How British experiments risked making the Covid pandemic ‘more lethal’

how british experiments risked making the covid pandemic ‘more lethal’


British scientists carried out experiments that risked creating more dangerous variants during the pandemic, it has been claimed.

In testing led by Imperial College London and funded by the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA), cells were infected with delta and omicron at the same time to see which had a competitive advantage.

Anton van der Merwe, professor of molecular immunology at the University of Oxford, said that such experiments risked combining the two variants to produce something “more lethal” that could have infected scientists or leaked from the laboratory.

“Coronaviruses like Sars-CoV-2 are well known to ‘evolve’ by exchanging genetic material when two distinct viruses infect the same cell,” he said.

“This makes it much more likely that these strains will ‘recombine’ and create a more dangerous variant, which could infect those doing the experiments, who could then spread it into the community.”

Experiments ‘in line with strict regulations’

Prof van der Merwe said using delta and omicron was particularly risky because they were from different lineages and had more differences than those variants closer to the original Wuhan strain.

Imperial College London defended the experiments, which took place in London, arguing that they were needed to inform the pandemic response. It added that they were carried out under high biosafety standards.

A spokesman for the university said: “This government-backed research used viruses no more pathogenic than those already circulating within the population and will provide crucial insights that support government decision-making on how to manage the pandemic.

“It was conducted in a biosafety level three laboratory in line with strict government regulations, and received ongoing approval from the Health and Safety Executive.”

Since the start of the pandemic, there have been fears that Covid-19 leaked from a laboratory in Wuhan, where researchers were carrying out experiments on bat coronaviruses.

In recent decades smallpox, swine flu, sars, and anthrax, as well as foot and mouth disease, have escaped through laboratory leaks.

This week, a report by King’s College London warned that laboratories containing dangerous pathogens are increasing. Three-quarters of maximum security facilities are now located in urban areas, increasing the risk of a leak.

‘Risky research’

Report authors said that many countries are conducting “risky research” that could lead to the “accidental or deliberate release of a pandemic-capable pathogen”.

Dr Filippa Lentzos, co-director of the Centre for Science and Security Studies at King’s College London, said: “There has been a global boom in construction of labs handling dangerous pathogens, but this has not been accompanied by sufficient biosafety and biosecurity oversight.”

Prof van der Merwe has argued previously that many scientists were reluctant to consider the possibility that a laboratory leak started the pandemic for fear of having to curtail their own risky viral experiments.

He discovered that in a separate experiment in Germany, scientists carried out similar tests as Imperial using the alpha and beta variants on hamsters, ferrets and humanised mice.

The paper, published in Nature, was led by Prof Lorenz Ulrich, now at the Friedrich-Loeffler-Institute, Greifswald. It was co-authored by Christian Dorsten, of Charité – Berlin University of Medicine, who signed a letter in the Lancet in 2020 dismissing the possibility that Covid-19 could have leaked from a laboratory.

“There is more opportunity for recombination in animal experiments and selection for more dangerous variants because they involve more cells infected for longer periods,” added Prof van der Merwe

“Handling animals is also riskier in terms of transmission to the experimenter than handling cells.”

He added: “Neither of these experiments are of any help in protecting us from Sars-CoV-2.

“If it was conclusively proven the Sars-CoV-2 pandemic was a result of a laboratory leak it would obviously strengthen that case for stricter global regulation of experiments on potentially dangerous pathogens.”

The UKHSA was approached for comment but said it had nothing more to add beyond Imperial’s response. The Friedrich-Loeffler-Institute had not responded at the time of publication and Charité – Berlin University of Medicine declined to comment.

Sign up to the Front Page newsletter for free: Your essential guide to the day’s agenda from The Telegraph – direct to your inbox seven days a week.

News Related


Belgium detains eight people over suspected attack plan

BRUSSELS (Reuters) – Belgian authorities detained eight people following raids on suspicion of planning an Islamist attack in Belgium, federal prosecutors said on Tuesday. They said in a statement that ... Read more »

Putin will escape Hague trial as key flaw in international arrest warrant, expert claims

Vladimir Putin and his presidential commissioner for children’s rights, Maria Lvova-Belova, were charged with the unlawful deportation of Ukrainian children to Russia by the International Criminal Court (ICC) this month. ... Read more »

Denmark lifts Brexit-related deportation threat for British nationals

Philip Russell and his Danish fiancee, Frederikke, who welcomed the move to give people more time to apply. British nationals have spoken of their “relief” after the Danish government lifted ... Read more »

Chelsea loanee learns surprising fate as Todd Boehly prepares showdown talks over discounted transfer

Chelsea could keep one of their on-loan players for less than the value of their option to buy at the end of the season, a report has claimed. In recent ... Read more »

Jack Ma’s Alibaba empire to be broken up after Beijing crackdown

Jack Ma – AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein, File Alibaba is planning to carve up Jack Ma’s e-commerce empire after a regulatory crackdown by Beijing on China’s technology sector. The Chinese online ... Read more »

2 cheap shares I’d buy as the FTSE 100 slides

Rainbow foil balloon of the number two on pink background Is the recent stock market downturn a cause for concern? Well, it’s certainly hard to remain calm when the FTSE ... Read more »

Man to run London Marathon on crutches after beating bone cancer

Adam Lever is taking on the London Marathon on crutches this year (Pictures: Adam Lever) A man who was diagnosed with a rare form of cancer as a teenager will ... Read more »

'Tricky' for Charles and William to alter plans to meet with Harry during surprise UK trip

The Duke of Sussex surprised royal watchers on Monday when he stepped inside the Royal Courts of Justice in central London to attend in person an ongoing hearing. Shortly after ... Read more »

Ukraine counts heavy cost of Russian attacks on hydropower plants

FILE PHOTO: A view shows the city without electricity after critical civil infrastructure was hit by Russian missile attacks in Kyiv By Pavel Polityuk KYIV (Reuters) – Ukraine is trying ... Read more »

Vin Diesel says the Fast Saga will "truly say goodbye" to Paul Walker's Brian

Vin Diesel has revealed that the Fast & Furious series will share an emotional final farewell to Paul Walker’s character Brian by the end. As fans will remember, Walker passed ... Read more »

Jessica Chastain joins Apple TV+ drama series about hate groups

Jessica Chastain has been cast in Apple TV+’s upcoming series The Savant, focusing on a woman who infiltrates online hate groups. The series is inspired by a real-life story originally ... Read more »

The pretty seaside town just an hour from London named the cheapest place for a beach holiday in the UK

A seaside town in Kent, just an hour’s drive from London, has been named the cheapest place in the UK for a beach holiday. Hythe, located just off the M20 ... Read more »

Donald Trump slams 'incompetent people' in US government for Putin's nuclear escalation

Donald Trump slams ‘incompetent people’ in US government for Putin’s nuclear escalation Donald Trump has blasted “incompetent people” in the US government for Russia’s nuclear escalation. The former US president ... Read more »

Elon Musk makes move which will completely change Twitter in two weeks time

Elon Musk has announced yet another change for Twitter as a way to reportedly tackle the onslaught of bot accounts on the platform. The tech mogul has decided to start ... Read more »

Bruno Fernandes RUBBISHES Cristiano Ronaldo's claim that new Portugal boss Roberto Martinez has been a 'breath of fresh air'

Martinez replaced Santos as Portugal boss after WC Ronaldo welcomed it as a positive change Fernandes claimed things were always good WHAT HAPPENED? The Spanish manager was drafted in to ... Read more »

The best bob haircut to suit your face shape

Big up the bob – shorter styles are currently having a major moment. If you’ve been floating the idea of a chop for some time, now is the time to ... Read more »

Average council tax bill to exceed £2,000 from next month - how much will you pay?

People check their bills Many council taxpayers in England face a bills hike of five percent from next month with the bill for a Band D home in many areas ... Read more »

Vladimir Putin sleeps in Kremlin office due to Ukraine war stress

Vladimir Putin sleeps in Kremlin office due to Ukraine war stress Vladimir Putin has been sleeping in his Kremlin office due to the stress of the Ukraine war. The paranoid ... Read more »

Tyson Fury vs Oleksandr Usyk 'is OFF' as Ukrainian quits training camp

The long awaited heavyweight unification bout between Tyson Fury and Oleksandr Usyk is off, according to reports. After months of negotiations, provisions for an April 29 bout at London’s Wembley ... Read more »

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Drones attack Russian fleet in Crimea port

Ukrainian servicemen fire with a D-30 howitzer at Russian positions near Bakhmut – AFP The Russian navy “repelled” a drone attack on the port of Sevastopol in Moscow-annexed Crimea early ... Read more »

The Apprentice finalist admits 'surprise' over behind-the-scenes clashes

The gruelling interview episode saw Dani Donovan, Megan Hornby, and Victoria Goulbourne fired from the BBC competition. Alan Sugar had some extra help in the latest episode as his advisers ... Read more »

Liverpool and Newcastle could be denied Champions League place even if they finish fourth

Liverpool, Brighton and Newcastle are amongst the Premier League teams that could be denied a Champions League place even if they finish fourth. The race to finish inside the top ... Read more »

Sir Jim Ratcliffe considers new strategy to secure world-record Man Utd takeover

Sir Jim Ratcliffe could team up with another party in an effort to match Manchester United takeover rival Sheikh Jassim bin Hamad Al Thani, it’s been claimed. The British billionaire, ... Read more »

Cannabis users ‘can wake up during surgery’

A man smokes a joint And other stories from the stranger side of life Doctors are warning that cannabis users could wake up in the middle of surgery, and that ... Read more »

This Morning star gets huge new tattoo on his neck for heartwarming reason

This Morning star Gok Wan has revealed his new tattoo as he paid tribute to his nearest and dearest. The fashion guru and occasional chef on the popular ITV daytime ... Read more »

Turned £10k into £40k: How UK's most popular fund has made Isa savers rich

Many private investors will be wary of using their £20,000 stocks and shares Isa allowance before the deadline on April 5, which is now just two weeks away. Yet if ... Read more »

Ukraine war: Xi urges Putin to work together for biggest global changes in a century

Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping attend a reception in Moscow (Reuters) -China’s President Xi Jinping left Russia on Wednesday after a grandiose display of solidarity with ... Read more »

I’ve been doing the TikTok 3-2-1 method workout — here’s what you should know

null With so many trending TikTok workouts flooding social media daily, it’s hard to know which ones actually work. But a recent trend called the 3-2-1 method workout is the ... Read more »

F1 LIVE: Wolff told to tear up Russell's contract, Hill takes swipe at Verstappen's dad

Toto Wolff has been told to rip George Russell’s deal in two as the 25-year-old will take points away from Lewis Hamilton in a future title battle. Russell has starred ... Read more »

F1 bosses are still ignoring Jackie Stewart demands that Lewis Hamilton totally supports

F1 bosses have failed to act on Jackie Stewart’s demands over a major rule change backed by Lewis Hamilton. Decision makers have not updated the rules around the Grand Prix ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự