How fish can still be part of a more sustainable food future

A fish-based diet is good for the environment and people’s health. nadianb/Shutterstock

If you want to reduce your personal impact on the environment, cutting back on eating animal products is one of the simplest things you can do. But becoming vegan and eating only plants is unlikely to be an appropriate solution for everyone in the world.

Fish and other seafood is often overlooked by the environmentally conscious, but new research known as the Blue Food Assessment show they can be part of meeting the twin challenges of climate change and food security. This year’s UN Summit of Food Systems is embracing “blue foods”, fish, shellfish and other food raised in water, to complement that of “green foods”, those that come from the land, plants and animals.

The five research papers from more than a hundred scientists led by Stockholm and Stanford universities highlight how aquatic foods could be used in the coming decades to address malnutrition, lower the environmental footprint of the food system, and provide livelihoods – echoing much other work that has been done in this area.

The growing, processing and distributing of food contributes a massive proportion of the greenhouse gas emissions that are the underlying cause of climate change, while huge numbers of people still suffer from malnutrition, obesity and sometimes both. Some seafood has the potential to provide people with high value nutrition while producing relatively low emissions.

But research suggests there are significant variations in the climate impacts and micronutrient content of both farmed and wild fish, that is affected by species, size and system. Scientists are only just beginning to understand these and the potential trade-offs.

The problem is that all seafood is often lumped together, making it hard to accurately compare it to other food sources. While we are able to draw some conclusions about what seafood is best for us to eat, the picture is usually complicated, and we don’t always have all the data we need.

The most commonly farmed species globally, including carp, trout, salmon, catfish and tilapia, have environmental impacts comparable to those of chicken, the most efficient and widely consumed meat –and so much lower than that of beef or lamb. But how fish are raised can make a big difference. For example, filter-feeding carps in freshwater systems have lower carbon emissions per portion but carnivorous marine fish such as seabass have much higher emissions.

More than half of seafood consumed globally is still fished, rather than farmed, and there is a significant range in the carbon emissions associated with different fisheries, largely reflecting the different methods used and stock abundance. Farmed fish can be made more environmentally friendly if less feed is used to produce the same amount of consumed product.

Meanwhile, some unfed farmed species can also have a positive impact on the environment. For example, mussels, clams and oysters filter natural feed from the water, removing excess nutrients.

There is also a stark difference in the diversity of aquatic farming compared with that on land. Whereas only a handful of farmed animals (chicken, pigs, sheep and cattle) provide the bulk of meat eaten by humans, more than 400 aquatic animal species are now farmed. A greater variety of food and sources for it helps improve food security as well as spreading risks for farmers. And, critically, this biodiversity can support more diverse and nutritious diets.

Source of nutrition

As one of the new studies highlights, many fish and seafood species are rich in important nutrients, which can give it a distinct advantage over meat with similar or higher environmental impact. Compared to chicken, trout has approximately 19 times more omega-3 fatty acids. Oysters and mussels have 76 times more vitamin B-12 and five times more iron. And carp have nine times more calcium.

The nutritional benefits of aquatic food are especially important for women, who benefit more than men from increased consumption in nearly three times the number of countries studied, the research found.

As such, seafood can be critical to reducing malnutrition among at-risk groups globally such as children and adolescent women. For the better off, substituting fish for meat can lower the risk of poor health associated with cardiovascular and other diseases.

The nutritional importance of fish is often ignored. CPG-Photo/Shutterstock

But again, the picture is complex. For example, small fish eaten whole are generally more nutritious than eating only fillets. Fish are often promoted as healthy because of the high levels of essential omega-3 fatty acids that some species contain. But the greatest dietary value will come from eating a diverse range of seafood to obtain a wider range of micronutrients.

Global climate challenges and fish

However, many challenges remain for seafood to fulfil its potential as a low-impact, highly nutritional food source for a large proportion of the world’s population. To have climate-friendly fishing, we must encourage the most sustainable development of the industry and protect the livelihoods of small-scale fishers and farmers. Incentivised production and trading of fish could drive down prices, ensuring poorer people can still afford seafood as other people’s incomes rise and demand increases.

But this latest research brings convincing evidence to the table of how good choices of fish and seafood can be both good for people and the planet and will be important in making sure they become a larger part of the global diet.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Dave Little is a Director of Nam Sai farms Thailand, has received funds from numerous public and corporate entities and works on various technical committees and oversight boards for international research consortia and non government organisations.

Richard Newton is Chair of the Global Seafood Assurance's Best Aquaculture Practice, Climate Action Committee.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Battlegrounds Mobile India esports tournament announced: All details

BGMI has announced its first esports tournament with Rs 1 crore pool, prize. Here’s everything you need to know about it. Battlegrounds Mobile India Series 2021Krafton has partnered with smartphone ... Read more »

Starfield's newest video introduces the game's setting and its backstory

Bethesda has released a brand new Starfield video, this time giving an overview of the game’s overall setting, known as ‘The Settled Systems’. Narrated by Bethesda Game Studios Design Director ... Read more »

Kerry Katona defends feeding her children takeaways for six months

Kerry Katona defended feeding her children so many takeaways. (PA) Kerry Katona has defended only feeding her children takeaways after she was accused of “child abuse” for not making a ... Read more »

Margaret Atwood sparks anger and disappointment with ‘why can't we say woman' tweet

Acclaimed author Margaret Atwood ignited outrage by sharing an article titled: “Why can’t we say ‘woman’ anymore?” The opinion piece, penned by Toronto Star columnist Rosie DiManno, explores the the ... Read more »

Gogglebox's Paige Deville says she wishes to never speak to her mum again

Paige Deville and her mother Sally Hayward (Channel 4) Gogglebox’s Paige Deville has dramatically confirmed she is cutting off contact with her mother. Ms Deville and her mother Sally Hayward ... Read more »

Detective who 'boasted about sex with boys' jailed after sting by his own police force

Christopher Richards, 45, boasted about sex with a 14-year-old boy. (SWNS) A detective who boasted about sex with a 14-year-old boy was caught after a sting by his own police ... Read more »

Brian Laundrie's belongings have been found in Florida park

The lawyer for Brian Laundrie’s parents says articles belonging to the missing fugitive have been located in a Florida reserve near his home on Wednesday morning. The discovery was made ... Read more »

Commerce Department limits sale of hacking tools to Russia and China

The US Commerce Department has announced new rules related to the export and resale of cyber intrusion software. Once the limits come into effect in 90 days, companies that want ... Read more »

Surgeons transplanted a pig kidney into a person, and it worked like normal

On September 25, in a two-hour procedure, surgeons successfully attached a kidney from a genetically engineered pig to a human patient, who was brain dead. The pig kidney successfully attached, ... Read more »

Fluance Ai41 stereo speakers review: Pint-sized powerhouses

With portable Bluetooth party speakers so common nowadays, it’s easy to forget what real left-and-right separation sounds like. We often sacrifice a wide stereo image for convenience. It’s understandable to ... Read more »

How to install Fortnite on Android

Epic Games launched its battle royale hit Fortnite on Android devices in 2018 with a big catch: it was exclusive to Samsung-made phones for a few days as a way ... Read more »

Startup is developing air taxi to shuttle passengers through cities

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A startup from Israel has unveiled its first ‘easy-to-operate’ two seater flying car, that it hopes will be used to shuttle passengers through ... Read more »

Dropbox is making big moves in the video space

Dropbox is making it even easier for distributed teams to work with video files with the release of its new video-focused online collaboration tool. Dropbox Replay, which was first announced ... Read more »

I went to the first in-person Pokémon Go event in two years and it was amazing

On March 9, 2020, Niantic alerted Pokémon Go players that the St. Louis Safari Zone would be canceled. The Covid-19 pandemic was starting to look a lot more serious than ... Read more »

James Harden Dismisses Lack of Contract Extension With Nets

© Provided by Sports Illustrated James Harden dismissed concerns regarding his commitment to Brooklyn on Tuesday after he opted to bypass a contract extension with the Nets. View the original ... Read more »

The Vikings 'beat Christopher Columbus to the Americas by 471 years'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo It has long been argued that it was the Vikings who first ‘discovered’ North America, arriving in the New World centuries before Christopher ... Read more »

Halloween treats can be a trick for the environment—but there are sustainable swaps

Halloween has arrived. Storefronts are lined with costumes, pumpkins, cider, and of course, tons and tons of candy available for purchase. Consumers can get anything from massive sized variety bags ... Read more »

It's time for the Pixel Watch

© Photo by Amelia Holowaty Krales / The Verge Google’s Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 Pro are the company’s most interesting devices in years. They might actually succeed at the ... Read more »

The latest Minecraft: Java Edition snapshot features brand-new music

© Provided by Windows Central The final steps to bring everything together. What you need to know Mojang Studios is in the final stages of finishing 1.18 ‘Caves and Cliffs ... Read more »

Cyberpunk 2077 and Witcher 3 free upgrades delayed to 2022

© Provided by Windows Central These free upgrades are no longer coming in 2021. What you need to know CD Projekt Red previously announced free current-generation upgrades for Cyberpunk 2077 ... Read more »

Best racing wheels: Thrustmaster, Logitech, Fanatec and more

If you’re on the hunt for the best racing wheels around, then you’re in the right place. A top-notch racing wheel setup can mean A force feedback racing wheel needs ... Read more »

Windows 11 finally gets native Android apps – but only for certain users

Windows 11 finally has the highly anticipated support for Android apps which Microsoft promised upon first revealing the OS – albeit just in testing for now, and only certain Windows ... Read more »

U.S. Democrats scramble to hammer out climate legislation ahead of Glasgow talks

FILE PHOTO: Democratic 2020 U.S. presidential candidate Biden walks past solar panels in Plymouth By Jarrett Renshaw, Jeff Mason and Timothy Gardner WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Congressional Democrats and the White ... Read more »

More taxes needed on cars and gas bills to reach net zero, warns Treasury

Net zero graphic New taxes will be needed to make Britain “net zero” in carbon emissions by 2050, the Treasury warned on Tuesday as it opened the door to extra ... Read more »

PS5 restock: new GameStop, Best Buy, Sony Direct and Walmart dates

Update: There’s a PS5 restock today, and if you’re desperate for a console, follow our PS5 restock Twitter tracker Matt Swider – follow and turn on notifications for alerts. Why ... Read more »

Black Friday TV deals 2021: the best early sales on 4K, OLED and QLED TVs

The Black Friday TV deals event is just over a month away, which means massive savings on 4K, QLED, and OLED TVs. To help you find all the top offers, ... Read more »

Scammers targeted 45m people over past three months

Scam graphic – The Telegraph Scammers targeted nearly 45 million people with fraudulent texts and calls over the summer, the telecoms watchdog has found. More than eight in 10 people ... Read more »

Amazon Prime annual membership may increase soon, here's how much you will pay

Amazon Prime annual membership is reportedly set to increase. The company is increasing its Prime subscription membership fee soon. As per online reports, the new Amazon Prime membership price in ... Read more »

Upserve point of sale system (POS) review

Upserve POS is designed for those in the restaurant and hospitality industries. In our Upserve point of sale system evaluation, we explore Upserve pricing, POS software features, usability and all ... Read more »

Three charts that show what's wrong with the UK's net zero plans

A solar farm in Devon, UK. Jeanette Teare/Shutterstock The UK government has finally published its net zero strategy, which sets out proposals for meeting the national target of net zero ... Read more »

45 million people in UK received scam texts or calls in last three months

Photograph: MITO images GmbH/Alamy The scourge of scam texts and calls has been laid bare by UK telecoms regulator research showing almost 45 million people received at least one in ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy Unpacked Part 2 live blog: what came and what we thought of it

Samsung’s October tech event has wrapped up – it began at 7am PT / 10am ET / 3pm BST today (or 1am AEDT on October 21), and only went on ... Read more »


© Provided by TechRadar Morphée sleep aid 30-second review The quirky little Morphée is a sleep aid built to transform your bedtime routine and offer relaxation sessions. The best thing ... Read more »

Mark Zuckerberg has been added to a DC lawsuit over the Cambridge Analytica scandal

District of Columbia Attorney General Karl Racine is adding Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg to a lawsuit over the Cambridge Analytica data-mining scandal. Racine announced the addition on Twitter this morning, ... Read more »

Geely's Lynk & Co car brand launches mid-size SUV, heads to Saudi Arabia and Kuwait

Lynk & Co, a mid-range car brand spawned out of Geely’s takeover of Volvo Cars, launched a mid-size SUV to take on bestselling electric vehicle models assembled by Tesla and ... Read more »

Cyberpunk 2077 stumbles at last hurdle with PS5 and Xbox Series X upgrade delay

Cyberpunk 2077 – a game synonymous with delays – has been hit with yet another that will see its next-gen upgrade release in early 2022 instead of later this year ... Read more »

Cloud gaming on Apple Arcade may never happen, but why compete with Xbox anyway?

Apple reportedly considered a cloud gaming component or counterpart to Apple Arcade, with one technology analyst claiming the idea was raised – and then mooted – by the tech giant ... Read more »

This Assassin's Creed spin-off is the deep-dive history game that Valhalla fans should play

Ubisoft has just released the latest entry in its Discovery Tour series, this time taking players to the Viking Age. The games are based on Ubisoft’s own Assassin’s Creed series, ... Read more »

9 best baby monitors for peace of mind, from video to audio models

We tried models that monitor your baby’s breathing, oxygen levels and temperature, and even connect to your smartphone (iStock/The Independent ) Any baby monitor worth its salt will leave you ... Read more »