Healing Space | Who are we cancelling today?

#Cancel Culture, #culture, #Healing Space, #Health, #Internet, #mental health, #social media

Illustration by Suneesh K.

Monica Lewinsky may have been Patient Zero, but each of our social set-ups bears a rap sheet of slut-shamed women, molesters, harassers, bigots, or simply people who made mistakes and poor choices from which there is no return. Cancel culture has a detrimental effect on how we perceive what justice is. And its participants, like any mob, carry the conviction of self righteousness.

Cancel culture has undeniably emerged as a powerful tool for turning the tables on a broken system, the oppressed acting against the once-privileged. People typically take to collective action when their faith in the power of individual action is depleted or laced with fear. You don’t believe you will get justice as an individual. So it moves to reputational justice and the cover of a group.

Here’s the problem, though: so does a mob. The greater story and ‘reputation’ wins a spontaneous verdict. Those who don’t have sufficient voice or platform to tell their story, or a support system of influencers to believe it, lose. It is constituted by anonymous people who depersonalize; that is, who do not operate as individuals owning their well-weighed decisions, but who get to blend their ‘verdict’ with the larger validation of group. It offers identity without accountability, making socially unacceptable actions acceptable. You wouldn’t call your neighbour’s boss and ask for them to be fired if it could be known that you had done it, but within the group you can because your responsibility for the consequences are diffused. The burden of the backlash – their unpaid bills or inability to support their family – is not your problem alone. It is nobody’s problem anymore. The choices or actions are carried on the momentum of peer pressure, whether to storm Capitol or the minority basti, or silently exclude an individual from social participation, and are nobody’s fault.

Wait, one of these is offensive and one is defensive, so it seems fair. Social exclusion may feel like fair retaliation, after all it is only a withdrawal of attention, a negation of reputation, and does not cause physical harm. But we tread a fine line. It is on the basis of reputation, a quickly circulated whisper, that mass mobs align themselves. Such exclusion is exactly what slain social justice activist Narendra Dhabolkar campaigned against, instituting the only law against it in the country, The Maharashtra Prohibition of People from Social Boycott (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2016. Social exclusion has been weaponized against nomadic tribes, the erstwhile ‘criminal’ tribes, and several castes and communities. We have record of people dying by suicide, or left to die for want of critical resources, opportunities, and medical attention, due to such ostracisation. Typically, people doing the withholding are privileged by the larger group. Cancel culture aligns with the conventionally-held standpoint often boosted by the media narrative. We also know some, like men, get rehabilitated from reputational loss more easily than others. As with any court of law, what of cancellations by consensus, that get the basis for this conviction-without-trial wrong? Whether it’s Britney Spears or Monika Lewinsky, few have the visibility, mental strength or financial resources to relocate, start afresh, tell their story, or remain standing long enough for the mob to dissipate or re-evaluate its stance. All individuals seek identity, belonging, productivity, and social validation within the larger group. The withdrawal of it is worse than a conviction in a criminal court – it is designed to destroy an individual’s sense of personhood.

We need to start taking more civil suits to court where justice is not only seen to be ordered but upheld as precedence. Courts of law are designed to remove emotion from the equation, and distinguish between justice and vengeance. In the interest of the principles of natural justice, even when the case seems to have a clear perpatrator according to public opinion, the sentence can only be in proportion to the evidence and arguments presented on both sides, audi alterem partem. It offers the convicted opportunities for furlough, re-investigation, parole, even employment, education or pardon. Further, a verdict offers finite sentencing. Someone who has served their time, even for murder or rape, should be seen as having paid their dues and worthy of a second chance.

Cancel culture makes no such allowances and delivers the maximum social penalty for willful wrongdoing and just not knowing better alike. It carries justice on a wave of sentiment. It also offers no space for progenitor causes like the inadequacy of the perpetrator’s own developmental schemas, their trauma or abuse, and offers no chance of reprieve, transformation or growth. The more we hold people to an arbitrary standard, we continue to fail to empower individual action and our notion of justice will change depending on who has social dominance at any given period of time.

#Cancel Culture, #culture, #Healing Space, #Health, #Internet, #mental health, #social media

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Celebs back #NetflixWalkout; why are Netflix employees protesting?

A growing number of celebrities are backing Netflix employees who staged a walkout on Wednesday in protest of the streaming giant’s decision to release comedian Dave Chappelle’s controversial new special, ... Read more »

100 heritage monuments to be lit in colours of Indian flag to mark 100 crore COVID vaccination feat

The Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) will light up 100 of its heritage monuments in colours of the national flag to mark 100 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses being administered in ... Read more »

Trump's new social media site will bar users from making negative comments about it

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. File: Former US president Donald Trump’s TRUTH Social app comes with a rider that bars users from making negative comments – ... Read more »

Donald Trump to float social media platform TRUTH next year

Trump was suspended from Twitter and Facebook Former US President Donald Trump plans to launch a social media platform called, Truth Social, early next year. A  statement from Trump Media and Technology Group ... Read more »

COVID-19 Vaccine Tracker: India achieves 100-crore-vaccinations milestone on October 21

Representative image. India has achieved the milestone of 100 crore (one billion) vaccinations on October 21. India accounts for about 15 percent of the total vaccine doses administered worldwide as ... Read more »

Storyboard | How brands can control narratives and fight cancel culture

(Representative image) In the face of a social media backlash, brands can either lie low until the dust settles or choose to activate a community of brand advocates who strongly ... Read more »

Trump announces launch of his very own social media site

FILE – In this Jan. 6, 2021, file photo, President Donald Trump speaks during a rally protesting the electoral college certification of Joe Biden as President in Washington. Trump has ... Read more »

India has hit the 100-crore vaccination mark

FIle image: AP Read more »

Hancock and Huq unite in call to end abuse and threats towards politicians

Rival politicians Matt Hancock and Rupa Huq have united to urge that Sir David Amess’s murder sparks permanent change to tackle online hatred of politicians and “set public debate on ... Read more »

How Elon Musk Reacted To Bitcoin Hitting Record High

Elon Musk (Illustration: Moneycontrol) Bitcoin has hit a new record, surging past $65,000 (Rs. 48,65,770) after it took another step towards mainstream status as the world’s biggest cryptocurrency forayed onto ... Read more »

Trump announces media company, social media platform coming next month

Former President Donald Trump announced that he will be starting a media company called Trump Media & Technology Group. AP Photo/Seth Wenig, File Former President Donald Trump announced Wednesday that ... Read more »

Lottery Sambad Result October 21: 'Dear Bangabhumi Bhagirathi' winners to be announced at 4 pm

Lottery Sambad Result: The West Bengal State Lottery Department is set to announce the results of its ‘Dear Bangabhumi Bhagirathi’ lottery on October 21 at 4 pm. The result can be checked at lotterysambadresult.in. ... Read more »

Donald Trump to launch new social network 'TRUTH Social'

former President Donald Trump speaks at Trump National Golf Club in Bedminster – Seth Wenig /AP Former US president Donald Trump has announced plans to launch his own social media ... Read more »

Revenue-Based Financing: The New Kid On the Block

India’s startup ecosystem is evolving as we speak, with newer business models coming to fore every day. To match up to the pace of innovation, the business of venture funding ... Read more »

Former Virgin Galactic Test Pilot Heads to Blue Origin

Mark “Forger” Stucky was the lead test pilot for Richard Branson’s Virgin Galactic for six years and piloted the first flight on the company’s SpaceShipTwo, which reached the edge of ... Read more »

7-Foot-Tall Harambe Gorilla Statue Stares Down Wall Street's Charging Bull Amid 10,000 Bananas

A 7-foot-tall bronze statue of Harambe the gorilla appeared opposite Wall Street‘s “Charging Bull” on Monday, garnering in-person crowds and leading many retail investors, who often refer to themselves as “apes,”  ... Read more »

Shipping Containers From Stranded Ships Abandoned in California Neighborhoods

Shipping containers stranded for weeks at sea are now reportedly being abandoned in California neighborhoods. Anaheim Street in Los Angeles has become one of the locations where an overflow of empty containers now line ... Read more »

Zillow to Stop Buying New Homes for the Rest of the Year as It Struggles to Manage Backlog in Renovations

Online real estate marketplace Zillow on Monday announced it will stop buying new homes for the rest of the year due to a backlog in renovations and operational capacity constraints. The company’s ... Read more »

Viral Video Exposes How One Luxury Fashion Company Destroys Unwanted Merchandise

Luxury fashion company Coach has been in hot water over the past week after a TikToker exposed its practices for disposing of unwanted goods. Edward Berthelot | Getty Images Under the username ... Read more »

Reliance Retail Acquires Majority Stake In Ritu Kumar's Brand

Reliance Retail Ventures Ltd (RRVL) on Tuesday acquired an additional 35 per cent equity stake in popular labels of Ritu Kumar. Ritika Pvt Ltd owns Ritu Kumar, Label Ritu Kumar, ... Read more »

Tom Brady, Gisele Bündchen Cause a Frenzy with 'Trade' Tease Tweets -- But It's Not What Fans Think

A well-executed play, coming from one of the best in the league. Kevin C. Cox | Getty Images Seven-time Super Bowl champion quarterback Tom Brady and his wife, supermodel Gisele ... Read more »

Netflix CEO Says He 'Screwed Up' Response to Employee Anger Over Dave Chappelle Special

Netflix co-CEO Ted Sarandos said he “screwed up” communicating with his staff after they expressed displeasure with Dave Chappelle’s new streaming comedy special, The Closer. Employees are planning a walkout ... Read more »

Gautam Adani Meets UK PM, Assures To Commit $70 billion to Energy Transition

Business tycoon, Gautam Adani on Tuesday, met United Kingdom(UK) Prime Minister Boris Johnson at the Global Investment Summit. The Adani Group chairman said he will commit $70 billion towards Energy ... Read more »

An Ant Colony Is the Perfect Metaphor for the Economy. Here's What Else You Need to Know.

Ants are fascinating creatures. Far more than a simple picnic pest or inspiring hero moving a rubber tree plant, ants are complex creatures that demonstrate the value of teamwork, networks ... Read more »

So You Want To Be an Angel Investor? The Issue Is Exit

Arvind Khaalibaithnewala shifted his considerable bulk on the sofa and absent-mindedly flipped channels on his television. Known as Khaali to his friends, he was in his fifties and had recently ... Read more »

Facebook Expected to Reveal Its Secret New Name

Next week, Facebook may forgo its household name.  KIRILL KUDRYAVTSEV | Getty Images According to a report posted by the Verge on October 19, the social media behemoth is planning to rebrand ... Read more »

Latest: FBI Confirms Items Belonging to Brian Laundrie, Human Remains Found in Florida Park

Update 4:37 P.M.: In a press conference held in Florida, the FBI confirmed that there were in fact human remains found in the Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park on Wednesday morning. Octavio Jones | ... Read more »

Trump announces launch of media company, social media site

FILE – In this Jan. 6, 2021, file photo, President Donald Trump speaks during a rally protesting the electoral college certification of Joe Biden as President in Washington. Trump has ... Read more »

Is it a fear or a phobia? How to identify — and treat — what you're feeling

A clinical psychologist unpacks the difference between fears and phobias. (Getty Creative stock photo) Halloween is a holiday that revels in our deepest, darkest fears, whether that's spiders, dark, confined ... Read more »

Financial Survey shows parents avoiding the ‘money' talk with their kids

November is Financial Literacy Month in Canada, and in anticipation of this, a poll was conducted by TD Bank to assess Canadian parents’ thoughts on teaching their children the value ... Read more »

‘We All Need to Know If You Looked At It': Georgia County Gave Potential Jurors Access to Documents About Ahmaud Arbery That Were Ordered Suppressed by the Judge

Jury selection in the case of Ahmaud Arbery, a Black man killed in February 2020 after being chased down by a father-son duo and their neighbor as he ran through ... Read more »

Board rules racism a public health crisis in New York City

New York City Board of Health declared, “To build a healthier New York City, we must confront racism as a public health crisis.” The New York City Board of Health ... Read more »

Netflix employee walkout protesters clash with Dave Chappelle supporters

Hundreds of Netflix employees and other demonstrators gathered Wednesday outside the company’s Los Angeles headquarters to protest Dave Chappelle’s new special, which critics have called offensive to the LGBTQ community. ... Read more »

Retirement Isn't Slowing Down Olympic Ski Champ Lindsey Vonn One Bit

© Lindsey Vonn: Courtesy of HEAD. Background: Lisla/AdobeStock. Lindsey Vonn built her career — and her legacy — on going full speed ahead. When the American alpine skier retired in ... Read more »

Changing Facebook's name will not deter lawmaker or regulatory scrutiny, experts say

Small toy figures are seen in front of displayed Facebook logo in this illustration By Sheila Dang and Supantha Mukherjee (Reuters) – Renaming Facebook Inc is unlikely to enable the ... Read more »

Fans on social media react as Newcastle are linked with Ross Barkley

Newcastle United have lucrative resources for transfers in January after their takeover by Public Investment Fund (PIF), PCP Capital Partners and RB Sports & Media, so they’re being linked with ... Read more »

Second arrest of a teen made after the threats of Monday shootings at Broward schools

A Fort Lauderdale high school student has been arrested and charged with making some of the school shooting threats via social media and text messages last weekend that prompted an ... Read more »

Rylan reassures fans 'he's good' after fears for his mental health

Rylan has reassured fans that he’s doing OK after a difficult year (Getty Images) Rylan has assured fans that he’s “doing good” following reports that he was being urged to ... Read more »

Teen charged in social media threat against school

A 17-year-old student at Stranahan High School was charged Wednesday in connection with threats on social media about school shootings. Police across Broward County spent Monday morning investigating social media ... Read more »

'Let's go Brandon' rap gains momentum on music charts

A gaffe-turned-meme about President Joe Biden is topping music charts. © Provided by Washington Examiner Loza Alexander first went viral on TikTok after releasing his rendition of a reporter flubbing ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic