Hailey Bieber faces accusations of 'cultural appropriation' for 'brownie glazed lips' look

Hailey Bieber faces accusations of 'cultural appropriation' for 'brownie glazed lips' look

The makeup look is said to have originated among women of color.

Hailey Bieber's viral TikTok post about her recent lip routine is facing some backlash and accusations of “cultural appropriation” among social media users.

“Ready for all the fall things including brownie glazed lips,” Bieber wrote in a caption to a video of her modeling makeup that included dark lip liner and clear lip gloss.

Some TikTok users have accused the model and wife of singer Justin Bieber of appropriating the makeup routine, which is thought to be a popular style from the late '80s and '90s originating among women of color — particularly Black and Latina women.

PHOTO: Jillian Hernandez, a University of Florida professor and author of

Jillian Hernandez, a University of Florida professor and author of “Aesthetics of Excess: The Art and Politics of Black and Latina Embodiment,” studies the autonomous aesthetics and sexualities of Black and Latinx people. ABC News

Jillian Hernandez, a professor at University of Florida's Center for Gender, Sexualities, and Women's Studies Research, told “Good Morning America” that her research has focused on the hyper-sexualization of working-class Black and Latina girls' aesthetics.

“African American and Latina women get denigrated for the ways that they present their body, the way they wear their hair,” Hernandez said. “People use words like ghetto or ratchet.”

Sandra E. Garcia, a New York Times style reporter, said Bieber's TikTok post is an example of a familiar double standard.

“[Black women and Latinas] are being looked at as lesser than any other woman just because of the way they decide to do their own makeup,” Garcia told “Good Morning America.” “But then another woman, a white woman, does the same thing, and her lip gloss is sold out and she's now the face of the trend.”

Hernandez described the co-opting of trends as an act of “stylistic or aesthetic gentrification,” which she said can be traced as far as the 19th century when Cubist artist Pablo Picasso, who is Spanish, took inspiration from traditional African art.

“The reason he innovated modern art was because he was looking at African masks,” Hernandez said. “So much Western innovation stems from colonialism. And that's where we get this kind of cultural appropriation.”

PHOTO: Sandra E. Garcia is a style reporter for the New York Times.

Sandra E. Garcia is a style reporter for the New York Times. ABC News

As a result, she said Black women and Latinas don’t often profit from their fashion and cultural trendsetting.

“The problem is around the politics of value — on whose body is that aesthetic valued, who's able to get value materially in terms of money, in terms of cultural capital?” Hernandez said. “We're in a society that unevenly attributes value to these body aesthetics depending on the identities of the people.”

Hailey Bieber has not responded to ABC News' request for comment.

Bieber's post is not the first to generate accusations of cultural appropriation on TikTok.

PHOTO: Hailey Bieber is facing backlash for her 'brownie glazed lips' look.

Hailey Bieber is facing backlash for her ‘brownie glazed lips’ look. Hailey Bieber/TikTok

For example, the TikTok “clean girl aesthetic” — a common style among Black and Latina girls characterized by gold hoop earrings, a low, slicked back bun, and outerwear — has drawn criticism for centering thin white women as both the image and inventors of the look.

Accusations of cultural appropriation have also touched other aspects of culture. Some online have criticized re-labeling “agua fresca” — a drink of Mexican origin made with puréed fruit, water, and sugar — as spa water, or ceviche — a South American seafood dish typically made with raw fish — as “cowboy caviar” on TikTok.

“I know it may seem as trivial as a lip gloss and a lip line, but this is a systemic issue,” Garcia said. “In the end, it is still the Black and Latino women that are losing. They lose parts of their identity. They lose their self-worth.”

However, Hernandez said the issue ultimately doesn't lie with Bieber using the lip look.

“It's totally fine for people to play around with body aesthetics and things that inspire them that they see in other cultures,” she said. “For me, it's more about just giving that due credit.”

“The ways that young people especially are using outlets like TikTok, for example, to share their stories to share histories,” she added. “I really hope that these issues become platforms that then can highlight Black and Latinx beauty creators, beauty influencers.”

News Related


Georgia ends 2022 midterm cycle that challenged and confounded Washington: ANALYSIS

Georgia ends 2022 midterm cycle that challenged and confounded Washington: ANALYSIS The “red wave” wasn't, but other lessons look less clear. By the numbers recorded in the history books, the ... Read more »

NASA's Orion Spacecraft Will Splash Down Off San Diego Coast This Weekend. Meet the Team Tasked With Recovering It

While Florida, Texas, and Pasadena, California, are often the epicenter of NASA’s space world here on Earth, San Diego will get its moment in the moonlight when the Orion spacecraft ... Read more »

Norman Pattiz, media entrepreneur who founded radio network Westwood One, dies at 79

Norman Pattiz, a media entrepreneur who created the Westwood One radio network that brought rock concerts and personalities such as Larry King and Casey Kasem to millions of listeners, has ... Read more »

Evelyn, oldest Los Angeles Zoo gorilla, dead at 46

Evelyn, the oldest gorilla living at the Los Angeles Zoo, has died, zoo officials announced Wednesday. The 46-year-old western lowland gorilla known for her fluff of red hair was euthanized ... Read more »

Billingsley sentenced for role in U.S. capitol insurrection

Billingsley sentenced for role in U.S. capitol insurrection Steven Billingsley was officially sentenced Tuesday to 24 months of probation after appearing in court via video. Billingsley, the Richmond man charged ... Read more »

North Market tower, Grandview Crossing projects awarded transformational mixed-use tax credits from state

North Market tower, Grandview Crossing projects awarded transformational mixed-use tax credits from state COLUMBUS, Ohio (COLUMBUS BUSINESS FIRST) — The planned North Market tower, now dubbed The Merchant Building, and ... Read more »

‘They act like we have a reverse time button on the damn register’: Baskin Robbins worker shares customer pet peeve

‘They act like we have a reverse time button on the damn register’: Baskin Robbins worker shares customer pet peeve A Baskin Robbins employee shared a pet peeve they have ... Read more »

Felipe Drugovich exclusive: On Brazilian pressure, Fernando Alonso and Aston Martin role

Aston Martin’s Felipe Drugovich Felipe Drugovich said he is aware of the “pressure” of being the next Brazilian in Formula 1 but wants to use it as “motivation”. Of the ... Read more »

Peru Impeaches President Pedro Castillo After Threat to Dissolve Congress

President Pedro Castillo of Peru, whose administration had been hobbled by corruption charges, had survived two previous impeachment attempts. LIMA — Peru’s president was ousted from office on Wednesday after ... Read more »

Apple: Most iCloud data can now be end-to-end encrypted

Apple: Most iCloud data can now be end-to-end encrypted Apple has embarked on its latest privacy-enhancing move FILE – The Apple logo is illuminated at a store in the city ... Read more »

Fashion executive lists Newport Beach stunner for $47.5 million

Entrepreneur Mike Gray and his wife, Lori, are chasing rarified air in Newport Beach, listing their waterfront compound for $47.5 million. If they get their price, it’ll be among the ... Read more »

Prison system blunders led to Whitey Bulger’s killing, DOJ watchdog says

Inmates at a West Virginia prison were taking bets on how long mob boss James “Whitey” Bulger would survive after his transfer there, but key federal prison officials were oblivious ... Read more »

Ventura sailor returns home nearly 81 years after dying in Pearl Harbor attack

Nearly 81 years after the bombing of Pearl Harbor, the body of Navy ship fitter Claude Ralph Garcia returned home to Ventura County, bringing closure to a death that stunned ... Read more »

Viral indeed: Jenna Ortega had COVID while filming that kooky ‘Wednesday’ dance scene

Jenna Ortega’s showstopping dance number from Netflix series “Wednesday” has once again gone viral — and not in a good way. The standout moment from the popular show has come ... Read more »

Jan Gaye, second wife of Motown legend Marvin Gaye, is dead at 66

Janis Hunter Gaye, the second wife of Motown legend Marvin Gaye and mother of two of his children, has died, her family said in a statement. She was 66. Jan ... Read more »

U.S. World Cup games no match for NFL in TV ratings

In the latest unsurprising example of the NFL’s popularity and the gap that soccer has to close to catch up, NBC’s “Sunday Night Football” drew more viewers than either of ... Read more »

‘The Masked Singer’ was Kirstie Alley’s last TV gig. Here’s how it’s paying tribute

“The Masked Singer” will bid farewell to Kirstie Alley days after the “Cheers” actor died of colon cancer on Monday. The Times confirmed on Wednesday that the Emmy-winning singing competition ... Read more »

How to survive a renovation without destroying your relationship

Scroll through the discussion boards of the home and interior design website Houzz and you’ll uncover a piercing truth: Relationships and renovations clash like wall-to-wall carpeting and avocado kitchen tile. ... Read more »

Five companies will pay the feds $750 million for the opportunity to build huge floating wind turbines off the West Coast

The Biden administration’s first-ever offshore wind energy lease sale for federal waters off the West Coast generated more than $750 million, as energy companies competed for five areas that could ... Read more »

Rare 'Freezing Fog' Likely Leads to Massive Highway Pile Up

Stock image of highway accident with winter weather on car tires. A rare winter phenomenon possibly contributed to a 30-car crash involving a dozen semi-trucks on Wednesday in Washington state. ... Read more »

Former Colorado recruit puts Deion Sanders on blast

Deion Sanders told his Jackson State team that he’s going to Colorado. The drama surrounding Deion Sanders‘s hire at Colorado continues as we’ve seen some current players and incoming recruits ... Read more »

Brown University becomes first Ivy League school to ban 'caste oppression'

Brown University becomes first Ivy League school to ban ‘caste oppression’ Brown University has updated its nondiscrimination policy to prohibit “caste oppression” in a first for an Ivy League institution. ... Read more »

Simply Beverages hops on ‘perfect’ mimosa trend with new orange juice dropper

The juice brand's sweepstakes gives mimosa lovers a chance to win a 'perfectly simple cocktail' kit Read more »

Interior secretary: `Unacceptable' to mine near famed swamp

Interior secretary: `Unacceptable' to mine near famed swamp A member of President Joe Biden's Cabinet is urging Georgia officials to deny permits for a proposed mine near the edge of ... Read more »

Review: Lonely souls at the cinema in ‘Empire of Light’

Review: Lonely souls at the cinema in ‘Empire of Light’ Olivia Colman plays the manager of a movie theater in Sam Mendes’ new film “Empire of Light.” This image released ... Read more »

Dallas Landmark Mockingbird Station Up For Sale

Steve Brown, Dallas Morning News Dallas’ first transit-oriented development is up for grabs. Opened in 2001, Mockingbird Station is next door to a Dallas Area Rapid Transit rail station and ... Read more »

27 flee plane in Spain after pregnant woman simulates labor

27 flee plane in Spain after pregnant woman simulates labor Spanish police are searching for 14 people who ran from a plane at Barcelona’s airport after it made an emergency ... Read more »

Many Americans believe inflation, the economy won’t improve in 2023: poll — Here's how to manage your finances

Inflation remains high as the Fed continues to raise interest rates Read more »

FBI involvement in Twitter censoring of Hunter Biden laptop story downplayed: ‘How deep’ did ‘collusion’ go?

Sen. Marsha Blackburn questions collusion between FBI and social media in the Hunter Biden story Read more »

Texas subpoenas BlackRock for documents related to ESG push

A Texas lawmaker tells FOX Business the state will not allow financial institutions to 'continue to use Texans’ money to force a narrow political agenda' Read more »

Llegaron los avatares a WhatsApp, conozca como puede usarlos

WhatsApp está liberando esta función para sus usuarios Los personajes personalizables que están disponibles en los servicios Meta llega a Whatsapp. Los avatares, los personajes personalizables que ya están disponibles ... Read more »

Ronaldo Kirim Pesan Menyentuh Usai Portugal Gasak Swiss, CR7: Penampilan Berkelas

TRIBUN-SULBAR.COM – Bintang tim nasional (timnas) Portugal, Ronaldo sampaikan pesan usai dirinya menghangatkan bangku cadangan di laga duel melawan Swiss pada babak 16 besar Piala Dunia 2022. Dilansir oleh Instagram ... Read more »

Gempa Terkini Guncang Jawa Timur Rabu Sore, BMKG: Pusat Guncangan di Laut

TRIBUNMANADO.CO.ID – Info gempa bumi di wilayah Jawa Timur, Rabu (7/12/2022) pada pukul 15:57 WIB, sore. BMKG mencatat, gempa berkekuatan magnitudo 3,8 dengan titik pusat guncangan di laut, 282 km ... Read more »

Hombre en EEUU acusado de liderar secta y tener 20 esposas

Samuel Bateman, líder de un pequeño grupo polígamo en la frontera entre Utah y Arizona, acusado de abuso infantil. Foto sin fecha proveída por la Policía del condado Coconino. (Policía ... Read more »

Who is Raphael Warnock? What to know about the Georgia Democrat reelected Tuesday

Sen. Raphael Warnock won the Georgia runoff election Tuesday, defeating Republican challenger Herschel Walker to retain his seat. Neither Warnock nor Walker received more than half of the vote needed to win the race on Nov. 8, ... Read more »

This Location Tops the List for Best Housing Market of 2023

Modern custom new England colonial home with an American flag on a sunny day With the new year less than a month away, many of us are looking ahead to ... Read more »

'They may dig their own grave': Conservative explains how 'wacky investigations' could doom House GOP in 2023

Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio speaking at the 2018 Conservative Political Action Conference in National Harbor, Maryland During the 2022 midterms, countless Democrats warned that if Republicans obtained a majority ... Read more »

BORSA ULTIME NOTIZIE: Btp superstar, spread a 180 punti. Biden dà la scossa al Made in Usa

Il presidente Joe Biden Oscilla attorno alla parità Piazza Affari, isola di attività nel cuore di Milano che festeggia il lungo ponte di Sant’Ambrogio facendo shopping di Btp. Poco messi ... Read more »

Justice Department subpoenas Maricopa County for communications with Trump, allies

Maricopa County Board of Supervisors Vice Chairman Clint Hickman holds up a claim about the 2020 general election made by Senate Republican contractor Cyber Ninjas during a hearing before the ... Read more »

Report: Bayern Munich interested in €30m French striker

Report: Bayern Munich interested in €30m French striker There still has not been a like for like replacement for Robert Lewandowski at Bayern Munich, though the club’s front office has ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network