Here's why Democrats' proposed elimination of Roth conversions for the wealthy doesn't start until 2032

Asia's Tech News Daily
Photo by Mike Kline (notkalvin) | Moment | Getty Images

House Democrats proposed a rule to forbid Roth conversions for the wealthy as part of a broad package of tax increases on affluent Americans.

But there's an irony in the proposal, according to tax experts.

A Roth conversion is a mechanism that allows taxpayers to switch their traditional (pre-tax) retirement savings to after-tax Roth funds. The person must pay income tax on the converted amount.

Unlike other aspects of Democrats' tax package, most of which would take effect in 2022, the prohibition on Roth conversions of pre-tax funds doesn't kick in for 10 years. The long lead time would give more wealthy taxpayers the ability to convert their retirement accounts before being disallowed — which would eke out extra tax revenue for Democrats' policy agenda, experts said.

More from Personal Finance:
Large cash lottery drawings not enough to increase Covid-19 vaccination rates
Covid-related scams have bilked Americans out of $586 million
Great Resignation may lead companies to offer financial wellness benefits

But the provision would also promote the very conversions they're trying to curtail, according to Ed Slott, an accountant and retirement expert based in Rockville Centre, New York.

“[The legislation] encourages an acceleration of Roth conversions,” Slott said. “[Democrats] need the money.

“They still want all the conversion tax revenue to pay for everything else in the bill.”

Of course, after the 10 years, the wealthy would no longer be able to use Roth conversions to skirt existing income limits on Roth individual retirement accounts.

Currently, single individuals can't contribute to Roth IRAs if they make at least $140,000 of income in 2021. (There's a $208,000 limit for married couples who file a joint tax return.)

But there isn't an income limit on Roth conversions – allowing the wealthy to get a “backdoor” Roth IRA.

Roth IRAs are financially attractive due to tax-free investment earnings, no future taxes upon withdrawal, and no annual required minimum distributions.

However, Democrats' tax proposal, passed last month by the House Ways and Means Committee, would disallow Roth conversions from a pre-tax IRA or employer-sponsored retirement plan for single taxpayers with over $400,000 of annual income (and married couples with more than $450,000) after 2031.

“By keeping Roth conversions up for high-income taxpayers on the table for another decade, legislators can count on the income from those conversions for budget projections,” wrote certified financial planner Jeffrey Levine and Michael Kitces, respectively chief planning officer and head of planning strategy for St. Louis-based Buckingham Wealth Partners, in an analysis of the tax proposals.

A spokesperson for the House Ways and Means Committee didn't return a request for comment on the proposal's timeline.

The Joint Committee on Taxation, Congress' tax scorekeeper, estimates the provision would raise $749 million through 2031. That's a sliver of the $2 trillion or so that would be raised over a decade by other tax provisions aimed at the wealthy and corporations, which would fund measures to expand education, child care, paid leave and health care, among other things.

The Senate hasn't yet unveiled its tax-reform package, which may not include the Roth-conversion prohibition.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Busy with Saints Shoppers, but measures observed

According to Intertoys CEO Eddy Assies, sales in the toy stores are going well. “People still come to buy gifts at the last minute or pick up items that have ... Read more »

Hero Electric aims to raise fresh funds of $200-$300 million; looking to tap PE funds

In June, Hero Electric raised around $30 million from Gulf Islamic Investments and existing investor OAKS Asset Management (formerly Alpha Capital). Six months after closing the first part of its ... Read more »

China finally approves Boeing 737 Max Long-awaited safety clearance 'light at the end of the tunnel' for American planemaker

A Boeing 737 Max passenger jet prepares to land after a test flight at Boeing Field in Seattle in June 2020. (Reuters File Photo) 
BEIJING: Chinese authorities have approved the ... Read more »

BP oil spill fund: $103M to projects in 3 Gulf states

The Associated PressFILE – Drilling rigs and workboats operate at the site of the Deepwater Horizon incident in the Gulf of Mexico Friday, July 16, 2010. Alabama, Florida and Mississippi ... Read more »

Best read on dft.nl: Helping construction workers, cliniclowns and the Bijenkorf

The cliniclown earns better than an IC nurse, says Armand Girbes, professor of intensive care medicine at Amsterdam UMC. Is that really so? So yes. But the salary of cliniclowns ... Read more »

Afghanistan may face economic collapse if its frozen assets are not released: Pak FM Qureshi

Representative image Afghanistan may face an economic collapse if its frozen assets are not released to cope with the burgeoning needs, Pakistan Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi said on Saturday. ... Read more »

Construction workers, cliniclowns and the Bijenkorf

The cliniclown earns better than an IC nurse, says Armand Girbes, professor of intensive care medicine at Amsterdam UMC. Is that really so? So yes. But the salary of cliniclowns ... Read more »

BCCI increases age limit for match officials, support staff to 65 years

BCCI President Sourav Ganguly (Image: Reuters) In a big relief to the scores of match officials and support staff who had to leave after reaching 60, the BCCI on Saturday ... Read more »

Kunal Rawal: ‘The landscape of menswear has changed, grooms are far more involved today'

When celebrity fashion designer Kunal Rawal began his career 15 years ago, he became one of the youngest designers in India to take on individual projects as costume designer and stylist ... Read more »

Shopkeepers: busy in shopping street, measures well observed

Photo: ANP It is busy in the shopping streets with people who still want to buy presents for Sinterklaas. The crowds are easy to maintain and people adhere to the ... Read more »

Vinod Dua, veteran journalist, dies at 67; daughter Mallika pens emotional note

Vinod Dua (Image credit: Twitter) Veteran journalist Vinod Dua who was being treated at a hospital and was critical for about a week, breathed his last on Saturday, his daughter, ... Read more »

Former BT Group chairman du Plessis in frame to chair UK audit watchdog

Jan du Plessis, who stepped down as BT's chairman last week, is on a shortlist of candidates to become the final chairman of the Financial Reporting Council, Sky News learns. Read more »

Maharashtra: MSRDC begins land acquisition process for Jalna-Nanded stretch of Samruddhi Mahamarg

Representational image. The Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation (MSRDC) on Saturday kicked off its land acquisition programme for the proposed Jalna-Nanded extension to the 701-mm Nagpur-Mumbai Samruddhi Mahamarg, an official ... Read more »

Bitcoin price down over 17% to $47,060, says CoinDesk data

It is a decentralized digital currency without a central bank or single administrator Read more »

Govt will bring a 'well consulted' cryptocurrency bill: Nirmala Sitharaman

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said on December 4 that the government will bring a well consulted cryptocurrency Bill. Speaking at the Hindustan Times Leadership Summit ... Read more »

Shriram Properties IPO price band set at Rs 113-118 per share

Shriram Properties IPO South India-based real estate development company Shriram Properties has fixed a price band at Rs 113-118 per share for its initial public offering, which will open for subscription ... Read more »

Primary market buzzing with activity as 4 IPOs hit the Street next week. Check out all the details

IPOs in December It’s raining IPOs on Dalal Street as four companies—RateGain Travel Technologies, Shriram Properties, CE Info Systems (MapmyIndia) and a Rakesh Jhunjhunwala-backed company Metro Brands—will launch their offers ... Read more »

Goldman Sachs lowers US growth forecast due to Omikron

Photo: ANP Investment bank Goldman Sachs lowers growth expectations for the United States economy due to the rise of the Omikron variant of the corona virus. The economists say that ... Read more »

Exclusive | Infosys does away with COO role after UB Pravin Rao, appoints co heads of delivery, CTO

Infosys COO UB Pravin Rao Software major Infosys will do away with the role of Chief Operating Officer after incumbent UB Pravin Rao retires this month. Instead, it will now ... Read more »

Canara Bank launches limited period offer, home loan now starting at 6.65%

Canara Bank on December 4 announced the launch of a limited period offer where customers can avail home loan at an interest rate starting from 6.65 percent per annum. This ... Read more »

No portfolio comes with zero risk, so these are 4 ways to reduce risk of your investment portfolio

Rahul Jain, President & Head, Personal Wealth, Edelweiss Wealth Management A constant companion to your investment portfolio that you need to take guard against is risk. The quantum of risk ... Read more »

Banking authority EBA wants restraint with high dividend

Photo: ANP The European Banking Authority (EBA) wants financial institutions in Europe to exercise restraint with high dividend payments and extensive share buyback programmes. The EBA warns lenders that the ... Read more »

Daily Voice | Star Health may see a weak debut, but insurance industry's medium-long term growth intact, says Vinod Nair of Geojit

Vinod Nair, Head of Research at Geojit Financial Services believes the market is in an oversold territory, and positive developments could ease caution. “Sentiment around Omicron has improved, and importantly, a ... Read more »

Windfall for Sinterklaas, slightly cheaper than last year

This is apparent from figures that the economic bureau of ING collects every year for Sinterklaas, and passes on to De Telegraaf. chocolate letters Chocolate letters in particular have become ... Read more »

Bitcoin plummets again amid stock market turmoil

Photo: ANP The price of bitcoin and other digital currencies fell sharply again on Saturday, amid the great turmoil in the financial markets due to the advance of the Omikron ... Read more »

Bitcoin crashes: -17%

The ether plunged 15 percent to less than $4,000. The total value of all digital coins in circulation worldwide fell by almost a fifth to about 2.2 trillion dollars, or ... Read more »

Bitcoin and other tokens plunge as worldwide capital market jitters spill over to cryptocurrencies

Bitcoin plunged along with other cryptocurrencies on Saturday, in another indication of the risk aversion sweeping across financial markets. The largest digital token fell to as low as US$42,296 before ... Read more »

Moldova to post tender for selecting company to audit debt to Gazprom this month

The finance ministry is dealing with the issue," Infrastructure Minister Andrei Spinu said, adding that "Moldova will pay for the audit as it is in its interests." Read more »

Rebound in gold imports widens India's trade deficit

Representative Image Indian households are once again hoarding gold, pushing up the import bill and widening the trade deficit. The country’s trade deficit widened to $122 billion in April-November 2021, ... Read more »

Column: new cabinet has to deal with increasing uncertainties

Premium The best of De Telegraaf Through allegedly and from the squad 13 min ago in FINANCIAL The new coalition, which will again be led by Mark Rutte, will face ... Read more »

Ombudsman: Apologizing counts

One day, mail for Annabel from the Youth Protection Department is sent to her old address. She gets the letter from the new residents. The letter has been opened. Annabel ... Read more »

Former Netflix engineer, friend sentenced in insider trading scheme

The group illegally made more than $3 million using non-public data about subscriber growth — a key metric that influenced stock price. Read more »

From Tesla to Nvidia, Wall Street's favourites keep tumbling

The highest flying of Wall Street’s stock-market darlings are now taking a major beating. Tesla, Netflix, Nvidia and Facebook-owner Meta Platforms have all lost over 10 per cent in the ... Read more »

'Watered-down hope': Experts wanted more from climate pact

The Associated PressClimate activists hold a demonstration through the venue of the COP26 U.N. Climate Summit in Glasgow, Scotland, Friday, Nov. 12, 2021. Negotiators from almost 200 nations were making ... Read more »

PepsiCo's intellectual property right on FL-2027 potato variety revoked

Farm activist Kavitha Kuruganti has contended that the intellectual property right (IPR) granted to PepsiCo India on a potato variety was not as per provisions laid down for registration and ... Read more »

U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israel-based NSO Group's spyware: Sources

Representative image Apple Inc iPhones of at least nine U.S. State Department employees were hacked by an unknown assailant using sophisticated spyware developed by the Israel-based NSO Group, according to ... Read more »

Addressing the need-gaps: How India's fintechs can make deeper inroads in rural India

Before UPI stepped into, and arguably inaugurated, the digital payments space in India, it was hard to imagine that transactions could ever be as swift and seamless. Launched by NPCI ... Read more »

GIC Re will continue to focus on bottom-line approach: CMD Devesh Srivastava

Devesh Srivastava, Chairman and Managing Director – General Insurance Corporation of India State-owned reinsurer General Insurance Corporation of India (GIC Re) is transitioning to a bottom-line approach and lowering the ... Read more »

Porn, bullying and body-part auctions: Inside Clubhouse India's content moderation struggles

“I feel violated and disgusted. Nobody, no woman, likes their body parts being auctioned by a troll army,” said Swaty Kumar, an IT professional, her voice cracking as she recounted ... Read more »

As Didi exits New York, will a listing by Chinese ride-hailing firm be welcomed in Hong Kong?

The US delisting of Didi Chuxing could offer a test case for whether Chinese companies being investigated by Beijing would be welcomed in Hong Kong, which is ramping up stock ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic