Google, Genius Battle In Appeals Court Over Song Lyrics

Asia's Tech News Daily

Google, Genius Battle In Appeals Court Over Song Lyrics
Google

Attorneys for Google and Genius clashed before a Manhattan federal appeals court Wednesday, arguing whether the lyrics database has the right to sue over lyrics that it doesn’t actually own.

Genius, a popular platform that lets users add and annotate lyrics, says Google unfairly copied the site’s carefully-transcribed content, but a federal judge dismissed the case last year on the grounds that only the actual copyright owners – like songwriters or publishers – could have filed such a case.

Now asking the Second Circuit Court of Appeal to revive the case, Genius argued before a three-judge panel Wednesday that Google had “stolen with impunity” from a small company that had spent millions to build a valuable service for music fans beyond the actual copyrighted lyrics.

“The rights were trying to protect are the substantial investment of time and energy in our service,” said Marion R. Harris of Pryor Cashman LLP, repping Genius. “They accessed our website, they agreed to our terms of service.”

“To add insult to injury, the defendants then used the very product created by our processes to compete with us,” Harris said.

Arguing back for Google was Brian M. Willen of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati PC, who told the court that Genius simply could not sue over copyrighted songs that it did not own and had been legally licensed by Google.

“The lyrics are not their property,” Willen told the court. “This case is an attempt by Genius to essentially stand in the shoes of the rights holders and assert … copyrighted works that they don’t own.”

Genius sued Google in 2019, claiming the tech giant had stolen the site’s lyrics and displayed them its own “information boxes” when users search for a song. In a splashy twist, Genius said it had used a secret code buried within lyrics that spelled out REDHANDED to prove Google’s wrongdoing.

Though it sounds like a copyright case, Genius didn’t actually accuse Google of stealing any intellectual property. That’s because songwriters and publishers, not Genius, own the rights to song lyrics. Both Google and Genius pay for copyright licenses for the lyrics displayed on their sites.

Instead, Genius argued it had spent time and money transcribing and compiling “authoritative” lyrics, and that Google had unfairly “exploited” that effort for its own profit. In technical terms, Genius claimed Google’s conduct amounted to unfair competition and a breach of the site’s terms of service, which say users cannot take material for commercial purposes.

But in August 2020, a federal judge dismissed the case, ruling that Genius could not sue over lyrics that it did not own. The judge ruled that accusations were “preempted” by federal law, since accusations like the theft of song lyrics are reserved solely the domain of federal copyright law.

Arguing Wednesday to overturn that ruling, Pryor Cashman’s Harris argued that Genius’s accusations were “qualitatively different” from a case over the copyrighted lyrics themselves. He said the company was instead interested in protecting the “tens of millions of dollars” Genius had invested to transcribe accurate lyrics that might not publicly exist otherwise, particularly for “difficult to decipher genres like rap and hip hop.”

But at times he faced tough pushback from the Second Circuit’s judges.

“To the extent that you took copyrighted material and wrote down ‘when they begin the beguine,’ once you put it out into the public, why do you have some right to it?” asked Judge Reena Raggi, referencing iconic lyrics by Cole Porter. “You didn’t create they lyrics.”

“And why do you have rights that are greater than the copyright owner?” asked Judge Eric Vitaliano.

LyricFind, another lyrics service that was also named as a defendant in the case because it licensed lyrics to Google, also participated in the arguments and was repped by Kenneth D. Freundlich of Freundlich Law.

A ruling on the case will be issued in the months ahead.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Mark scores 22, No. 15 Houston routs Bryant 111-44

HOUSTON (AP) — Tramon Mark tied a career high with 22 points, Josh Carlton added 17 and No. 15 Houston won its third straight, beating Bryant 111-44 on Friday night. ... Read more »

What Parents Should Know About the Omicron Variant Heading Into the Holidays

A new and likely more transmissible coronavirus variant has emerged, prompting travel restrictions, extended mandates and concern about what this means for the pandemic. The variant, Omicron, was first identified ... Read more »

Rewards offered for parents of Michigan shooting suspect after manslaughter charges

Authorities are searching for the parents of a teenager accused of killing four people in a Michigan high school shooting this week, the Oakland County Sheriff's Office confirmed Friday. Late ... Read more »

Homeowner convicted in killings of 2 teens smoking marijuana

DAYTON, Ohio — An Ohio man has been convicted in the fatal shooting of two teens he found smoking marijuana inside a vehicle in his garage. Victor Santana, 65, of ... Read more »

Darlene Hard, 3-time major tennis champion, dies at 85

Darlene Hard, an aggressive serve-and-volley player who won three major singles titles and 18 major doubles titles in a Hall of Fame tennis career, has died. She was 85. She ... Read more »

Five are accused of running stolen-gun trafficking ring in Kansas City

Five men are accused of running an organized crime ring in Kansas City, a group said to be responsible for the theft and sale of dozens of firearms that were ... Read more »

Sheriff's Office blasts prosecutor for parents of Oxford shooting suspect being on the lam

Oakland County sheriff officials blamed the county prosecutor Friday for the parents of the suspect in the Oxford High School mass shooting being on the lam. “In my entire 44-year ... Read more »

Violent carjacking in Ventura leaves victim, suspect with major injuries

A woman was reportedly beaten by a group that included juveniles during a violent carjacking in midtown Ventura late Thursday night, authorities said. The incident also left one of the ... Read more »

Mom charged in Thanksgiving crash that killed two kids will be released for son's funeral

NORTH BRUNSWICK – The New Brunswick woman accused of manslaughter and homicide in the Thanksgiving night crash in area of Routes 1 and 130 in which two children were killed ... Read more »

Cruz scores 16 to lead Fairfield over Canisius 74-68

BUFFALO, N.Y. (AP) — Jesus Cruz came off the bench to score 16 points to lift Fairfield to a 74-68 win over Canisius on Friday night. The game marked the ... Read more »

Boothby scores 21 to lift Cornell over Coppin State 92-77

ITHACA, N.Y. (AP) — Keller Boothby had 21 points as Cornell topped Coppin State 92-77 on Friday night. Boothby made 7 of 9 3-pointers for the Big Red (7-1), who ... Read more »

Junior Joseph carries Iona past Rider 80-54 in MAAC opener

NEW ROCHELLE, N.Y. (AP) — Nelly Junior Joseph recorded 17 points and 10 rebounds to lift Iona to an 80-54 win over Rider on Friday night. Dylan van Eyck had ... Read more »

Man shot, killed in neighborhood near North Rural Street

A man was shot and killed in an east-side neighborhood Friday night. Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department officers responded to reports of a person shot on East 19th Street – off ... Read more »

Braunwyn Windham-Burke Kisses Model Victoria Brito in Miami: RHOC Alum Is 'Smitten,' Source Says

Braunwyn Windham-Burke, Victoria Brito LionsShareNews/BACKGRID Victoria Brito, Braunwyn Windham-Burke Braunwyn Windham-Burke isn't afraid to show a little PDA. The Real Housewives of Orange County alum, 44, showed some love to ... Read more »

Backstage With... Little Mix's Leigh-Anne Pinnock on 'hardest thing she's ever done' - her film debut in Boxing Day

Boxing Day caps of a big year for Pinnock - in May she made history as part of the first girl band to ever win the best British group prize at the Brit Awards, and in her personal life she's become a mother - welcoming twins with her fiance Andre Gray in August. Read more »

Furman tops College of Charleston 91-88 in OT

GREENVILLE, S.C. (AP) — Jalen Slawson had a career-high 33 points plus 13 rebounds as Furman edged past College of Charleston 91-88 in overtime on Friday night. Alex Hunter scored ... Read more »

Nets escape Timberwolves 110-105 behind Durant's 30

Read more »

SKorea sets daily records for new coronavirus cases, deaths

1 / 2Virus Outbreak South KoreaA medical worker wearing protective gear in a booth, takes sample from a man at a temporary screening clinic for the coronavirus in Seoul, South ... Read more »

Thursday's fatal stabbing over a parking dispute marks 35th homicide in St. Paul, most on record

Dec. 3—A Thursday evening fatal stabbing that broke St. Paul's record for the most homicides in one year happened over a parking dispute, according to authorities. Brian Harry Kjellberg, 50, ... Read more »

Judge declines lower bond for Fairfield teens

Dec. 3—FAIRFIELD — Bond will stay at $1 million cash only for two Fairfield juveniles accused by police of killing a high school Spanish teacher. Judge Joel Yates, in a ... Read more »

Microsoft reverses Windows 11 changes that made it hard to switch browsers

Microsoft appears to be eliminating Windows 11 changes that made it harder to switch default browsers, according to a report from The Verge's Tom Warren. A new Insider build now ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing: Rose Ayling-Ellis on making history as the first deaf contestant and her moving silent performance

Rose Ayling-Ellis, Strictly Come Dancing's first deaf contestant, is favourite to win the series with partner Giovanni Pernice after wowing viewers with her performances - including a routine featuring an emotional silent section. Here, she speaks to Sky News about being "part of history". Read more »

EC man convicted for failing to tell police about overdose death

Dec. 3—EAU CLAIRE — An Eau Claire man has been convicted of failing to let police know a drug overdose victim died in his residence. The incident occurred nearly three ... Read more »

Post Falls coffee shop shooter caught on video before fleeing

Dec. 3—Surveillance cameras captured the Wednesday shooting at Kokopelli Coffee in Post Falls that left two men injured, according to court documents filed Thursday. Post Falls police received multiple 911 ... Read more »

Braun, No. 8 Kansas turn back St. John's at Islanders' home

NEW YORK (AP) — Christian Braun had a career-high 31 points, Ochai Agbaji scored 23 and No. 8 Kansas emphatically turned back a second-half charge to beat St. John’s 95-75 ... Read more »

Hawkish Fed boosts value stocks' appeal for some investors

FILE PHOTO: An entrance to the NYSE on Wall Street in New York By David Randall NEW YORK (Reuters) – Some investors are preparing for a hawkish turn from the ... Read more »

Police investigating after video of violent home invasion surfaces online

Map of home-invasion robbery Authorities are investigating a violent home invasion in the Fairfax district after video surfaced on social media. The robbery occurred in the 100 block of North ... Read more »

Seventeen-year-old arrested and charged with murder in Northland shooting

A light-colored Lincoln sedan with its doors open and multiple bullet holes in the front windshield sits behind crime scene tape at the back of a parking lot on Friday ... Read more »

Man convicted of molesting 18-month-old boy; woman also convicted earlier

A Desert Hot Springs man was convicted on Friday of molesting an 18-month-old male relative, following the conviction two days earlier of a Coachella woman who also molested the boy. ... Read more »

Roundup: Oxnard man hospitalized in fiery crash, Ventura crash victim named, more news

Here's a roundup of recent incidents and announcements from Ventura County agencies: Driver hospitalized after fiery crash OXNARD – A 66-year-old Oxnard man was hospitalized with critical injuries after driving ... Read more »

Boston leads No. 1 South Carolina to 65-44 win over Wildcats

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — Dawn Staley knows about point guards. And the Hall of Famer saw all she needed the past few seasons to tell her 6-foot-4 Laeticia Amihere had ... Read more »

Man faces murder charge after fatal shooting outside Chipotle restaurant near Palm Beach Gardens

PALM BEACH GARDENS — A dispute between co-workers at a Chipotle Mexican Grill led last month to an exchange of gunfire in its parking lot that killed one person and ... Read more »

Medical examiner: Matthew Lindquist was stabbed 67 times in Griswold attack

Dec. 3—After being chased into the woods on a cold December night, Matthew Lindquist was stabbed 67 times, causing stab, slice and 'chop' wounds across his body, according to a ... Read more »

2nd man arrested in Suffolk killing; 3rd still sought

Police arrested the second of three men wanted in connection with a shooting that left one man dead and another wounded Sunday afternoon in Suffolk. Suffolk Police have warrants charging ... Read more »

Sonora police arrest student for allegedly threatening a shooting at Cassina High campus

A student at a Sonora high school was arrested Friday afternoon after allegedly making threats against the school and students, police said. Cassina High School administration notified the Sonora Police ... Read more »

Former Suring substitute teacher and Village Board member pleads guilty to federal child sex abuse charges

SURING – A 37-year-old former substitute teacher and Village Board member pleaded guilty to federal child sexual abuse charges, the U.S. Department of Justice announced in a news release Friday. ... Read more »

Montgomery County Sheriff's deputy charged with domestic related harassment and stalking

A Montgomery County Sheriff's Office Deputy was arrested Friday and charged with domestic related harassment and stalking. On Monday, MCSO received information on possible stalking and harassment incidents involving an ... Read more »

US hiring stumbles in November as economy adds just 210,000 new jobs

Economists expected payrolls to increase by 550,000 in November Read more »

Strome scores as Rangers beat Sharks 1-0; Shesterkin hurt

NEW YORK (AP) — Ryan Strome scored in the first period, and Igor Shesterkin and Alexander Georgiev combined for a 28-save shutout as the New York Rangers beat the San ... Read more »

Braun leads No. 8 Kansas past St. John's 95-75 at new arena

NEW YORK (AP) — Christian Braun had a career-high 31 points, Ochai Agbaji scored 23 and No. 8 Kansas emphatically turned back a second-half charge to beat St. John’s 95-75 ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic