Grafton Street shop wants €500,000 rent cut over Covid closure

Asia's Tech News Daily

The operator of a Grafton Street footwear and clothing store is asking the High Court to declare it has no liability for more than €500,000 in rent during 253 days of pandemic-ordered closures.

The Foot Locker store accepts the rent was only part paid to its landlord Percy Nominees Ltd for the lockdown days, but says the landlord should share some of the pain caused by the closures.

It claims the store is still suffering from low footfall and is now trading in a very poor location.

Foot Locker Retail Ireland Ltd seeks a declaration that, by reason of the government-

ordered lockdown, it has been unable to trade from Grafton Street and therefore the lease between it and the landlord has been partially frustrated.

The rent on the store is €750,000 per year and Foot Locker only paid part of the rent during the lockdown.

Percy Nominees says it is “nothing more than a transparent and ill-judged attempt to unilaterally renegotiate the terms of the lease for the commercial benefit of Foot Locker”.

Percy Nominees contends Foot Locker is obligated to pay rent in accordance with the terms of the lease. It is dependent on the rent roll from Grafton Street and other premises it leases to support its business operations and discharge its liabilities

Yesterday, John Lowry, Foot Locker Retail Ireland real estate director, told his counsel, Gavin Ralston SC, the number of days the store was directed to close by the Government was 243. The rent in dispute was just over €519,000, he said.

Under cross examination, Aidan Redmond SC asked Mr Lowry if a statement he made for this case about the lease having been frustrated meant it was at an end, witness replied it had been “temporarily frustrated”.

Asked why Foot Locker offered part payment during the pandemic, he said he was attempting to come to some agreement with Percy Nominees as Foot Locker had done with every other landlord of its stores in Ireland. He accepted that by saying the lease had been frustrated that it conveyed the intention that Foot Locker would not trade from Grafton Street for the remainder of the lease, which lasts until 2025.

Mr Lowry said this was the position in June last year but now it does intend to trade until the end of the lease.

He said: “We are trading, albeit very badly”. It was not like it used to be and is “a very poor location”.

They were doing their best to trade but none of the high level of footfall and high-spending footfall envisaged by the Grafton Street location was there today, he said.

He agreed with counsel that none of those matters were relevant to the interpretation of the lease but “we believe the landlord should share some of the pain”.

Mr Justice Brian O’Moore said he would hear an application today from Foot Locker to amend its statement of claim to include a claim for unjust enrichment by Percy Nominees.

Get ahead of the day with the morning headlines at 7.30am and Fionnán Sheahan’s exclusive take on the day’s news every afternoon, with our free daily newsletter.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Steven Ward outlines Carl Frampton quality he learned most from

Steven Ward believes Carl Frampton’s humility outside the ring cemented the Jackal’s status as the people’s champion. Frampton retired from boxing back in April after winning world titles in two ... Read more »

Health dept to issue booster guidelines

Updated at 1:04 am THE Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved the administration of Covid-19 vaccine boosters to Filipino adults aged 18 years old and above. FDA Director General ... Read more »

Teenager Injured in Waukesha Christmas Parade Arrives Home From Hospital

A 16-year-old who was injured when a man drove an SUV into a Christmas parade in Waukesha, Wisconsin, returned home from hospital on November 30. At least six people were ... Read more »

Daniel Jones surprisingly practices amid neck injury confusion

Daniel Jones took the field for practice and his head coach, Joe Judge, called it “really a normal Wednesday for him.’’ Judge went on to say he expects Jones to ... Read more »

Best ski and snowboard goggles 2021: 8 top-reviewed options

NY Post It’s hard to believe that it’s been almost two years since the ongoing coronavirus pandemic has changed all of our lives. With so much time at home and ... Read more »

Stephen A. Smith melted down after Knicks' brutal loss to Nets

Stephen A. Smith’s reaction to the Knicks’ Tuesday night loss to the Nets was priceless. The ESPN personality screamed in frustration in a Twitter video he shared moments after Brooklyn’s ... Read more »

Visa CEO: COVID caused permanent shift to digital payments

The Associated PressFILE – Visa CEO Al Kelly speaks on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, Thursday, Oct. 25, 2018. Kelly said he believes the pandemic caused a ... Read more »

Liam Gallagher: ‘I'm jealous' of Oasis cover band trapped in pub due to snow

Cover bands get no respect — except when it comes to Noasis, the Oasis cover band who found themselves stuck in a pub for three nights last week during a ... Read more »

Unions ready to call strike at Telecom Italia

© Reuters/YARA NARDI FILE PHOTO: The Tim logo is seen at its headquarters MILAN (Reuters) – Italy’s telecommunications unions are preparing to call a strike at Telecom Italia (TIM) amid ... Read more »

Conan Byrne set to embark on his latest charity event to raise funds for Make-A-Wish Ireland

CONAN BYRNE’S UPCOMING – and latest – fundraising effort is sure to be a good one. The former League of Ireland star has teamed up with Shelbourne goalkeeper Brendan Clarke ... Read more »

Italian parliamentary panel accuses Egyptian security of Regeni murder

© Reuters/SIMON DAWSON FILE PHOTO: Demonstrators from Amnesty International hold placards outside the Egyptian embassy in support of Giulio Regeni, who was found murdered in Cairo two years ago, in ... Read more »

Natasha Thahane: I didn't get R1mil & don't have a relationship with Mam'Baleka

© Natasha Thahane. @Natasha_Thahane/Twitter JOHANNESBURG – South African actor Natasha Thahane has clarified what she said were words taken out of context during an interview, which had landed her ... Read more »

Exclusive: Jessica Wright reveals surprising plans for wedding dress

© Provided by Hello! jessica-wright-outfit Jessica Wright has had quite the year! The brunette beauty not only got married to William Lee-Kemp in September, but she has just announced she ... Read more »

FIFA 22 TOTW 11 leaks with Virgil van Dijk and Bukayo Saka and rumoured to be included

Liverpool’s Virgil van Dijk is rumoured to be included in this week’s FIFA 22 Team of the Week (TOTW 11). The FIFA 22 TOTW will be revealed and released into ... Read more »

EastEnders' Ricky Champ's forgotten previous role, stunning home and lookalike daughter

EastEnders hard-man Stuart Highway is set to be rocked by a shock health condition in upcoming scenes on the soap. After spotting a rash on his body, Stuart heads to ... Read more »

2021 LiveWire ONE First Ride Review: Lightning Strikes Twice

2021 LiveWire ONE – Mounted 2021 LiveWire ONE – Dash 2021 LiveWire ONE – Rear, Left 2021 LiveWire ONE – Underpass 2021 LiveWire ONE – Front Wheel 2021 LiveWire ONE ... Read more »

Stay 'Sharp' this festive season: SAB launches responsible drinking platform

©… © peterbraakmann/ CAPE TOWN – South African Breweries (SAB) on Wednesday launched Sharp, a platform committed to championing the responsible consumption of alcohol by rallying South Africans to ... Read more »

Tesla Model Y Takes Home Norway's COTY People's Favorite Award

© Copyright Tesla Model Y (Bildquelle: “Press-Kit” Remember when Tesla CEO Elon Musk said the Model Y would be Tesla’s most popular EV? Norway is the EV capital ... Read more »

Review: Leaving the Children of God 'sex cult'

The Associated PressThis cover image released by William Morrow shows “Sex Cult Nun: Breaking Away from the Children of God, a Wild, Radical Religious Cult” by Faith Jones. (William Morrow ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity star ‘tried to escape camp five times and was held back by crew' after starving on rice and beans diet

EX I'm A Celebrity star Mark Wright has revealed he “tried to escape the camp five times” but was “held back by crew”. The presenter dished on his “horrendous” experience ... Read more »

Here's Why Hawkeye's Recognizable Costume Is So Important

Marvel/Disney+ Marvel’s latest Disney+ series, “Hawkeye,” is already three episodes deep and has given plenty of material in the form of Easter eggs and world-building for fans to muse over. ... Read more »

Discovery pushing to get remaining 500 unvaxxed staffers 'across finish line'

© Provided by 702 There’s only one month left until Discovery gives effect to its mandatory vaccination policy Discovery was one of the first major companies in SA to announce ... Read more »

Europe: Plug-In Cars Continue To Expand Market Share In October 2021

© InsideEVs Renault ZOE in the UK So far this year, almost 18% of new cars in Europe are rechargeable (23% in October). The number of new passenger car registrations ... Read more »

Trevor Noah To Host 2022 GRAMMYs

© Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for The Recording Academy Trevor Noah is returning to the GRAMMYs! On Wednesday, the Recording Academy and CBS announced that the comedian, who hosted the 2021 ... Read more »

Love Island star Teddy left red-faced after exposing himself to 3,000 people in major ‘blunder' on The Real Full Monty

LOVE Island star Teddy Soares signed up to strip off for charity – but he got more than he bargained for in front of a 3,000-strong crowd. The 26-year-old was convinced ... Read more »

Keanu Reeves says 'The Matrix: Resurrections' cast and crew 'barely rehearsed, if at all' on set

© Provided by INSIDER Carrie-Ann Moss and Keanu Reeves in “The Matrix: Resurrections.” Warner Bros. Keanu Reeves told Entertainment Weekly “The Matrix: Resurrections” team “barely rehearsed.” Reeves compared the filming ... Read more »

The best Sky deals you can get in December 2021

GETTING a good TV deal can be a tedious process, as there is a baffling array of offers available in the UK. But if you're looking for one of the ... Read more »

Ben&Ben raises importance of mental health in 'Lunod'

It doesn’t always have to be sink or swim when it comes to mental health. Ben&Ben chronicle the experience of drowning in torrential distress and anxiety on the music video ... Read more »

Free Universal Credit and benefits calculators work out how much you should get

HOUSEHOLDS who claim Universal Credit and other benefits can use free online calculators to work out how much money they should get. Millions of Brits will get an extra £1,000 ... Read more »

Handre Pollard set to become a Tiger

© PA Images Handre Pollard – PA A number of reports suggest that South Africa fly-half Handre Pollard is set to join Leicester Tigers when his contract with Montpellier ends ... Read more »

I found ‘biggest SECRET iPhone hack' that makes it way easier to find your favourite photos

YOUR iPhone photos are always at your fingertips – but finding your favourite snaps can be tricky. Thankfully, a TikTok fan has showcased a quick and easy way to organise ... Read more »

Kyle Rittenhouse says AR-15 he used in Kenosha riots is ‘being destroyed'

Kyle Rittenhouse is destroying the AR-15 he used during his deadly shooting in Kenosha, Wisconsin. The 18-year-old cleared gunman told “The Charlie Kirk Show” on Tuesday that the weapon he ... Read more »

Kevin Bridges 2022 Tour: How to get tickets to The Overdue Catch-up

KEVIN Bridges has announced a 2022 tour and here's how you can get your hands on tickets. The Overdue Catch Up tour will take place next year, and we can't ... Read more »

General Motors announces it will build a new cathode plant in North America

General Motors announced that it will construct a new cathode factory in North America for its electric vehicle batteries. The factory, which will be built under a joint venture with ... Read more »

Michigan school shooter fired with ‘intent to kill,' sheriff says

The Michigan teenager accused of killing three students and wounding eight others at his high school “came out with the intent to kill,” the local sheriff said on Wednesday. “The ... Read more »

Malala Yousafzai Fast Facts

© Christopher Furlong/Getty Images/File Here’s a look at the life of education activist and Nobel Peace Prize recipient, Malala Yousafzai. Personal Birth date: July 12, 1997 Birth place: Mingora, Swat ... Read more »

Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr Pay Tribute to George Harrison 20 Years After His Death: 'Miss You Man'

© Provided by People Express/Getty George Harrison, Ringo Starr and Paul McCartney Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr are paying tribute to their late bandmate George Harrison on the 20th anniversary ... Read more »

Russia says Ukraine has deployed half its army – 125,000 troops – to conflict zone

© REUTERS A militant of the self-proclaimed Donetsk People’s Republic (DNR) watches from a frontline position outside the rebel-controlled city – Reuters Russia has accused Ukraine of deploying half its ... Read more »

N.B. COVID-19 roundup: 4th wave 'cresting,' says Higgs

© Ed Hunter/CBC Premier Blaine Higgs says New Brunswick’s COVID-19 cases are ‘levelling off,’ but he doesn’t see an end to the pandemic ‘anytime soon.’ Premier Blaine Higgs says the fourth ... Read more »

Follow These Stars' Tips to Staying Fit After 50

Let’s be real: with every birthday, it gets easier to be discouraged and compare yourself—and more pointedly, your physique—to your younger self. And while you can make every excuse in ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic