Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch loses bid to have his legal costs in murder trial paid for by the State

gerry 'the monk' hutch loses bid to have his legal costs in murder trial paid for by the state

The State refused the application from Hutch’s lawyers in the Special Criminal Court today.

CRIME FIGURE “The Monk” Hutch has failed in a bid to recoup his legal costs from the State after he was acquitted seven weeks ago of the murder of Kinahan Cartel member David Byrne at the Regency Hotel.

Delivering the court’s judgement on Mr Hutch’s costs application this evening, Ms Justice Tara Burns sitting with Judge Sarah Berkeley and Judge Grainne Malone said that an unfairness did not arise in denying the applicant his costs and there was a reasonable possibility that nothing was carried out by the Hutch Organised Crime Group (HOCG) without Mr Hutch’s “say so”.

Ms Justice Burns, presiding, in the non-jury court, said that whilst the court had rejected the prosecution case that Mr Hutch was one of the shooters in the Regency attack, the court was satisfied that he was recognised as the “figurehead” and “patriarchal figure of the HOCG”, an organisation which the court had found was responsible for and had orchestrated the attack.

She said that although the applicant was acquitted of the murder charge against him, there were other relevant considerations in the mix.

“He was involved in serious criminal conduct underlying the charge against him in terms of his possession of the guns from the Regency which he knew had been used to murder David Byrne,” she stated.

The judge said in the context of the murder charge, the Special Criminal Court was asked to determine that he had possession of the three AK-47′s by March 7 2016 at least, as part of the case that he was guilty of the murder of Mr Byrne.

She went on to say that: “The court was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt this was the case, this was serious criminal conduct by him accompanied by specific knowledge the guns were used in the Regency attack and had been used to murder David Byrne.”

In summary, Ms Justice Burns ruled that it was not unfair to deny Mr Hutch his costs and refused his application.

Earlier today, lawyers for Mr Hutch argued that he was “vindicated” by the Special Criminal Court after he was acquitted of the murder of Mr Byrne at the Regency Hotel last April and that there was “no strong, valid ground” as to why their client shouldn’t be entitled to his legal costs for the trial.

Mr Hutch’s defence lawyer Brendan Grehan SC alongside Michael D Hourigan BL submitted that it would be unfair if their client, who was not legally aided, was “denied the substantial costs of defending himself from the allegation and particularly unfair if there was any suggestion that he could or would have been charged with other offences”.

Counsel said whilst Mr Hutch was acquitted of the only charge brought against him, it was important to “lay down as a marker” that “others decide what charges are brought”.

Mr Grehan told the non-jury court that the initial decision to prosecute his client for the offence of murder based on secret audio recordings was “a wrong decision”, which had since been vindicated by the Special Criminal Court’s judgment.

“In our submission the prosecution for murder was never warranted on the audio in the context of which there were multiple matters which the court had averred to. In terms of what Mr Hutch knew or didn’t know, there isn’t one single unambiguous admission of involvement of what happened in the Regency through ten hours of unguarded conversation,” he submitted.

The lawyer added that “it certainly was the case” that former Sinn Fein councillor and convicted torturer Jonathan Dowdall had “played his hand” to exert the maximum amount of pressure on the prosecution before giving a statement to gardai on the eve of the trial, which had resulted in a fundamental reappraisal of the defence case.

His side had not unduly elongated the trial and only sought a two-week adjournment after the DPP accepted Dowdall’s plea to the lesser charge.

“One is left wondering what the prosecution case ever was before Jonathan Dowdall came on board. Dowdall coming on board, rather than strengthening what was there in any way, had the opposite effect,” he added.

The lawyer said his lengthy cross-examination of Dowdall was necessary to expose “his true nature” and the issue of his credibility given the allegations he was making against Mr Hutch. The barrister said the stance taken by the defence had been vindicated by the court’s judgement.

Mr Grehan said it did seem extraordinary that the kind of due diligence that resulted in the cross-examination of Dowdall by the defence did not appear to have occurred in the prosecution’s examination of him as a witness.

“The type of due diligence regarding the gathering of information on Dowdall does not seem to have been done prior to him being called as a witness,” he said.

Taking the court’s findings about other matters into account in deciding costs would be contrary to the principle of innocent until proven guilty, and create a danger of guilt by association especially when operating in the context of other family members, counsel said. People can choose their friends but not their family, he stated.

Mr Grehan said Mr Hutch was acquitted of the only charge against him and that the Special Criminal Court had given detailed and very firm findings in their judgement so that no one was left in any doubt as to why it arrived at its conclusion.

Mr Grehan went on to say there was no dispute that the starting point for an award of costs is a person being acquitted and that the actual result of a prosecution is still the most important consideration when regarding the award. He said Mr Hutch on the advice of his lawyers had not made an application for legal aid.

However, Sean Gillane SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), argued that the costs issue comes down to judicial discretion in relation to the facts and circumstances of the case.

He stated that it was not unfair to remind the court of some of the findings it made in relation to Mr Hutch as Mr Grehan had submitted that the court’s verdict “involved some kind of vindication of Gerard Hutch”. “The court’s verdict does not amount to an approbation of him or his conduct,” he argued.

Mr Gillane said he took “full responsibility” for decisions made in the carriage of the prosecution case. There was, he said, an established sequence of Mr Hutch’s association with firearms used to carry out the killing of Mr Byrne.

“It’s not a passing or glancing association. It’s an involved possession and contribution to what the court found to be an orchestrated series of events to have these weapons moved,” he said.

Mr Gillane said it was clearly not the law that a conviction was required for an award of legal costs and that Mr Hutch had previously conducted himself in “such a way as to bring suspicion on himself”.

This investigation involved a number of agencies, the collection of an “incredible” range of material and the assessment of evidence in connection with a number of people.

“This was a prosecution of originally five people, against four of whom convictions were recorded and substantial sentences imposed and in terms of the global picture the prosecution [of Mr Hutch] was absolutely warranted,” he submitted.

The barrister said this was a case where an award of costs should not be exercised in Mr Hutch’s favour and urged the court not to award costs in this matter.

Mr Hutch (60) was seeking an order from the Special Criminal Court providing for his legal costs on the basis of his acquittal by the non-jury court last April.

The hearing on the costs application, which the State opposed, went ahead today on the first day of the Trinity term before the three-judge court.

Last April, following the 52-day trial at the Special Criminal Court, Mr Hutch was acquitted by the three judges of the murder of Mr Byrne and walked from court a free man.

It is believed Mr Hutch left Ireland for Spain last month but it is unknown if the father-of-five has permanently moved back to Spain.

In acquitting Mr Hutch, the Special Criminal Court found that it could not rely on the unsupported evidence of Jonathan Dowdall.

It also found that surveillance audio recordings of a conversation between Dowdall and Mr Hutch did not corroborate Dowdall’s claim that Mr Hutch had confessed to being one of the hitmen at the Regency Hotel where Mr Byrne was shot dead.

Mr Hutch (60), of The Paddocks, Clontarf, Dublin 3, had denied the murder of Kinahan Cartel member David Byrne (33) during a boxing weigh-in at the Regency Hotel on the Swords Road, Whitehall, Dublin 9 on 5 February, 2016.

News Related


Cleaning fanatics share £1 trick to banish condensation from windows this winter

This easy and cheap trick will banish the condensation from your windows As the colder weather approaches, with frosty mornings and icy temperatures, people will start to make small tweaks ... Read more »

GOP lawmaker accidentally creates hilarious new nickname for Trump

A Republican lawmaker inadvertently created a hilarious new nickname for Donald Trump by making a verbal slip while speaking on the floor of the US House of Representatives. Representative Andy ... Read more »

George and Amal prove they are the most powerful couple in Hollywood as the elite flock to their charity awards

Is there anybody that George and Amal Clooney don’t know and are they possibly the most powerful couple in Hollywood/America? Their Albie Awards held by the Clooney Foundation for Justice ... Read more »

Honda CT125 Gets New Bright And Sunny Yellow Color In Thailand

2023 Honda CT125 – Yellow SunGlow Poster Thailand New color, same price. If you’re someone who’s been lamenting the drab colors that seem to dominate many a motorcycle lineup in the ... Read more »

Ice Spice 'confused' by The 1975's Matty Healy's racist remarks

Ice Spice ‘confused’ by The 1975’s Matty Healy’s racist remarks Ice Spice was “confused” by Matty Healy’s racist remarks about her but “didn’t really care”. The 1975 frontman called the ... Read more »

Europe's stars shine and the Americans collapse in astonishing Ryder Cup opening

USA 1.5 EUROPE’S RYDER CUP team today affirmed what was once said in Rome: the fault is not among their stars. Jon Rahm, Viktor Hovland, and Rory McIlroy led Europe’s ... Read more »

Million-Dollar Barn Find Uncovers Classic Corvettes With Less Than 100 Miles

Barn Find Corvettes Among 23 cars is a 25-mile 1990 ZR-1, a 1979 Stingray with 41 miles, and for truck fans, there’s a 1990 Chevy 454 SS with 19 miles. ... Read more »

Cocaine seizure: Two men rescued from stricken Wexford trawler appear in court charged with conspiracy to import drugs

Two men have appeared before Waterford District Court charged with conspiracy to import drugs. Jamie Harbron (31) with an address listed at 26 South Avenue, Billingham, Stockton on Tees, UK ... Read more »

Noel Fielding says Bake Off fans ‘freaked’ out over complicated format last year

Noel Fielding said ‘this year we’ve gone back to some classics’ (Matt Crossick/PA) Noel Fielding has said The Great British Bake Off has gone back to basics this year as ... Read more »

Ryder Cup 2023: 'Act like a child': Brooks Koepka takes a wild shot at Jon Rahm after tense match

ROME, ITALY – SEPTEMBER 29: Brooks Koepka of Team United States looks on on the 11th hole during the Friday afternoon fourball matches of the 2023 Ryder Cup at Marco ... Read more »

EastEnders star Vicki Michelle heartbroken after ‘baby sister’ dies as she pays tribute

‘Allo ‘Allo! star Vicki Michelle has been left utterly heartbroken as her beloved “baby sister” Suzie has sadly died. The comedy actress, 72, who most recently appeared on EastEnders, shared ... Read more »

Greggs is giving out free food and there really isn't a catch

Just sign up to the app and enjoy (Picture: Getty Images) We all love a Greggs, and when it’s free, we reckon it’ll taste even better. Sometimes, it feels impossible ... Read more »

Red Bull never considered Mercedes concept: 'We went by our gut feeling'

Red Bull never considered Mercedes concept: ‘We went by our gut feeling’ In Formula 1, people are always looking to the competition for inspiration. Even Adrian Newey, responsible for one ... Read more »

Woman living in real Gavin and Stacey house gets surprise of her life

Glenda Kenyon had a birthday she will never forget (Picture: Wales News Service/BBC) The woman living in Gavin and Stacey’s real home was overwhelmed when dozens of fans showed up ... Read more »

The UK prison dubbed 'Monster Mansion' where only the worst criminals are locked up

The B-wing at Wakefield Prison, West Yorkshire The roll call of men locked up at Wakefield prison includes some of Britain’s most notorious and violent criminals. It is one of ... Read more »

Record high number of children in emergency accommodation, August figures show

Record high number of children in emergency accommodation, August figures show MORE THAN 12,000 people slept in emergency accommodation around the country in August, including a record-high number of children. ... Read more »

Strictly's Adam Thomas forced to miss training ahead of Tango on second live show

Strictly Come Dancing contestant Adam Thomas has shared with fans that he has been forced to miss some rehearsing time with his dancing partner Luba Mushtuk ahead of Saturday’s show. ... Read more »

'I was frustrated not to be in the last squad' – Belfast boy Sykes targets Ireland recall

Mark Sykes believes that his form with Championship side Bristol City merits a recall to the senior Ireland squad. Following his decision to declare for the Republic of Ireland, after ... Read more »

Carjacker kills woman by zip-tying her throat - before leaving eerie note

A carjacker killed a woman by zip-tying her throat – before leaving behind an eerie note apologising for the horrific killing. Suspect Reese Miller, 24, was caught driving a blue ... Read more »

Susanna Reid replaced on GMB again as she continues to struggle after the NTAs

Susanna Reid has apologised to her followers as she revealed that she would not be presenting Good Morning Britain again on Monday as she continues to recover from an illness. ... Read more »

Meghan Markle's unprecedented pre-royal interview 'left Palace furious'

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle have always done things their way when it comes to their relationship, ripping up the royal rule book at every twist and turn. While many ... Read more »

Thousands of local authority workers begin industrial action today

FÓRSA TRADE UNION members working in local authorities are beginning industrial action today. The union, which represents over 12,000 local authority workers, said that the decision to take action comes ... Read more »

Mother-of-one (48) is jailed for 506th conviction after stealing handbag from coffee shop

A serial thief with 505 prior convictions who stole from a woman’s handbag in a coffee shop has been jailed for four months. Mother-of-one Catherine Lambert (48) clocked up her ... Read more »

Tony Ward: If Johnny Sexton stays in this form and injury-free, Ireland will give World Cup one hell of a rattle

Johnny Sexton holds his hand after picking up a knock when scoring his first-half try Think back to those schooldays, to that dreaded final public exam, and this in a ... Read more »

Postcard from the TGV: An odyssey of a World Cup weekend

THE SUN IS rising to the right of the train as we speed past Lyon and on towards Paris. Another lovely day is upon France although, mercifully, it’s set to ... Read more »

Kingspan said to make rebuffed proposal for tie-up with Carlisle

Kingspan Group Plc made an informal approach to combine with American firm Carlisle Cos., which rebuffed the move to build a global building materials giant, people familiar with the matter ... Read more »

Americans look back on 9/11 and remember the victims on 22nd anniversary

A man leans on parapet surrounding the South reflecting pool of World Trade Center 9 11 Memorial. AMERICANS ARE LOOKING back on the horror and legacy of September 11, gathering ... Read more »

Ukraine LIVE: Russia to send ‘thousands of zombies' to fight in Putin's war of ‘madness'

Putin is increasing its professional soldier pool, according to the British MoD Russia intends to recruit more than a hundred thousand professional recruits and prisoners to “avoid further unpopular mobilisations”, ... Read more »

NFL Fans Are Praying For Family Of Legendary Giants Star

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. – DECEMBER 14: Quarterback Phil Simms #11 of the New York Giants huddles with the offense, including wide receiver Stacy Robinson #81 and tight end Mark Bavaro ... Read more »

Jimmy Nesbitt reveals Late Late Show date with Patrick Kielty as he tips Irish rugby team for World Cup success

Jimmy Nesbitt has revealed he will appear on the Late Late Show this month — with the actor currently in Northern Ireland training for a gruelling endurance challenge in aid ... Read more »
Top List in the World