Hefei's risky investment strategy paid off handsomely, here's how the city did it

Hefei’s playbook involves active scouting, fiscal benefits, and a steady stream of incentives for workers to entice major tech companies.

part one, interview

This is the second entry of a two-part series covering the Hefei government’s playbook in investments. Check out part one here to find out the city’s officials grew the city’s GDP by 2,600% in 20 years.

Hefei, a city near the eastern seaboard of China, is an investment powerhouse where big bets made by the government in tech have paid off handsomely. Its stakes in LCD maker BOE, ChangXin Memory Technologies, and Nio have invigorated its commercial sector in the past two decades, setting it apart from other administrations, like the Wuhan government, which have poured money into embarrassing duds.

There are several reasons behind Hefei’s success. One is its goal to not only identify individual enterprises that have the right teams, targets, and technological know-how, but to also absorb entire supply chains related to the industry. In all three cases of BOE, ChangXin, and Nio, the Hefei government essentially provided cash injections that gave these companies the means to break out of cash crunches or tough financial conditions. In return, they positioned their core operations in Hefei, bringing new businesses with high-growth potential to the region.

The Hefei government designed this strategy in the 2000s because it believed China’s domestic electronics industry could be a driving force for the city’s economy. When white goods manufacturers indicated they would need a steady supply of steel and components like compressors and motors, authorities in Hefei approached suppliers and built the relevant production facilities and infrastructure, ensuring factories that make appliances would have everything they need for smooth operations.

Cultivating production for more advanced products, like LCD screens, involved a similar arrangement. Landing BOE in Hefei was the first step to developing a wide-reaching network of enterprises in the LCD sector. Now, more than 300 enterprises that operate in the industry are present in Hefei.

Kong Linggang, the counselor of the Anhui provincial government, said in an interview that Hefei’s investment in BOE laid the groundwork for the overall development of LCD-related businesses in Hefei. The move set a precedent and gave ChangXin Memory Technologies a reference point when the Hefei government began discussions with the company, Kong said.

Active Scouting

It wasn’t just the local government’s gutsiness to take on risky ventures that made Hefei the right destination for companies like BOE, Nio, and ChangXin Semiconductor. To ensure a steady stream of funds went into building up these operations, the Hefei government and strategic stock market investors channeled RMB 9 billion toward BOE, then arranged for another RMB 8.5 billion from bank loans, all to construct a production line for LCD panels.

The Hefei government takes a long view with its investments—much longer than the five- to ten-year outlook that private venture capital investors typically hold. It also weights success with a different measure compared to VCs. Improvements to broader supply chains, industrial capabilities, and infrastructural features all feed into taxes, higher employment, and generally higher standards of living. Government funding doesn’t simply build up individual companies; it’s meant to elevate the overall business landscape.

Identifying BOE, Nio, and ChangXin as investment targets was a lengthy process that involved a task force that assessed the potential of 24 industries, including AI, LCDs, integrated circuits, voice recognition, and more, before officials figured out which sectors and companies could match what Hefei could offer. The process also involved the acquisition of publicly traded shares or private equity of these companies so the government could wield voting power that influences their business management.

Members of this task force are constantly on the road—some spend more than 200 days per year traveling to scout the right targets, at times flying to multiple cities within a day. It’s a significant departure from the work of a typical public servant.

Fiscal benefits

Entrepreneurs who are folded into the Hefei government’s investment program are issued a “green card” that guarantees preferential tax rates, easy household registration, medical coverage, access to local schools for their children, and other benefits as incentives to ease their transition after relocation. This extends to their employees as well.

For technical personnel who move to Hefei to work for key industrial enterprises, the Hefei government offers three years of rental subsidies, again making it easier for newcomers to settle down in the city.

Another attractive element of working with the Hefei government is its control over taxes. With the flick of a pen, tax and social security policies can introduce immense favor toward industries and enterprises that officials deem key to the city’s economic future. In all, BOE received RMB 400 million in domestic tax rebates and RMB 1.8 billion in export tax rebates in 2020. It also deducted RMB 300 million as R&D expenses from its tax bill that year.

A unique playbook?

Some other cities and provinces that have attempted their own variations of investment schemes have not fared as well as Hefei. An example is Jiangsu Province’s ventures in Selin, Boshan, and Baiting—three new energy vehicle companies. These firms were unable to pay their workers, had to shut down factories, and went bankrupt. All failed to develop production capabilities after bagging financing from Jiangsu’s government. Ventures in semiconductor firms like Nanjing Dekema, Chengdu Gexin, Shanxi Kuntong, and Wuhan Hongxin all ended up in bankruptcy, in at least some cases due to fraud. Billions of dollars were burned.

Hefei’s government has managed risk well. The question is: can this model be duplicated elsewhere?

The answer isn’t an immediate yes. Hefei was able to reach this point only because there were pre-existing conditions that gave it an edge. Even before BOE was brought to the city, Hefei was already one of China’s three major home appliance manufacturing zones. This gave it a head start in infrastructural improvements that were prerequisites for more advanced manufacturers. Hefei’s investments paid off because this factor mingled with its willingness to make bold bets in BOE, Nio, and ChangXin, as well as the government task force that was essential in identifying these enterprises as good fits. The presence of all these elements is what made Hefei unique.

Even so, there are consequences to weather when governments venture into this type of investment scenario. It skews resource distribution toward the picks of officials. A limited number of companies receive tax deductions, low-cost financing, prime land for factories, and infrastructural support. This can be interpreted as a sure-win endorsement that disrupts fair competition.

Yet, that isn’t about to stop Hefei’s government from augmenting its industrial supply chain for even more developments in science and tech. The city’s investment plan for 2021 includes a quantum science and technology park that will host researchers from the China University of Science and Technology, the construction for the second phase of the Chinese Academy of Sciences’ Hefei Institute of Technological Innovation and Engineering, and a frontier research center for earth science and space. It will also invest RMB 77.69 billion in 619 projects in emerging industries.

The officials involved in Hefei’s investments are setting the standard for government-led ventures. It’s a work in progress that already has an impressive track record. Will its next steps pay off?

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Gabby Petito case becomes point of interest for internet sleuths on social media

The extensive reach of social media has become a focal point in the disappearance of travel blogger Gabby Petito. Petito had been traveling cross-country with her boyfriend, Brian Laundrie, in ... Read more »

88% of Nifty50 stocks trade above 200-DMAs. Here's what they hint at

NEW DELHI: As many as 44 of the 50 Nifty stocks traded above their 200-day simple moving averages (SMAs) on Monday. For a similar number of stocks, their 50-day SMAs ... Read more »

Investors grappling with Evergrande fallout weigh risk of wider pain

NEW YORK: Investors unnerved by the fallout from heavily indebted Chinese real estate company Evergrande were gauging the potential for a wider shakeout after a selloff hit stocks around the ... Read more »

Jaishankar raises COVID-19 quarantine issue during his meeting with UK counterpart

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar urged for an “early resolution” of the COVID-19 quarantine issue and discussed the situation in Afghanistan and the developments in the Indo-Pacific during his meeting ... Read more »

The Polestar 2 is a Reasonably Priced EV with Panache and Performance

© Paul Barshon / Beadyeye The “guiding light” in the EV space has found the Goldilocks zone with an electric vehicle that offers equal parts torque and opulence. The Takeaway ... Read more »

No indication of COVID-19 third wave yet: Maharashtra health minister

(Representative image: Reuters) Maharashtra Health Minister Rajesh Tope, on September 20, said there was no indication of the onset of COVID-19 third wave in the state. He, however, said that ... Read more »

Xiaomi has a new ‘offline problem' to deal with

The rift between smartphone major Xiaomi and its offline retailers seems to be widening. Some Mi preferred partner store owners across India are unhappy with Xiaomi launching new smartphones online ... Read more »

Haitian journey to Texas border starts in South America

1 / 3Border Haitian DiasporaRobins Exile, of Haiti, eats at a Haitian restaurant, Monday, Sept. 20, 2021, in Tijuana, Mexico. Exile arrived to Tijuana the day before after changing his ... Read more »

Justin Trudeau to remain Canada's prime minister; Liberal Party appears to fall short of majority

Canadians gave Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Liberal Party a victory in Monday’s parliamentary elections, but his gamble to win a majority of seats appeared to have failed. The Liberals were ... Read more »

How Tata is betting big on online healthcare

With the ambition of launching a Super App, the Tata group is betting big on the healthcare segment through Tata Health, which provides teleconsultation services and, in the future, aims ... Read more »

Older sisters better than older brothers for elephants, research suggests

Young elephants benefit from having older sisters more than older brothers, new research suggests. Researchers at universities in Finland, the UK and Myanmar found that Asian elephant siblings influence younger ... Read more »

Kena: Bridge of Spirits Pixar-like charm is lost behind a ton of performance issues

I wasn’t sure what to expect from Kena: Bridge of Spirits. Developer Ember Lab’s adorable adventure caused quite a stir when it was revealed at the PlayStation Future of Gaming ... Read more »

Sensex gains in early trade, Nifty above 17,450; HCL Tech gains 3%

NEW DELHI: Domestic equity benchmarks started Tuesday’s session on a strong note amid buying interest in IT stocks. The S&P BSE Sensex index rose as much as 288 points to ... Read more »

US SEC warns investors of risks from certain Chinese business entities

WASHINGTON: The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on Monday issued its latest warning to people looking to invest in Chinese companies listed in the United States. In an alert ... Read more »

Packers dominate 2nd half, bounce back to beat Lions 35-17

1/9APTOPIX Lions Packers FootballGreen Bay Packers’ Aaron Jones celebrates his touchdown run during the second half of an NFL football game against the Detroit Lions Monday, Sept. 20, 2021, in ... Read more »

NFL Power Rankings: Maybe this is the season someone challenges Chiefs in AFC West

On New Year's Day in 2017 the Kansas City Chiefs won their regular-season finale, with Charcandrick West's two touchdown catches from Alex Smith leading the way over the San Diego ... Read more »

New film finds 'The Wonderful' aboard the space station: director Q&A

© Provided by Space “The Wonderful: Stories from the Space Station” shares the lives of astronauts in space on the biggest human outpost in orbit. Clare Lewins did not think ... Read more »

mSpy parental control software review

MSpy is a hugely powerful phone monitoring app which can report on almost every area of your kid’s online activities (and one or two of the offline ones, too.) Need ... Read more »

Mahant Narendra Giri's death: FIR against Anand Giri, others

According to Inspector General of Police KP Singh, Mahant Giri’s body was found hanging from the ceiling by his disciples. (File image: ANI) An FIR has been registered against Anand ... Read more »

Watch an astronaut working out in space aboard the ISS

Thomas Pesquet, an ESA astronaut who is currently aboard the International Space Station (ISS) posted a video of himself on Twitter in which he can be seen doing squats using ... Read more »

Amazon app quiz September 21, 2021: Get answers to these five questions to win Rs 20,000 in Amazon Pay balance

Amazon’s daily app quiz is now live. As part of today’s quiz, the e-tailer is giving the participants a chance to win Rs 20,000 in Amazon Pay balance.The daily app ... Read more »

Evergrande chairman confident company will "walk out of its darkest moment"

BEIJING: China Evergrande Group is confident the company will “walk out of its darkest moment” and deliver property projects as pledged, its chairman said in a letter to staff reported ... Read more »

Up to 215% rise in 1 year! Stocks common among top 5 smallcap schemes

NEW DELHI: Top performing mutual funds schemes have a dozen common stocks — such as Persistent System, Carborundum Universal, Bajaj Electricals and eClerx Services — that have delivered solid gains ... Read more »

