Has a time of reckoning come for Norwegian museums?

galleries, museums, The ‘Benin Bronzes’, 1970 UNESCO convention regulating

With multiple galleries and museums, including the Museum of Cultural History, either being renovated or rebuilt in Norway, the next few years will see a cultural flowering nationwide. In the shiny exteriors of these million-kroner cultural palaces lie various ethnographic collections. These are culturally and historically important objects and artifacts, often taken by both legal and illegal means. Many arrived in Norway during the height of the European colonial and imperial epoch. Will Norway’s cultural and historical institutions take an active role in the broader debate about returning these collections to their original countries or cultures? Or is a well-funded museum, in a safe and peaceful country, the best place to experience world history?

History in the era of ‘Black Lives Matter’

Since the rise of the ‘Black Lives Matter’ movement worldwide, many Western countries are, perhaps for the first time, engaging in debates about their colonial and imperial pasts and their effect on race relations today. Part of this debate has been focused on the ethics of various museums, from The Metropolitan Museum of Art, across the British Museum, to the recently opened Humboldt Forum – all of which possess vast ethnographic collections.

Originally from non-European cultures and countries, these collections were acquired during the early modern period, but especially in the 19th century, the watermark of European colonial and imperial exploitation. They consist mainly of sculptures, paintings, tools, and monuments but can also include human remains and skeletons.

Most collections were assembled as a direct result of imperialism, colonialism, and/or conquest.

A case study: Benin Bronzes returning soon

The ‘Benin Bronzes’ (a vast collection of metal, ivory, wood, and bronze objects from the Kingdom of Benin, in modern-day Nigeria) are a well-known example of museums acquiring looted art.

When the British Empire invaded the area in 1897, the ‘Benin Bronzes’ were pillaged as means to finance the invasion. They were eventually auctioned off to museums throughout Europe, and the majority of the collection ended up in Berlin at the Ethnologisches Museum.

After years of campaigning by the Nigerian Government, who see the Bronzes as a prized cultural and historical treasure bizarrely residing in faraway Berlin, the German Government announced this April, that thousands of these objects would be returned starting in 2022.

A slice of Madagascar in… Bergen?

Though Norway was never among the biggest colonial powers – in fact, some would argue it was a victim of European colonialism (sorry, Sweden and Denmark) – there are still various ethnographic objects dotted throughout the country.

The University of Oslo (UiO) and the University of Bergen (UiB) house two of the most extensive such collections. Indeed, the University Museum of Bergen has one of the largest ethnographic exhibitions in Norway.

Wandering through Bergen’s University Museum, visitors can have a cultural smorgasbord for their eyes with objects and artifacts from Asia, the Pacific islands, the Middle East, the Americas, and Africa. The museum is particularly famed for its ethnographic collection from Madagascar.

However, the museum website does not mention or explain how most of these foreign objects, from countries and cultures with no apparent link to Norway, came to be housed in Bergen.

galleries, museums, The ‘Benin Bronzes’, 1970 UNESCO convention regulating

Bergen University. Photo: Marit Hommedal / NTB

What’s an Egyptian mummy doing in Oslo?

The Museum of Cultural History, run by the UiO, is one of Norway’s museums undergoing an expensive renovation. Although it’s responsible for mainly telling a history of Norway (it manages, for example, the Viking Ship Museum), Oslo’s Museum of Cultural History also owns an ethnographic collection. Exhibits include an extensive array of Egyptian antiquities (including mummies), along with Inuit objects and Roman marble sculptures.

The UiO admits that the last Egyptian artifact arrived in 1962 (a century after the European empires – the era, in fact, of decolonization) and does name many of its ‘generous collectors or donors.’ But, the website has little more than a throwaway line that ‘most (artifacts) came during the 19th century, when European museums built large Egyptian collections.’

They were acquired because ‘it was impossible for the museum in Cairo to take care of such large a find‘ referring to the 1891 discovery of a vast cache of Egyptian antiquities. There is no mention of by what means the ‘collectors’ acquired them or that surely, in 2021, Egypt possesses the storage capabilities for its own cultural treasures.

galleries, museums, The ‘Benin Bronzes’, 1970 UNESCO convention regulating

Inside the newly renovated Museum of Cultural History, Oslo. Photo: Berit Roald / NTB

UNESCO’s 1970 cultural property treaty

It must be time for the Norwegian government to work with authorities to undertake a serious analysis of these ethnographic collections – or at least to acknowledge, educate, and present how they were really acquired. The fact remains that many of these collections arrived in Norway, within the past two centuries, when the proper legal and official documentation of transactions, purchases, or ‘gifts’ was simply non-existent. Even if some were legally ‘bought’ – under what conditions were they purchased? Every year, for thousands of schoolchildren here, these collections represent their first taste of broader world history and culture. Don’t they deserve to know the truth behind what’s on display?

The 1970 UNESCO convention regulating the transport of cultural property has sought to halt the illicit trade in arts and antiquities throughout the world. It now has around 140 signatories – yet Norway only ratified this in 2007, almost four decades after it became legally effective. Given its cultural and societal progressiveness, why did it take various governments (of both the left and right) so long to sign this treaty?

Still, cultural and historical institutions in Norway, at least, seem to have learned a lesson. Both the UiO and UiB have stated that they no longer actively pursue the acquirement of foreign objects or antiquities.

Norway’s museums can be a place of cultural exchange and education

Yet, for all these murky details of the acquisition of Norway’s ethnographic collections, some historical and cultural museums are doing important work.

For example, Norwegian Polar Explorer Roald Amundsen visited an area now called Gjoa Haven on Canada’s King William Island from 1903 to 1905. A collection from his visit, which features documents, photographs, and Inuit cultural material, was bequeathed to the Museum of Cultural History at UiO.

Since 2010, UiO and the Nattilik Heritage Center in Gjoa Haven have worked to digitize this collection for educational purposes. In addition, there is frequent collaboration, including workshops, between the two institutions aimed at better promoting Inuit culture and history.

Regardless of Gjoa Haven’s remote location and small size (it has a population of less than 2,000), UiO was instrumental in helping to establish the Nattilik Heritage Center. This sort of cross-cultural collaboration is the epitome of what museums, galleries, and other palaces of culture, in the West should be aiming to achieve.

No time like the present

As many cultural and historical institutions in the West are now rethinking their relationship to their ethnographic and foreign collections, the time is ripe for Norway to act.

Given that the government has spent millions of kroner updating, renovating, and rebuilding many cultural institutions with significant historical meaning, isn’t it about time that a serious debate about cultural repatriation, better cultural collaboration, and a corrective history should be undertaken?

The opinions expressed are those of the author and are not held by Norway Today unless specifically stated.

About the author:

Jonathan is a lover of the written word. He believes the best way to combat this polarization of news and politics, in our time, is by having a balanced view. Both sides of the story are equally important. He also enjoys traveling and live music.

Source: #NorwayTodayTravel

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Norwegian to return to normal use of bonus points from November 1

From November 1, Norwegian will remove the temporary restrictions on the use of bonus points. “We have always said that we will bring the benefits program back to normal when ... Read more »

Get Up, Stand Up! The Bob Marley Musical review: Arinzé Kene is a knockout

Arinzé Kene as Bob Marley (Craig Sugden) “My name is Arinzé Kene and I will be Bob Marley,” and with those words, this stellar performer ascends to the West End ... Read more »

BankID is down Thursday morning due to change of supplier

BankID is down on Thursday due to a change of supplier. The downtime was supposed to last until 8 AM but was extended. The service will probably be up again ... Read more »

Coronavirus incidence may grow until establishment of herd immunity, expert says

"It is difficult to name any deadlines," Deputy Director for Clinical Research of the Gabrichevsky Institute of Epidemiology and Microbiology Tatyana Ruzhentsova noted Read more »

Hot tickets for half-term: great ways to spend the October break

Science The fifth Dark Skies festival is taking place on Exmoor with lots of family-friendly events, including wildlife safaris, owl experiences, space workshops and, of course, stargazing (22 Oct-7 Nov, ... Read more »

Russia records isolated cases of AY.4.2 COVID-19 variant, says expert

MOSCOW, October 21. / TASS /. Russia registered some isolated cases of the AY.4.2 COVID-19 variant, a subtype of the Delta strain, Kamil Khafizov, Head of the Scientific Group for ... Read more »

UNGA president slams 'unacceptable' vaccination rate among developing countries

Abdulla Shahid also believes that the international community, all 193 countries, have the capacity to immunize the entire world by the end of 2022 Read more »

Policeman who was shot with an arrow during the Kongsberg attack: “It's strange to be described as a hero”

48-year-old policeman Rigoberto Villarroel was not at work when he was shot with an arrow at Coop Extra in Kongsberg. He says it is strange to be described as a ... Read more »

WHO to decide on approval of Russian Sputnik V jab after last inspection

CEO of the RDIF Kirill Dmitriev expressed hope that the vaccine would be authorized by the WHO in the next couple of months Read more »

Norway's Yara: High gas prices in Europe could lead to food shortages

Sky-high gas prices in Europe could threaten food security in the world, Yara warns. European nitrogen production is important for fertilizer production for agriculture. Yara President Svein Tore Holsether fears ... Read more »

Meteorologist: Expect sunny weather in the east of Norway and heavy rainfall in the west

The weather in Norway is currently characterized by contrasts, meteorologists say. “Our country is full of contrasts, and there will be a bit of everything in different parts of the ... Read more »

WHO resumes approval process for Sputnik V jab - Russian Direct Investment Fund

Meanwhile, RDIF CEO Kirill Dmitriev said in an interview with CNN that WHO experts were expected in Russia soon and that he was hopeful Sputnik V would be approved by the WHO within the next two months Read more »

Sharon Stone leaves fans breathless as she struts in stunning little black dress

Sharon Stone left fans gasping with another incredible fashion moment as she wowed social media with her latest post. MORE: Sharon Stone dazzles in sensational gold gown you need to ... Read more »

New Bergen Engines owner says some employees will lose their jobs

Bergen Engines’ new owner Anthony Langley says some employees will lose their jobs after the takeover but does not yet know how many. Langley is behind Langley Holdings, which he ... Read more »

Theatre in spotlight over demands that staff educate themselves on white privilege

Roy Alexander Weise is the first black person to hold the position of artistic director at the Royal Exchange – Piers Allardyce/Shutterstock Theatre staff will be made to read about ... Read more »

Hol Municipality asks residents to wear face masks and keep their distance

Due to an increase in the number of infection cases in October, Hol Municipality is asking residents to use face masks and keep their distance. Municipal chief medical officer Silje ... Read more »

Christine Lampard wears a totally wild dress to Jamie Redknapp's wedding

Are you off to a wedding in the foreseeable future? Not sure what to wear? Look no further than the fabulous Christine Lampard. READ: Christine Lampard wows Loose Women fans ... Read more »

Spotify and co. under fire in UK government investigation over industry power

Britain’s competition regulator plans to launch an examination of the music streaming market to see whether the likes of Spotify and co. are giving fans enough choice. The watchdog’s announcement ... Read more »

One person arrested after stabbing incident in Åsnes

A man has been sent to the hospital after being stabbed at Arneberg in Åsnes Municipality on Wednesday morning. One person has been arrested. The person in question has been ... Read more »

How not being 'bound by history' helped Copenhagen become the world's number one city for food

In early October, organisers of The World’s 50 Best Restaurants confirmed what many in gastronomy had known for years – there’s no beating the Vikings. By naming Copenhagen’s Noma and ... Read more »

Syrian refugee puppet Little Amal arrives in the UK to complete her journey

A giant puppet of a Syrian refugee child created to symbolize millions of displaced children has arrived in England on the last leg of its journey across Europe. The 11.5-foot ... Read more »

World's biggest book fair opens its doors in Frankfurt

After a ‘virtual break’ due to COVID last year, the world’s biggest book fair just kicked off its 73rd edition in Frankfurt. With 2,000 publishers from 80 countries presenting their ... Read more »

Hainan's Sanya is recognized as one of the healthiest cities in China

A special index takes into account the resources of the health care system, the services it provides, the extent to which the health of its residents is protected, the environment, and the overall health of the population Read more »

This week, Oslo's new Munch Museum finally opens to the public!

Oslo’s iconic Munch Museum is back and better than ever, following a multi-year, multi-billion kroner renovation. The museum revamp comes with a name change in tow. This is no longer ... Read more »

Yellow danger warning issued for heavy snowfall in the mountains in Southern Norway

Difficult driving conditions are expected in the mountains in Southern Norway on Thursday afternoon due to heavy snowfall. Western Norway will get the first snow of the year, according to ... Read more »

How our art critic ended up in the Beano: The Art of Breaking the Rules – review

What should a critic do? I’m sure there must be rules: don’t take backhanders from galleries. Don’t get too intimate with artists, especially not dead ones. Declare any conflicts of ... Read more »

The top photographs from the World Pano awards

The Epson Pano Awards‘ winning entries take you from the wetlands of Louisiana to a jellyfish-filled lake in the republic of Palau Curious travellers have spent a long period cut ... Read more »

A new educational program opened its doors in the experimental educational zone in Hainan

Some 86 students will take part in a one semester internship program in the framework of the project Read more »

Putin signs decree declaring non-working days from October 30 to November 7

The presidential decree comes into force on the day of its official publication Read more »

Many pupils in Norway feel insecure at school due to adults: “We have been worried for a long time”

In 2019 and 2020, 230 pupils reported that they did not feel safe at school because an adult bothered them. “We have been worried for a long time about children ... Read more »

Three men and a literary lady: how the Planeta Literature Prize proved that pseudonyms still work

Earlier this week it was revealed that Carmen Mola, author of a number of widely praised Spanish crime thrillers and recipient of the world’s most expensive literary prize, was actually ... Read more »

Our favourite tiny airports from around the world

gustaf iii airport, st barts – Getty Airports are usually the low-point of any holiday, with queues, bad food, clinical strip lighting and, now, reams of documentation to contend with. ... Read more »

Appeal case against 25-year-old man from Skien accused of terrorism set to start next week

A man from Skien was sentenced in the district court to twelve years in prison for attempted complicity in a terrorist attack. The appeal case starts in Borgarting Court of ... Read more »

Ex-principal dancer at English National Ballet jailed for sexual abuse of female students

Former English National Ballet principal Yat-Sen Chang (PA Archive) A former principal dancer at the English National Ballet who sexually assaulted young female students has been jailed for nine years. ... Read more »

Nine hacks for making your half-term getaway as smooth as possible

Rome – Getty We are approaching by far the most ‘normal’ half term season since the beginning of the pandemic. Only seven countries are on the UK’s red list: Colombia, ... Read more »

Can I travel to India?

Unsplash ( ) In 2019, more than one million British nationals visited India. After closing its borders to foreign nationals in March 2020, India announced that it would grant tourist ... Read more »

Quentin Tarantino receives Lifetime Achievement Award at Rome Film Festival

American film director Quentin Tarantino, known for ‘Pulp Fiction, ‘Kill Bill’ and ‘Reservoir Dogs’, honoured with Lifetime Achievement Award at the Rome Film Festival. He was awarded by Italian horror ... Read more »

Erik Hillestad appointed as knight of the Royal Norwegian Order of St. Olav

Music producer Erik Hillestad has been appointed by King Harald as a knight 1st class of the Royal Norwegian Order of St. Olav for his efforts for the church and ... Read more »

Sør-Rogaland District Court: Man accused of sexually abusing 40 dogs

A man in his 40s has been charged with the sexual abuse of about 40 dogs. For a period of ten years, he is said to have abused both his ... Read more »

COVID-19 deaths reach critical level in 17 Russian regions, Deputy PM says

Tatyana Golikova noted that the continued increase in mortality from COVID-19 causes particular alarm Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic