Green funds might be saving the world – but here’s why they’re failing investors

green funds might be saving the world – but here’s why they’re failing investors

Wind turbine green ethical funds

The majority of professional “green” investors are falling behind the stock market this year, as sustainable funds fail to protect investors’ money from volatility.

Over three-quarters of sustainable funds failed to beat their benchmarks, according to the data provider Morningstar. It found that the proportion of lagging sustainable funds has been steadily increasing since the pandemic: a third underperformed in 2020, rising to 45pc in 2021, and 79pc in the year to date.

The worst performer this year was the Baillie Gifford Health Innovation fund, which invests in global health companies. It has fallen 24 percentage points behind its benchmark, the MSCI World Health Care Index.

The L&G Future World Sustainable and the EdenTree Responsible & Sustainable UK Equity funds ranked second and third in the table of worst performers, falling 23 percentage points and 21 percentage points respectively behind their benchmarks.

A spokesman for Baillie Gifford said that the fund had suffered from a market-wide move away from expensive fast-growing stocks that featured heavily in its portfolio. “We ask investors to judge us over a five and preferably 10-year period,” the spokesman said.

“At the moment, we are seeing a marked dislocation between share price and corporate progress of many growth stocks. At some stage this will change, and valuations will again begin to reflect the worth of exceptional growth businesses.”

A spokesman for EdenTree said: “We remain focused on investing sustainably and responsibly.”

A spokesman for L&G said its fund has been “challenged during this part of the cycle by the current market volatility. A considerable part of this has been driven from our asset allocation, away from energy, commodities and tobacco, areas we typically avoid.”

He added: “We continue to believe there is still significant long-term potential for the fund and our investors.”

Fund house Columbia Threadneedle had the highest number of underperforming green funds in the year to date, with 10 failing to match their benchmarks.

The worst performer among them was the Columbia Threadneedle Responsible UK Equity fund, which has lost investors a tenth of their money so far this year, while the FTSE All Share, which tracks all the companies listed on the main market in London, has dropped by just 3pc. A spokesman for the firm said: “While some of our funds have underperformed so far this year, we have an absolute belief in our ability to add value for clients.”

Boya Wang, of Morningstar, said that while the market rotation away from growth stocks this year was partly responsible for poor performance, structural issues in the industry have made it increasingly difficult for fund managers to outperform.

“The definition of environmental, social and governance continues to change,” he said. “Just a few years ago, sustainable investing was a relatively new concept and there was much less competition.

“Now there are more green funds, managers are trying to find new ways to differentiate themselves. For example, a few years ago a green fund manager might exclude a company from their portfolio because it was too carbon intensive.

“But investors are realising that some of the major contributors to climate change mitigation come from the energy companies themselves. And some of the technology to combat climate change can be very carbon intensive, such as the manufacturing process for wind turbines, but some green investors are willing to accept them because their potential contribution is huge.”

The number of funds going green is also growing at pace, as managers seek new ways to justify higher fees to cost-conscious DIY investors. Just three funds rebranded as sustainable in 2019, but this spiked to 24 in 2020 and 22 in 2021. The industry is on track to match this figure this year, with no fewer than 11 investment funds rebranding as green or taking on a sustainable mandate in the first half of 2022.

Sign up to the Front Page newsletter for free: Your essential guide to the day’s agenda from The Telegraph – direct to your inbox seven days a week.

News Related


Malaysia PM orders misconduct probe into former attorney-general

Former Malaysian Deputy Prime Minister Ismail Sabri Yaakob waves to members of the media before departing for a meeting with the King, in Kuala Lumpur KUALA LUMPUR (Reuters) – Malaysian ... Read more »

P&O Ferries reaches settlement with last seafarer after mass dismissal

John Lansdown has reached a settlement with P&O Ferries. The last remaining seafarer to reach a settlement with P&O Ferries claims they admitted he was unfairly dismissed. John Lansdown, of ... Read more »

As Tory conference looms, the PM cuts a diminished figure after squandering much of her political capital

The PM seems to be gradually willing to publicly accept a link between her policies and market turmoil - describing this overnight as "short-term disruption" - but there is no sign she is considering reversing any of the measures. Read more »

DWP winter cost of living boost as extra £421million put into Household Support Fund

Homes in serious need can apply to the Household Support Fund Thousands of hard-up homes can apply for financial help from their council as the government is putting another £421million ... Read more »

Family of Briton, 52, found hanged in Qatar after 'being tortured by secret police' says England's World Cup stars should be 'very worried' about travelling to the 'barbaric regime'

Marc Bennett, 52, was found hanged by a receptionist on Christmas Day in 2019  Was labelled suicide by authorities but a court said was no sufficient evidence  He had resigned from Qatar Airways and considered a job with a rival Saudi firm Widow Nancy Bennett, 51, said the regime's suicide claims 'didn't make sense'  Read more »

Our portfolio has taken a hit – but here's how we've protected the income

Stocks Our Income Portfolio’s capital value has taken a pounding from the recent crisis in the financial markets. Its ability to generate income, fortunately, has not. The damage to capital has ... Read more »

ALEX BRUMMER: The data shows the UK is no ‘sick man of Europe’ after ONS says the country is NOT in a recession

Just over a week ago those doomsters at the Bank of England declared that the economy was in recession. Always alert to a negative headline to exploit, much of the ... Read more »

The fun police: Pub landlord is given noise warning by busybody council killjoys because his punters were LAUGHING too loudly

Richard Nattriss was issued a noise abatement order after locals complained He is putting the bins out later and spending £10,000 on soundproofingThe news comes as boozers are closing earlier to buckle their energy bills Read more »

Hundreds of students will be unable to get to college due to Stagecoach bus cuts

Hundreds of students are expected to be impacted by bus cuts being made by Stagecoach as two local sixth form colleges have revealed there students will be unable to get ... Read more »

Liz Truss has just TWO WEEKS to convince Tories to back her tax-cutting plans or she risks a rebellion in the Commons, MPs warn

Tories warned Liz Truss she has just two weeks to get them to back her tax cutsSome backbenchers considering voting down parts of Finance Bill to block plansEx-minister said Truss is 'finished' with 'lots' of letters calling for confidence voteEven allies of the PM say Government must improve how it communicates policy  Read more »

Stacey Solomon's energy bill 'might be beyond our means' if it doubles

Stacey Solomon has expressed her concerns about surging energy bills amid the country’s cost-of-living crisis. Currently the cost of living is rising at the fastest pace in 30 years leaving ... Read more »

Six money saving tips Martin Lewis says to do ahead of winter

Martin Lewis urged Brits to submit their meter reading this week ahead of the upcoming price cap on October 1. The Money Saving Expert took to Twitter with the “#MeterReadingWeek” ... Read more »

Drivers warned of heating car as it can 'shorten life of your engine' and waste fuel

With temperatures starting to fall and the winter months approaching, drivers are preparing for cold mornings spent heating up their car. From clearing frost and ice off the windscreen to ... Read more »

What happens with energy bills from October if you are on a fixed rate tariff

The new Energy Price Guarantee comes into effect from October, increasing our gas and electricity bills but by less than if the Ofgem price cap increase had gone ahead. An ... Read more »

Tesco to face questions over consumer demand concerns despite ‘rise in sales’

Tesco is expected to reveal higher sales over the first half of the year despite pressure on consumer budgets. The grocery giant is among the retailers facing huge pressure from ... Read more »

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Don’t be turkeys, Tories – stick with Liz Truss

When Liz Truss was crowned Tory leader just 26 days ago, the annual party conference was meant to be a victory parade. But instead of burnishing her credentials with the ... Read more »

Potential blow for Man Utd as target now convinced he's moving elsewhere; Reds had made contact

Ruben Neves, Wolves, Molineux, Premier League Manchester United are reportedly set to miss out on signing Wolves star Ruben Neves next summer, with Barcelona now looking like his most likely ... Read more »

Chainsaw sales soar as Brits buy 35,000 woodburners in three months to keep themselves warm during the energy crisis

Retail giant Toolstation revealed that sales have rocketed by a third recentlyThe news comes as people have been finding cheaper ways to heat their homesExperts warn the rise in woodburning could lead to higher pollution levels Read more »

Investment zone a massive opportunity for remarkable improvements for Plymouth

CLLR RICHARD BINGLEY IS THE LEADER OF PLYMOUTH CITY COUNCIL From my perspective, it was great news last week when our Ocean City was announced within the first wave of ... Read more »

Good news for pensioners as annuities soar by nearly 40% - ‘surrogate state pension'

It has been a difficult time recently for those looking to plan their retirement and achieve later life goals. However, there is a silver lining amongst the financial clouds in ... Read more »

Des Lynam blasts the BBC's decision to axe the classified football results on Radio 5 Live, calling it a ‘mistake’

The corporation has faced criticism since it stopped reading out the results BBC bosses axed it in place of a build-up to 5.30pm Premier League gamesLynam criticised: ‘it’s part of the heritage of the programme and the sport' Read more »

London Underground: Bakerloo line extension 'should be approved with £3bn budget'

South London council leaders have called on the government to start digging tunnels for the proposed Bakerloo line extension. Mayor of Lewisham, Damien Egan, and Southwark Council leader Kieron Williams, ... Read more »

Eels star Shaun Lane vows to win premiership ring for his mate Kurt Drysdale who suffered a CATASTROPHIC spinal injury in rugby league tackle gone wrong

Kurt Drysdale injured his spine when playing footy for Cabramatta back in 2015 He is unlikely to ever walk again, grew up best mates with Eels star Shaun Lane Lane is determined to beat Panthers so Drysdale can wear his premiership ring Read more »

Cannabis is just as harmful as cocaine and crack and should be classified as a Class A drug, police chiefs say

Police chiefs say cannabis is as harmful as cocaine and should be made Class ATory police and crime commissioners to demand it be put on a par with crackChange would see penalties for possession increase from five to seven yearsMaximum penalty for supplying cannabis would be a life jail sentence Read more »

Experts grow trees resistant to Dutch elm disease as part of plans to repopulate the countryside after 100million were wiped out by killer fungus

100 million elms were wiped out in the 1960s and 1970s by Dutch elm diseaseThe killer fungus, spread by beetles changed the UK's countryside landscape Scientists and landowners from the across the UK, Netherlands and Spain gathered at Kew Gardens in June to devise a strategy for the elm comeback Read more »

How to dry clothes indoors this winter without a dryer: 10 expert tips and tricks

null Knowing how to dry clothes indoors is all the more important during the colder months as laundry can quickly become damp if it’s left for too long in cool ... Read more »

81,000 carers could receive an extra £245 payment before Christmas - are you eligible?

Thousands of Carer’s Allowance Supplement payments were made in June and the next one is due in December. This year’s supplement payments are worth £245.70 each and the latest figures ... Read more »

Martin Lewis issues new warning as benefit payments boost could be scrapped

Martin Lewis has expressed concern as ministers refuse to confirm whether or not they’ll raise benefits to match inflation Martin Lewis has said he is “very concerned” after ministers refused ... Read more »

Inside the Aussie celebrity 'Burn Book': Anonymous TV host leaks list of the most difficult stars to deal with behind the scenes

A Reddit ‘ask me anything’ thread has become the talk of the celebrity scene, after an anonymous former TV presenter spilled the beans on the best and worst stars he ... Read more »

Bindi Irwin and her husband Chandler Powell share sweet footage of daughter Grace 'doing some maintenance' at Australia Zoo

Bindi Irwin and her husband Chandler Powell have shared an adorable video of their daughter Grace Warrior ‘working’ at Australia Zoo. The 24-year-old wildlife conservationist, who is the daughter of ... Read more »

Video: Hurricane Ian transformed a laid-back paradise island into a rubble-strewn ghost town: Survivors of tight-knit beachfront community, including famed TV storm chaser, were ferried to safety

Read more »

Prisoners in Scotland are given 660 games consoles in a £100,000 cost dubbed an 'insult to victims'

Inmates of Scottish jails have been bought games consoles, data request revealsMore than 660 consoles have been bought for criminals for more than £100,000Prison bosses say cash is 'directly' from prisoners - via taxpayer-funded 'wages'  Tory community safety spokesman Russell Findlay called it 'an insult to victims'  Read more »

Gabriel Jesus is in the ‘right place’ to book place in Brazil’s World Cup squad, says Mikel Arteta

jesus.jpg Mikel Arteta says Gabriel Jesus knows he is in “the right place” to force his way into Brazil’s World Cup squad and believes Arsenal will see the benefit of ... Read more »

Ex-private school girls start a TikTok trend revealing the 'heinous' strict rules they had to follow with jewellery banned, skirt lengths measured and detentions for not wearing their blazers

Former private school girls have opened up on their experience at their school Claire Champion, 22, racked up more than half a million views on her videoIn it, she explained some of the bizarre uniform rules the pupils had to follow Read more »

Granit Xhaka's 'niche' role explained ahead of North London Derby amid Mikel Arteta decision

Granit Xhaka of Arsenal applauds the Arsenal fans after the Premier League match between Brentford FC and Arsenal FC at Brentford Community Stadium on September 18, 2022 in Brentford, United ... Read more »

Political leaders and actors among those set to take part in Irish unity rally

Cold Feet star Jimmy Nesbitt will deliver the keynote address at the Ireland’s Future event in Dublin. Read more »

Teenager jumped and stamped on a defenceless man’s head in violent attack

Jamie Knowles’ previous convictions include robbery, affray, and possession of a knife A teenager jumped and stamped on a defenceless man’s head while leaving his wife lying on the floor ... Read more »

Woman assaulted while walking her dog near River Severn

Police want to speak to this man A woman was hurt after she was assaulted while walking her dog near the River Severn. The victim was on a river path ... Read more »

Brother of NRL star who swindled $5,000 in flood relief payments and bragged about having 'the gift of the gab' learns his fate after he was caught

Drew Reynolds fined $5000 for fraudulent flood disaster relief payments Reynolds is the brother of ex-NRL star and state of origin player Josh Reynolds He made five fraudulent Centrelink claims impersonating friends and family  Reynolds co-conspirators Aaron and William Sowter were also sentenced Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network