S&P downgrades Chinese developer Sinic due to unclear repayment plans

Credit-rating firm S&P Global Ratings downgraded Sinic Holdings (Group) Co Ltd to ‘CCC+’ on Tuesday, citing the Chinese developer’s failure “to communicate a clear repayment plan“. “Sinic had previously prepared ... Read more »

Best eBay Australia deals: bargains on laptops, monitors and PCs from Dell

Dell’s official eBay store is back with another ripper sale this week, where you can get laptops, monitors and desktop PCs for 20% off their listed price. Some of our ... Read more »

S Jaishankar threatened Nepal not to adopt Constitution: KP Sharma Oli

K P Sharma Oli revealed this in the set of “political documents” submitted to the standing committee of the Communist Party of Nepal-UML on September 19, which marked the country’s ... Read more »

US securities regulator opens probe into Activision Blizzard over employment issues

Activision Blizzard spent the summer grappling with accusations of sexual misconduct and workplace discrimination. WASHINGTON, D.C. (NYTIMES, REUTERS) – Activision Blizzard, the video game maker behind Call Of Duty and ... Read more »

Facebook rebuffs reports on Instagram's negative impact on young people, cites policy trade-offs

Several lawmakers have called on Facebook to scrap plans for an Instagram product aimed at children. MENLO PARK (BLOOMBERG) – Facebook pushed back on reports that the company was aware ... Read more »

Engaged with India to expand recognition of COVID-19 vaccines, says UK amid backlash over new travel rules

Reuters After facing intense backlash from Indians over the revised travel guidelines, the UK on September 20 said that it is engaging with New Delhi to explore how it could ... Read more »

Oppo, OnePlus merge India R&D operations; to launch integrated OS next year

Chinese handset makers Oppo and OnePlus are working together to bring an integrated operating system by merging their Oxygen OS and Color OS by early next year. This follows their ... Read more »

Asia markets, yuan fight to stabilise as Evergrande looms large

TOKYO/SYDNEY: Global stock markets grappled with contagion fears on Tuesday, sparked by troubles at China Evergrande as growing risks the property giant could default on its massive debt pile prompted ... Read more »

HC seeks government reply on false stock info plea

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Monday sought the government‘s response on a petition seeking a “comprehensive policy” to stem the circulation of false information on stocks on social ... Read more »

Facebook, Google and other Big Tech firms face more fines in Russia as Kremlin curbs access to information online

Russia’s internet regulator is poised to significantly raise the fines it has slapped on US technology companies such as Facebook Inc and Alphabet Inc as the Kremlin escalates its push ... Read more »

Jordyn Woods is a ‘dream girl' in stunning draped crystal dress: ‘All of your dreams shall be furfillleeeeeed'

Jordyn Woods celebrated her 24th birthday early and in style. On Sunday, the 23-year-old influencer shared images from her birthday festivities over the weekend attended by friends and family, including ... Read more »

SGX Nifty up 55 points; here's what changed for market while you were sleeping

Domestic stocks look set to open on a positive note on Tuesday but weak trend in other Asian markets may hurt investor sentiment, thanks to Evergrande crisis and two-day US ... Read more »

Unsure if demand will stay, inflation a concern for 2022: Nestle India chairman Suresh Narayanan

Demand trends are still indicating mixed signals about the next few quarters, and it is difficult to say that sustained consumption is here to stay, Nestle India chairman Suresh Narayanan ... Read more »

Australia's New Supercomputer Has Been Unveiled and Its Name Is Adorable

Australian researchers have caught a glimpse of a new mega-powerful computing system described as the fastest public supercomputer in the Southern Hemisphere and named after one of the country’s cutest ... Read more »

Even the Mafia is getting involved in phishing attacks now

Cybercriminals have raked in millions from phishing attacks which is why it’s not a big surprise that the Italian Mafia has adopted similar tactics in recent years. According to a ... Read more »