Heating homes with hydrogen is bad for both your wallet and the planet

heating homes with hydrogen is bad for both your wallet and the planet

An artist’s impression of a hydrogen heating unit petrmalinak/Shutterstock

Hydrogen, often touted as a green alternative to heating buildings with natural gas or other fossils fuels, is unlikely to play a significant role in decarbonising homes, a review of international studies has found.

That is bad news for governments, including the UK, that are hoping to use hydrogen as a simple substitute for existing gas boilers. “I think hydrogen is ultimately the silver bullet,” Jacob Rees-Mogg, the UK’s newly-appointed energy minister told the House of Commons on 23 September. “We create it from renewable sources… we use it as an effective battery and it can then, with some adjustments, be piped through to people’s houses to heat them during the winter.”

The future of UK science and innovation Patrick Vallance at New Scientist Live this October

The review by Jan Rosenow at the Regulatory Assistance Project, a non-governmental organisation, looked at 32 studies from the UK, European Union, California and São Paulo in Brazil. Overall, they show that hydrogen is “less economic, less efficient, more resource intensive and associated with larger environmental impacts”, writes Rosenow.

Cost and energy efficiency are two main problems, says Rosenow. Today, more than 95 per cent of hydrogen is produced using natural gas or coal. Carbon capture and storage technology could help reduce emissions from this production, but policymakers largely agree that green hydrogen, made via electrolysis with renewable electricity, is the better solution.

But if you are going to use renewable electricity to heat your home, you might as well power a heat pump instead, as this is cheaper and more efficient. “It takes about five times more electricity to heat a home with hydrogen than with an efficient heat pump,” says Rosenow. Hydrogen-dominated heating would cost UK consumers 73 per cent more than systems relying on district heating and heat pumps, according to a recent study.

Further, “significant uncertainties” exist over the viability of converting countries’ existing gas networks to hydrogen, and hydrogen infrastructure is more extensive than that needed for heat pumps, increasing environmental impacts, writes Rosenow.

“It is difficult to think of any circumstances in the decarbonised future when it would make sense to use hydrogen for heating,” says David Cebon at the University of Cambridge. When the ambient temperature drops below -20°C, air source heat pumps become less efficient, but even in such cold conditions, “heat pumps still deliver heat with lower carbon emissions than hydrogen boilers”, says Cebon.

Countries like the US and Australia, which are also toying with the idea of using hydrogen to decarbonise heating systems, have “huge” renewable electricity potential, says Cebon, which they should use “in the most efficient way possible, via heat pumps”. If they have excess electricity, it will be more profitable to sell it directly via interconnectors “than to waste energy converting the electricity into hydrogen”, he adds.

Hydrogen could play a limited role in certain circumstances — Rosenow estimates it could provide “about 1-2 per cent of total [domestic] heating demand”. And, for example, green hydrogen power plants will be required to decarbonise other sectors, such as heavy industry processes, and for the seasonal storage of electricity.

With that in mind, countries like the UK should continue existing trials to better understand “important details around the technical challenges of heating with hydrogen”, says Rosenow. Just don’t expect a silver bullet.

Journal reference: Joule, DOI: 10.1016/j.joule.2022.08.015

Sign up to our free Fix the Planet newsletter to get a dose of climate optimism delivered straight to your inbox, every Thursday

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Joyce Bryant, ‘bronze blond bombshell’ of the 1950s, dies at 95

Joyce Bryant, ‘bronze blond bombshell’ of the 1950s, dies at 95 Joyce Bryant, an African American singer who became known as the “bronze blond bombshell” of the 1950s, electrifying nightclub ... Read more »

Jeff Saturday defends clock management at end of Colts' loss

Jeff Saturday defends clock management at end of Colts' loss INDIANAPOLIS — Colts interim coach Jeff Saturday defended his clock management in the final minutes of Monday night's loss to ... Read more »

Bayern Munich 2 - 0 SGS Essen in the Frauen-Bundesliga: Recap and highlights

Bayern Munich 2 – 0 SGS Essen in the Frauen-Bundesliga: Recap and highlights After a Champions League letdown against FC Barcelona, Bayern Munich got back into the swing of things ... Read more »

World Cup 2022: Cameroon GK Andre Onana misses Switzerland match, reportedly leaves team after disagreement with coach

AL WAKRAH, QATAR – NOVEMBER 24: Andre Onana of Cameroon during the FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 Group G match between Switzerland and Cameroon at Al Janoub Stadium on November ... Read more »

Economic reports, 2023 market volatility, oil prices and more: Tuesday's 5 things to know

Events to watch on Tuesday include release of home prices for September and the latest consumer confidence index for November Read more »

Trump’s Jewish Allies Denounce Dinner With Kanye West and Nick Fuentes

Former President Donald J. Trump addressed the Republican Jewish Coalition’s conference in Las Vegas on a video call this month. For much of Donald J. Trump’s presidency, Jewish Republicans rationalized ... Read more »

European Markets Nudge Higher as China's Covid Policy Takes Center Stage

Kevin Frayer | Getty Images News | Getty Images This is CNBC’s live blog covering European markets. European markets were slightly higher on Tuesday as investors continued to monitor news ... Read more »

30 Gift Ideas For Anyone On Your List

This page may contain affiliate links.  As an Amazon and Rewardstyle affiliate, we may earn a small commission for any purchases made through these links. Click here for the disclosure ... Read more »

Soccer-Senegal welcome pressure of decisive Ecuador clash, says Cisse

FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 – Senegal Press Conference By Hritika Sharma AL RAYYAN, Qatar (Reuters) – Senegal coach Aliou Cisse said his team are expected to reach the World ... Read more »

Facing indictment, Ald. Ed Burke will end his run as the longest-service City Council member ever, won’t seek reelection

With old photos and a slide show of his long history, Ald. Edward Burke, 14th, was honored at the City Club in Chicago on March 7, 2018, for his 50 ... Read more »

Predictions of lowland snow send Snohomish County residents scrambling to prepare

Predictions of lowland snow send Snohomish County residents scrambling to prepare The potential for the season’s first lowland snow has people in Snohomish County stocking up and hunkering down. With ... Read more »

Will Householter’s triple-double leads Mira Costa to big win over Lynwood

Will Householter sprung for rebounds, turning in one motion with nary a dribble and flinging the ball the length of the court, a floppy-haired high school point guard turning into ... Read more »

Wendy Williams Barely Able To Walk, Begs For Assistance While Entering Her New York Apartment

mega Fans have once again voiced their concern for Wendy Williams. In a shocking video shared to Instagram on Sunday, November 27, the former host of The Wendy Williams Show ... Read more »

Best Small Towns in Tuscany... Under The Sun

Who doesn’t love Tuscany, amiright? But Global Debauchery isn’t here to tell you everything you already know about a place. No, it exists to help you travel deeper. And how ... Read more »

Biden’s Genderfluid, Drag Queen Nuclear Official Charged With Stealing Woman’s Luggage

BEVERLY HILLS, CALIFORNIA – NOVEMBER 17: Sam Brinton attends The Trevor Project’s TrevorLIVE LA 2019 at The Beverly Hilton Hotel on November 17, 2019 in Beverly Hills, California. (Photo by ... Read more »

YES Network interested in two Yankees legends

YES Network may be able to get two big names in the broadcasting booth. And it would be something of a reunion. The New York Post’s Andrew Marchand reports that ... Read more »

South Hill Mall brawl leaves man hurt, teen in custody; search continues for accomplices

A brawl at the South Hill Mall left one man hurt, a teenager in custody and four other teenagers wanted for assault. The victims say it began after a group ... Read more »

China lockdown protests pause as police flood city streets

HONG KONG —  With police out in force, there was no word of additional protests against strict government anti-pandemic measures Tuesday in Beijing, as temperatures fell well below freezing. Shanghai, Nanjing ... Read more »

USMNT’s Tyler Adams asked by Iranian reporter about being Black, representing the US

USMNT’s Tyler Adams asked by Iranian reporter about being Black, representing the US Tyler Adams, the captain of the U.S. men’s national team, took a question about discrimination in the ... Read more »

Jimmy Kimmel Trashes Trump’s Nick Fuentes Meal With Withering 1-Liner About Eric Trump

Jimmy Kimmel on Monday mocked the “meeting of the mindless” between Donald Trump, Kanye West, and notorious white nationalist Nick Fuentes at the former president’s Mar-a-Lago home. Trump tried to ... Read more »

Blood, ski masks, and bumps in the night: 911 logs reveal how Idaho student murders have shaken city of Moscow

55658851-8050-45F7-871E-5521AE66BAD7.jpeg In a small college town that normally sees one murder every year at most, the killing of four students in one house on the same night was bound to ... Read more »

Atlas Air Boeing 747 Makes Emergency Landing At Chicago O'Hare International Airport

Cargo and charter airline Atlas Air is investigating after a flight operated by a Boeing 747 made an emergency landing on Monday. The charter flight originated in Topeka, Kansas, and ... Read more »

Iran wants Team USA kicked out of World Cup over flag image

Nov. 28 (UPI) — A state-affiliated Iranian news agency called for the United States to be kicked out of the World Cup for releasing an edited image of the Iranian ... Read more »

Man Shot in Head, Killed in Northeast Philadelphia

Man Shot in Head, Killed in Northeast Philadelphia A man is dead after being shot in the head in Northeast Philadelphia on Sunday night, police said. The 38-year-old victim was ... Read more »

Virginia Rep. Donald McEachin Dies at 61 After Cancer Battle

McEachin, a Democrat who represented a district stretching from Richmond to the North Carolina line, was first elected to Congress in 2016. Read more »

John Roberts and Barack Obama: 4 Oaths of Office?

John Roberts and Barack Obama: 4 Oaths of Office? Obama and Justice Roberts will have recited oath together four times. Jan. 17, 2013 — By next Monday afternoon, President Barack ... Read more »

Lakers blow 17-point lead late as they fall to Pacers at the buzzer

As far as trades that haven’t happened go, this one has been talked about plenty. The idea goes something like this: Buddy Hield is one of the best high-volume three-point ... Read more »

China’s lockdown protests spread to campuses and cities abroad

HONG KONG — Protests against China’s strict zero-Covid policy and restrictions on freedoms have spread to at least a dozen cities around the world in a show of solidarity with rare displays ... Read more »

Utah football’s Kyle Whittingham closes the door on Pac-12 tiebreakers debate

(Trent Nelson | The Salt Lake Tribune) Kyle Whittingham as the University of Utah hosts USC, NCAA football in Salt Lake City on Saturday, Oct. 15, 2022. The University of ... Read more »

9 Years On: Inside Air India’s 2 Daily Boeing 787 Flights To Australia

9 Years On: Inside Air India’s 2 Daily Boeing 787 Flights To Australia Air India is one of three airlines offering nonstop flights between South Asia and Australia. It joins ... Read more »

Hawaiians say it’s no coincidence Mauna Loa erupting on La Kuokoa

On Monday, Hawaiians celebrated La Kuokoa, also known as Hawaiian Independence Day. Many believe Mauna Loa erupting on this day is a sign of a revival. HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) – Many ... Read more »

Police seek to ID alleged Price Chopper thief suspect

Police seek to ID alleged Price Chopper thief suspect HAMILTON, N.Y. (NEWS10) — Police are investigating a larceny that occurred at the Price Chopper in Hamilton on the night of ... Read more »

New Germantown residential development begins construction

New Germantown residential development begins construction GERMANTOWN, Tenn. (WMC) – One of the largest residential developments in Germantown is getting ready to begin Phase 1 of construction this week. Glasgow ... Read more »

Ringo Starr Said There Was a Possibility The Beatles Could Have ‘Carried On’ Until a Move by Paul McCartney

Before The Beatles publicly broke up, the band sent Ringo Starr as an emissary to talk to Paul McCartney. McCartney planned on releasing his solo album ahead of The Beatles’ ... Read more »

How the Legend of the Gurhkas' Kukri Blade was Forged

In 1814, the British Army first encountered Nepalese soldiers known as Gurkhas. While both were initially enemies, the British later brought the Gurkhas into their fold. Much has changed about ... Read more »

Stanford Athletics says it ‘deeply regrets’ offense caused by band’s halftime show

Empty seats at Stanford Stadium are shown during the first half of an NCAA college football game between Stanford and Colorado in Stanford, Calif., Saturday, Nov. 14, 2020. The Stanford ... Read more »

Brazil, Portugal advance to last 16; Ghana, Korea, Serbia, Cameroon entertain with goalfests

Brazil, Portugal advance to last 16; Ghana, Korea, Serbia, Cameroon entertain with goalfests Brazil and Portugal became the second and third teams to book their places in the Last 16 ... Read more »

ComfortDelGro, Gojek Partner to Tackle Driver Shortage as Ride Demand Surges in Singapore

Singapore’s largest taxi operator ComfortDelGro will allow ride-hailing app Gojek access to its taxis to address the shortage of private-hire drivers in Singapore. Private-hire companies have been rushing to attract ... Read more »

'Everything Everywhere All at Once' wins at Gotham Awards

'Everything Everywhere All at Once' wins at Gotham Awards “Everything Everywhere All at Once” has won best feature at the 32nd Gotham Awards on Monday, taking one of the first ... Read more »

Snap is ordering employees back to the office 4 days a week. CEO Evan Spiegel wants workers to sacrifice ‘individual convenience’ for ‘collective success’ in a policy called ‘default together’

Snap CEO Evan Spiegel Snap is the latest company to try to bring workers back to the office. Starting in February, Snap employees will be expected to spend at least ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network