[Herald Interview] When is a death linked to a COVID-19 vaccine?

Asia's Tech News Daily

[Herald Interview] When is a death linked to a COVID-19 vaccine?
Dr. Lee Soo-kyoung, director of the National Forensic Service’s forensic medical examination division, poses during an interview with The Korea Herald at the government agency’s headquarters in Wonju, Gangwon Province. (Park Hyun-koo/The Korea Herald)WONJU, Gangwon Province — The challenge during the COVID-19 pandemic is to vaccinate as many people as possible. Concurrently with that campaign, postmortem examinations play a key role in determining whether a vaccine is to blame when a death takes places.

Because the COVID-19 vaccines are new, the science surrounding them is continually evolving, says Dr. Lee Soo-kyoung, director of the forensic medical examination division at the National Forensic Service.

At first, no one knew vaccination could cause blood clots with low platelets. And the task of staying up to date on related information was added to his day, about half of which is typically spent in the autopsy room and the rest writing reports and attending meetings.

“Cases involving a vaccinated individual require more work, in a sense,” he said. “Working with the possibility that an unknown mechanism may be going on can be stressful.”

As an increasing number of people got vaccinated, deaths that might not normally have stood out were getting noticed, he said. So many inquiries were pouring in from police stations all over the country that the forensic service was struggling to keep count of so-called “vaccine cases.”

“But abrupt deaths do happen in healthy people in the absence of vaccination,” he said. He says people who were apparently healthy are the ones usually referred to the service for autopsy. If they had obvious health problems when they were alive, “then they wouldn’t need to be here,” he said.

Often, there would be records of health checks showing they were not previously afflicted with any issues, making their untimely deaths even more of a shock for those left behind.

“It’s like that with nearly every case that gets an autopsy,” he said.

With post-vaccination deaths, getting the clear-cut answer that people expect isn’t always possible, said Lee, who is also part of the national health protection agency’s vaccine injury investigation unit. Since joining the unit in February, he’s sat in on more than 30 meetings.

Myocarditis, an inflammation of the heart muscle that is associated with the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines, was a regular screening in non-vaccine-relate cases, too.

Clinicians cannot confirm heart inflammation through a biopsy, but pathologists can.

“An autopsy can find out for certain if myocarditis was present, and where, and see if there might have been other contributing factors, like underlying conditions that health checkups could not pick up.”

Asked if an autopsy could reveal whether a condition was caused by a vaccine, Lee said it could not. There isn’t a marked difference between a vaccine-induced myocarditis and a naturally occurring one, for example.

“What autopsies achieve is look for injuries, diseases and other things that a clinical chart alone cannot demonstrate,” he said.

Assessing a causal relationship between a death and a vaccine was done over a spectrum of causality from “definitely not related” to “possibly or probably related” to “definitely related,” he said, so interpretations mattered as well.

“Determining whether the death is attributed to the vaccine, I think, is about how the criteria will apply.”

COVID-19 adds an extra layer of stress and peril to the job of a medical examiner.

“After an autopsy had already been done, if investigations reveal later on that the dead person had been in close contact with an infectious patient, the whole team has to get tested,” he said. “These are the kind of things that have become a routine occasion.”

Since the police carry out preliminary investigations of suspicious deaths, or deaths not from natural causes, the findings from their investigations, together with hospital records, if there are any, are handed over to the forensic service. “And then we work from there,” he said.

Testing the dead for COVID-19 is also done with the highly accurate PCR tests, using samples taken from the nasal airways all the way to the lungs.

South Korea’s custom of burying a person three days after death forces the examiners to work as expeditiously as possible. “Once the body gets here, it’s a matter of a day or two until everything is completed,” he said. Often, sections of organs and other samples that may hold important clues are kept for a microscopic inspection. The body is then sent back to the person’s loved ones. 

The state forensic service headquarters in Wonju is equipped with the only biocontainment laboratory in the country that meets the requirements for autopsies of patients with confirmed or suspected infection.

The biosafety Level 3 lab, like most national infectious disease infrastructure, was built in the aftermath of the 2015 outbreak of another coronavirus disease, Middle East respiratory syndrome.

Fewer than a dozen autopsies have taken place in the special lab since COVID-19’s onset, Lee said, because “there haven’t been a whole lot of requests.”

“The few cases conducted last year at the biosafety lab were of passengers from overseas who died shortly after arrival — all of them were found to be negative later on,” he said.

“So far just three were definitely positive,” he said. All three were done this year, to clarify the role COVID-19 played in their deaths.

Korea counts all deaths with a positive test, pre- or postmortem, as COVID-19 deaths, “probably out of statistical convenience,” he said. “But dying with COVID-19 is different from dying from it, and autopsies can help draw that distinction.”

In March last year, in a small city near Daegu, Korea’s initial epicenter of the pandemic, a 17-year-old died after developing pneumonia. Medics who treated him said he had COVID-19, which would have made him the country’s only teen fatality. The government, concluding that the result was a false positive, said no autopsy was necessary. Incomprehensibly, though, his family was still denied a proper funeral “out of caution.”

The teenager’s high-profile death is an example of a case where an autopsy would have helped elucidate the questions and put the controversy to rest, Lee said.

In Korea the forensic service has no authority to call for an autopsy — the court grants that permission, usually at the request of the police. The Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency’s commissioner can also request the procedure, although to date no such request has ever been filed for a COVID-19 patient.

Lee cited the US system, where the medical examiner decides if an autopsy must be performed, as “ideal,” especially amid a complex web of challenges posed by the present pandemic that would not have been a problem in ordinary times.

“In investigations of deaths of COVID-19-vaccinated subjects, for instance, the public health agency can be considered a party of interest. For credibility, it’s better to put a third party in charge of making the related decisions and presenting the results to the public and so on,” he said.

Lee believes the reason that so few autopsies have taken place in Korea is twofold.

“One reason is people’s reluctance toward the idea of autopsies of their loved ones,” he said. “Another is the policy that mandates cremation for everyone who has had a positive test result for purposes of infection control.”

From the beginning of the pandemic, the Korean government has stated that people who have died with COVID-19 must be cremated — burial is not an option — despite the World Health Organization guidance that says cremation should be “a matter of choice.”

On a personal level, autopsies offer a final chance at finding out the truth in the face of an unexplained death. They can also provide crucial insights into the many mysteries of the new disease — which then could lead to lifesaving discoveries, like a treatment.

“The efforts are worthwhile, and beneficial to the families and society,” he said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

New cases soar to new high, PM warns of tougher measures

A patient transfer official passes in front of the video of the hospital room control system in the situation room of Bagae Hospital in Pyeongtaek, a hospital dedicated to COVID-19 ... Read more »

Runaway bear remains at large south of Seoul for 3rd day

This photo taken Monday, shows hunters conducting a search operation in Yongin, south of Seoul, to find Asiatic black bears that escaped from a farm. (Yonhap)A massive search operation resumed ... Read more »

Daily infections, critical cases soar to all-time highs

Medical workers in full protective gear care for COVID-19 patients at an intensive care unit of a COVID-only hospital in Pyeongtaek, 70 kilometers south of Seoul, on Tuesday. The operating ... Read more »

Remains of Korea's first Catholic priest to be enshrined in Burkina Faso

In this photo provided by the Catholic Archdiocese of Seoul, Cardinal Andrew Yeom Soo-jung (L) gives part of the remains of St. Andrew Kim Tae-gon, the first native Korean Catholic ... Read more »

Korea extends eligibility for COVID-19 home care as beds fall short

Health care workers at a hospital in Pyeongtaek, Gyeonggi Province, look after COVID-19 patients on Tuesday. (Yonhap) South Korea is extending home recovery to older patients amid critical shortages of ... Read more »

[What's your say?] A ‘runaway' officer

A neighbor had a grudge against the family downstairs and attacked them with a knife in the western city of Incheon on Nov. 15. The mother was stabbed in the ... Read more »

Civic groups slam late ex-President Chun for leaving no apology for Gwangju crackdown

The South Korean defense ministry launches a probe into the 1980 military crackdown on a pro-democracy movement in Gwangju. (Yonhap)Victims of the bloody crackdown on a 1980 democracy uprising voiced ... Read more »

Seoul, UN-Habitat to co-host webinar on heritage, metropolis next week

This image provided by the Seoul city government shows the promotional poster for an international expert workshop on “Heritage and Metropolis” to be co-hosted by the city and the UN-Habitat ... Read more »

Temperatures dive below zero, snow falls in many parts of S. Korea: KMA

People wear hats, winter jackets and earmuffs during a cold day in Seoul on Tuesday. (Yonhap)Temperatures fell by over 10 degrees to below zero in many parts of the country ... Read more »

[URGENT] Former President Chun Doo-hwan dies at 90

Former President Chun Doo-hwan (Yonhap)Former President Chun Doo-hwan, who served as the fifth president of South Korea from 1980 to 1988, died at the age of 90 on Tuesday. The ... Read more »

Daily infections stay below 3,000, but critical cases hit all-time high

A long line of people forms yet again at an outdoor COVID-19 testing station in Seoul on Monday, as the country’s new cases show no signs of declining since the ... Read more »

COVID-19 situation ‘very dangerous,' says Korea's disease control chief

Jeong Eun-kyeong, the Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency chief, speaks during a televised briefing Monday at the agency headquarters in Osong, North Chungcheong Province. (KDCA)The head of Korea’s disease ... Read more »

1,956 people caught for drug-related charges from Aug.-Oct.: police

This Nov. 1, 2021, file photo, provided by the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency, shows illegal drugs confiscated in a crackdown. (Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency)A total of 1,956 people have been ... Read more »

In-person classes fully resume at schools nationwide amid virus resurgence

Students head to in-person classes at an elementary school in Seoul’s Yongsan district on the first day of the full resumption of in-person school attendance on Monday. (Yonhap)In-person school classes ... Read more »

Daily infections fall below 3,000, country's guard up as in-person classes resume

Students arrive at their junior high school in Incheon, 40 kilometers west of Seoul, on Monday, as in-person school classes at all kindergartens, elementary, middle and high schools across the ... Read more »

Police chief apologizes over bungled response to violent dispute between neighbors

National Police Agency Commissioner-General Kim Chang-yong (Yonhap) Police chief Kim Chang-yong apologized Sunday for the police’s bungled response to a violent dispute between neighbors that left one person unconscious. “I ... Read more »

Rising number of COVID-19 patients waiting for hospital care in Korea

Portable negative pressure wards for housing COVID-19 patients are set up outside a public hospital in Seoul. (Yonhap) More than 800 patients with COVID-19 in Seoul were waiting for hospital ... Read more »

[From the scene] As home isolation becomes default, bed availability remains issue

Health at Hallym University Medical Center give telephone consultations to Yeongdeungpo-gu patients in home isolation on Thursday. (Ministry of Health and Welfare) Health care workers in charge of looking after ... Read more »

[News Focus] Pay gap for regular, nonregular workers widening

A participant in a job fair in Seoul experiences an experimental interview via virtual reality devices earlier this month. (Yonhap)SEJONG — Nonregular workers’ pay has risen quite slowly compared to ... Read more »

Fine dust blankets much of South Korea

A road around Gwanghwamun Square in Seoul, is shrouded in fine dust on Saturday. (Yonhap)A choking pall of fine dust plagued much of South Korea on Saturday, prompting authorities to ... Read more »

US service member detained for refusing sobriety test after car accident

A US service member stationed in South Korea was detained by local police after refusing to take a field sobriety test following a minor car accident, authorities said Saturday. The ... Read more »

S. Korea's daily COVID-19 cases hover over 3,000 for 4th day

People wait in a line to undergo COVID-19 test at a coronavirus testing site at Seoul Station, Friday. (Yonhap) South Korea’s new coronavirus cases stayed above 3,000 for the fourth ... Read more »

Ultrafine dust advisory in effect in Seoul

(Yonhap) An ultrafine dust advisory was issued for all of Seoul on Friday for the first time in about six months, the metropolitan government said. The advisory was issued at ... Read more »

[From the Scene] Korea's top health protection agency chief gets third COVID-19 shot

KDCA Commissioner Jeong Eun-kyeong receives a Moderna booster on Friday morning at a hospital in Cheongju, North Chungcheong Province, near the agency’s headquarters. (Kim Arin/The Korea Herald)The head of South ... Read more »

Return to normal could stop with rise in serious COVID-19 cases: PM

Prime Minister Kim Boo-kyum (Yonhap)South Korea could stop its return to normal, Prime Minister Kim Boo-kyum said Friday as the country continued to see a sharp rise in the number ... Read more »

Quintuplets born in South Korea for first time in 34 years

Photos of the quintuplets born at the Seoul National University Hospital on late Thursday night. (Seoul National University Hospital)South Korea saw the first successful birth of quintuplets in 34 years, ... Read more »

In-person school classes to fully resume next week

A high school teacher conducts online classes in the southeastern city of Daegu last Thursday, a week before the country’s nationwide college entrance exam. (Yonhap)In-person school classes will fully resume ... Read more »

S. Korea's daily COVID-19 cases hover over 3,000 for 3rd day

Makeshift wards made of containers are set up at a parking lot of the Seoul Medical Center in Seoul on Thursday. (Yonhap)South Korea’s new coronavirus cases stayed above 3,000 for ... Read more »

17 days of normal push Korea's COVID-19 cases to hit new high

People stand in line to receive coronavirus tests at a screening clinic in southeastern Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)South Korea saw the highest number of new COVID-19 cases since the start ... Read more »

[News Focus] Nonregular jobs increase faster in 5 major cities

A bulletin board at the regional unit of Employment Welfare Plus Center in Seoul shows job information earlier this month. (Yonhap)SEJONG – Major cities outside the capital have led the ... Read more »

Beaumax donates 30,000 masks to Myanmar upon high school kid's request

A ceremony is held for Beaumax’s donation of 30,000 face masks to children in need in Myanmar through Worldshare. (Beaumax)Cosmetics firm Beaumax donated 30,000 face masks to support disadvantaged children ... Read more »

[Photo News] Rogers family in hanbok

Investor Jim Rogers (left), his wife Paige Parker (right) and their daughter Hilton Augusta pose in contemporary hanbok at their residence in Singapore in this file photo acquired by The ... Read more »

Daily reports of stalking sharply increase after implementation of anti-stalking law: police

View from the outside of a police station (Yonhap)The number of stalking complaints filed with police shot up to about 103 cases a day since the anti-stalking law went into ... Read more »

S. Korea's daily virus cases hit new record high amid relaxed virus curbs

People stand in line to receive coronavirus tests at a screening clinic in southeastern Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)South Korea’s new coronavirus cases hit an all-time high on Thursday since the ... Read more »

National college entrance exam kicks off amid pandemic

College aspirants at a high school in Seoul’s Yongsan district prepare to take the College Scholastic Ability Test on Thursday. (Yonhap)Nearly 500,000 high school seniors and other exam takers nationwide ... Read more »

Gimhae city apologizes for mandatory virus testing of foreign children amid xenophobia concerns

The headquarters of the National Human Rights Commission of Korea in Seoul. (Yonhap)The government of the southeastern city of Gimhae apologized Thursday for ordering mandatory COVID-19 tests of foreign children ... Read more »

USFK begins COVID-19 inoculation program for affiliated children

A seven-year old child gets a Pfizer vaccine shot at a US Forces Korea base in Pyeongtaek, on Wednesday. (Yonhap)The US Forces Korea on Wednesday started inoculating children in its ... Read more »

Korea reviewing emergency approval for Merck's COVID-19 pills

Minister of Food and Drug Safety Kim Ganglip speaks to reporters during a press conference held Wednesday at the ministry headquarters in Osong, North Chungcheong Province. (Ministry of Food and ... Read more »

[Newsmaker] Ex-lawmaker's home, Hana Bank head office searched in Daejang-dong scandal

Investigators from the Seoul Central District Prosecutors Office carry boxes containing items they seized during the raid on ousted lawmaker Kwak Sang-do on Nov.17.(Yonhap)South Korean prosecutors on Wednesday searched ousted ... Read more »

Korea to shorten wait for COVID-19 boosters as breakthrough hospitalizations rise

People stand in line to receive coronavirus tests at a screening clinic in southeastern Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)South Korea will shorten the wait for COVID-19 booster shots as the daily ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic