Has Britain got its booster strategy WRONG?

Has Britain got its booster strategy WRONG?
© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo

Mixing and matching first and second Covid vaccines may work better, according to a study that questions Britain’s original jabbing strategy.

All 46million fully-inoculated adults have so far received the same vaccine, made by either AstraZeneca, Pfizer or Moderna. But new research suggests giving a different jab for a second dose triggers an even stronger immune response.  

A first dose of AstraZeneca followed by Moderna or Novavax offered higher levels of antibodies and T-cells than two of the Oxford-made injections. And those who had Pfizer then Moderna had a more robust immune response than those who had two Pfizer jabs.

However, Pfizer followed by Novavax produced a less robust response, according to the results published in the Lancet. 

Oxford University researchers carried out analysis of six different combinations. They didn’t measure vaccine effectiveness in the real world but looked at antibody and T cells levels in lab trials — the key indicators of immunity. 

Chief investigator Professor Matthew Snape said the findings show there is a ‘great deal of flexibility’ around which vaccines are used and people are not ‘locked into’ having the same second dose. 

It comes with the UK facing huge pressure to achieve a successful booster drive to protect against an expected Omicron wave, with immunity from two doses waning after several months. Experts believe top-up jabs will have a huge effect on the impeding resurgence.

Ministers have already expanded the third dose rollout to all over-18s and halved the waiting time between second and third jabs to three months.  

So far 20.5million have received an extra dose of Pfizer or Moderna, or AstraZeneca if they cannot have the mRNA vaccines, regardless of which jab they had for their first two doses. 

Extra vaccine sites, volunteers and the military are being brought in to help with the rollout and health chiefs are easing NHS staff workload so they can help.

Professor Snape said there is ‘no signal’ yet that Omicron causes more severe illness than previous variants, but if scientists confirm it is truly more infectious, it will cause more hospitalisations due to larger numbers of people catching the virus. 

Has Britain got its booster strategy WRONG?
© Provided by Daily Mail (
Has Britain got its booster strategy WRONG?
© Provided by Daily Mail The above chart shows the number of vaccine doses ordered by the UK, and which orders have been donated or cancelled. It includes the latest orders of 54million more Pfizer doses and 60million Moderna dose

Omicron wave could put as much pressure on hospitals as last winter even if it IS mild

The incoming Omicron wave could be as bad or worse for the NHS than the second coronavirus peak last winter even if the super-mutant variant is weaker than its predecessors, scientists have warned.

Real-world data suggests the highly-evolved variant is three-and-a-half times more likely to infect people than Delta because of its combination of vaccine resistance, increased infectiousness and antibody escape. 

Dr Simon Clarke, a microbiologist at the University of Reading, said it was ‘entirely possible’ that Omicron could trigger a wave of hospital admissions on par with the peak in January 2021 — even if it is milder than Delta.

He told MailOnline: ‘It’s not uncommon for a more transmissible but less disease-causing pathogen to cause a bigger problem than a virus that is less lethal. If it infects a very large number but only hospitalises a small percentage, we could still end up with an awful lot of people in hospital.’ 

There have been only 246 official Omicron cases confirmed in the UK so far, but there are likely more than a thousand already, according to Professor Paul Hunter, an epidemiologist at the University of East Anglia.

Professor Hunter said he expected it to become the dominant variant ‘probably within the next weeks or a month’, based on how rapidly it is outpacing Delta in the South African epicentre. He claimed while that timeline mean there is little need for more curbs at Christmas, it does not rule out more restrictions being needed at some point in the New Year. 

But Boris Johnson today refused to rule out tougher Covid curbs over the festive period, merely insisting that Christmas will be ‘better’ than last year. He is due to review the current measures in two weeks’ time. Mr Johnson said on a trip to Merseyside: ‘We’re still waiting to see exactly how dangerous it is, what sort of effect it has in terms of deaths and hospitalisations.’

In the UK, people either received two doses of Pfizer, AstraZeneca or Moderna and only received different first and second jabs if they were participating in a trial. 

Ministers last week ordered another 54million Pfizer and 60million Moderna jabs to ‘future proof’ the vaccination scheme. 

The new study is one of six launched this year at the request of the UK Government’s vaccine taskforce, which have compared different booster jabs and whether Covid injections and flu shots can be given at the same time.

The most recent trial enrolled 1,072 participants who had been given either Pfizer or AstraZeneca for their first Covid jab between January and March.

For their second dose around nine weeks later, the participants were given either the same vaccine, Moderna or Novavax.

Novavax is not yet approved in the UK, but data on the jab — which was found to be 96.4 per cent effective against mild, moderate and severe disease — was submitted to the medicine’s watchdog in October.

The researchers aimed to find out whether the mix-and-match approach triggered just as many binding antibodies, neutralising antibodies and T cells as as two doses of the same vaccine.

Antibodies attack the virus and stop it attaching to and infecting the body’s cells. 

Binding antibodies stick to the virus cell and alert the body to the virus, while neutralising antibodies stop the virus in its tracks. 

If the virus manages to breach that defence, T cell protection identifies them and stops them spreading further.

One dose of AstraZeneca followed by a dose of Moderna increased binding antibody levels 10-fold, compared to two of the Oxford-made jab.

While Novavax as the second injection triggered 2.8 times more antibodies. 

Professor Snape, the study’s chief investigator, said AstraZeneca alone is very effective at preventing hospitalisation.

He added it was ‘great to see it is at least as good as and actually statistically better’ when given alongside another jab.

Meanwhile, a Pfizer then Moderna jab triggered 1.3 times more binding antibodies compared to two Pfizers.

However, a combination of Pfizer and Novavax had the opposite effect and triggered half as many antibodies.

This means the Pfizer and Novavax schedule failed to meet the threshold. However, this mixture still produced four times as many antibodies than two AstraZeneca jabs alone.

Researchers recorded a similar pattern of effectiveness for the different combinations when looking at neutralising antibodies and T cells.

AstraZeneca followed by Moderna or Novavax triggered a more robust response, as did Pfizer and Moderna, while Pfizer and Novavax were less effective.

Professor Snape said the AstraZeneca/Novavax combination produced a ‘fantastic’ T cell and immune response, and the Oxford jab followed by any vaccine gives a ‘stonking’ reaction, showing a strong immune response can be achieved without mRNA vaccines, which need to be kept at freezing cold temperatures. 

If Novavax is approved in more countries it could ‘ramp up’ the rollout in low income nations because there are less logistical challenges, he said.

Has Britain got its booster strategy WRONG?
Has Britain got its booster strategy WRONG?
Has Britain got its booster strategy WRONG?
In total, there are 46,000 Covid cases on average each day in the UK and data from the Covid Genomics UK Consortium (COG-UK) suggests the new strain is already behind around one in 66 of them, or 1.4 per cent Total Covid cases are rising fastest in London and the South East of England with most of the Omicron infections linked to travellers flying back into the UK

Just 20% of children aged 12-15 have had their first Covid vaccine in parts of London

Fewer than a fifth of children in parts of London have already had their first Covid vaccine, according to official figures.

The entire programme has been beset by delays and cancellations, with critics arguing the decision to only let youngsters originally get jabbed in schools hampered the drive. 

Up-to-date NHS statistics have prompted Labour to call on No10 to ‘turbocharge’ the campaign for younger age groups. 

Uptake for 12 to 15-year-olds is lowest in Hackney, where only 19.8 per cent have had their first jab. All of the worst five performing areas are in the capital. 

For comparison, rates are three times higher in more affluent parts of the country. In Fareham, Hampshire, 67 per cent of children are jabbed while in South Oxfordshire the rate is 64.3 per cent, and in the New Forest, also in Hampshire, it is 64.1 per cent.

Shadow Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson, who was promoted to Labour’s frontbench last week, today urged ministers to open more walk-in clinics so children can get their jabs. Nationwide, six in ten are yet to get their first dose.

Overall, Pfizer then Moderna gave the best antibody levels, while AstraZeneca then Moderna triggered the most T cells. 

Scientists have known for decades that a viral vector vaccine such as AstraZeneca, followed by a different jab for a second dose gives the best T cell response and this approach is used for inoculating against Ebola, he said.

The study also found the combinations that were effective against the original strain also protected against the Beta and Delta variants.

Professor Snape, who is also an associate professor in paediatrics and vaccinology at the University of Oxford, said the ‘obvious question’ is whether this finding was also true for the Omicron variant, but warned the results were still a ‘few weeks’ away.

He noted that South Africa, the epicentre of the Omicron outbreak, is recording breakthrough infections, but so far there is ‘no signal’ of an increase in disease severity, ‘so there is some reassurance from that point of view’.

But there is a lag between people getting infected and becoming very unwell, ‘which is why the next few weeks are so revealing’, Professor Snape said.

‘Even if there is no increase in severity from it — which is great and promising if that is the case — an increase in cases will mean there are more people who have severe disease, because more people are infected,’ he added.

Professor Snape said the world is moving ‘so quickly’ that the study is most relevant for the ‘many, many countries’ still dishing out first and second doses.

All combinations were found to be safe. However, those who received a mRNA jab as their second dose reported more arm pain.

People who had the Pfizer and Moderna combination reported the most side effects, such as headaches and a fever, while Novavax was the most well-tolerated jab.

Professor Penny Ward, an expert in pharmaceutical medicine at King’s College London, said the study demonstrates ‘the superiority of mixing two different vaccines’ to repeat dosing with the same vaccine ‘in terms of the antibody and cellular response generated following the second dose’.

It comes as scientists today warned the incoming Omicron wave could be as bad or worse for the NHS than the second coronavirus peak last winter.

Real-world data suggests the highly-evolved variant is three-and-a-half times more likely to infect people than Delta because of its combination of vaccine resistance, increased infectiousness and antibody escape.

Dr Simon Clarke, a microbiologist at the University of Reading, said it was ‘entirely possible’ that Omicron could trigger a wave of hospital admissions on par with the peak in January 2021 — even if it is milder than Delta.

He told MailOnline: ‘It’s not uncommon for a more transmissible but less disease-causing pathogen to cause a bigger problem than a virus that is less lethal. If it infects a very large number but only hospitalises a small percentage, we could still end up with an awful lot of people in hospital.’

There have been only 246 official Omicron cases confirmed in the UK so far, but there are likely more than a thousand already, according to Professor Paul Hunter, an epidemiologist at the University of East Anglia.

Professor Hunter said he expected it to become the dominant variant ‘probably within the next weeks or a month’, based on how rapidly it is outpacing Delta in the South African epicentre. He claimed while that timeline mean there is little need for more curbs at Christmas, it does not rule out more restrictions being needed at some point in the New Year.     

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Liverpool transfer round-up: Luis Diaz issues as Fabio Carvalho update issued

After a relatively quiet January transfer window, things have sped up for Liverpool in a big way of late. The Reds are on the verge of completing a big-money deal ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15 Grand Finale: Nishant Bhat to leave BB house for 'briefcase'? Here's what we know

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Entertainment Desk: Bigg Boss 15 Grand Finale is all set to telecast from today, January 29 and will conclude on January ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Hrithik Roshan to join Salman Khan and Shah Rukh Khan in Spy Universe after War 2

© Provided by Pinkvilla There has been widespread speculation about when Shah Rukh Khan as Pathan, Salman Khan as Tiger and Hrithik Roshan as Kabir will be seen together on ... Read more »

COMELEC's Guanzon says Marcos' party is threatening her

Commission on Elections (COMELEC) Commissioner Rowena Guanzon. (Source: Rowena Guanzon/Facebook) Commission on Elections (COMELEC) Commissioner Rowena Guanzon claims that she is being threatened by Partido Federal ng Pilipinas (PFP) – ... Read more »

Senate approval of Marawi Bill hailed

ZAMBOANGA CITY: Deputy Speaker and Basilan Rep. Mujiv Hataman on Thursday praised senators who approved in the second reading the Marawi Compensation Bill, referring to the southern Muslim city destroyed ... Read more »

Kanye West may be unable to bring his Donda tour Down Under due to Australia's extreme rules on Covid and vaccinations

Kanye West may be unable to receive an Australian visa under the same vaccine-related rules that saw tennis legend Novak Djokovic kicked out of the country this month. According to News.com.au, ... Read more »

Umno bangkit semula bukan kerana ‘ubat' PAS, tapi kerana dukungan orang Melayu, Tok Mat bidas Hadi

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Mohamad Hasan berkata Umno bangkit semula kerana dukungan orang Melayu terhadap parti itu dan kerana buruknya prestasi kerajaan Pakatan Harapan dan Perikatan Nasional. PETALING ... Read more »

Nur zwei Städte bewarben sich um die Austragung der Spiele 2022

© KEYSTONE/AP/JOSHUA PAUL Als erste Destination der Geschichte trägt Peking nach den Sommerspielen 2008 auch Winterspiele aus. Das Bewerbungsdossier der chinesischen Hauptstadt bekam bei nur zwei Bewerbern den Zuschlag. Bewerbern ... Read more »

Schweizer nur mit Aussenseiterchancen

© KEYSTONE/EPA/CHRISTIAN BRUNA Die Schweizer Biathleten haben gute Erinnerungen an die letzten Olympischen Spiele in Asien. 2018 klassierten sie sich in Pyeongchang in elf Rennen sieben Mal in den Top ... Read more »

