Nebraska prosecutors to pursue death penalty in only one of two grisly small-town killings

FILE – The front door of the rectory where the Rev. Stephen Gutgsell’s was fatally stabbed on Dec. 10, 2023, in tiny Fort Calhoun, Neb., remained wrapped in crime scene tape on Dec. 14. Prosecutors have decided not to seek the death penalty in the December killing of the Catholic priest inside his home, but they are pursuing execution in the brutal killing of a retiree during a break-in that happened in the same tiny Nebraska town four months earlier. (AP Photo/Josh Funk, File)

OMAHA, Neb. (AP) — Nebraska prosecutors have decided not to seek the death penalty in the December killing of a Catholic priest inside his home but will pursue execution in the brutal killing of a retiree during a break-in that happened in the same tiny town four months earlier.

FILE – The isolated home where Linda Childers was killed during a break-in on Aug. 13, 2023, is shown on Dec. 14, about a mile outside Fort Calhoun, Neb. Prosecutors have decided not to seek the death penalty in the December killing of a Catholic priest inside his home, but they are pursuing execution in the brutal killing of Childers, a retiree, during a break-in that happened in the same tiny Nebraska town four months earlier. (AP Photo/Josh Funk, File)

Kierre Williams has been charged with fatally stabbing the Rev. Stephen Gutgsell, 65, during a break-in at the rectory next door to St. John the Baptist Church in Fort Calhoun just hours before he was scheduled to lead mass on Dec. 10.

William Collins, meanwhile, has been charged with shooting Linda Childers, 71, with a crossbow three times in her back, neck and face before slitting her throat after breaking into her isolated home about a mile north of the community in August.

Investigators haven’t found any connection between the suspects and victims in either case, which is part of what has made them so troubling to the roughly 1,100 residents of the town that sits only 8 miles (12.87 kilometers) north of Omaha near the Missouri River.

FILE – Kierre Williams, right, sits with his attorneys in court, Jan. 3, 2024, in Blair, Neb. Williams of Sioux City, Iowa, pleaded not guilty on Feb. 8, in the attack that killed the Rev. Stephen Gutgsell, who was fatally stabbed on Dec. 10, 2023, in tiny Fort Calhoun, Neb. Prosecutors have decided not to seek the death penalty in the December killing of the Catholic priest inside his home, but they are pursuing execution in the brutal killing of a retiree during a break-in that happened in the same tiny Nebraska town four months earlier. (AP Photo/Josh Funk, File)

Both men have pleaded not guilty to murder, burglary and weapons charges; Collins also faces assault and theft charges that he’s pleaded not guilty to. They’re both scheduled to return to court next Tuesday to ask the judge to order prosecutors to provide more details about the charges against them.

Collins’ attorney didn’t immediately respond to a message about his case Tuesday, but has previously declined to discuss the case outside of court. Judge Bryan Meismer earlier this month rejected a motion to have the death penalty ruled out as unconstitutional in Collins’ case on grounds that courts have held in other cases that Nebraska’s death penalty is constitutional and it’s too early to determine if it is being applied fairly.

Nebraska Town Two Grisly Killings

Williams’ attorney, Brian Craig, said the charges against him don’t include any of the requirements under state law for someone to be sentenced to death. A sheriff’s deputy who responded to the priest’s 911 call found Williams, 43, sprawled across Gutgsell, who was bleeding profusely.

FILE – This booking photo provided by the Washington County, Neb., Sheriff’s Office shows William Collins. Collins is charged with murder and burglary in connection with the Aug. 13, 2023, death of Linda Childers. Prosecutors have decided not to seek the death penalty in the December killing of a Catholic priest inside his home, but they are pursuing execution in the brutal killing of Childers, a retiree, during a break-in that happened in the same tiny Nebraska town four months earlier. (Washington County Sheriff’s Office via AP)

“Based on the allegations, as they’ve been set forth, there aren’t any aggravating circumstances … that would support a finding of aggravating circumstances that would subject Mr. Williams to the death penalty,” said Craig, who is with the Nebraska Commission on Public Advocacy that serves as the public defender in many murder cases across the state.

In the charges against Collins, prosecutors spelled out three aggravating circumstances they plan to prove to justify the death penalty if he is convicted. They say Childers’ killing was especially heinous and cruel, and she was killed partly to conceal Collins’ identity or another crime.

A family member found Childers’ body in a pool of blood in her kitchen a day after she was killed.

Authorities have said Collins took her vehicle, purse and shotgun and fled to Texas where the 30-year-old was arrested about two weeks later.

FILE – This photo provided by the Archdiocese of Omaha shows the Rev. Stephen Gutgsell. Prosecutors have decided not to seek the death penalty in the December killing of the Catholic priest inside his home, but they are pursuing execution in the brutal killing of a retiree during a break-in that happened in the same tiny Nebraska town four months earlier. (Archdiocese of Omaha via AP, File)