Here's why Biden's vaccine mandate for private employers is a horrible idea

Last week, President Biden announced that the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) soon will require all private employers with more than 100 employees to require workers to become vaccinated or submit to weekly COVID-19 tests. Whatever you think of vaccines or vaccine mandates, if you care about constitutional government, you should oppose this action.

© getty Here’s why Biden’s vaccine mandate for private employers is a horrible idea

Let’s get this out of the way up front: Vaccines are a brilliant, lifesaving innovation. That’s doubly true of the COVID-19 vaccines, which were developed in record time and have allowed Americans to return to some semblance of normalcy during the pandemic. If you aren’t fully vaccinated, you probably should be.

But not every good idea should be mandated by law. Indeed, in a free society, we all have the right to make important decisions about our lives and we must bear the consequences of those decisions. Governments exist, as the Declaration of Independence puts it, to protect our rights, not to force us to make good choices.

True, no one has the right to infect another person with a deadly virus. But how the government should police that is a knotty question that we’ve been grappling with throughout the pandemic. At this point, though, those who are primarily at risk are people who have chosen not to get vaccinated. We should all be free not to associate with them – which means employers have every right to require workers to get vaccinated or quit – but I’m skeptical that governments should force them to get vaccinated.

Whatever you think about these issues, though, if we are going to have a national vaccine mandate, it must come from Congress, not the president or unelected bureaucrats at OSHA.

Video: Some health care workers push back against mandates (CNBC)

Under our Constitution, only Congress has the power to make law. The job of the executive branch – including agencies such as OSHA – is to enforce the laws written by Congress. Unfortunately, over the past century or so, Congress has handed much of its lawmaking power over to the executive, typically by authorizing agencies to pass rules that have the force of law.

OSHA is a good example. Congress gave it the broad, undefined power to establish workplace safety standards that are “reasonably necessary or appropriate.” In an emergency, OSHA can pass temporary rules that are necessary to prevent a “grave threat” from toxic or physically harmful “substances or agents,” or from “new hazards.” These standards give the agency incredibly broad discretion to mandate the safety protocols for virtually every workplace in the nation. Simply put, like most regulatory agencies today, OSHA makes law. And Congress rarely has anything to do with it.

This is a serious threat to constitutional government. The separation of powers exists to ensure that, as John Adams put it, we have “a government of laws and not of men.” Imagine if the police and prosecutors not only enforced the laws against you but also wrote them. James Madison called the concentration of government power in one branch “the very definition of tyranny.” Every authoritarian government proves his point. They always end up concentrating the power in one leader, who then can dictate the laws and change them at will.

And a breakdown of the separation of powers means a breakdown in accountability. Our government can be based on the consent of the governed only if the governed have a role in the lawmaking process. But when our laws come from agencies such as OSHA, there’s no debate in Congress and no ability to vote the bums out of office if you don’t like the result.

Meanwhile, Congress gets to take credit for popular regulations and then blame agencies when something goes wrong. We saw an example of this when President Biden declined to renew the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) eviction moratorium and then changed course after members of Congress protested the “tidal wave of evictions” that allegedly would result without a moratorium. How can anyone take lawmakers seriously when they refuse to do the hard work of passing laws they support and instead complain that the president or an agency won’t do their jobs for them? And forcing the CDC to pass housing laws can’t have helped its already tarnished reputation. Likewise, ramming a vaccine mandate through OSHA – whose purpose is workplace safety, not public health – will breed contempt for the agency and for the rule of law.

It’s no secret that the president is using OSHA to avoid the difficult process of getting a vaccine mandate passed by Congress. The courts may allow him to get away with it. They’ve permitted Congress to cede its authority to agencies for decades. But that doesn’t make it proper. If we want constitutional government, we need to start demanding that our political leaders follow the separation of powers. The Constitution and the rule of law are too important not to.

Steve Simpson is an attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation, a nonprofit legal organization that defends Americans’ liberties when threatened by government overreach and abuse.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


I'm a mum-of-11 and I'm sick of people judging me – trolls assume our house is pandemonium but I'm incredibly organised

AFTER having kids, most of us mums resign ourselves to never having a tidy house again… or at least, not until they move out in 18 years' time. But just ... Read more »

Brit kidnapped and held for ransom says he was tasered and waterboarded

A WEALTHY Brit adventurer who was kidnapped and held for ransom for eight days has said he was tasered and waterboarded by his captors. Sam Demilecamps, 25, was also beaten ... Read more »

Legal Aid lawyers attack a solid move to reduce the Rikers chaos

REUTERS Gov. Kathy Hochul offered another helping hand on the Rikers crisis, agreeing to move more than 200 women and transgender detainees out of the island’s jails to state prisons ... Read more »

Biden's inflation games will do lasting damage, especially to the elderly and poor

President Joe Biden keeps denying that inflation is hurting American wallets across the country, regardless if they’re rich or poor. REUTERS/Leah Millis White House Chief of Staff Ron Klain recently ... Read more »

8 jenis makanan terbaik di saat anda jatuh sakit

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Buah-buahan segar dan sayuran hijau sangat bagus sebagai pilihan makanan untuk orang sakit. (Gambar Rawpixel) Kita semua mungkin tidak akan selalu sihat dan ketika ... Read more »

Watchdog: Psaki violated ethics law by promoting McAuliffe

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved Biden – Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved A government watchdog group said Friday that it had filed an ... Read more »

College degree is now ‘a matter of life and death,' say Nobel Prize winners

© Getty Images Research suggests a college education is a better signifier than ethnicity for morality – Getty Images Two Nobel prize winners have argued that having a college degree ... Read more »

Kayleigh McEnany accused of hypocrisy for complaining about Psaki backing candidates: ‘Sit this one out'

© Reuters White House press secretary Kayleigh McEnany, who was cut off by Fox – Reuters Kayleigh McEnany, the former White House Press Secretary whose boss’s tenure was marked by ... Read more »

AP source: No one else in NFL cited with email violations

© Provided by Associated Press Raiders Gruden Football The NFL has found no other current team or league personnel to have sent emails containing racist, homophobic or misogynistic language similar ... Read more »

Irdai moots premium hike for rebuilding in disaster areas

© Provided by The Times of India Mumbai: The insurance regulator has mooted the introduction of a differential premium for insured properties that are rebuilt on sensitive terrain after a ... Read more »

Bankers see risk in chase for commercial papers

© Provided by The Times of India Mumbai: Availability of cheap funds in the money markets through commercial papers is prompting financial intermediaries to arbitrage and chase higher returns. While ... Read more »

Shriram Housing raises Rs 300 crore from parent

© Provided by The Times of India Chennai: Shriram Housing Finance, part of the Shriram Group, has received a second round of equity capital funding of Rs 300 crore from ... Read more »

Hackers steal $600,000 from Troyer Foods

Oct. 15—GOSHEN — An executive with Troyer Foods told police a hacker stole more than $600,000 from the company. An unknown suspect hacked into email accounts between the company and ... Read more »

Biden says those who refuse to testify in Jan 6 probe should be prosecuted

FILE PHOTO: Supporters of U.S. President Donald Trump gather in Washington WASHINGTON (Reuters) -U.S. President Joe Biden said on Friday the U.S. Justice Department should prosecute people who are subpoenaed ... Read more »

ACT allows travel to more NSW regions

Residents of the ACT have been given the green light to visit a further 26 NSW postcode areas after a relaxing of coronavirus quarantine requirements. © Mick Tsikas/AAP PHOTOS The ... Read more »

Police enforcement officer launches foul-mouthed rant at legally-parked driver

A POLICE enforcement officer launched a foul-mouthed rant at a motorist who parked legally to take in a sea view. The campervan driver pulled up behind a police van on ... Read more »

Russell Wilson's IR stint ends his streak of Seahawks starts

RENTON, Wash. — The Seattle Seahawks will place quarterback Russell Wilson on injured reserve and are considering a similar move with running back Chris Carson after ruling him out of ... Read more »

25 years after the Criminal Assets Bureau was formed, its success is illustrated by the retreat of mobsters from these shores

THE State agency tasked with seizing the ill-gotten gains of the country’s criminals over the past quarter-century is now investigating more targets than ever before. And while the criminal landscape ... Read more »

Chandigarh: Police vehicle damaged in hit-and-run accident

© Provided by Hindustan Times No one was injured in the mishap that took place near Sector 36 in Chandigarh. (HT Photo/for representation only) A police vehicle was damaged after a ... Read more »

At 162, India logs lowest Covid-19 deaths in 211 days

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Amid Dussehra and Vijayadashami celebrations, India reported around 16,000 fresh cases of Covid-19 while the death toll from the virus fell ... Read more »

Contamination concerns over 90km wastewater pipeline in Central West NSW

© Provided by ABC NEWS Rebecca and David Price’s farm fronts 10km of the Belubula River, downstream of the proposed Regis McPhillamy gold mine. (ABC Central West: Luke Wong ) Lithgow’s ... Read more »

Terminally ill have been ‘failed' by legislators, says man set to end life early

A terminally ill man who plans to travel to Switzerland to end his life before the year is out says legislators have so far “failed” people on assisted dying laws. ... Read more »

Brazil pandemic probe to recommend Bolsonaro face 11 criminal charges, senator says

FILE PHOTO: Brazil’s President Bolsonaro leads a motorcade rally, in Brasilia RIO DE JANEIRO (Reuters) – A Brazilian Senate probe into the government's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic will recommend ... Read more »

Devin Nunes warns 'future of this country' hinges on Durham indictments

The “future of this country” depends on who is indicted next in special counsel John Durham's criminal inquiry into the Russia investigation, warned a top House Republican. Rep. Devin Nunes, ... Read more »

UK pledges £29m extra in aid for northern Ethiopia as Tigray conflict spreads

The UK will provide another £29 million of humanitarian aid to northern Ethiopia as conflict in the region continues to spread, the Government has announced. The UN estimates that 5.5 ... Read more »

Bundesliga side have no fear of Newcastle over rumoured January target

There is no feeling at Eintracht Frankfurt that Filip Kostic will leave them for Newcastle United in January, it has been claimed. © PA Images Niklas Sule and Filip Kostic ... Read more »

Mum, 34, shot in the head by man, 29, trying to kill former school bully in office rampage

A MUM has been shot in the head by a man trying to kill a former school bully in an office rampage. Mariela Marquez, 34, was accidentally killed when she ... Read more »

There's a sex toy for ‘Succession' fans who are hot for cousin Greg

There’s now a sex toy for “Succession” fans who have a thing for cousin Greg in the popular HBO series. HBO; Shutterstock “Succession” fans now have another way to become ... Read more »

US Treasury says ransomware payouts in 2021 could top entire past decade

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge The ransomware business is booming this year and could be bringing in billions for some of its top players, according to a ... Read more »

Caraway Cookware Really Is Worth the Hype—And Not Just Because It's Ridiculously Easy To Clean

© Photo: Caraway caraway cookware set review Surely by now you’ve seen Caraway cookware splashed across your Instagram feed, reviewed in top cooking magazines, or even in the cabinets of ... Read more »

I Put Plus-Size Activewear From Popular Brands To The Test

Years of body negativity brought on by the latest fad diet or fitness craze have made my relationship with exercise a rocky one. Growing up, I was surrounded by “Beach ... Read more »

“He's a fantastic player” – Assistant lauds Queens Park Rangers talisman

© PA Images Queens Park Rangers’ Lyndon Dykes (centre right) celebrates scoring their side’s first goal of the game during the Sky Bet Championship match at the Kiyan Prince Foundation ... Read more »

Uber Freight boss warns US is entering shipping ‘Armageddon'

© AFP via Getty Images An aerial image taken on October 15, 2021 shows cargo shipping containers at the Port of Los Angeles in San Pedro, California. The port, North ... Read more »

Hillary Clinton pictured visiting Bill as he is hospitalised with ‘sespis'

© REUTERS Hillary Clinton leaves University of California Irvine Medical Center after visiting her husband Bill Clinton – REUTERS Hillary Clinton has been pictured visiting her husband Bill Clinton after ... Read more »

Australian authorities seize 450kg of heroin found in shipping container in Melbourne

Australian authorities say the seizure of 450 kilograms of heroin found inside a shipping container in Melbourne marks the largest ever onshore detection of the drug. Boxes containing the heroin, which has ... Read more »

Biden building tent cities for migrants that will cost $24.6M a month

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The Biden administration will have to rebuild large-scale encampments known as ‘court tents’ in the Texas border cities of Laredo and Brownsville as ... Read more »

Michigan Schools With No Mask Mandate Have 61 Percent More COVID Cases

A new study by the University of Michigan revealed that Michigan schools without any mask mandates in place have 61 percent more COVID-19 cases. © Getty Images A new study ... Read more »

Three Michigan women face voter fraud charges tied to 2020 election

Three women face voter fraud charges connected to the 2020 election in Michigan. © Provided by Washington Examiner Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel and Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson ... Read more »

U.S. will accept mixed doses of vaccines from international travelers

FILE PHOTO: Travelers reclaim luggage at Denver airport By David Shepardson WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) said late on Friday that it will ... Read more »

Texans signing Jeff Driskel to active roster

© Provided by NBC Sports The Texans called up Jeff Driskel from the practice squad as a game-day promotion the past three weeks, twice as a standard promotion and once ... Read more »