Canada's 'Freedom Convoy' of up to 50,000 truckers begins to arrive in Ottawa ahead of a weekend of protests against the vaccine requirements to cross the US-Canada border

A convoy of 50,000 trucks, stretching over 40 miles long, has arrived in the Canadian capital, OttawaThe convoy set out from British Columbia on Sunday and was cheered by hundreds of Canadians as it made its 2,000-mile journey to protest vaccine mandatesSince mid January, Canada and the United States have imposed a COVID-19 vaccine mandate for foreign truck drivers crossing the border between the two countriesCanadian drivers are unable to enter the U.S. unless they are vaccinated, and U.S. drivers are unable to enter Canada Furthermore, unvaccinated Canadian drivers returning home must get tested and quarantineUnvaccinated American truckers are not forced to test and quarantine when returning to the U.S.   Prime Minister Justin Trudeau called the huge group a 'small fringe minority' and pointed out 90 percent of Canadians are vaccinatedThe group plan to protest in Ottawa over the weekend, with some vowing to stay until the government rescinds the vaccine mandate  Read more »

Medvedev tekad sekat Nadal cipta rekod Grand Slam

© Provided by Sinar Harian BINTANG tenis Rusia, Daniil Medvedev bertekad mahu menghalang bintang Sepanyol, Rafael Nadal mencipta rekod memenangi gelaran Grand Slam ke-21 pada aksi final Terbuka Australia, pada ... Read more »

Pemain Senegal perlu berikan aksi terbaik

© Provided by Sinar Harian BIARPUN dilabel antara pasukan pilihan pada Kejohanan Piala Negara-Negara Afrika (AFCON) 2022, namun pengendali Senegal, Aliou Cisse tetap mengingatkan skuad kendaliannya itu untuk sentiasa memberikan ... Read more »

Joni Mitchell joining Neil Young in protest over Spotify

NEW YORK — Joni Mitchell said Friday she is seeking to remove all of her music from Spotify in solidarity with Neil Young, who ignited a protest against the streaming ... Read more »

Taliban does not feel beholden to ISI for Kabul takeover, says think tank

© Provided by The Statesman Taliban does not feel beholden to ISI for Kabul takeover, says think tank The recent incidents at the Pakistan-Afghanistan border have brought to light the ... Read more »

West Bengal Lottery Result 2022: Dear Bangasree Damodar Results for January 29 at 4 PM; 1st Prize Winner to Get Rs 50 Lakh

© Provided by News18 West Bengal Lottery Result 2022: Dear Bangasree Damodar Results for January 29 at 4 PM; 1st Prize Winner to Get Rs 50 Lakh West Bengal Lottery ... Read more »

CISF Constable Recruitment 2022: Apply for 1149 posts on cisfrectt.in

Central Industrial Security Force, CISF has invited applications from candidates to apply for Constable/Fire posts. Eligible candidates can apply online through the official site of CISF on cisfrectt.in. The last ... Read more »

Trial in German museum jewel heist worth over Rs 937 crore starts

© Provided by DNA Dresden’s Gruenes Gewoelbe (Green Vault) Museum was looted during the early hours of Nov. 25, 2019, and jewellery containing over 4,300 diamonds valued at more than ... Read more »

Important values to teach your kids by age 5

Every parent has some lessons in mind that they wish to impart to their child, yet many are unsure about what the right age is to begin. While some wait ... Read more »

Punjab Elections 2022: What prompted Congress to leave its policy of not projecting its CM face | Jagran Explainer

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Politics Desk: Rahul Gandhi’s announcement that Congress will soon declare its chief ministerial face for the Punjab assembly elections 2022 left ... Read more »

Thousands of flights canceled as Eastern US braces for winter storm

© Scott Eisen A truck delivers road salt in preparation for a winter storm at the Boston Public Works Department yard on January 28, 2022 Thousands of flights in the ... Read more »

Mouni Roy-Suraj Nambiar Wedding: Newlyweds groove to 'Rowdy Baby' on sangeet | See pics and videos

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Entertainment Desk: Popular actress Mouni Roy got hitched to her longtime beau Suraj Nambiar, a Dubai-based businessman, on Thursday in Goa. ... Read more »

Pakistan police to seek ban on China's PUBG, other videogames after youth shoots mother, siblings dead

© Provided by The Statesman Pakistan police to seek ban on China’s PUBG, other videogames after youth shoots mother, siblings dead Pakistan police have decided to send recommendations to the ... Read more »

India 'willing' to engage with Pakistan on expanding list of shrines for visits

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: India on Friday (January 28, 2022) said that there is an interest on both, the Indian and Pakistani sides, to expand the agreed ... Read more »

Bodies Of Indian Family Who Died While Crossing Into US May Not Be Flown Back: Report

© Provided by News18 Bodies Of Indian Family Who Died While Crossing Into US May Not Be Flown Back: Report The bodies of the Patels who died on the Canadian ... Read more »

How to evolve Burmy into Mothim in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by GamePur Burmy has appeared in several Pokémon games, and you can catch it in Pokémon Legends: Arceus. First, you’ll want to check out the shaking trees in ... Read more »

Yuzi Chahal Next On ‘Hit-List'? Parthiv Patel Comments On Spinner's Future With Team India

© Provided by MensXP The ODI and T20I teams for the forthcoming limited-overs series against the West Indies were revealed by the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15 Grand Finale: Rakhi Sawant suffers an OOPS moment in a blue deep neck dress; netizens calls her 'Sasti kim didi' – watch

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com A post shared by Viral Bhayani (@viralbhayani) A post shared by IANS TV (@ianstvbollywood) Rakhi Sawant and husband Ritesh are going to grace the Grand Finale ... Read more »

Iranian man balances 85 spoons on body to set new Guinness World Record- Watch

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: An Iranian man broke Guinness World Record for most spoons balanced on the body. 50-year-old Abolfazl Saber Mokhtari from AKraj in Iran broke ... Read more »

'Franchise might have found that inappropriate': Aakash Chopra on why RCB released Chahal, feels 'they can buy him back'

Former Indian cricketer Aakash Chopra on Friday looked at the reasons behind Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB) not retaining their star player Yuzvendra Chahal ahead of the 2022 season of the ... Read more »

Best Nature for Croagunk and Toxicroak in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by GamePur During your travels through the Crimson Mirelands, you undoubtedly got spotted by a Croagunk hiding in the swamp. Croagunk, and their evolution Toxicroak, are Poison and ... Read more »

Trump facing legal, political headwinds as he eyes comeback

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – Former President Donald Trump speaks at a rally on Jan. 15, 2022, in Florence, Ariz. Trump is already declaring himself the 45th and ... Read more »

India administers more than 56 lakh COVID-19 vaccine doses in last 24 hours

The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare on Saturday stated that India has administered more than 56 lakh doses of COVID-19 vaccine in the last 24 hours with this India’s ... Read more »

Video: Heartbreaking details emerge about the killing of two children, aged four and six, found dead with their father in suspected double murder-suicide - as how their mother found out is revealed

Read more »

Video: Snow arrives in NYC as powerful storm Kenan bears down on the East Coast and 75million people prepare: Travel is in limbo after than 2,000 flights were grounded Friday and Boston braces for historic storm 

Read more »

Video: Incredible moment Australian woman who was abducted for three days as a toddler is reunited with one of the men who found her 53 years later 

Read more »

Curves and confidence! Star of Netflix hit series 'My Unorthodox Life' launches collection of high-tech shapewear inspired by Bridget Jones's Diary designed to empower women

Julia Haart is the star of the Netflix hit series “My Unorthodox Life” she’s also the CEO of Elite World Group and a modern day boss babe. While filming a ... Read more »

Nachbarschaftsstreit in Italien: Priester läutete zu oft die Glocken – 2000 Euro Busse

Er läutete zu oft die Glocken und wurde dafür nun bestraft. Ein Priester in Italien wurde zu einer Busse von 2000 Euro verurteilt. Nachbarn der Kirche kämpften vier Jahre lang ... Read more »

Das letzte Hurra der Schweizer Langlauf-Ikone

© KEYSTONE/GIAN EHRENZELLER Mit Dario Cologna gibt das Schweizer Langlauf-Aushängeschild schlechthin seinen Abschied von der grossen Bühne. Eine weitere Medaille wäre für den vierfachen Olympiasieger ein kleines Wunder. Dario Cologna ... Read more »

Blue Bloods delayed: Reagan family drama won't air next week in huge shake-up

© CBS Blue Bloods: season 12 schedule shake up cbs Blue Bloods is the CBS drama revolving around the Reagans, an Irish Catholic family of police officers. Since it started ... Read more »

Childhood obesity can hamper your kid's mental health in future

Obesity is on rise worldwide and so are the plethora of diseases associated with it from diabetes, heart disease, stroke to some types of cancer. As our lifestyle has undergone ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic