Government scheme to boost green homes ‘underperformed badly' – report

A Government scheme intended to bolster a “green recovery” from the pandemic by boosting jobs and cutting home carbon emissions “underperformed badly”, putting net zero ambitions at risk, a damning new report has found.

And it is possible the department in charge has not “fully acknowledged the scale of its failures”, according to MPs scrutinising the project.

The findings are laid out in a report published today by the Commons’ Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on the Government’s Green Homes Grant Voucher Scheme.

The scheme, which was announced in July 2020 and overseen by the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS), was implemented as an “urgent response” to the Covid-19 crisis, the committee said.

It offered people the chance to apply for up to £5,000 in funding, rising to £10,000 for low-income households, to install energy efficiency improvements and low carbon heat measures – such as insulation and heat pumps – in their homes.

The plan was for homeowners to identify a certified installer and apply for vouchers to pay towards the work. The installer would then receive the grant funding after completing the job.

But the voucher scheme “did not perform to the department’s expectations”, the committee said.

It found that BEIS now anticipates that, by the time all remaining vouchers are processed and paid, it will have upgraded only 47,500 of the 600,000 homes it had hoped to reach.

And while it “initially anticipated” the scheme would support up to 82,500 jobs over six months, the department now expects that it will in fact manage this for only 5,600 jobs over 12 months, the report said.

In addition, the committee said the project accounted for just £314 million of its original £1.5 billion budget, and £50 million of that was administration costs – more than £1,000 per home upgraded.

The committee warned that the failure to deliver the scheme continued the Government’s “troubled record of energy efficiency initiatives” and risked “damaging the department’s future efforts to harness both consumer and industry action” to deliver on net zero commitments.

The PAC noted the Government’s “commendable intentions” for the project, but criticised its “unrealistic” 12-week timescale for implementation, from July to September 2020.

It said it was told by BEIS that the quick turnaround was “necessary to boost jobs” as a majority of the construction industry were on the furlough scheme, which was due to end.

The PAC was told that if the delivery was pushed back to the winter, it would have been “less practical to install energy efficiency measures”.

The committee added that the department proceeded with the scheme “despite its own Projects and Investment Committee rejecting its full business case”.

The result, the PAC said, was a scheme with “poor design and troubled implementation”.

It said the department “did not consult meaningfully enough with industry and consumers”, which led to an “overly complex” design, with “poor customer experiences” and a “lower uptake” than hoped.

The scheme opened to voucher applications from the public in September 2020. But roughly two months later, the PAC said “evidence began to emerge” that it was “not issuing vouchers as quickly as expected”.

A year-long extension to the scheme was subsequently scrapped, and it closed as originally planned in March 2021.

While the scheme’s “primary aim” was to “support jobs”, its “abrupt closure” may have actually led to redundancies, the PAC said.

The committee said the department “acknowledged that homeowners and installers had a poor experience with the scheme”, with more than 3,000 complaints made up to April 2021. Delays caused a headache for customers – with those who applied for the scheme in October facing a wait of up to 137 days for a voucher to be issued.

By August 2021, the committee said 52% of homeowners’ voucher applications were rejected or withdrawn, and 46% of installer applications failed.

The PAC said that difficulties relating to the “complexity” of the scheme, as well as “poor communications”, were “further exacerbated” by the “underperformance” of the administrator, ICF Consulting Services Ltd, creating delays in processing applications and issuing vouchers to homeowners, as well as making payments to installers.

“The department argued that this was the primary reason for the scheme’s poor performance, and that it had seen a lot of demand at the start of the scheme before these customer service issues arose,” the report said.

A focus on the problems with the administrator prompted concern among the committee that the department would “fail to learn from this scheme”.

ENVIRONMENT Climate

“When asked what the primary failings of the scheme were, whilst acknowledging the short duration and the design of the scheme as factors, the department largely attributed its failings to the poor performance of its scheme administrator,” it said.

“This contrasted with one of the department’s ministers who, giving evidence at the Environmental Audit Committee, readily acknowledged the multiple causes of the scheme’s difficulties set out in the Comptroller and Auditor General’s report.

“The department needs to recognise the breadth and scale of what went wrong on this scheme, so that it can begin to regain the confidence of homeowners and industry in future attempts to decarbonise buildings.”

The PAC made a series of recommendations based on its findings, including that the department must “regain the confidence of consumers and industry” if it is to realise the ambitions set out in its Heat and Buildings Strategy, which aims to “significantly cut carbon emissions from the UK’s 30 million homes and workplaces”.

Dame Meg Hillier, Labour MP and Chair of the Public Accounts Committee, said: “It cost the taxpayer £50 million just to administer the pointlessly rushed-through Green Homes Grant scheme, which delivered a small fraction of its objectives, either in environmental benefits or the promised new jobs.

“We heard it can take 48 months – four years – to train the specialists required to implement key parts of a scheme that was dreamed up to be rolled out in 12 weeks.

“It was never going to work at this time, in this way, and that should have been blindingly obvious to the department. That it was not is a serious worry. I am afraid there is no escaping the conclusion that this scheme was a slam-dunk fail.

“We will need this massive, step change in the way our homes and public buildings are heated, but the way this was devised and run was just a terrible waste of money and opportunity at a time when we can least afford it.”

A Government spokesperson said: “As the National Audit Office acknowledge, the Green Homes Grant voucher scheme was designed as a short-term economic stimulus and was delivered during a global pandemic. Despite this and other challenges with delivery, all applications have now been processed, with almost 80,000 vouchers having been issued.

“We have taken the experience of the Green Homes Grant into account when designing new measures, with a commitment to go further and faster by investing £6.6 billion in improving the energy efficiency of our buildings, including £1.3 billion this year alone to upgrade up to another 50,000 homes.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Rationalise levies for clean energy tech: Sumant Sinha, senior V-P, Assocham

© Provided by The Financial Express Given that there is no GST on power output, all these input taxes are a cost to the developer and impact the viability of ... Read more »

Ukraine crisis: US offers no concessions in response to Russia's demands

The Biden administration and Nato told Russia on Wednesday there will be no US or Nato concessions on Moscow’s main demands to resolve the crisis over Ukraine. In separate written ... Read more »

Tesla Q4 2021 Earnings Report: Beats Expectations Yet Again

© InsideEVs Tesla Model Y Another profitable quarter in the books. Tesla just released its Q4 2021 earnings report and the numbers are impressive. Tesla again turned a profit, which makes ... Read more »

Another TikTok exec heads for the exit

TikTok executive Sean Kim left the company earlier this month. Main: Getty Images; Inset: Linke A week after TikTok ousted its marketing chief Nick Tran, the short-video app’s head of ... Read more »

Budget may provide booster dose to meet climate goals

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: At a time when India is focusing on decarbonising its economy, industry is pitching for steps to encourage green mobility in ... Read more »

Boris Johnson came out fighting in style against Keir Starmer – especially for a man under pressure

Battler Boris FOR a man under insane pressure Boris Johnson came out fighting yesterday and with some style. Of course nothing short of a nuclear blast will wipe away Keir ... Read more »

Highway Code rule changes LIVE – Every new 2022 change REVEALED including safety for cyclists at roundabouts & junctions

THERE are major changes happening to the Highway Code from next week The new rules are split into three main categories and ultimately aim to improve safety for pedestrians, cyclists ... Read more »

Arizona marks 2 years since state's first COVID-19 case

© Provided by Associated Press FILE — Dr. Rebecca Sunenshine, of Maricopa County Department of Public Health, left, and Dr. Shauna McIsaac, of Pinal County Department of Public Health, speak ... Read more »

GOP redistricting plan passes in Kansas; court fight looms

© Provided by Associated Press This image shows the “Ad Astra 2” congressional redistricting plan for Kansas drafted by the Kansas Legislative Research Department for Republican leaders in the GOP-controlled ... Read more »

Gates Foundation adds board members following Bill and Melinda's divorce

The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation named four new members to its board of trustees on Wednesday, marking the first outsiders added to the charity’s board in its two-decade history. ... Read more »

Israeli settlers rage through Palestinian town, marking the latest 'nationalistically-motivated' attack in the region

Israeli settlers in a convoy of cars rampaged through a Palestinian town in the West Bank near Nablus on Monday evening, marking the latest in a string of violent incidents ... Read more »

Moderna begins testing omicron-matched COVID shots in adults

The Associated PressFILE – A sign marks an entrance to a Moderna building in Cambridge, Mass., on Monday, May 18, 2020. On Wednesday, Jan. 26, 2022, the pharmaceutical company announced ... Read more »

Janet Jackson doc explores her scandalous marriage to James DeBarge

Janet Jackson and James DeBarge eloped in 1984 but the marriage was annulled the next year. Getty Images It was an attempt to take control of her life from father ... Read more »

England keeper Sam Johnstone is LEFT OUT of West Brom's home defeat against Preston amid claims he's fallen out with boss Valerien Ismael... with Baggies team-mates baffled by his exclusion

West Brom keeper Sam Johnstone was left out of their squad to face PrestonThe promotion chasers were beaten 2-0 at home to Ryan Lowe's men There were suggestions the England star has fallen out with Valerien Ismael  Team-mates were baffled by the exclusion with David Button replacing him Johnstone - who was wanted by West Ham - is out of contract in the summer  Read more »

SPECIAL REPORT: China's Winter Olympics should be renamed the GENOCIDE Games... a million Muslims have been sent to camps where rape, torture and forced abortion are rife. So, one week out, why is Beijing seen as a suitable host?

There have been worldwide protests for athletes to boycott the Winter OlympicsChina beat out competition from Kazakhstan to win 2022 hosting privilegesCampaigners have pointed to China's treatment of Uyghur Muslims in protests It has been claimed that as many as one million Uyghur Muslims are detained Rahima Mahmut told Sportsmail it should be known as the 'Genocide Games'  Read more »

DOMINIC KING: The madcap world of Farhad Moshiri is a masterclass in how NOT to run a football club… he's allowed Vitor Pereira and his loose lips to turn Everton into a laughing stock

Farhad Moshiri's reign in charge of Everton has not gone as supporters hoped Moshiri is on the search for another manager after sacking Rafael Benitez Everton fans are angry at the prospect of Vitor Pereira as his possible successorFrank Lampard hasn't worked for a year but Pereira has been vocal about the job Read more »

Henrik Lundqvist's best Rangers moments No. 2: Comeback complete

Leading up to Friday’s ceremony in which the Rangers will retire Henrik Lundqvist’s No. 30 at the Garden, The Post is taking a look at the King’s five best moments ... Read more »

Jockey Jonjo O'Neill Jnr thrilled to keep high-profile ride on Champ following landmark Grade One success at Ascot last month

Champ was named after multiple champion jockey AP McCoy O’Neill bagged his first Grade One success on Champ in the Long Walk Hurdle Pair will line-up again in Saturday’s Chapel Stud Cleeve Hurdle at Cheltenham Read more »

‘Property Brothers' renovation home sells fast for $730K

A home renovated by the “Property Brothers” in 2014 has found a buyer just one week after it hit the market. HGTV A Georgia home renovated by the “Property Brothers” ... Read more »

Woman praises man for not staring at her at the gym during an ‘uncomfy' squat but some slam her for her double standard

GOING to the gym should be a comfortable experience for everyone. However, when Libby Christensen was doing her daily work out, she was pleasantly surprised to see a man had ... Read more »

Sergio Garcia lifts the lid on Saudi row as European and PGA Tours try to block events... as sceptic Rory McIlroy admits 'it's hard to stay no' to the mind-boggling appearance fees

Sergio Garcia has revealed the simmering tensions behind the scenes Skeptic Rory McIlroy will not play in the Saudi Invitational next weekBut the Northern Irishman expressed his sympathies towards the players Read more »

Advienne speaks on being replaced by Mikyx at Excel

Henk “Advienne” Reijenga has spoken out on his sudden replacement as the LEC support for Excel former by Mid-Season Invitational champion Mihael “Mikyx” Mehle. Advienne was suddenly replaced by Mikyx ... Read more »

The £100,000 allotment war: Couple face eviction from plots they have cultivated for 20 years... despite spending six-figure sum on legal battle to stay put

Couple spent £100,000 fighting to keep the allotments they have cultivatedElsie Price, 71, and husband Wayne Armsby, 70, faced eviction from the two plotsCouple are accused of using theirs as gardens but refused to accept losing land  Read more »

World Rugby locked out in European power play with Six Nations' £365m commercial deal preventing private equity firm CVC from selling their stake to sport's governing body

The stipulation in the deal shows the split in rugby's leadership and governanceWorld Rugby have made attempts to unite the sport around a global calendarThey were pushing a new 12-team Nations Championship two years agoThe Six Nations are determined to retain control of rugby in Europe  Read more »

'He is a MAD MAN!': Eric Bailly leaves fans in DISBELIEF on social media as his bizarre one-step, no-look penalty vs Egypt dumps Ivory Coast out of AFCON... with some joking that he 'turned into Jorginho, Bruno Fernandes and Roberto Firmino' all at once

Egypt beat Ivory Coast on penalties to advance to the AFCON quarter-finalsManchester United's Eric Bailly missed the decisive penalty for the ElephantsBailly produced an unusual one-step run-up and appeared to try a no-look effortFans flocked to social media to express their bemusement with his approach  Read more »

Newcastle have all but given up hope of reviving Jesse Lingard loan deal after Manchester United demanded a £12m survival bonus - with the England star FUMING at Old Trafford bosses

Jesse Lingard is wanted on loan by Newcastle after being unused at Man UnitedUnited demanded an initial £2.5m loan fee plus a £12m survival bonus thoughThis included covering the 29-year-old's £100,000-a-week wages in full tooLingard is upset that his boyhood club are driving such a hard bargain in the deal  Read more »

How to scan enemies in Rainbow Six Extraction

© Provided by Dot Esports Rainbow Six Extraction can be an intense experience, especially at higher difficulty levels when new mutations and enemies turn incursions into deadly missions. Trying to ... Read more »

LEC Team of the Week: 2022 Spring Split week 2

© Provided by Dot Esports Another exciting week has flashed by in Europe as the LEC Spring Split is well underway in Berlin, with teams jockeying for early positioning within ... Read more »

Jamie Carragher sends message to Everton fans after more Goodison Park protests

Jamie Carragher has sent a message to Everton fans amid what he has described as “understandable” frustrations, amid renewed protests outside the club’s stadium. With a number of supporters opposed ... Read more »

‘Useless', ‘Absolutely embarrassing' – These West Brom fans slam key figure after Preston setback

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Barnsley v West Bromwich Albion West Brom fell to a disappointing 2-0 defeat at home to Preston this evening as the fans ... Read more »

Mizkif loses $20K after bet with MrBeast in League of Legends

Sometimes the streaming community is shocked by the amount of money content creators make, but at least Matthew “Mizkif” Rinaudo and Jimmy “MrBeast” Donaldson have decided to use some of ... Read more »

Hearts 1-2 Celtic: Japanese star Hatate nets first goal in Scotland

For Celtic the width of a Tynecastle post proved crucial in the end. Stepping forward to take a Hearts penalty with 19 minutes to play Liam Boyce had the opportunity to ... Read more »

Celtic survive second-half scare to win at Hearts and keep pressure on Rangers

© Alamy Stock Photo Celtic’s Nir Britton celebrates victory. CELTIC SURVIVED A strong second-half fightback from Hearts to grind out a 2-1 victory in a pulsating cinch Premiership encounter at ... Read more »

The Repair Shop fans joke man's 135-year-old family heirloom is a time machine

The Repair Shop viewers were bemused by what they joked was a ‘time machine’ on the latest episode of the heartwarming show. The BBC series followed the journey behind an ... Read more »

Frankreich komplettiert EM-Halbfinals

© KEYSTONE/AP/Tibor Illyes Olympiasieger Frankreich erreicht an der Handball-EM als letztes Team die Halbfinals und trifft dort auf Schweden. Den zweiten Finalisten machen Titelverteidiger Spanien und Dänemark unter sich aus. ... Read more »

#Showbiz: Mila Jirin glad her business picked up again

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: With her catering and wedding planning business interrupted for almost two years due to the pandemic, singer-turned-entrepreneur Mila Jirin is relieved that ... Read more »

NYC spread owned by Warhol superstar Brigid Berlin sells for $1.1M

Ich bin ein Berlin-er: The one-time home of the actress and photographer (above) just sold. Matthew McDermott It’s picture-perfect. A Kips Bay apartment owned by the late Brigid Berlin — ... Read more »

PICS: Farhan Akhtar pulls off a smart white co ord set as he goes out and about in the city

Farhan Akhtar is one of those performers who has always dazzled audiences with his unwavering commitment and ability to immerse himself in the flesh of each character he portrays. And, ... Read more »

Adele fans fear she will NEVER say Hello to Las Vegas shows after pulling out at the 11th hour as set is out and her slot is ALREADY filled

It seems increasingly unlikely her ‘Weekends with’ residency will go ahead any time soon, if at all, as her sets were seen being removed from the venueKeith Urban, who is the husband of Nicole Kidman, has announced he will now be playing weekends at Caesars Palace in late March and early AprilFans have already pointed out that given the venue’s programme of events, it is possible that the earliest she will be able to perform is 2023In a video posted on social media she blamed the delay on ‘half her crew’ being off work with COVID-19 and on ‘delivery’ issuesBut it has since been claimed that the star had ‘butted heads’ with her set designer Esmeralda Devlin over aspects of the showSources in Las Vegas also claimed her team were a ‘total nightmare’ during preparations for her three-month residency Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Long COVID expert says the world is in 'deep trouble' and millions may suffer from debilitating physical and cognitive issues for YEARS after being infected

While the Covid pandemic could come to an end at some point this year, the long-term effects of the virus will linger'Long Covid' is a mysterious yet surprisingly common condition where someone feels effects of Covid long after infection - sometimes to a debilitating effectWith millions of Americans having contracted Covid in recent weeks, and up to 30% of them likely to develop long Covid, it could be a massive issueOne expert, Dr Leonard Jason, warns that the condition can disrupt the every day life of millions and hurt society as a wholeAnother, Dr Noah Greenspan, warns that the world's current Covid situation puts it in 'deep trouble'  Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic