Get ready for Manhattan DA’s made-for-TV Trump prosecution: high on ratings, but short on the law

get ready for manhattan da’s made-for-tv trump prosecution: high on ratings, but short on the law

Get ready for Manhattan DA’s made-for-TV Trump prosecution: high on ratings, but short on the law

“The moment that we are waiting for, we made it to the finale together” — those familiar words from “America’s Got Talent” — could well be the opening line for Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg next week, when he is expected to unveil an indictment of former President Trump. With Trump’s reported announcement that he expects to be arrested on Tuesday, it would be a fitting curtain raiser for a case that has developed more like a television production than a criminal prosecution. Indeed, this indictment was repeatedly rejected only to be brought back by popular demand.

Trump faces serious legal threats in the ongoing Mar-a-Lago investigation. But the New York case would be easily dismissed outside of a jurisdiction like New York, where Bragg can count on highly motivated judges and jurors.

Although it may be politically popular, the case is legally pathetic. Bragg is struggling to twist state laws to effectively prosecute a federal case long ago rejected by the Justice Department against Trump over his payment of “hush money” to former stripper Stormy Daniels. In 2018 (yes, that is how long this theory has been around), I wrote how difficult such a federal case would be under existing election laws. Now, six years later, the same theory may be shoehorned into a state claim.

It is extremely difficult to show that paying money to cover up an embarrassing affair was done for election purposes as opposed to an array of obvious other reasons, from protecting a celebrity’s reputation to preserving a marriage. That was demonstrated by the failed federal prosecution of former presidential candidate John Edwards on a much stronger charge of using campaign funds to cover up an affair.

In this case, Trump reportedly paid Daniels $130,000 in the fall of 2016 to cut off or at least reduce any public scandal. The Southern District of New York’s U.S. Attorney’s office had no love lost for Trump, pursuing him and his associates in myriad investigations, but it ultimately rejected a prosecution based on the election law violations. It was not alone: The Federal Election Commission (FEC) chair also expressed doubts about the theory.

Prosecutors working under Bragg’s predecessor, Cyrus Vance Jr., also reportedly rejected the viability of using a New York law to effectively charge a federal offense.

More importantly, Bragg himself previously expressed doubts about the case, effectively shutting it down soon after he took office. The two lead prosecutors, Carey R. Dunne and Mark F. Pomerantz, resigned in protest. Pomerantz launched a very public campaign against Bragg’s decision, including commenting on a still-pending investigation. He made it clear that Trump was guilty in his mind, even though his former office was still undecided and the grand jury investigation was ongoing.

Pomerantz then did something that shocked many of us as highly unprofessional and improper: Over Bragg’s objection that he was undermining any possible prosecution, Pomerantz published a book detailing the case against an individual who was not charged, let alone convicted.

He was, of course, an instant success in the media that have spent years highlighting a dozen different criminal theories that were never charged against Trump. Pomerantz followed the time-tested combination for success — link Donald Trump to any alleged crime and convey absolute certainty of guilt. For cable TV shows, it was like a heroin hit for an audience in a long agonizing withdrawal.

And the campaign worked. Bragg caved, and “America’s Got Trump” apparently will air after all.

However, before 12 jurors can vote, Bragg still has to get beyond a series of glaring problems which could raise serious appellate challenges later.

While we still do not know the specific state charges in the anticipated indictment, the most-discussed would fall under Section 175 for falsifying business records, based on the claim that Trump used legal expenses to conceal the alleged hush-payments that were supposedly used to violate federal election laws. While some legal experts have insisted such concealment is clearly a criminal matter that must be charged, they were conspicuously silent when Hillary Clinton faced a not-dissimilar campaign-finance allegation.

Last year, the Federal Election Commission fined the Clinton campaign for funding the Steele dossier as a legal expense. The campaign had previously denied funding the dossier, which was used to push false Russia collusion claims against Trump in 2016, and it buried the funding in the campaign’s legal budget. Yet, there was no hue and cry for this type of prosecution in Washington or New York.

A Section 175 charge would normally be a misdemeanor. The only way to convert it into a Class E felony requires a showing that the “intent to defraud includes an intent to commit another crime or to aid or conceal the commission thereof.” That other crime would appear to be the federal election violations which the Justice Department previously declined to charge.

