Govt cites ‘lack of options' for making Asthana Delhi top cop

© Provided by The Times of India

NEW DELHI: Lack of suitable options in the AGMUT cadre of an officer with “appropriate seniority with balanced experience” to head Delhi Police led the Centre to appoint Gujarat-cadre IPS officer Rakesh Asthana in “public interest”, the Delhi high court was informed on Thursday.

The “prime consideration” was Delhi was “witnessing diverse and extremely challenging situations of public order, law and order situation and policing issues, which not only had national security implications, but also international/cross border implications”. This required an officer “with exposure to complexities of governance and who had the knowledge of nuances of broad canvas policing”, the government said.


In an affidavit filed through standing counsel Amit Mahajan, the Centre said no fault could be found in the appointment of Asthana as the city police commissioner that had been done in accordance with and after scrupulously following all applicable rules and regulations.

The Centre highlighted that the “best attempt of finding a suitable IPS officer having multifarious and diverse experience of policing in a vast state, central investigating agency, national security or paramilitary force” was made in the AGMUT cadre, but “it was found after thorough examination of available options that the experience of handling the police force” was not available.

“It was felt that requisite experience of working and supervising the central investigating agency/paramilitary force and police force of a large state having diverse political and law and order problems was lacking in the present pool of available officers,” the affidavit added.

Invoking “public interest”, the Centre said a decision was made to have an officer who had experience in all the above fields to supervise Delhi Police and to provide effective policing on the recent law and order situation that arose in the capital.

“Delhi being the capital of our country has its own characteristic factors that do not exist in any other commissionerate. Any incident happening here has far-reaching impact and implications not only throughout the country, but beyond the borders,” the affidavit contended.

It also differentiated between appointment of state DGPs according to the SC ruling in Prakash Singh case and appointment of the commissioner, adding that “requirement of a certain minimum tenure has no application for appointment of commissioners/police heads of Union Territories.”

The affidavit contended that the petition by Sadre Alam, a lawyer, challenging the appointment was an “abuse of process of law and manifestly an outcome of some personal vendetta”. It submitted that a PIL in service matter couldn’t be entertained. It added that the PIL, as well as intervention of NGO Centre for Public Interest Litigation in Asthana’s appointment, “deserves to be dismissed with exemplary costs”.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Saurashtra University cancels faculty recruitment after protests

© Provided by The Indian Express Hours after the National Students Union of India (NSUI) demonstrated outside the office of Saurashtra University (SU) vice-chancellor (V-C), alleging favouritism in recruitment for ... Read more »

A road well travelled: How my life as a journalist has changed

Dismantling a Soviet-era telephone took only a couple of minutes. The cheap plastic cover was easy to remove, and the rudimentary design made it easy to identify the two copper ... Read more »

17 Missionaries from the U.S. and Canada Have Been Kidnapped in Haiti, Ministry Says

Seventeen missionaries, including 16 Americans and one Canadian, have been kidnapped during a trip to an orphanage in Haiti, the Christian Aid Ministries says. © Provided by People Chandan Khanna/AFP ... Read more »

Impact of scams on well-being calculated as £9bn

© Getty Images Phone fraud has soared during the pandemic The cost to scam victims’ well-being can be calculated at a monetary total of £9.3bn a year, according to the ... Read more »

Pay later firm Klarna to offer 'pay now' option

© BBC Klarna has 10 million customers in the UK and was recently valued at £7.5bn The buy now, pay later firm Klarna is extending its services, including offering the ... Read more »

One shot dead, second injured on Bemiss Road

Oct. 17—VALDOSTA — A 21-year-old is dead and a 19-year-old is injured after a weekend shooting along the 2100 block of Bemiss Road, according to the Valdosta Police Department. Authorities ... Read more »

INEOS to invest $2.3 billion on green hydrogen production

© Reuters/Denis Balibouse FILE PHOTO: The logo of chemicals company INEOS pictured at its headquarters in Rolle, Switzerland (Reuters) – INEOS, Europe’s largest Hydrogen producer, said on Monday it would ... Read more »

Ally McCoist named Scotland captain for tennis' Battle of the Brits

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Jamie Murray has recruited football legend Ally McCoist to be the captain of the Scottish team in the ‘Battle of the Brits’ match ... Read more »

Pentagon, State Department square off on Afghanistan accountability

Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle say constant finger-pointing between the Pentagon and State Department is making it difficult to get a full accounting of the messy withdrawal from ... Read more »

New Zealand boosts climate aid ahead of Glasgow summit

New Zealand pledged Monday to quadruple foreign aid spending on climate change, addressing its “woefully inadequate” response to the challenge in recent decades. © Marty MELVILLE New Zealand’s existing climate ... Read more »

Christopher Steele, who created controversial Trump Russia dossier, speaks out

Former British intelligence officer Christopher Steele, the man behind the “Steele Dossier” that claimed Russian officials held compromising information on former President Donald Trump, defended the claims made in the ... Read more »

Stansted Airport hit by baggage system 'chaos'

© Chris Ratcliffe File photo: Passengers wait beneath information screens in the check-in area at London Stansted Airport, operated by Manchester Airport Plc, in Stansted, UK on Monday July 19 ... Read more »

College Football World Reacts To Dabo Swinney Speculation

© Provided by The Spun A closeup of Clemson football coach Dabo Swinney. Dabo Swinney, LSU Tigers head coach? Almost certainly not, but with the SEC program in need of ... Read more »

Seahawks inactives: These 6 players are out vs. Steelers

© Provided by Seahawks Wire The Seahawks get the privilege of playing under the lights this evening as they visit the Steelers. Neither team is 100% coming into this week, ... Read more »

Watch: Joe Mixon, Bengals use fan's phone for awesome selfie celebration

© Provided by Fansided The Cincinnati Bengals got to have some fun celebrating a touchdown during their win against the Detroit Lions. One Cincinnati Bengals fan got a unique souvenir ... Read more »

Look: Fans Are Furious With This Laughable Roughing The Passer

© Provided by The Spun Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray throws a pass against the Browns. Today was not a good day for the Cleveland Browns even before they got docked ... Read more »

NFL World Reacts To Tony Romo's Performance Today

© Provided by The Spun Tony Romo gets interviewed by NBC Sports after a golf tournament. Sunday afternoon’s game on CBS between the New England Patriots and the Dallas Cowboys ... Read more »

3 replacements Giants can hire for Joe Judge after blowout loss

© Provided by Fansided As head coach Joe Judge’s seat gets hotter, the New York Giants need to begin the search for his replacement. After a devastating 38-10 beat down ... Read more »

Cowboys Fans Have 1 Main Complaint On Sunday Night

© Provided by The Spun A closeup of a Dallas Cowboys football helmet. The Dallas Cowboys and the New England Patriots are locked in a tight battle on Sunday evening. ... Read more »

Prime Minister to lead tributes to murdered MP as family urge ‘set aside hatred'

The Prime Minister is set to lead tributes to Sir David Amess in the House of Commons on Monday after his family urged people to be tolerant and “set aside ... Read more »

Nun imprisoned over peace activism, Megan Rice, dies at 91

ROSEMONT, Penn. (AP) — Megan Rice, a nun and Catholic peace activist who spent two years in federal prison while in her 80s after breaking into a government security complex ... Read more »

Two men stabbed inside Melbourne shop

Two men have been taken to hospital after being stabbed by another man inside a Melbourne shopping centre. © Daniel Pockett/AAP PHOTOS A man is in custody after two men ... Read more »

Joe Biden breaks DC's mask mandate during date night dinner with Jill

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Joe and Jill Biden dined out in Washington DC on Saturday night for the first time since moving to the White House – ... Read more »

Pete Buttigieg Fires Back at Tucker Carlson After Paternity Leave Criticism: 'I'm Not Going to Apologize'

New father Pete Buttigieg has no time for the haters. © Provided by People Pete Buttigieg/Twitter The 39-year-old U.S. Transportation Secretary, who had been on paid paternity leave since August, ... Read more »

Bouncer shortage poses ‘threat to public safety', warn nightclubs

© PA Media Coronavirus – Mon Jun 14, 2021 Nightclubs are urgently calling for Government intervention to a worsening shortage of bouncers which industry bosses say could become a “threat ... Read more »

Love and Other Acts of Violence at the Donmar Warehouse review: Gripping but frustratingly shambolic

© Helen Murray Tom Mothersdale and Abigail Weinstock – Helen Murray There are three different plays struggling to get out of Cordelia Lynn’s somewhat bewildering 90-minute script titled Love and ... Read more »

Tens of thousands on waiting lists for safe space to store bikes, figures show

© Provided by Evening Standard A bike hangar on a north London residential street (Emily Beament/PA) Tens of thousands of city dwellers are on waiting lists for a safe place ... Read more »

Welsh Government pledges certainty for businesses facing volatile recovery

© PA Archive Coronavirus The Welsh Government will pursue a progressive economic policy that focusses on better jobs, narrowing the skills divide and tackling poverty, the economy minister will say. ... Read more »

Kane akhiri kemarau gol, penyokong pengsan warnai aksi di Newcastle

© Provided by Sinar Harian KAPTEN Tottenham Hotspur, Harry Kane mengakhiri kemarau jaringan liga musim ini apabila membantu kelabnya melakar kemenangan 3-2 ke atas Newcastle United di Stadium St James’ ... Read more »

Tandukan padu Ogbonna tumbangkan Everton

© Provided by Sinar Harian TANDUKAN padu Angelo Ogbonna sudah cukup membolehkan West Ham United membawa pulang tiga mata apabila melakar kemenangan 1-0 ke atas Everton ketika mengadakan kunjungan ke ... Read more »

Perkukuh kekuatan mental, psikologi

© Provided by Sinar Harian PERSATUAN Badminton Malaysia (BAM) perlu memikirkan cara untuk mengukuhkan kekuatan mental dan psikologi sebelum seseorang pemain menyertai kejohanan besar pada masa depan. Bekas Pengarah Prestasi ... Read more »

MKT UMNO belum buat ketetapan mengenai kerjasama dengan PN

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Majlis Kerja Tertinggi (MKT) UMNO belum membuat ketetapan mengenai kerjasama untuk menghadapi Pilihan Raya Negeri (PRN) Melaka dengan Perikatan Nasional (PN). Ahli ... Read more »

Gandhi Ashram Redevelopment: Received bids from 3 firms, says AMC officials

© Provided by The Indian Express Three firms have bid for the Gandhi Ashram redevelopment project work, for which the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) had issued a tender worth an ... Read more »

UK's rarest fish are returning to shallows used by their ancestors over 180 years ago

BRITAIN’S rarest fish is using a “bypass” to return to waters where its ancestors were often seen more than 180 years ago. Green campaigners are celebrating after the Twaite shad ... Read more »

Police appeal to find suspect after man left in critical condition with head injury after 1am street attack

MET police have launched a manhunt after a man was left in critical condition after a “street confrontation”. Officers were called to High Street in Beckenham in the early hours ... Read more »

UK spy bosses rubbish James Bond's gadgets in latest movie No Time to Die

KILLJOY spy bosses have rubbished James Bond’s tech in his latest movie. They released a video insisting “smart blood” used in No Time to Die — Daniel Craig’s last outing ... Read more »

Stansted ‘chaos' as baggage meltdown causes queues snaking 'round the whole airport' and families miss flights

STANSTED Airport today fell into chaos with queues snaking around the whole airport causing families to miss flights. A technical issue affected the airport's hold baggage system, meaning that luggage ... Read more »

One in four women in financial services want to leave work due to menopause

© Provided by City AM Pervasive taboos, a “culture of silence” in the workplace, and the impact of the physical symptoms of the menopause are all contributing to a blockage ... Read more »

Clubs face bouncer shortage as UK staffing squeeze hits nightlife

Nightclubs are suffering from a growing shortage of bouncers, in the latest staffing squeeze to hit the UK’s economic recovery, with some estimates suggesting venues are having to pay security ... Read more »

Two in hospital, man in custody after shopping centre stabbing in Brunswick, Melbourne

© Provided by ABC NEWS The shopping centre on Sydney Road has been closed while police investigate. (ABC: Sephanie Ferrier) Two men are in hospital and a third has been arrested after ... Read more »