GP did clinically unnecessary breast exams

GP did clinically unnecessary breast exams

A Sydney doctor carried out unnecessary breast examinations on two women, pulling at their nipples and making the demeaning comment “bunch of grapes” to one patient, a tribunal has found.

Tharumalingam Sinnathurai also breached Sexual Boundaries Guidelines by saying “you wouldn't want to get fat”, suggesting a patient could spend money to buy a new dress and commenting how unattractive women are to men if they get drunk.

The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal on Thursday found him guilty of unsatisfactory professional conduct and professional misconduct but will impose a penalty on a later date.

It found he was not motivated by sexual gratification, but had breached sexual boundaries in several respects.

He carried out unnecessary breast and abdominal examinations on two patients, aged 18 and 28, while working as a GP in a medical centre in Merrylands in 2019.

“If his motivation was to properly care for his patients, then he should have armed himself with the clinical knowledge and expertise necessary for him to do so,” the tribunal said.

“Even if these examinations had been justified, he performed them in an arrogant and insensitive manner.”

The highly trained and experienced Sinnathurai was aged 71 at the time of the June hearing of complaints brought by the Health Care Complaints Commission,

The teenager, who wanted to renew her prescription for the pill, was told if she used a cheaper brand she could use the money to buy a dress or something.

He also said: “You wouldn't want to get fat. I recommend to all my patients, no sugar, bread or potatoes and you will be slimmer. Your weight will change but I expect that you will lose weight when you come for your next visit.”

The third inappropriate comment related to no man liking a drunk woman.

“Making three sexual remarks to Patient A during the consultation constitutes a pattern of behaviour,” the tribunal said, noting it exploited the power imbalance between doctor and patient.

He also inappropriately examined the woman's torso for acne, inappropriately conducted breast and abdominal examinations, and even if they had been appropriate did not obtain her informed consent.

He had massaged the patient's breasts with both his hands and pulled her nipples upwards, saying words to the effect of “it's like holding a bunch of grapes”.

“There is no clinical reason to manipulate a patient's breast in that way,” the tribunal said.

“We are satisfied that Dr Sinnathurai did so while demonstrating his point about the breasts of pregnant women looking like a bunch of grapes. Patient A was not pregnant.”

The second patient had wanted a blood test to confirm she was pregnant, but was also subject to the two unnecessary examinations.

The tribunal found Sinnathurai inappropriately squeezed and twisted each of her breasts and squeezed her nipples hard.

“The abdominal examinations of Patient A and Patient B are more serious because they involved pulling down the patients' clothing, in one case exposing pubic hair, and carrying out an unnecessary physical examination without consent.”

The tribunal found no mitigating factors.

“Dr Sinnathurai partially undressed and dressed these patients and did not offer a chaperone or even give them a sheet to cover themselves.

“While not meeting the definition of 'sexual abuse or exploitation' or 'sexual assault', which are at the highest end of the spectrum, these examinations involved a very significant departure from the standards of ethical practice.”.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

World shares at one-month low

World shares have skidded and the US dollar has firmed ahead of a week packed with global central bank meetings, while debt troubles at property group China Evergrande dragged Hong ... Read more »

NSW barking dogs murder accused acquitted

A young man who fatally shot his ice-fuelled neighbour wielding a pickaxe handle acted “reasonably” in self-defence and has been found not guilty of murder. Justice Stephen Rothman also found ... Read more »

Hot computer led Yarra Trams to IT thief

A former Yarra Trams worker who stole IT gear worth $230,000 got caught when a computer overheated, a court has heard. Paul Hewer, 36, worked in Yarra Trams' IT department ... Read more »

WA bushfire a threat to lives and homes

A bushfire burning southwest of Broome in Western Australia is a threat to lives and homes in the area, Emergency WA says. The blaze is burning out of control in ... Read more »

Coroner slams Vic police pursuit policy

Raymond Noel Thomas was driving to the shops to buy chocolate in the Melbourne suburb of Northcote in June 2017 when police in a patrol vehicle saw he was driving ... Read more »

No more whole classes home in primary education if one child is infected

The GGD looks together with the parents of an infected child with whom there has been close contact. If there are several corona cases in one group, the GGD can ... Read more »

Gomarus schools investigated by the Public Prosecution Service for discrimination on grounds of orientation

According to a spokesperson for the Inspectorate, the school group had established that schools would enter into discussions with parents of students who have a homosexual relationship. This does not ... Read more »

Palm oil price rise threatens with extension of ban on new palm oil plantations

According to experts, an extension of the ban on new palm oil plantations could cause prices to rise further. The price of palm oil has already risen enormously this year. ... Read more »

‘Moderate to very poor maintenance of tens of thousands of housing association homes'

Of the more than 2 million social rental homes in the Netherlands, at least 80,000 are moderately to very poorly maintained. This is the conclusion of RTL Nieuws based on ... Read more »

Criminal investigation into sexual orientation discrimination in Gomarus schools

The Public Prosecution Service has launched a criminal investigation into the reformed school community Gomarus. The Education Inspectorate has reported that students would be discriminated against because of their sexual ... Read more »

Pedagogical Professional of the Year winners are known

The Pedagogical Professional of the Year 2021 was announced on Thursday by initiators Pedagogical Professionals in Childcare (PPINK) and the trade journal Childcare. The winners are Denise Rondeel of Tante ... Read more »

Work pressure high in childcare, quarter of employees are considering quitting

The survey shows that a third of healthcare workers were able to take less time off. In branches where an annual hours system is used, such as in childcare, hours ... Read more »

ROC Tilburg teacher Kirsten Cuppen nominated for ‘Global Teacher Prize'

Dutch teacher at the ROC Tilburg, Kirsten Cuppen, has been nominated for the Global Teacher Prize 2021. She is one of the fifty nominees for a chance to win one ... Read more »

VR glasses should make primary school students resilient against shame sexting

A new program is intended to make students from groups 7 and 8 resilient against shame-sexting. Shame-sexting is making or distributing sexually explicit photos or videos without permission. Ten percent ... Read more »

Research into special funding in primary and special education

Just like last year, the Inspectorate will also this year carry out an investigation into the lawful acquisition of special funding at some of the boards in primary and special ... Read more »

Fifty children kidnapped by parent during the summer holidays

Last year there were 34 kidnappings, the lowest number in five years. According to the International Child Abduction Center (IKO), this had to do with travel restrictions due to corona. ... Read more »

FNV vice-chairman: ‘We should not try to maintain all jobs'

Increasing waiting lists in healthcare, factories that have to refuse orders, restaurants that shorten their opening hours. For employers, the staff shortages are starting to hurt. But ask Zakaria Boufangacha, ... Read more »

Universities of applied sciences agree in principle for collective labor agreement 2021-2022

The Association of Universities of Applied Sciences and the trade unions in education – Aob, FNV, FvOv and CNV Education – have succeeded in agreeing an agreement in principle for ... Read more »

NHL Stenden Lector Nynke Boonstra nominated for Els Borst Award

On Thursday, September 16, Dr. Nynke Boonstra lecturer Care & Innovation in Psychiatry at NHL Stenden that her colleagues have nominated her for the Els Borst Award. The Award is ... Read more »

Students University of Twente successfully launch their first rocket

Students from the University of Twente launched their first rocket on a field in Baarlo on Sunday 12 September. With the launch, the students wanted to gain experience with their ... Read more »

A European school is Europe in miniature: ‘Multilingual and multicultural'

Suppose you are going to work for a European institution. The European Central Bank, for example, or the European Commission. Then your children can go to a European school. “European ... Read more »

absenteeism in childcare is rising fastest

Figures from Statistics Netherlands (CBS) show that absenteeism among childcare employees (6.9 percent) has risen fastest compared to last year. In the second quarter of 2021, absenteeism due to illness ... Read more »

Woman visits gynecologist for 9 years ‘who suddenly turns out to be her own father'

A New York state doctor is accused of using his own sperm to impregnate at least two female patients at his fertility clinic. One of his alleged children, Morgan Hellquist, ... Read more »

Equal Opportunity, Diversity and Inclusion

Today the Knowledge Point MBO Equal Opportunities, Diversity and Inclusion of the MBO Council launches its website. “Every citizen in the Netherlands must be given the opportunity to participate. That ... Read more »

The broadcast of September 16

Pieter Omtzigt is back in the political arena Pieter Omtzigt is back in the House of Representatives after four months of sick leave. When he went on leave, he was ... Read more »

school staff are more likely to bully LGBTI+ youth than heterosexuals

“It is the first study with nationally representative data on the experiences with bullying behavior of LGBT students in the Netherlands,” said researcher Tessa Kaufman. The researchers’ findings were recently ... Read more »

closure of schools least popular corona measure

Even though a large part of the Dutch have been vaccinated and the pressure on healthcare has decreased in recent months, the virus can erupt in full force again. RIVM ... Read more »

Digital higher education still vulnerable

The study ‘Inside without knocking – Digital resilience in higher education’ shows that, partly due to the incidents, digital security has become a topic of discussion among higher education boards. ... Read more »

European School The Hague is opened by Princess Laurentien

Princess Laurentien’s visit includes a tour of the school, meetings with students and an official ceremony where she will hand over the keys to the building to student representatives and ... Read more »

Scared at PSG about Kylian Mbappé

Mbappé had to be replaced shortly after the break in the Champions League match against Club Brugge (1-1) due to an ankle injury. “He sprained an ankle and he already ... Read more »

Podcast | ‘Umpteenth masterpiece by Erik ten Hag' | Champions League & Europa League

Ajax has started the new Champions League season convincingly. In Lisbon, Sporting won 1-5. Partly thanks to four goals from Sébastien Haller. In the AD Voetbalpodcast, reporter Maarten Wijffels and ... Read more »

Truck tax introduction by 2026 will cost twice as much

Trucks on Dutch highways will have to pay a charge per kilometer in the course of 2026. However, introducing such a truck tax will cost at least twice as much ... Read more »

More and more HBO lecturers are slightly decreasing in terms of salary.

According to the collective labor agreement, a pay scale is tailored to the tasks of employees. They get more pay for more difficult work. The salary differences between universities of ... Read more »

Central registration moment for secondary education: House of Representatives votes in favour

The bill regulates, among other things, that all group 8 students can register for secondary education at one central moment, in the week of 1 April. However, after any adjustments ... Read more »

Small party leaders ‘constructive' towards minority government

Many small parties will approach a minority government constructively. That is the common thread in the conversations that informateur Remkes had today with group leaders of smaller parties who supported ... Read more »

Further growth of children with dyslexia and dyscalculia; further research is required

What is Dyslexia? Dyslexia actually means ‘not being able to read’. It is the inability of not being able to understand letters, words and sentences. It is obvious that this ... Read more »

Action #PakJeSupply for students who are entitled to Individual Study Allowance

Some students are unable to have a side job next to their studies because of their limitations. There is therefore the Individual Study Allowance for these students. However: the amount ... Read more »

From now on, students from mboRijnland will learn to apply via a video of themselves

It is still too common for students to be rejected in their search for an internship on the basis of a letter of application. MBORijnland thinks that video applications will ... Read more »