Hidden trauma: mental illness exacts unseen toll on loved ones

It’s midnight when she has cajoled her 42-year-old son to sleep. Then she rushes to change her 44-year-old daughter who has wet her pants.

To say that 71-year-old Ngo Thi Nam has her hands full would be an understatement.

As soon as lays back on her bed, she jumps again. The noise coming from the next room is loud. "Don't worry Cuong, mommy is coming!"

Mummy rushes over, hands trembling as she opens the door to the room, which is always locked and covered with foam. Its windows are made of wire mesh, leaving only a small opening to give food and drink. Her son, Nguyen Hung Cuong, calls his room a "dog house" in his more "normal" moments.

Cuong had called out to his mother as he always does when he wakes up at all odd hours. If Nam does not appear, he will start banging his head against the iron door. For the last 16 years, after a traffic accident damaged his brain, he has been screaming, smashing things, and only occasionally recognizing people around. He can't distinguish between day and night. Nam has to grab some sleep whenever her son does and be awake whenever he is.

Vietnam, mental illness, mental disorder, mental health, depression

Nam comforts Cuong, who has been suffering from a mental illness for 16 years after a traffic accident damaged his brain, at her house in Bac Giang Province. Photo by VnExpress/Hai Hien.

Nam keeps her son locked most of the time, only letting him out to bathe once every two days. Each time she does that, she asks her her younger brother, who lives next door, to help keep an eye on him. Cuong often runs around. Once he fell into a pond. Another time he banged his against a wall and had to go to the emergency room. Each time he his brought back to his room, Cuong puts up a fierce fight.

"Once my son screamed and clung so hard to the door that three of his fingernails got detached, causing blood to splash everywhere. I could nothing but cry on seeing his bewilderment because he didn't know the pain."

Nam lives in Xuan Bieu Village, Xuan Cam Commune, Hiep Hoa District, Bac Giang Province.

About a month ago, Cuong climbed onto his bed, hit his head against the non-cushioned part of the wall, causing blood to spill and losing consciousness. Since then, Nam also has to tie her son’s hands and spoon feed him to protect him from himself. She also moved her bed from the front yard of her house into Cuong's room. He sleeps on the bed while the mother sleeps on the ground.

Next to the "dog house" is Cuong's sister’s room. Nguyen Bich Hanh was born normal, Nam says, but the bigger she gets, the more she is afraid of strangers. At 14, Hanh was diagnosed with depression, which then descended to an uncurable psychotic illness. The girl once cut her mother's legs with a knife and hit her father's head with a hammer.

Having lost her husband before her son’s accident, for nearly 30 years, Nam has shouldered the burden of her mentally ill children by herself. This also means that she has been living on tenterhooks for nearly 30 years.

"There was a time when I was taking a shower and suddenly heard Cuong calling out for me. Since I was afraid he would hurt himself, I quickly put one leg inside my pants and rushed out, but fell down."

Currently, the three of them live on Nam's meagre monthly pension of around VND3 million ($130), plus an additional allowance of VND540,000 ($23.42) for each disabled child. She has thought many times of admitting Cuong to an institution, but cannot afford it. She loves him too much anyway. "Now I keep him locked up like this for easier management. If I let him free, I have to be afraid of Cuong harming my neighbors."

Vietnam, mental illness, mental disorder, mental health, depression

The Mental Health Department at Hanoi’s Bach Mai Hospital. Photo by VnExpress/Hai Hien.

Mostly undetected, untreated

At a recent workshop to develop a National Plan for the Prevention and Control of Non-communicable Diseases for 2021-2025, a health ministry representative said that about 13.5 million people, accounting for 15 percent of the Vietnamese population, suffer from mental disorders.

According to Dr. Lai Duc Truong of the World Health Organization (WHO), out of 13.5 million people with mental health problems in Vietnam, up to 70-80 percent go undetected and untreated. These patients are a burden for families and some seriously ill people are a risk to the community.

Dr. Nguyen Doan Phuong, head of the Mental Health Department at Hanoi's Bach Mai Hospital, said that the reason for so many untreated mental patients is the lack of specialized staff, the absence of a care center for mental disorders and the symptoms being easily confused with symptoms of other diseases. In addition, because of the stigma involved, the patient's family members avoid examination by psychiatrists, resulting in delayed or avoided treatment.

"People with some mental disorders have a high risk of recurrence. If these are not detected and timely interventions made, they can endanger people around them as well as themselves," Phuong said.

Life on the edge

Under the eaves of a building at the National Institute of Mental Health, Nguyen Van Tinh, 70, was about to step out to buy food when it started raining. The man with silver-streaked hair did not rush back inside. His eyes were fixed on the stream of people coming in and out of the hospital, some with umbrellas, others without. The hospital was as busy as his hometown market in a mountainous district in Thanh Hoa Province.

Hong, his wife, was in the poison detox ward of the Bach Mai Hospital after she drank some herbicide. After more than ten days of taking care of his wife, Tinh was used to the hustle and bustle here, but a leg injury sustained in a past accident troubled him, especially because he had to constantly go up and down the stairs to buy things like rice and water.

Two years ago, Hong had suddenly developed a chronic headache. She did not get better after taking different kinds medicines and the sickness got worse after she started taking some herbal medicines.

Ever since she fell sick, Hong has become very irritable, and curses her husband and breaks things. If her husband says anything aloud, she tells him to stop shouting and scolding her, and if he speaks softly, she thinks he is saying bad things about her. Tinh feels like he is living next to a bomb that can explode at any time.

In the middle of last year, their children took Hong to the hospital and the doctor advised a mental health check at a bigger hospital. Doctors there concluded that she was clinically depressed and are treating her as an outpatient.

"I still think that this disease will be controlled with daily medication. If I knew she could do something dangerous, I would have been more careful and helped her better," Tinh said.

To this day, he does not know why she tried to commit suicide.

Vietnam, mental illness, mental disorder, mental health, depression

Nguyen Van Tinh spends his days these days walking up and down the stairs as he takes care of his wife at the Mental Health Department in Hanoi’s Bach Mai Hospital. Photo by VnExpress/Pham Nga.

The morning of the day Hong drank the herbicide, he was feeding chickens when he heard a loud sound and ran to check. He found his wife frothing at the mouth in the middle of the house. After two days in the emergency ward, she regained consciousness, but no one dared to ask her why she did it. After her health recovered, the doctors transferred her to the Mental Health Institute for treatment.

Even though the worry about the danger of his wife's life has receded, Tinh worries about what rumor and gossip will do the rounds among his neighbors about the incident. In his hometown, depression and mental illness are still a taboo disease despite its wide prevalence. The damage that depression can cause to human health is ranked second after cardiovascular diseases.

According to the WHO, nearly 800,000 commit suicide every year as a result of depression. Up to 85 percent of people who commit suicide are from low-income and middle-income countries and are not treated for the condition.

But another huge part of the problem that goes mostly ignored, especially in countries like Vietnam, is the trauma that caretakers of the patients suffer.

Tinh rues: "They will think I was bad husband, that’s why she tried to commit suicide. But my children tell me to ignore what other people say as long as they believe in me."

When the rain stopped, Tinh dragged his painful leg back to the department after getting the things needed. He does not know how long he will have to stay in the hospital this time and how he will move on from the incident.

However, when his wife is awake, he walks with her around the hospital, the two laughing together like when they were in love more than 40 years ago.

Nam does not know what the future will bring, but she still loves her children dearly. Pushing her hands through the small opening and trying to feed her son, she says: "Cuong, you have to eat well then take a nap for mommy, ok?"

News Related


Cần Thơ celebrates Reunification Day

Visitors view an exhibition of 1,000 books and documents called “Hiền Tài Đất Việt” (Great Vietnamese People) organised by the Cần Thơ City Library until May 24. VNA/VNS Photo by Ánh Tuyết HCM… Read more »

"True Italian Taste" 2021 in Vietnam: Promoting famous Italian cuisine

Italian Ambassador to Vietnam Antonio Alessandro at the press conference. Photo: The People’s Army Newspaper Over the years, “True Italian Taste” events have been held in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City with… Read more »

Vietnamese abroad never forget love for homeland

Photo: VOV Solidarity towards the homeland No matter where they live, what they do, or how difficult their circumstances, it has always been a precious tradition of overseas Vietnamese people to look towards… Read more »

System kicked off to receive feedback in tourism

The app “Du Lịch Việt Nam An Toàn.” Photo dms.gov.vn HÀ NỘI — By installing an app named Du Lịch Việt Nam An Toàn (A Safe Trip in Việt Nam), visitors can provide… Read more »

The dark side of telesales work

At 8:00 a.m. every day the 32-year-old leaves home in Thu Duc City in HCM City for her office four kilometers away. She receives a list of 200 numbers from her team leader,… Read more »

Vietnamese turn lax amid looming Covid-19 threat

On April 25, thousands of people gathered in the pedestrian zone surrounding Hanoi’s Hoan Kiem Lake. Though local authorities had set up several checkpoints reminding visitors to wear their masks and maintain a… Read more »

Vietnamese expats fearful amid India Covid-19 carnage

Nguyen Thi Toan, a Vietnamese resident of Mumbai, wakes up to the sound of ambulances every morning these days. “Too many Covid-19 patients and too many people have died, I have no idea… Read more »

Retired lecturer opens physical therapy clinic for pets

In a 30-meter-square room near the dog training center of the university, Van, 88, is showing her students how to insert thin acupuncture needles into specific points along the body of eight cats… Read more »

Houseplant obsession: an expensive new hobby in Vietnam

A group of about 50 plant enthusiasts in central Da Nang City met one evening in March to show off and admire the beauty of rare, unusual houseplants with complicated scientific names like… Read more »

​Racist hatred leaves psychological mark on Vietnamese living in the west

While Tran Hong Yen was waiting for a train in Munster, Germany last year, two white men passed by and said in German, “Go back to China and take the virus back with… Read more »

Vietnamese in Cambodia anxious amid Covid lockdown

Hong Nhung, living in Phnom Penh, has lived in fear for days as Cambodia sees a spike in new Covid-19 cases. “The pandemic is getting more complicated here, the daily number of new… Read more »

Vietnamese salon workers in US devastated by pandemic, hate attacks

Le Nguyen, 46, emigrated to the U.S. more than 10 years ago and spent years working for a nail salon in California’s Orange County before opening her own in 2018. But not too… Read more »

String portraits depict prominent global artists

The artist from Tan Phu District said he discovered string art during the Covid-19 outbreak last year. “This type of art entails a web of yarn wrapped around a nail system fastened onto… Read more »

Former Hanoi drug addict recalls 20-year road to rehab

“After six miscarriages, my mother gave birth to me, her only child. That’s why I was pampered from a young age. It was part of the reason I fell into drug addiction when… Read more »

'Invisible Love' gains visibility with five int'l film fest prizes

At the Indie Fest in the U.S., which promotes independent filmmakers and unique voices, the movie won the Award of Excellence for its art direction, and the Award of Merit (Asian Film Feature).… Read more »

Fire hazard stalks Vietnam’s tube houses

In just one week recently, there was a fire each in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh which claimed 10 lives. The one in Saigon’s Thu Duc City on March 30 killed six members… Read more »

Vietnamese students adjust to pandemic times in the US

“I came to the U.S. in August last year, right when the Covid-19 outbreak in both America and Vietnam was quite severe. “Besides studying via Zoom, I also interned in the palliative care… Read more »

Saigon girl creates dance challenge to support autistic brother

The 11th grader in Ho Chi Minh City introduces her brother in a YouTube video thus: “His name is Ryan, and he was diagnosed with autism as a child. He never calls me… Read more »

Old at heart Vietnamese youth plan early retirement in nursing homes

“I’m doing fine. Tell everyone that I will be staying here for a while,” Dinh Ngoc Han said as she wrapped a call with her husband at home before continuing to chat with… Read more »

Laid low by pandemic, tourism workers down but not out

Le Trung Truc, a resident of the ancient town of Hoi An, begins his day by walking from home to his boat docked on the banks of the Hoai River. He sits in… Read more »

‘Vietnamese strength’ turns student into an international teacher

“Teacher Tien, may Toshi ask you a question?” The question was asked in Vietnamese during a break in his zoom class. Toshy, a project manager in the U.S., is one of 145 students… Read more »

With fiery resolve, Phu Yen woman rises from the ashes

Ngan, 34, woke up early and went to a local market in Saigon to buy some offerings to place on the altar, preparing for her store’s opening. Her sons were excited and happy… Read more »

Putting parents in old people’s homes still troubling for Vietnamese

For the last year or so Phuong Thu, 37, has not been at ease since she does not know how to take care of her mother, a 70-year-old retired doctor with no interest… Read more »

Bombarded Saigonese yearn to consign the din to the bin

Nguyen Thi Huong was rudely woken up at around midnight by ear-splitting sounds. The din emanated from a nearby pub in Saigon’s Binh Tan District on a Friday. She tried to rest again… Read more »

Tasers, guns, protests: Vietnamese diaspora responds to American anti-Asian violence

Hang Nguyen, a Vietnamese student at the University of California, Davis, never leaves her apartment without a pepper spray given by her relatives a couple of weeks ago. The 29-year-old graduate student also… Read more »

Hanoi watering holes attract huge crowds on reopening day

After remaining closed for nearly two months following the latest Covid-19 outbreak, bars, karaoke parlors and dance clubs in the capital were allowed to open on Tuesday. All businesses in the country are… Read more »

Tasers, guns, protests: Vietnamese diaspora respond to American anti-Asian violence

Hang Nguyen, a Vietnamese student at the University of California, Davis, never leaves her apartment without a pepper spray given by her relatives a couple of weeks ago. The 29-year-old graduate student also… Read more »

Da Nang's Golden Bridge named a new world wonder

“Vietnam’s Golden Bridge, opened in 2018, is designed as though a giant’s hands (made of fiberglass and mesh wire) are gently supporting the 490 feet path (150 m) for pedestrians, which overlooks the… Read more »

Hanoian rolls out hoverboard pho delivery

A pho restaurant on Tran Te Xuong Street, Hanoi’s Ba Dinh District has drawn public attention since its owner, Nguyen Thanh The, 43, employed a hoverboard to deliver bowls of pho to neighborhood… Read more »

​Vietnamese-American actress gets lifetime achievement award at US film festival

The 84-year-old received the Snow Leopard Lifetime Achievement Award, the festival’s highest accolade, at an event in Los Angeles on Tuesday. The AWFF wrote in a Facebook post that the actress “is being… Read more »

​Parents rattled as baleful videos stalk young minds

On March 10 members of an online forum for parents were shaken after Tho Nguyen, who has a hugely popular YouTube channel, uploaded two clips about Kuman thong, a Thai occult doll with… Read more »

Saigonese spends 30 years ripping jeans

At 3 p.m. each day, Vien, traveling from Saigon’s Binh Tan District to Ho Xuan Huong Street in District 3, opens his ripped jeans “shop”. The “shop” comprises a plastic stool on which… Read more »

Separation pangs torment children left behind by migrant parents in rural Vietnam

Six-year-old Nguyen Thanh Tien in the central Ha Tinh Province had a fever after returning from school last week, but it was not until the next day that his grandmother found out the… Read more »

To quit or not: a Covid-19 dilemma for Vietnamese workers

When his roommates turn the lights off to go to bed at 10 p.m., Hoang Minh is just starting his eight-hour shift at work. Sitting with a laptop on his bunk bed, the… Read more »

Vietnamese in US rattled by rising hate crimes against Asians

Walking their dog after dinner has always been a favorite daily activity of Tho Pham and his wife, a Vietnamese couple who live with their 39-year-old son in Garden Grove City, California. But… Read more »

Vietnamese in U.S. rattled by rising hate crimes against Asians

Walking their dog after dinner has always been a favorite daily activity of Tho Pham and his wife, a Vietnamese couple who live with their 39-year-old son in Garden Grove City, California. But… Read more »

Amid political instability, Vietnamese in Myanmar keen to return home

The country has been churning since the army seized power and detained government leader Aung San Suu Kyi and much of her party leadership on February 1. Hundreds of thousands of people have… Read more »

Hai Duong residents overjoyed as social distancing ends

A few hours before the lifting of the province-wide social distancing, local officials work at Covid-19 checkpoints in Chi Linh Town’s Sao Do Square. Social distancing and lockdowns ended on Wednesday. Those crossing… Read more »

Hanoi’s Covid-19 fight leaves street food vendors in the lurch

Nguyen Thi Nhung, 39, decided to stay back in Hanoi instead of returning to her hometown for the Lunar New Year holidays (Tet) because she hoped to open her tea stall soon after… Read more »

Young Vietnamese on the verge of becoming 'lost generation' amid pandemic

Nguyen Thanh Tung, 22, graduated from university in June 2020, and was thrilled to enter a new stage in life. But reality turned out to be harsher than he thought as he spent… Read more »

Burnout, depression stalk Vietnamese mothers coping with pandemic stress

Le Thi Phuong, an hourly wage worker at a textile firm in Hanoi’s Long Bien District, starts her 90-minute lunch break at noon by rushing home to feed her children, whose school and… Read more »

Burnout stalk Vietnamese mothers coping with pandemic stress

Le Thi Phuong, an hourly wage worker at a textile firm in Hanoi’s Long Bien District, starts her 90-minute lunch break at noon by rushing home to feed her children, whose school and… Read more »

Vietnamese Texans suffer with no power or water

On Thursday, Trinh Nguyen, 31, woke up to another day without power and water in Houston, Texas. In close to subzero temperatures, the Vietnamese woman and her four-member family used a fireplace to… Read more »

Covid-19 anxieties mute post-Tet festivities in Hanoi

Nguyen Thi Anh had a very unusual return to work in Hanoi’s Long Bien District on February 17. Instead of partying with her colleagues and going to Buddhist pagodas on the first working… Read more »

Mekong Delta bridge guards maintain suicide watch

It was around 11 p.m. and there was a motorbike parked on the side of the bridge. Then Hua Nhan Hau saw her. The young woman was crying her heart out, standing outside… Read more »

Covid-19 takes a toll on frontline workers’ personal lives

The two, nurses in the outpatient and intensive care units at the newly set up field hospital in the northern province, Vietnam’s coronavirus epicenter now, have spent the last couple of weeks tending… Read more »

Tet in the times of pandemic: muted celebrations for Vietnamese diaspora in US

Thanh Nguyen, 35, an ethnic Vietnamese man living in Virginia, always returns home to Maryland during Tet (Lunar New Year). But this year the nurse decided to stay back and instead celebrate the… Read more »

At Covid-19 epicenter, field kitchens cook up a storm

The shopping and cooking had begun at 5 a.m. and at 10:30 a.m. last Saturday, Nguyen Thi Huyen and other volunteers from Chi Linh Town had delivered more than 140 boxes of chicken… Read more »

With no escape route, expats enjoy Tet ‘at home’

In the five years that he has lived and worked in Vietnam, Daniel Woollacott has developed a tradition of “escaping” Tet, when shops and services are normally shut down and major cities become… Read more »

Early start to Tet exodus over pandemic fears

At 3 p.m. on February 5, Tran Nguyen Thuy Trang was supposed to be in her office in downtown Saigon. Instead she was at the Mien Dong (Eastern Region) Bus Station in Binh… Read more »