The linkage to a federal offense is critical for another reason: Bragg’s office ran out of time to prosecute this as a misdemeanor years ago; the statute of limitations is two years. Even if he shows this is a viable felony charge, the longer five-year limitation could be hard to establish.

Of course, none of these legalistic problems will be relevant in the coming frenzy. It will be a case that is nothing if not entertaining, one to which you can bring your popcorn — so long as you leave your principles behind.

Indeed, some will view it as poetic justice for this former reality-TV host to be tried like a televised talent show. However, the damage to the legal system is immense whenever political pressure overwhelms prosecutorial judgment. The criminal justice system can be a terrible weapon when used for political purposes, an all-too-familiar spectacle in countries where political foes can be targeted by the party in power.

None of this means Trump is blameless or should not be charged in other cases. However, we seem to be on the verge of watching a prosecution by plebiscite in this case. The season opener of “America’s Got Trump” might be a guaranteed hit with its New York audience — but it should be a flop as a prosecution.

Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at The George Washington University. Follow him on Twitter @JonathanTurley.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

News Related


‘Somebody knows something’ – gardaí renew appeal on sixth anniversary of missing Tina Satchwell

Gardaí are issuing a renewed appeal for information on the whereabouts of Cork woman Tina Satchwell on the sixth anniversary of her disappearance. Gardaí in Midleton continue to investigate the ... Read more »

Calls for DAA to be hauled in before Oireachtas Transport committee over terror attack fears in whistleblower claims

Dublin Airport chiefs face being questioned by TDs over allegations that poor standards of security could lead to a terror attack. Calls have now been made by members of the ... Read more »

Dublin Port launches €400m redevelopment plans

Floodlit playing pitches, a dog run and seaside cycle paths have been added to Dublin Port’s 2040 redevelopment plan, mainly to assuage local residents. Launching an official public consultation on ... Read more »

Record number of centenarians as Ireland now has highest life expectancy rate in the EU

The number of Irish people living to 100 or more hit record levels last year and will continue to rise exponentially as our life expectancy at birth is now the ... Read more »

No more negotiation, says Sunak as DUP digs in its heels over Windsor Brexit deal

DUP leader Sir Jeffrey Donaldson speaks to the media. Photo: Getty Images The British government has insisted it has no plans to renegotiate the Windsor Framework Brexit deal despite the ... Read more »

WHO chief is confident Covid-19 pandemic will be declared over this year

The pandemic will be declared over some time this year – but not just yet, according to the World Health Organisation’s (WHO) director general Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus. He noted ... Read more »

Meet the saucy centenarian who wrote a steamy novel in her 70s and hosted wild parties for Behan, Kavanagh and Donleavy

You wouldn’t expect to find the steamy Fifty Shades trilogy on the bookshelves of a 102-year-old woman – but there is nothing conventional about Countess Joan de Frenay. The Dubliner ... Read more »

Man caught with stolen bike ‘should have asked a few questions’

A man caught with a stolen bicycle and more “bits and pieces” of other old bikes in his hands on the street was involved in a “thriving black market”, a ... Read more »

UN report predicting climate catastrophe in 2030 met with mockery: 'Every single prediction' has been 'wrong'

The United Nations released a report on Monday that that claimed the planet will approach a catastrophic threshold in the 2030s unless further action is taken. The Intergovernmental Panel on ... Read more »

Pub's apology after being unable to 'honour any Mother's Day bookings'

The World’s End pub A pub apologised to customers for being unable to honour any Mother’s Day reservations. Managers said the issue arose because the pub had recently been taken ... Read more »

Russian cruise missiles destroyed in Crimea blast, Ukraine claims

An advisor to Ukraine’s interior minister tweeted a video that he claimed was an explosion in Dzhankoi – TWITTER Ukraine’s defence ministry said on Monday that an explosion in Dzhankoi ... Read more »

Man, 28, vanished on camping trip with friends two days ago

An urgent search has been launched for Reece Rodger (Picture: Police Scotland) A young man disappeared after heading to bed on a camping trip over the weekend. Police say they’re ... Read more »

Broncos miss another opportunity to upgrade offense

Denver Broncos coach Sean Payton After a 5-12 season and ranking last in scoring offense, Denver requires several upgrades, so just missing on a two-time Pro Bowler is a frustration. ... Read more »

Bacon placed in Muslim police officer’s boots as racist behaviour 'dismissed' by Met

Metropolitan Police sign A Muslim police officer described how he had bacon placed inside his boots while a Sikh colleague had his beard cut as part of racist behaviour written ... Read more »

‘What is RTÉ's problem with Louth?’ – Peter Fitzpatrick questions lack of TV coverage of Wee County's NFL games

Louth chairman Peter Fitzpatrick has criticised RTÉ’s failure to cover any of the county’s six Allianz Division 2 football league games this season, particularly their four home games in Ardee. ... Read more »

New Amy Winehouse Exhibition is perfect for fans and fashionistas in Ireland

Amy Winehouse fans are going to absolutely love the exhibition all about her life that’s landed in Ireland today. Not only was Amy a national treasure and beloved songbird, but ... Read more »

A man-made climate disaster is close, UN environmental report warns

Climate change is believed by scientists to affect millions of people The world is on the brink of a man-made climate change disaster, but there are still multiple different methods ... Read more »

British dad dies in shock fall during first-ever overseas holiday to Spain

Dion A British dad has died following a horror fall from a balcony at a holiday home in Spain. Dion Atherton had jetted off for his first-ever holiday abroad with ... Read more »

Lost cat found after six years - but her family had moved 10,500 miles away to Australia

‘I couldn’t believe it’ (Picture: Jam Press) When Tallulah the tabby vanished six years ago, Lisa Gregory, her husband James and their three kids Mia, Jed and Ostyn were crushed. ... Read more »

Mum wakes up screaming at night after finding 18-year-old son's lifeless body

Michael Toohey was brutally murdered in an internet cafe in Liverpool A mother has described how she begged paramedics to save her son’s life after finding his lifeless body on ... Read more »

Asda shoppers 'terrified' after man 'slashed with machete' outside shop in brutal rampage

Asda shoppers ‘terrified’ after man ‘slashed with machete’ outside store in brutal rampage A man has been stabbed in a supermarket row that got “out of hand”, eyewitnesses have recalled. ... Read more »

83 year old who knitted the jumpers for The Banshees deserves an Oscar

There are plenty of things to set the pulses racing in The Banshees Of Inisherin, Martin McDonagh’s macabre black comedy set on an imaginary island off the west coast of ... Read more »

Denzel confesses to an embarrassing secret in EastEnders

Denzel lands himself in a sticky situation (Picture: BBC) They say that lies always come back to bite you, and Denzel Danes (Jaden Ladega) is set to find that out ... Read more »

‘Crying writing this': Waspi woman's heart-rending plea for justice weeks before dying

Waspi stands for Women Against State Pension Injustice, a campaign group that represents around 3.8million women who were hit by moves to increase their retirement age to bring it into ... Read more »

Niamh De Brún and TJ Reid enjoy night off parent duties as he's named GWA personality of the year

TJ Reid is continuing his winning streak as he picks yet another accolade and as ever his wife Niamh was by his side cheering him on. The Kilkenny star has ... Read more »

Profits at PR firm Murray rise to more than €1m

Accounts just filed for Murray, one of the country’s biggest domestically owned public relations firms, show profits more than doubled last year to €1,067,260 after providing for depreciation and taxation. ... Read more »

Jamie Oliver's son Buddy, 12, follows dad's footsteps in the kitchen with fajita video

Jamie Oliver’s son Buddy caught the attention of fans on social media after he debuted his cooking skills in an adorable video. The 12-year-old has been the main focus of ... Read more »

WATCH: Spencer Matthews goes on an emotional journey to recover brother's body

Spencer Matthews and Bear Grylls have teamed up for a new documentary where they attempt to retrace the steps of Spencer’s brother after he disappeared on Mt Everest in 1999. ... Read more »

Chelsea boss Graham Potter reveals he and his kids have received death threats

Chelsea boss Graham Potter. CHELSEA HAVE PROMISED to offer Graham Potter whatever support he needs after the manager was sent emails threatening him and his family. Potter said he had ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự