the opposite), or whether it is vaccine-resistant, the sudden imposition of measures smacks of panic. As such, there are plenty of questions that need to be answered.

Are travel restrictions already pointless?

Efforts to stem the tide of delta, including the widespread ban of flights from India, where it was first identified, proved fruitless. Just weeks after naming the variant, in May 2021, the World Health Organisation declared that it was already well on the way to becoming globally dominant. By August it had spread to just about every nation in the world, including those with strict border closures such as New Zealand, Australia and China.

Therefore, if omicron is even more transmissible than delta, attempts to stop it with travel restrictions will prove even more futile (if it is less transmissible than delta, restrictions will be equally pointless as it should be elbowed aside). The variant emerged in southern Africa, prompting the UK to put 10 countries in the region on the dreaded red list. But it is surely too late. Already nine cases have been identified in the UK, which means the true scale of the spread is likely to be far higher.

One could argue that we are slowing the spread of omicron, but even that is debatable. Stefan Baral, an epidemiologist at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, argued that travel bans “have the effect of increasing travel in the short term – creating more desperation in potentially hiding symptoms, more crowded conditions at airports, as well as full airplanes. My guess is [this] increased the seeding across the US in early 2020.”

He added: “By the time you close the borders, the variant is already there. Travel bans may have a role in the syndromic (early) phase of an epidemic. But the epidemiologic transition from travel to local transmission happens quickly. Blaming outsiders may be easy, but addressing determinants of local transmission is impactful.”

Why is the world picking on Africa?

The variant has already been found in at least 15 nations, including the Netherlands, Hong Kong, Germany, Israel and Australia. Yet most countries’ travel restrictions – including Britain’s – focus solely on Africa. Indeed, no omicron infections have been identified in eight of the 10 red list countries – they have simply been added due to geography – yet the Netherlands, which has 13 confirmed cases and numerous direct flights to Africa, has been spared.

Dr Ayoade Alakija, co-chair of the Africa Vaccine Delivery Alliance, was apoplectic about the situation in an interview with BBC News last week. She said: “These travel bans are based in politics, and not in science. It is wrong. Why are we locking away Africa when this virus is already on three continents?

“What is going on right now is inevitable, it’s a result of the world’s failure to vaccinate in an equitable, urgent and speedy manner. It is as a result of hoarding [of vaccines] by high-income countries of the world, and quite frankly it is unacceptable.”

This content is not available due to your privacy preferences.Update your settings here to see it.

In many African countries, where furlough schemes and extensive personal savings are rare, travel restrictions can be devastating on those who rely on overseas visitors.

“For so many Africans dependent on tourism, the UK Government’s drastic decision will be devastating,” says Sarah Marshall, Telegraph Travel’s Africa expert, who has spent much of the pandemic visiting the continent and assessing the impact of restrictions. “Having barely been given an opportunity to recover from 20 months of crippling travel bans, camps, operators and communities will be wondering how to deal with this latest blow.”

Are travel bans actually counterproductive to the policing of variants?

The heavy-handed response to omicron will damage the economies of South Africa and Botswana, the two countries that worked together to identify it. What message does that give to governments elsewhere? Where is the incentive to sequence the Covid virus?

This is a point made by Prof Francois Balloux, director at the UCL Genetics Institute. He said: “Botswana and South Africa have remarkably good SARSCoV2 variant surveillance in place. Their scientists have been proactive and transparent about the emergence of B.1.1.529. The predictable – and up to a point understandable – international response has been ‘shut the borders’. An unintended side-effect of such a 'punitive' response may be to disincentive global SARSCoV2 surveillance or at least make them think twice before sharing data. At the very least, the punitive measure of border closure should be counterbalanced by positive incentives, such as support for their genomic surveillance programmes and far more generous help with the healthcare challenges they are currently facing.”

Testing centre at Heathrow – Frank Augstein/Virus Outbreak Britain

Why are some countries blaming vaccinated travellers?

Spain responded to the emergence of omicron by banning unvaccinated British tourists, who previously could visit if they presented evidence of a negative test. This is a curious tactic given that the variant has been identified in vaccinated people (Australia – which only grants entry to double-jabbed travellers – has registered five imported cases) and that much of the concern surrounding it is down to the possibility that it could escape the current crop of vaccines. It seems that the policy favoured by many countries of banning unvaccinated travellers – even though the jabs don’t prevent transmission – continues to find favour as a political tool.

Whether that remains the case if omicron is found to comprehensively bypass the vaccines, we can only guess. But logic dictates that it shouldn’t.

Will the UK enforce the new self-isolation period?

Having permitted vaccinated Britons returning from overseas to take just a single lateral flow test in the 48 hours after they return (with no mandatory quarantine period), the new rules – effective from 4am on November 30 – require them to take a costlier PCR test and to wait at home until they receive a negative result. This could mean a few hours of self-isolation, or a few days (or longer if the test results are delayed). But how strictly will this quarantine period be enforced? Having wound down its travel restrictions in recent months, one can only assume that there is a shortage of quarantine martinets within the bowels of the Home Office. Will there be enough to check up on the hundreds of thousands of Britons returning from city breaks, winter sun sojourns and ski holidays in the coming weeks?

How long will these rules remain in place?

Thousands of holidays have already been ruined by the new rules, but that will extend to hundreds of thousands if they linger into the key festive period and the ski season. Apparently they will be reviewed in three weeks (around December 17), when fears about omicron will have hopefully been laid to rest, but few will have any confidence in a quick return to normal on that date. After all, we’ve been told before of Covid measures lasting just three weeks…

Holidaymakers will be understandably nervous, but so too will travel businesses. With the furlough scheme wrapped up, many tour operators will not survive another lean winter.

Edward Argar, Minister of State for Health, said: “We’re not saying cancel your holidays to France or other countries, but we have put in place proportionate testing and border controls.

“We cannot say what will happen over the coming weeks, and in travelling at the moment with this virus, particularly with a new variant around, there is an element of risk.”

Is this how we will deal with future variants?

The sudden closure of borders is not sustainable in a global economy. It is bad for business, bad for people’s mental health, and many will be worried that it risks becoming our fallback response.

Former British Airways boss Willie Walsh, who now leads airline industry body IATA, today called the Government’s decision “knee-jerk”, and said he was “very disappointed” at the move, arguing it would not have any long-term benefit.

He told BBC Radio 4: “It’s clear that these measures have been completely ineffective in the past but impose huge hardship on people who are trying to connect with family and friends and clearly massive financial damage to the tourism and airline industry.”

The airline chief argued that the UK would fail to keep out the virus as the borders remained open, arguing that a “sensible testing regime” should be imposed instead.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

What does Huawei's trade ban mean for your present or future Huawei phone?

© Provided by Pocket-lint What does Huaweis Google ban mean for your Huawei or Honor phone image 1 (Pocket-lint) – In May 2019, Huawei was subject to a US trade ... Read more »

World Cup final price hike as Qatar 2022 tickets go on sale to fans

© Getty Images Tickets for the Qatar World Cup are on sale – Getty Images The cost of attending the World Cup final is up to 46 per cent higher ... Read more »

How Ralf Rangnick's first and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's last eight Man Utd games compare

Manchester United finally cut ties with Ole Gunnar Solskjaer in late November of last year after a particularly disastrous run of results. The nail in the coffin proved to be ... Read more »

India's Covid cases hit eight-month high with full impact weeks away

© AFP via Getty Images India covid India saw its Covid-19 infections reach an eight-month high on Wednesday amid warnings it will take weeks before its Omicron peak is reached. ... Read more »

Aldi crowned the UK's cheapest supermarket of 2021

Aldi was the cheapest supermarket for six of the last 12 months while Lidl was the cheapest for five, including December 2021, according to the annual survey from the consumer ... Read more »

Alden Richards, napagtapos ng kolehiyo ang 2 beneficiaries sa kaniyang foundation

Alden Richards in the States for the holidays Labis na ikinatuwa ni Alden Richards na nakapagtapos na ng kolehiyo ang dalawa sa kaniyang mga benepisaryo o iskolar sa kaniyang AR ... Read more »

Coughing Boris Johnson 'refused to isolate' saying he was 'strong like bull!'

Coughing Boris Johnson refused to isolate just before he was diagnosed with Covid, beating his chest and proclaiming he was “strong like bull”, it has emerged. Bombshell fresh claims about ... Read more »

The day Eric Dier and Dele Alli went at it in Tottenham dressing room after Wolves collapse

Eric Dier has reflected on his heated clash with teammate and good friend, Dele Alli, which was aired on Amazon Prime’s Documentary: ‘All or Nothing’. On March 1, 2020, Tottenham ... Read more »

Eden Hazard has already told Thomas Tuchel how to get the best out of Chelsea star Romelu Lukaku

Eden Hazard has already approved the moment Romelu Lukaku confronted Hakim Ziyech in Chelsea’s draw against Brighton as the Belgian winger believes this is the key to unlocking the club ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic deportation delights Andy Murray's former coach - 'I hated that'

Andy Murray’s former coach Darren Cahill was more than pleased to see Novak Djokovic deported from Australia ahead of this week’s Australian Open in Melbourne. Djokovic was ordered to leave ... Read more »

Compromising note left on man's car made his furious wife leave him

A man has been forced to take to social media to save his marriage after a mysterious note was left on his car.  The man from Scone, a regional town ... Read more »

“Original, funny, biting... and utterly fabulous” — tributes pour in for legendary fashion editor André Leon Talley

© Getty Images for SCAD andereleontalley190122 Long-serving Vogue editor André Leon Talley has passed away aged 73. The industry heavyweight had a fashion career spanning five decades in which he ... Read more »

"I've heard": Sky Sports man drops "worrying" Spurs transfer claim, fans will be livid - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Spurs boss Antonio Conte with Harry Kane Sky Sports reporter Michael Bridge has bad news for Tottenham Hotspur supporters ahead of the transfer deadline on ... Read more »

WHO counts 18 million virus cases last week as omicron slows

The Associated PressA heath worker takes a nasal swab sample from a student to test for the coronavirus at a school, in Karachi, Pakistan, Wednesday, Jan. 19, 2022. (AP Photo/Fareed ... Read more »

Dad & pal killed in horror crash as wife and baby, 1, fight for their lives in hospital after car smashed by HGV

A DAD has died after a horror crash with a HGV which killed his family friend and left his wife and baby fighting for their lives in hospital. Tributes have ... Read more »

I was called Chewbacca by school bullies after medical condition meant I had to shave my entire body at eight-years-old

A WOMAN has revealed how she was bullied by cruel kids in school because of her excessive hair growth, caused by a medical condition. Samantha Allen, 28, from New York, ... Read more »

Sibongile Khumalo's daughter to honour her at Hugh Masekela Heritage Festival

© AFP FILE: Legendary South African musicians, singer Sibongile Khumalo and Hugh Masekela, perform at a concert on 4 April 2014 in New York. JOHANNESBURG – The daughter of the ... Read more »

Vanilla Sponge Cake: Birthdays and tea-time is sorted

There is no person who doesn’t enjoy cake. Cake is the birthday must-have and the party necessity and there can be no arguments about it. There are thousands of different ... Read more »

National Popcorn Day: 3 genius ways to use popcorn as an ingredient

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) January 19, is National Popcorn Day, a day to celebrate one of the most loved treats worldwide. This time-honoured snack can be sweet or ... Read more »

Be aggressive but play by rules: Uday Kotak's advice to start-ups

© Provided by Business Today Be aggressive but play by rules: Uday Kotak’s advice to start-ups Kotak Mahindra Bank Executive Vice-Chairman and Managing Director Uday Kotak packed in plenty of ... Read more »

Joe Oliver: Health-care reform could be COVID's silver lining

© Provided by Financial Post A health-care worker talks to people as the wait to receive a COVID-19 test in Montreal on Dec. 17, 2021, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues ... Read more »

Matthew Lau: Tax the un-vaxxed? A tangled business

© Provided by Financial Post People walk by a sign at a restaurant advising customers of Quebec’s COVID-19 vaccine passport in Montreal on Sept. 6, 2021. For the past week, ... Read more »

Telecom Italia shares slide further as doubts over KKR's bid intensify

FILE PHOTO: The TIM logo is seen at its headquarters MILAN (Reuters) – Telecom Italia (TIM) shares fell for a straight second day on Wednesday following an internal meeting over ... Read more »

Holly Willoughby shows off incredibly flexible yoga move!

It’s Holly Willoughby as you’ve never seen her before. The This Morning star has appeared in a brand new photo on the Wylde Moon Instagram account – and wow! MORE: ... Read more »

Pearson lifts profit outlook on strong sales

Pearson is being buoyed by increases in education enrolments. Photo: Getty Pearson (PSON.L) said its sale growth for the last quarter of 2021 exceeded expectations in part thanks to strong ... Read more »

Calvin Ramsay will be sold in this transfer window claims Derek McInnes as Aberdeen star watched by army of scouts

Former Aberdeen boss Derek McInnes believes Calvin Ramsay will leave the Granite City before the close of the January transfer window. But he hopes his former club will be able ... Read more »

A total of 26 people in Norway died in leisure boat accidents at sea last year

The Norwegian Maritime Directorate registered 26 deaths related to leisure boats in 2021.  The number of deaths in 2021 is higher than in 2020 – 6 more deaths have been ... Read more »

This is the version of Liverpool hero Luis Suarez Aston Villa would be signing

Recent news has emerged out of Spain that Steven Gerrard has been in contact with his former teammate Luis Suarez about possibly bringing him to Aston Villa. Whilst Suarez is ... Read more »

Free Fire OB32 update APK and OBB download links

© Provided by GamePur Free Fire OB32 update has been released officially for Android and iOS devices globally. After the maintenance break ends, players will be able to enjoy the ... Read more »

Pasig City hires health workers, contact tracers as COVID-19 cases expected to rise

vico sotto The Pasig City government  on Wednesday hired additional contact tracers and health frontline workers to augment its healthcare system to prepare for an increase in COVID-19 infections. On ... Read more »

Biden to address skeptics as presidency nears one-year mark Wednesday

© Reuters/LEAH MILLIS FILE PHOTO: U.S. President Biden promotes “Build Back Better Agenda” during visit to Connecticut By Trevor Hunnicutt WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. President Joe Biden is likely to ... Read more »

U.S. Supreme Court weighs Senator Cruz's campaign finance challenge

© Reuters/EVELYN HOCKSTEIN FILE PHOTO: Senator Ted Cruz outside the Capitol building By Lawrence Hurley and Andrew Chung (Reuters) – The latest conservative attack on a major campaign finance law ... Read more »

Turkey: Kirkuk-Ceyhan pipeline operational after fire put out

© Provided by Al Jazeera The pipeline carries oil from Kirkuk in northern Iraq to the Turkish port of Ceyhan, on the Mediterranean Sea. [Umit Bektas/Reuters] Istanbul, Turkey – A ... Read more »

Gov't workers absent for work due to COVID-19 considered excused —CSC

Photo: CSC on FB The Civil Service Commission (CSC) on Wednesday said the absence from work of government employees under quarantine, isolation or treatment for COVID-19 are considered excused. “Absence ... Read more »

Power Finance Corporation, REC reduce lending rates by 40 basis points

© Provided by Zee Business State-owned Non-Banking Financial Companies, Power Finance Corporation and REC Limited have further reduced their lending rates across all types of loans by 40 Bps. Union ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: NCLAT stays order on insolvency proceedings against HCL Tech

© Provided by Business Today EXCLUSIVE: NCLAT stays order on insolvency proceedings against HCL Tech In a major relief to the IT services company, HCL Technologies, the National Company Law ... Read more »

Woman fuming after catching husband looking at other women online – but people reckon it's much worse than that

THERE'S no denying just how tempting it can be to have a quick scroll through your partner's phone when they're not looking… but as a general rule, it's probably not ... Read more »

Cabinet Clears Rs 1,500cr for Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency, Other Announcements

© Provided by News18 Cabinet Clears Rs 1,500cr for Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency, Other Announcements Union Cabinet Decision: The Union Cabinet Committee of Economic Affairs chaired by Prime Minister ... Read more »

'Partygate': timeline of a scandal

© JESSICA TAYLOR Boris Johnson has come under sustained pressure and criticism due to revelations about lockdown-breaking parties at Downing Street UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson has faced repeated claims ... Read more »

Germany: Former far-right lawmaker on trial over bid to storm Reichstag

© Provided by DW The former lawmaker Stefan R. was kicked out of the AfD after calling for the violent overthrow of the state The trial against a former German ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic