Here's why the Evergrande crisis is not China's 'Lehman moment'

The Evergrande headquarters is seen in Shenzhen, southeastern China on September 14, 2021, as the Chinese property giant said it is facing “unprecedented difficulties” but denied rumours that it is about to go under.Noel Celis | AFP | Getty Images

BEIJING — Property developer China Evergrande's debt woes are not likely to cause the same fallout as the collapse of U.S. investment bank Lehman Brothers in 2008, analysts said.

Evergrande's Hong Kong-listed shares have tumbled nearly 90% since July 2020, as the Chinese government cracked down on speculation in the real estate market.

The stock has lost more than 20% in the last five trading days and investors are watching to see if the highly indebted real estate giant will be able to make millions of dollars in interest payments on U.S. dollar-denominated bonds in the coming days. The jitters have contributed to global stock market declines this week.

Evergrande holds physical assets

However, when it comes to the scale of potential impact on international financial markets, analysts point to a major difference between the Evergrande crisis and the Lehman collapse: Evergrande holds land, while Lehman held financial assets.

Evergrande has cash flow problems, but talk of systemic risks is “a bit overdone, frankly,” Rob Carnell, regional head of research for Asia-Pacific at ING, said Wednesday on CNBC's “Squawk Box Asia.”

“Let's face it, this is not Lehman's, this is not LTCM,” Carnell said, referring to a large American hedge fund, Long-Term Capital Management, that failed in the 1990s. “It's not a hedge fund with massive leveraged positions or a bank whose financial asset prices are hurtling towards zero. It's a property development firm with quite a lot of debt, you know, 300 billion plus thereabouts in dollar terms.”

He expects that if Evergrande can get some cash flow into its physical assets, the company can finish its development projects, sell them and start paying down debt.

On Wednesday, the company's real estate group announced it would pay the interest on time on a mainland-traded bond denominated in yuan.

“Evergrande is facing a liquidity crunch although it owns a large land bank,” Larry Hu, chief China economist at Macquarie, said in a report Tuesday. He noted the developer's assets consist primarily of land and housing projects that are worth just over 1.4 trillion yuan ($220 billion).

No Lehman-style contagion story makes sense here and therefore no Lehman Moment will there be.
China Beige Book

The collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008 led to a crash in financial derivatives — credit default swaps and collateralized debt obligations — “causing the market to doubt the health of other banks,” Hu said.

“But it's quite unlikely that the Evergrande saga would cause the land price to crash,” he said. “After all, the value of land is simply more transparent and stable than financial instruments. It's especially so in China, where local government monopolizes the land supply.”

“As the result, [the] local government has a strong incentive to stabilize land price. In the worst-case scenario, local government could even buy back land, as they did in 2014-15,” he added.

Strong government control

Another critical difference in Evergrande's case is the greater level of government control and involvement in China's real estate industry.

“Chinese banks and many other entities are government arms first, intermediators a distant second,” analysts at research firm China Beige Book said in a report Monday. “Even non-state financials can be controlled to an extent rarely seen outside China. Commercial bankruptcy is a state choice.”

“Beijing says lend, so you lend; when or even whether you get your money back is secondary,” the report said. “No Lehman-style contagion story makes sense here and therefore no Lehman Moment will there be.”

The legendary U.S. investment bank collapsed 13 years ago this month in an iconic moment of the global financial crisis. The bank underwrote tens of billions of dollars' worth of securities backed by risky mortgages during a U.S. housing bubble. The U.S. government ultimately allowed Lehman to fail, while bailing out other financial institutions.

In China's case, Beijing has tried to allow the market to play a greater role in the economy by letting more state-owned enterprises' loans default.

Authorities will be patient in Evergrande's case as they have two goals of preventing excessive risk-taking and maintaining stability in the property market, said Macquarie's Hu.

Read more about China from CNBC Pro

“Policymakers would choose to wait first, then step in later to ensure an orderly debt restructuring,” he said. “A wholesale bailout is not very likely and shareholders/lenders might take a big loss. But the government would make sure that the pre-sold apartments get done and delivered to homebuyers.”

Hu also pointed to the Chinese government's recent track record in restructuring giants such as Anbang Insurance, Baoshang Bank, HNA Group and China Huarong Asset Management. “China's banking system has an annual profit of 1.9 [trillion yuan] and a provision of 5.4 [trillion yuan], which could easily absorb the loss from Evergrande,” he said.

'China has the tools,' IMF says

In Evergrande's case, the property developer has more direct ties to foreign investors than the bulk of China's economy.

The company has about $19 billion in total offshore bonds outstanding, equivalent to about 9% of U.S. dollar-denominated Chinese bonds, according to investment bank UBS. Evergrande's total liabilities of about $313 billion is about 6.5% of the total liability of China's property sector, the report said.

The UBS analysts expect Evergrande to restructure its debt, and predict that bond prices will recover from their lows and limit contagion.

The analysts also laid out a range of possible spillover effects if Evergrande were to enter the less likely scenario of full liquidation, such as the failure of exposed banks and selling across emerging market credit.

International Monetary Fund Chief Economist Gita Gopinath told Reuters this week the organization believes “China has the tools and the policy space to prevent this turning into a systemic crisis.”

The IMF can organize bailouts for countries or regions in financial stress.

Loading chart…

Even though public government statements in recent months have called for preventing major financial risks, Chinese authorities' intervention is not a given.

Chinese officials have so far made few major public statements about Evergrande.

At a press conference last week, a National Bureau of Statistics spokesman said the department is monitoring the difficulties of some large real estate companies and the potential impact on the economy.

China's real estate market, along with related industries such as construction, accounts for more than a quarter of national GDP, according to Moody's estimates.

Bets that property prices would only rise ultimately forced many Chinese households to take out mortgages to afford homes. In the last few years, the government has tried to cool the market with measures such as restrictions on the level of debt developers can take on.

— CNBC's Eustance Huang and Weizhen Tan contributed to this report.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Popular Penny Stocks to Buy in October? 3 For Your Watchlist

3 Penny Stocks That Are Popular With Retail Traders in October  In the past year and a half, retail traders have taken penny stocks by storm. It’s worth noting that ... Read more »

Buying Stocks: Investing Myths and Facts

We always hear or read about how important it is to invest . What’s more, even financial experts tell us that saving is useless if you don’t plan to invest ... Read more »

Women VCs have the edge to transform the world with more balanced funding

The Venture Capital industry creates a thriving ground for the establishment and growth of innovative and strategic businesses. Not only does a venture capitalist play a significant role in building ... Read more »

The 5 basic principles to start investing according to Eduardo Rosas from 'Personal Finance'

In August 2019, Eduardo Rosas was very clear about two things: his path to financial freedom and that there was very little information about it. So I created the YouTube ... Read more »

Another Rally Lifts Stocks More Than 1.5% for the Week

A robust start to earnings season combined with a reassuring series of economic data sparked three straight days of gains for the market, leaving each of the major indices with ... Read more »

Knowing and knowing yourself, the two basic elements to be an investor according to Alfonso Marcelo

With 20 years of experience in the financial world, Alfonso Marcelo is an authority in the field. The founder of Finformado and co-author of the book ‘Dear money, I hate ... Read more »

Will Hurricane Ida Put a Dent on Chemical Industry's Q3 Earnings?

Hurricane Ida that barreled into Louisiana with a devastating force on Aug 29 left behind widespread destruction across the U.S. Gulf Coast and the Northeast. The Category 4 hurricane caused ... Read more »

Are You Prepared for a Major Medical Crisis? Here's How a Crisis Can Affect You Financially

My mom contracted pancreatic cancer when she was just 55 years old. Thankfully, eight years later, she still plays a mean game of pickleball — good luck if you get ... Read more »

50 tips to save in your day to day

Ant expenses are responsible for our portfolio becoming thinner than expected. These do when the time comes to pay for basic services, it does not reach you, that you become ... Read more »

The Bitcoin Breakout Is Here. Don't Take My Word for It. Look at This Chart!

InvestorPlace – Stock Market News, Stock Advice & Trading Tips Investorplace.com – InvestorPlace Bitcoin (CCC:BTC-USD) finally did it. For the first time since April, Bitcoin reclaimed the psychologically important $60,000 ... Read more »

VeChain Price Predictions: How High Can Coming Upgrades Take the VET Crypto?

InvestorPlace – Stock Market News, Stock Advice & Trading Tips Investorplace.com – InvestorPlace It’s most definitely upgrade season across the sea of blockchain networks. Ethereum (CCC:ETH-USD) is beginning to make serious ... Read more »

Alibaba Stock Is Ready to Make Its Big Comeback Before This Fall Is Out

InvestorPlace – Stock Market News, Stock Advice & Trading Tips Investorplace.com – InvestorPlace Alibaba (NYSE:BABA) stock has taken a hammering at the stock market as a result of Beijing’s crackdown on ... Read more »

3 Cryptocurrency Comeback Stocks to Buy Now

After taking a major downturn in the summer, cryptocurrencies have been bouncing back in a big way throughout October and proving that investors still have an appetite for these high-flying ... Read more »

3 No-Brainer Stocks to Buy in the Financial Sector

With rising yields and persistent concerns about inflation, it might be prudent to consider making a deposit into some of the top names in the financial sector at this time. ... Read more »

Watch CNBC's Sustainable Future Forum 2021: Responsibility & Regulation

[The stream is slated to start at 2 a.m. ET. Please refresh the page if you do not see a player above at that time.] Click on the stream above ... Read more »

Banks likely to maintain tight grip on household loans in Q4

SEOUL, Oct. 18 (Yonhap) — Banks in South Korea are expected to maintain their tight grip on lending to households in the fourth quarter of this year as the government ... Read more »

COP26: 'Climate risk is investment risk', says BlackRock ESG lead

© Provided by City AM “Climate risk is investment risk,” the ESG lead at investment heavyweight BlackRock has said, as the UN’s Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI) outlines not only ... Read more »

S. Korea to soon decide whether to join CPTPP: finance minister

WASHINGTON, Oct. 17 (Yonhap) — South Korea plans to decide whether to join a mega Asia-Pacific free trade agreement involving 11 nations as early as this month in an effort ... Read more »

Property asking prices increase in all regions of UK in October

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo Every region of Britain saw house asking price records broken in October, as the national average jumped nearly £5,000.  It was the ... Read more »

Cost of car insurance fell by 9.4% in year to August, analysis finds

The average motor insurance premium plunged by 9.4% over the year to August, according to analysis. © Ben Birchall The average motor insurance premium plunged by 9.4% over the year ... Read more »

Back to 2007: UK house prices rise for every region and buyer type

© Provided by City AM It’s a full house for the UK home buying market, with property prices rising last month in every region of the UK, London included, and ... Read more »

Dow futures gain slightly ahead of a big week of earnings

U.S. stock index futures were slightly higher during overnight trading on Sunday, after the major averages posted their best week in months amid a stronger-than-expected start to earnings season. Futures ... Read more »

Bitcoin bull Mark Yusko sees trouble at $60,000, calls the cryptocurrency 'overbought' right now

A bitcoin bull is on pullback watch. Hedge fund manager Mark Yusko believes investors will take profits due to the cryptocurrency's sharp rally over the last few weeks. “There are ... Read more »

Afghan families 'are selling their CHILDREN to make ends meet'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Families in Afghanistan are being forced to sell their children to pay off debts, as the country’s economy teeters on the brink of ... Read more »

Interest rate hike could add £687-a-year to mortgages - but charge can be avoided

Analysts at Moneyfacts.co.uk calculated that should the Bank of England raise the base rate from 0.1 percent to 0.5 percent people could end up paying £57.25 extra a month – ... Read more »

Christmas payment dates 2021 - Every payment date plus Christmas bonus

A wide range of benefit recipients will also receive a Christmas bonus this year. Many claimants can receive a small boost to their income, and the payment is tax-free too, ... Read more »

DWP benefit claimants eligible for £1,000 in support after loved one dies - how to apply

Funeral Expenses Payment is available to DWP benefit claimants if they receive money from one of the department’s various social security schemes. The payment goes towards the costs that accumulate ... Read more »

Hands off our fuel! Sunak facing new £1.50 petrol tax headache as cost of living soars

A report by the Centre for Policy Studies also urges the Chancellor to freeze alcohol duty ahead of the upcoming spending review as a pack of lager faces a 36p ... Read more »

Social Security beneficiaries will soon see the biggest jump in monthly checks in 40 years. How to prepare

VALERIE MACON | AFP | Getty Images People who collect Social Security are about to see bigger checks. The cost-of-living adjustment in 2022 will be 5.9%, the Social Security Administration ... Read more »

Caernarfon pub in dispute with holiday giant Booking.com over fraudulent card use by guest

A pub landlord in Caernarfon is in dispute with holiday giant Booking.com over fraudulent card use by a guest. John Evans runs the Black Boy and is signed up with ... Read more »

Bitcoin price – live: BTC analyst makes $150k prediction as investors prepare for ETF ‘frenzy'

LIVE – Updated at 13:18 © Getty Images bitcoin price all time high new.jpg Bitcoin has broken above $60,000 for the first time since April, prompting a market-wide price surge. ... Read more »

Inheritance Tax warning as Britons dragged into ‘hidden wealth bracket' by Rishi Sunak

Inheritance Tax (IHT) is a levy payable on the value of an estate above a particular threshold – usually £325,000 – of a person who has passed away. The tax ... Read more »

‘Outrageous!' Family holidays from Heathrow could increase by £100, expert warns

The cost of a family summer holiday could rise next year due to Heathrow airport‘s planned price hikes. Passengers flying from Heathrow will be charged substantially more for a holiday ... Read more »

Polygenic screening of embryos is here, but is it ethical?

The birth of the first IVF baby, Louise Brown, in 1978 provoked a media frenzy. In comparison, a little girl named Aurea born by IVF in May 2020 went almost ... Read more »

Cleaning guru Aggie MacKenzie tells ME & MY MONEY she made £440,000 from TV work in one year... but felt like she didn't deserve it

© Provided by This Is Money ( The best financial decision Aggie MacKenzie ever made was giving up her job at the Good Housekeeping Institute to present Channel 4 TV ... Read more »

Five ways to reduce your mortgage as one in 10 struggle to afford monthly payments

One in ten homeowners have struggled meeting their mortgage repayments over the past year, according to government figures. The government’s Household Resilience Study said this has more than doubled from ... Read more »

[Law Talk] Trademark issues in the world of the metaverse

Lee Keun-woo (left) and Helen H. HwangThe word “metaverse,” a portmanteau of the prefix “meta” (meaning beyond) and “universe,” is typically used to refer to a communal and interactive cyberspace ... Read more »

Tightened lending still under way amid eased rules on housing rent loan

A pedestrian passes by a commercial bank promoting jeonse and mortgage loans, on Sunday. The FSC is considering toughening up rules for the current debt service ratios, or DSR, as ... Read more »

Pensioners who claim this ONE key State benefit could instantly get up to SIX more

Campaigners are urging everyone to check whether family, friends or neighbours are claiming pension credit, as many are confused about what support is available. By helping somebody out, you could ... Read more »

HMRC warning as Britons could face £100 penalty if missing vital tax deadline this month

HMRC helps millions of people to deal with their tax affairs each year, and October is a particularly busy month. This is because October 31, 2021 at midnight marks the ... Read more »