Health-care worker fired for drinking can't challenge termination using Human Rights Code: Supreme Court

Asia's Tech News Daily

Health-care worker fired for drinking can't challenge termination using Human Rights Code: Supreme Court
© Justin Tang/The Canadian Press The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that disputes between a unionized employee and their employer that are covered by a collective agreement must be settled by a labor arbitrator under the Labour Relations Act.

A Manitoba health-care worker who was fired from her job for drinking alcohol cannot challenge her termination under her province’s Human Rights Code, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled. 

The ruling sided with the employer’s argument that disputes between a unionized employee and an employer on an issue covered by a collective agreement, can only be settled by a labour arbitrator working with both parties. 

The ruling is significant and has ramifications across the country because the human rights codes and labour relations acts of many provinces are based on similar principles of law.

This case stems from the 2011 suspension and subsequent firing of Linda Horrocks from a personal care home run by the Northern Regional Health Authority in Flin Flon, Man. 

Horrocks, who suffered from alcohol dependence; a disability recognized by her employer, her union’s collective agreement and Manitoba’s Human Rights Code, was suspended from work for being intoxicated. 

The health authority offered Horrocks her job back, providing she agreed to a total abstinence from alcohol. She refused to sign the agreement, saying it discriminated against her based on her recognized disability, and was fired as a result. 

Horrocks grieved her termination to the union and in 2012 she struck a deal allowing her to return to work providing she abstained from drinking, sought counselling and submitted to random alcohol tests. 

When her employer received reports that Horrocks was intoxicated outside of work, she denied drinking. But her employer told her that those “denials are not believed,” and concluded that she was in breach of her agreement to abstain from alcohol, and she was fired.

Human rights claim 

Rather than filing another grievance with her employer, Horrocks brought her complaint to the Manitoba Human Rights Commission where an adjudicator ruled that she had been discriminated against based on her disability. 

The adjudicator ordered the health authority to rehire Horrocks and compensate her with lost wages and $10,000 for injury to her “dignity, feelings and self respect.”

The health authority objected to the jurisdiction of the Human Rights Commission and a court agreed, ruling that a labour arbitrator had jurisdiction in the case. Horrocks had that decision overturned at the court of appeal, which ruled in 2017 that both the commission and a labour arbitrator had jurisdiction in the case and sent it back to the lower court judge. 

The health authority appealed that decision to the top court where six of seven justices that heard the case sided with Horrocks’ employer, ruling that the Labour Relations Act trumps the Human Rights Code in this case. 

“The [labour] arbitrator’s jurisdiction under the Labour Relations Act over claims that arise, in their essential character, from the interpretation, application, or alleged violation of the collective agreement is exclusive and, more particularly, exclusive of the [Human Rights] Commission,” the judgment said. 

“In its essential character, Ms. Horrocks’ complaint alleges a violation of the collective agreement, and thus falls squarely within the [labour] arbitrator’s mandate.”

The ruling means that the decision by the province’s Human Rights Commission requiring Horrocks to be reinstated has no legal standing. 

It remains unclear what Horrocks’ next course of actions will be. 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Meryl Streep looks ready for bed in a dressing gown style coat

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo She’s been busy promoting her latest project Don’t Look Up.  And Meryl Street looked upbeat as she stepped out in a grey floral-lined coat ... Read more »

US stocks trade mixed following massive rally on receding Omicron fears

© Xinhua News Agency/Getty Images Xinhua News Agency/Getty Images Major US stock benchmarks were mixed on Wednesday following a massive Tuesday rally. Pfizer and BioNTech said data indicate a third ... Read more »

‘My friends turned me into a slave – and the police didn't intervene'

© Elizabeth Livermore/ Moment RF ‘The police sent me back to my prison of slave labour and abuse’ – Elizabeth Livermore/ Moment RF I was 23 when I moved into ... Read more »

Jason Garrett being considered for Duke coaching vacancy after Giants firing

Jason Garrett may be on the verge of finding a new job. The ousted Giants offensive coordinator is being considered to be the next head coach at Duke University, according ... Read more »

Southwest Air Sees Profit This Quarter, Dividend in 2023

(Bloomberg) — Southwest Airlines Co. said it expects to be profitable this quarter and for all of next year, on its way toward generating as much as $1.5 billion in ... Read more »

Putin says Russia will continue U.S. dialogue, send proposals in a week

© Reuters/SPUTNIK Russian President Vladimir Putin takes part in a ceremony via a video link in Sochi MOSCOW (Reuters) – Russian President Vladimir Putin said on Wednesday that Russia would ... Read more »

TfL crisis: Sadiq Khan ‘needs to get real and provide own solution', says Paul Scully

© PA Wire Tube strike The Government insisted on Wednesday there was no need to cut bus and Tube services as it accused Sadiq Khan of making unfounded and “melodramatic” ... Read more »

Under fire, UK PM apologises for staff joking about Christmas lockdown party

By Guy Faulconbridge and Kylie MacLellan © Reuters/TOM NICHOLSON British PM Johnson holds news conference in Downing Street LONDON (Reuters) -British Prime Minister Boris Johnson apologised on Wednesday after a ... Read more »

'This is unacceptable:' What we know about Tuesday's triple homicide near Canal Winchester

Sorrow and outrage are mounting Wednesday morning after three people, including two children, were fatally shot inside a vehicle Tuesday night on Columbus' Southeast Side near Canal Winchester. Police identified ... Read more »

Magnus Carlsen and Ian Nepomniachtchi draw World Chess Championship Game 10 – live!

LIVE – Updated at 14:41 Rolling report: Magnus Carlsen meets Ian Nepomniachtchi in Game 10 of the World Chess Championship from Dubai. Follow it all with Bryan Graham. Game 10 ... Read more »

‘Generation Unmute': WISE education summit convenes in Doha

© Provided by Al Jazeera Speakers highlighted the plight of marginalised youth and refugees that has been exacerbated by the coronavirus pandemic [File: Nasser Nasser/AP Photo] Doha, Qatar – Some ... Read more »

Homeless man charged with setting fire to Christmas tree at Fox News HQ

© Richard Drew A worker disassembles a Christmas tree outside Fox News headquarters (Richard Drew/AP) A homeless man has been charged with arson and other crimes for setting fire to ... Read more »

Schools are best place for children but they must be safe, union leaders say

School crossing in east Belfast (Peter Morrison/PA) (PA Archive) The best place for children is in school, but that “must be done safely”, teachers’ unions have said. Representatives of the ... Read more »

The #1 Worst Drink That Increases Visceral Fat

If you’ve heard of visceral fat, you may know that it can be a dangerous type of fat to your overall health. But many people still don’t fully understand visceral ... Read more »

German police target alleged human smuggling with nationwide raids

German police have conducted dozens of raids in a nationwide investigation against alleged human smuggling. The searches focused on 20 suspects accused of illegally bringing temporary workers into Germany from ... Read more »

What if Chris Paul was traded to the Lakers to team up with Kobe Bryant in 2011?

Do you remember where you were on Dec. 8, 2011? Far from the typical “on this date,” we look back to something that didn’t happen 10 years ago to this day. I remember ... Read more »

Hutchinson makes case for boomer boosters

Data: CDC; Chart: Jared Whalen/Axios Gov. Asa Hutchinson wants all who are eligible to get a booster shot. He's especially concerned about anyone who's 65 or older. Why it matters: ... Read more »

Passionfruit and Coconut Linzer Cookies Will Be the Star of Your Cookie Swap

Say hello to melt-in-your-mouth soft coconut sable cookies layered with tangy passionfruit curd. This is a perfect addition to your holiday parties or as a gift for your loved ones, ... Read more »

Rebel Wilson got 'pushback' from her team over weight loss

According to Rebel Wilson, not everyone on her management team was excited about her weight loss journey. © Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images for AFI Rebel Wilson, at an event in Sydney ... Read more »

Frequent Chelsea buyer waiting in January if risky Tuchel power play backfires

© PA Images Chelsea players Hakim Ziyech, Kepa Arrizabalaga and Andreas Christensen AC Milan are prepared to sign Chelsea defender Andreas Christensen in January to partner Fikayo Tomori if Thomas ... Read more »

What's in a bottle? What the climate crisis means for the future of olive oil.

For generations, families in Italy, and all across the Mediterranean Basin, have relied on the olive tree for its golden elixir: olive oil. The tree grows naturally in this part ... Read more »

Holiday travel and Omicron: What you need to know

Holiday travel will be ramping up again soon, and it’s likely to be another very busy time for US travelers. © Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images DALLAS, TX – NOVEMBER 24: A ... Read more »

Death toll from Indonesia volcano eruption rises to 39

The death toll from the eruption of Indonesia’s Mount Semeru has risen to 39, authorities said Wednesday, as rescuers scrambled to retrieve more bodies under the threat of further volcanic ... Read more »

Influenced by pop culture, Korean is now the fastest growing language in India, says language app

© Provided by The Times of India MUMBAI: When it comes to learning new languages, more and more Indians between the age groups of 17 to 25 are taking online ... Read more »

Wieder auf freiem Fuss: In Paris festgenommener Saudi-Araber ist nicht der Gesuchte

Saudi-Arabien hatte die Verbindung des Mannes zum Khashoggi-Mord bestritten. © Bereitgestellt von Blick In Paris festgenommener Saudi-Araber ist nicht der Gesuchte Einen Tag nach der Festnahme eines Verdächtigen in Paris ... Read more »

Interesse ist gross: Corona-Freiwillige rennen Armee die Bude ein!

Wegen der sich verschärfenden Corona-Lage hat der Bundesrat erneut einen Armeeeinsatz bewilligt. Bereits haben sich viele Freiwillige für einen Einsatz in Impfzentren und Spitälern gemeldet. © Keystone Corona-Freiwillige rennen Armee ... Read more »

Waseem Rizvi's family says ‘not concerned' with his decision to convert to Hinduism

Waseem Rizvi’s family says ‘not concerned’ with his decision to convert to Hinduism The family of Waseem Rizvi, the former Uttar Pradesh Shia Waqf Board chairman who converted to Hinduism ... Read more »

3 Lashkar-e-Taiba Militants Killed in Encounter in J&K's Shopian

© Provided by News18 3 Lashkar-e-Taiba Militants Killed in Encounter in J&K’s Shopian In a day-long gunbattle, three militants owing allegiance to the Lashkar-e-Taiba outfit were killed in an encounter ... Read more »

Matteo Guidicelli hopes to see more “out-of-the-box” guests for ‘Masked Singer Pilipinas' second season

On December 1, Matteo Guidicelli expressed his hopes of having more “out-of-the-box” guests for the second season of Masked Singer Pilipinas. © Provided by LionhearTV During an interview for the ... Read more »

Miss Universe PH 2021 Beatrice Luigi Gomez, One of the Favorites at the 70th Miss Universe Competition

Miss Universe Philippines 2021 Beatrice Luigi Gomez has emerged as one of the frontrunners in the 70th Miss Universe Competition that will air LIVE from Eilat, Israel this Monday (December ... Read more »

The Countess of Wessex's secret trip abroad as she makes heartfelt statement

© Provided by Hello! sophie-wessex-belgium The Countess of Wessex travelled to Belgium on Tuesday to deliver a powerful keynote speech about making the internet a safer place for children and ... Read more »

Quincy Township supervisor, charged with stealing taxpayer money, has died

Quincy Township Supervisor Kerry Bumbaugh, who was charged earlier this year with defrauding the municipality and the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania of about $150,000, has died. “It is with deep grief ... Read more »

Sleuth, 14, uses Ring doorbell to snare parcel thief after secretly placing GPS tracker on package

A TALENTED teenager used a $30 tracking device and a Ring doorbell camera to sensationally catch a porch thief. Justin Bankhead, from Utah, decided to offer a $500 reward to ... Read more »

Jacob Rees-Mogg caught joking about No 10's Xmas party as Ben Wallace left ‘repulsed' by leaked videos

JACOB Rees-Mogg has been caught joking about the No10 lockdown Christmas party fiasco in a second leaked video. A police probe has been launched into the alleged boozy bash in No10 ... Read more »

UK fines water co Severn Trent 1.5 million pounds for sewage discharges

(Reuters) – Water company Severn Trent has been fined 1.5 million pounds ($1.98 million) for illegal sewage discharges, Britain’s Environment Agency said on Wednesday, after the country launched a major ... Read more »

Tesco strikes called off by Unite; Usdaw shopworkers union still in talks with company – business live

LIVE – Updated at 14:32 © Photograph: Robert Melen/REX/Shutterstock Empty baskets of vegetables on shelves at a Tesco store in Swansea, South Wales as many supermarkets continue to run low ... Read more »

Navy SEAL dies after weekend training accident in Virginia

Nine SEALs died in training mishaps between 2013 and 2016, according to Task & Purpose. Getty Images/iStockphoto A Navy SEAL died Tuesday from injuries sustained during a weekend training session, ... Read more »

'Can't play too defensively on these pitches' - Mominul Haque

© AFP/Getty Images Mominul Haque drives watchfully © AFP/Getty Images Bangladesh captain Mominul Haque said that playing too defensively against Pakistan in the second Test cost his side wickets, holding ... Read more »

'No school for becoming queen': Dutch princess in limelight

1 / 8Netherlands RoyalsHeir to the Dutch throne Princess Amalia, left, takes an honorary seat at the Council of State, the highest government advisory body in The Hague, Netherlands, Wednesday, ... Read more »

Reports: CEO who fired over 900 employees via single Zoom call has history of fraud, mistreating workers Chief Executive Officer Vishal Garg, who is currently making headlines after firing over 900 people before the holidays, has a history of fraud, mishandling finances and mistreating employees, according ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic