How Hong Kong’s next chief executive can show he means business with ‘result-oriented’ reform

how hong kong’s next chief executive can show he means business with ‘result-oriented’ reform

Since Hong Kong’s first chief executive Tung Chee-hwa introduced the Principal Officials Accountability System in 2002, successive chief executives have tried their hand at enacting new measures to enhance public governance.

Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor, the current chief executive, moved to review the existing promotion and appointment mechanism of senior civil service positions in her last policy address. The incoming chief executive, John Lee Ka-chiu, suggested in his election manifesto the use of key performance indicators (KPIs) for certain important tasks to underline the “result-oriented” approach of his government.

The intention is to be applauded. However, the real test is what KPIs are to be set and how senior officers, political appointees and civil servants alike will be held to account if they fail to meet the set targets.

It is perhaps not fair to say that the terms of previous chief executives were not “result-oriented” as policy addresses have been awash with pledges and targets in various policy areas. By the end of the period covered in the policy address, the chief executive takes stock of these targets and, lo and behold, few of them are unmet.

In theory, the people of Hong Kong should have cause to rejoice, but we know this is rarely the case. The policy address is a product of collective work within the government through a largely bottom-up process. Very few officials would propose to their political masters targets that they are reluctant to or cannot achieve.

Even some of the chief executive’s own pet projects might not find their way into the policy address, should it be the wise counsel of the ministers and senior civil servants around them that the projects are too ambitious.

As a result, policy addresses are normally long on pledges to review existing systems, formulate proposals to tackle long-standing problems, expedite ongoing projects and the like, but they are short on any guarantee or measure of customer satisfaction.

Take the housing and land initiatives that were mentioned in the latest policy address as an example. The most notable target is to ensure timely delivery of the 10-year public housing production of 330,000 units by advancing projects in the latter five-year period as far as possible. Such a pledge offers little comfort to public housing applicants today as the average waiting time for a housing unit has hit a historic high of 6.1 years.

If the incoming government is serious about being result-oriented, it should make a pledge to reduce the waiting time for a public housing unit to three years by the end of its term since this is the result that really matters to the average person and is a metric that they can readily understand. Also, how about a pledge to reduce the proportion of household income that the average family spends on their mortgage, which is among the highest in the world?

Environmental policy is another example. The government has been talking for years about the solid waste charging scheme, but in the 2021 policy address, the pledge was still to make preparations for the scheme. As a truly meaningful KPI, how about pledging to implement it for real within the first year of the new government?

Meaningful KPI are those that convey an immediate sense of gain to the people, or huodegan as they say on the mainland. A meaningful KPI, like one pledging to reduce the waiting time for public housing, can spur a large spectrum of the civil service into action.

It involves enhancing multiple tasks relating to town planning, site identification, transport and infrastructure planning, provision of amenities and social services, and building work. Such a KPI should cascade down the bureaucracy and be reflected in the indicators for senior officers in all the departments and bureaus concerned.

how hong kong’s next chief executive can show he means business with ‘result-oriented’ reform

A woman dries laundry on April 11 in front of a public housing estate in Ngau Tau Kok which will be redeveloped in two phases. Photo: Nora Tam

Lee has suggested the KPIs are broad government objectives and might not apply to individual officers. This would be a pity as the indicators will only work if the officers concerned feel they have a material stake in the targets set. The only “carrot” in the present system is the prospect of promotion, but this has ceased to be an incentive for many senior civil servants, and this could even be a disincentive for those who prefer a stable life.

A certain percentage of the annual pay for officers involved in a KPI should be set aside, payable only if the targets or related milestones are met, plus perhaps a bonus for outstanding performance. This concept of performance-linked pay, though widely practised in the private sector, is seen by some as a heresy to the civil service.

To allay any possible concerns of civil service labour unions, it should only apply to political appointees and directorate officers. The portion of their pay that is linked to their performance should be a modest one, perhaps starting with the annual civil service pay adjustment while leaving their basic salary intact. This is a bold move, but it is just a small step that the new chief executive should take if senior civil servants who enjoy the highest level of job security are to be motivated to deliver the results he wants.

Raymond Young Lap-moon was permanent secretary for home affairs from 2010 to 2014

News Related


Lockdowns, a lion dance and red carpet: how Hong Kong welcomed Chinese President Xi Jinping

Hong Kong placed sections of its business district under strict lockdown on Thursday, together with a tech hub and a high-speed rail terminus, as part of a two-day visit by ... Read more »

Coronavirus outbreak in Hong Kong shifting from pandemic to endemic says government health adviser

The coronavirus outbreak in Hong Kong is shifting from a pandemic phase to an endemic one, a government health adviser has said, as he advised authorities to ease the city’s ... Read more »

Hong Kong protests: kitchen worker receives longest jail time so far for rioting and breaching mask ban during Wan Chai demonstration in 2019

A kitchen worker who admitted taking part in an illegal protest in 2019 has been jailed for 43 months for rioting and breaching the Hong Kong government’s ban on wearing ... Read more »

BN(O) scheme: London mayor underlines support for Hong Kong people who move to the capital

The mayor of London has reaffirmed his support for Hongkongers arriving in the British capital on the second anniversary of the imposition of the national security law. Sadiq Khan said ... Read more »

Hong Kong police arrest alleged driver of vehicle seen travelling against traffic in dashcam video posted online

An online video of an Audi sedan travelling against traffic on a flyover in Hong Kong on Tuesday has led to the arrest of its alleged driver, according to police. ... Read more »

Chinese President Xi Jinping making first visit to Hong Kong since 2017 to mark 25th anniversary of city's handover

This blog has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing. Chinese President Xi Jinping on Thursday begins a two-day ... Read more »

In 1 word: how 25 people describe Hong Kong, a city close to their hearts

The Post invited 25 people to sum up how they would describe the city. Resilient Hong Kong radio DJ “Uncle” Ray Cordeiro in his home at Kowloon Tong in 2021. ... Read more »

No 3 typhoon warning signal looms for Hong Kong on Thursday night, with Xi Jinping expected to be in city by afternoon for 25th anniversary of handover

This story has been made freely available as a public service to our readers. Please consider supporting SCMP’s journalism by subscribing. The Hong Kong Observatory may consider issuing a No ... Read more »

Hong Kong U-turns on tightening pollution rules for classic cars, keeping exemptions for vehicles aged 30 years or more

Hong Kong authorities have made a U-turn on tightening pollution rules for classic cars, allowing vehicles aged 30 years or more to be exempted at first registration if owners provide ... Read more »

What Chinese President Xi Jinping told Hong Kong in 2017 and key messages he can be expected to deliver on 25th anniversary of handover

“‘One country’ is like the roots of a tree. For a tree to grow tall and luxuriant, its roots must run deep and strong.” That metaphor came from Chinese President ... Read more »

Hong Kong readies for visit by Chinese President Xi Jinping for 25th handover anniversary celebrations

Hong Kong has pulled out all the stops for a smooth and secure visit by Chinese President Xi Jinping on Thursday, his first outside mainland China since the start of ... Read more »

As Beijing tightens its grip over Hong Kong, does ‘one country, two systems’ still apply?

Shipping magnate Tung Chee-hwa had a clear vision for Hong Kong in the 21st century when he campaigned in 1996 to be the city’s first chief executive after its return ... Read more »

Seoul ranks world’s second-best city for studying abroad, while Hong Kong climbs 3 spots to 12th place in annual QS report

Seoul for the first time has been ranked the world’s second-best city for studying abroad, while Hong Kong has risen by three spots to 12th place for the quality of ... Read more »

China’s first lady Peng Liyuan expected to join Xi Jinping on two-day visit to Hong Kong this week for July 1 celebrations

China’s first lady Peng Liyuan is expected to accompany President Xi Jinping during his two-day visit to Hong Kong this week, the Post has learned. But she will not join ... Read more »

Coronavirus: Hong Kong business leader calls for quota boost in quarantine-free ‘Return2HK’ scheme in light of mainland China easing rules for arrivals

A major business chamber in Hong Kong has urged the government to increase the daily quota of a quarantine-free scheme for residents returning from mainland China, a day after Beijing ... Read more »

Six arrested by Hong Kong police after two cars alleged to be involved in illegal racing crash

A total of six drivers alleged to have been part of an illegal road race that ended with a car being engulfed in flames after a crash have been arrested, ... Read more »

‘Piloting ship to weather storm’: Chinese state-run paper highlights ‘vitality’ of Hong Kong’s ‘one country, two systems’ principle ahead of Xi Jinping visit

The Chinese leadership under Xi Jinping has ensured the steadfast implementation of the “one country, two systems” governing formula in Hong Kong as if it had “piloted a ship to ... Read more »

Hong Kong’s economy of the future: plugged into Greater Bay Area, but still a global financial centre?

At the peak of Hong Kong’s fifth wave of Covid-19 infections in March, the city ran out of vegetables and fresh pork, leaving supermarket shelves empty for several days. With ... Read more »

Is Chinese University of Hong Kong head Rocky Tuan a patriot? Vice-chancellor addresses criticism, vows CUHK will link China and West

Rocky Tuan Sung-chi was pursuing a college degree in the United States in the 1970s when he was struck by how the students reacted when The Star-Spangled Banner was played ... Read more »

More than 10 journalists denied permission to cover Hong Kong handover anniversary events due to security reasons, reporters’ group says

More than 10 journalists, including at least one government photographer, have had their applications to cover ceremonies marking the 25th anniversary of Hong Kong’s return to Chinese rule rejected on ... Read more »

Coronavirus: Hong Kong could cut hotel quarantine to 5 days, with another 2 in home isolation, incoming health minister says

Hong Kong could cut hotel quarantine for travellers to five days, with another two to be spent in home isolation, the incoming health minister has told the Post. Professor Lo ... Read more »

3,000 guests, staff to begin hotel quarantine in Hong Kong ahead of Chinese President Xi Jinping’s visit and July 1 celebrations

Nearly 3,000 guests and staff will be placed under hotel quarantine from Wednesday in preparation for a two-day visit by Chinese President Xi Jinping to celebrate the 25th anniversary of ... Read more »

Hong Kong Palace Museum ‘ready to be fully opened’ on July 2, with security checks in place

The Hong Kong Palace Museum is set to open its doors on Saturday, having sold more than 70 per cent of tickets for next month and received a final shipment ... Read more »

Carrie Lam makes final comments on social media as Hong Kong’s leader, will shut down accounts after stepping down on Thursday

Hong Kong’s outgoing chief executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor has made her last comments on social media as the city’s leader, and will shut down her accounts once she steps ... Read more »

BioNTech can provide Covid-19 vaccine targeting Omicron to Hong Kong as early as the third quarter of the year if approved

Hong Kong will have another choice of Covid-19 vaccine targeting Omicron, with drug maker BioNTech offering to make its second-generation jabs available locally as early as the third quarter of ... Read more »

No-fly zone above high-speed rail terminus part of area lockdown, as Hong Kong rolls out security blanket for Xi Jinping’s visit to mark 25th anniversary of handover

A no-fly zone that will also ban the use of drones will be established above a high-speed train terminus in West Kowloon as part of a security blanket for Chinese ... Read more »

Hong Kong opposition camp rues its future: will it be able find its place in new political landscape?

When social worker Lo Kin-hei was elected chairman of the Democratic Party in December 2020 at the age of 36, he became the youngest leader to head the city’s largest ... Read more »

Can Hong Kong’s next leader John Lee fix the city’s housing crisis?

Zoe But said it was the luckiest day in her life when she and her fiancé were chosen in the ballot to buy a subsidised home 25 years ago. “We ... Read more »

Coronavirus: airlines want to return to Hong Kong but city’s chance of regaining status of global aviation hub fading by day, trade body chief warns

Global airlines want to get back to Hong Kong but it is becoming harder for the city to regain its status as an aviation hub with each passing day amid ... Read more »

Hong Kong is a city of duelling narratives, but deep down we know the truth

Anyone following Chinese and Western media knows there are two Hong Kongs. The former says that, with the city now being ruled by patriots, stability and good governance are guaranteed, ... Read more »

Hong Kong’s greenhouse gas emissions fall for third year in a row

Hong Kong’s greenhouse gas emissions decreased for the third year in a row in 2020, the latest statistics have revealed. But environmentalists called for more control over energy use and ... Read more »

Hong Kong police arrest 6 men in connection with predawn shooting in Central; 3 others detained in separate firearm cases

Hong Kong police have rounded up six more men in connection with a shooting that left three people injured two weeks ago at a popular entertainment district, taking the total ... Read more »

Power company to remove remains of bridge and finish laying cables a week after fire that left 160,000 Hong Kong households without electricity

A cable bridge in Hong Kong that collapsed into a river after it caught fire will be removed by the power company concerned, with the firm aiming to complete replacement ... Read more »

Number of coronavirus cases linked to Hong Kong nursing homes rises as health experts call for unvaccinated elderly residents to get jabs

The number of coronavirus infections recorded in Hong Kong’s nursing homes has worsened, with health experts calling on the remaining 10 per cent of unvaccinated elderly residents at such facilities ... Read more »

HK Express flight lands at Hong Kong airport with smoke billowing from plane, no injuries reported so far

Smoke was seen billowing from a HK Express plane after it landed at Hong Kong International Airport on Monday afternoon. No one was reported to have been injured. A police ... Read more »

Hong Kong protests: 2 teens allegedly involved in clash that led to cleaner’s death cannot be held liable for murder, judge rules

Two teenagers allegedly involved in a clash between anti-government protesters and local residents leading to an elderly cleaner’s death in Hong Kong in 2019 cannot be held liable for murder, ... Read more »

International schoolteachers on the future of education, from pandemic-era online lessons with Zoom and Google tools, to AR and VR – and the importance of social skills and empathy too

Read more of SCMP’s Good Schools Guide The future of education matters for the whole planet. How can we tackle the gravest issues facing humanity if we don’t have the ... Read more »

Could Chinese President Xi Jinping be planning a 2-day trip to Hong Kong for July 1 events? Hotel quarantine begins on Wednesday for politicians

President Xi Jinping could be planning a two-day visit in Hong Kong to mark the 25th anniversary of its return to Chinese rule as senior officials and politicians will be ... Read more »

Hong Kong-mainland China ties after 25 years: a chance for a reset or will underlying unease fester?

Tsui Kuen-nang won a historic right to stay in Hong Kong after a contentious court battle in 1999 that triggered the first storm over the city’s rule of law since ... Read more »

Hong Kong’s Cathay Pacific back on hiring spree in anticipation of take-off in global air travel, but faces recruitment challenges

When Jasmine Lau received an email from Cathay Pacific Airways last month asking if she wanted to return to her old job as a flight attendant, she contemplated the proposition, ... Read more »