Germany's post-Merkel Middle East policy: What to expect

© Provided by Al Jazeera German Chancellor Angela Merkel, left, talks to Saudi Arabia’s State Minister Ibrahim al-Assaf, prior to a working session at the G-20 summit in Hamburg, northern Germany, Saturday, July 8, 2017 [Michael Sohn/AP]

On September 26, Germany’s general election will usher in the end of Angela Merkel’s 16-year reign as head of government.

Merkel’s legacy in the Middle East can be assessed as twofold, often noble goals clashed with reality. After Merkel, Berlin should not be expected to significantly change course in the Middle East.

Even so, Merkel’s successor, whether Annalena Baerbock (Greens), Armin Laschet (CDU) or Olaf Scholz (SPD), will have to answer questions relating to Germany’s position on arms sales, Israel-Palestine and refugees in the Middle East.

On the one hand, Germany has been a harbinger of peace in the region, a promoter of democracy, the rule of law, championing arms control and human rights while providing refuge to individuals in peril.

On the other hand, however, the Merkel years are also synonymous with significant German arms sales into the region.

This was not driven by a grand strategy or a stringent foreign policy doctrine, but primarily by economic interests, with the Middle East being home to the countries with the highest global demand for military equipment, Thomas Jager, professor of international politics and foreign policy at Cologne University, told Al Jazeera.

Germany is one of the largest arms exporting countries globally, Pieter D Wezeman, senior researcher at the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI), told Al Jazeera.

“In 20016-2020, SIPRI estimates that Germany accounted for 5.5 percent of global arms exports, globally and 3.9 percent of arms imports in the Middle East, making it the fourth-biggest exporter,” he said.

This explains why actors such as Egypt or Saudi Arabia – despite widespread accusations that both commit serious rights abuses – have long been championed as valuable trade partners.

This dichotomy of business interests and humanitarianism under Merkel is reasonably common in international relations, Jager noted.

“States, especially successful states, always base their foreign policy on a solid double standard. Idealism and realism go hand in hand.

“Germany pursues the goals of not supplying into international conflicts and not supplying states that pursue foreign policy goals by military means. However, the latter seemingly does not apply to actors in the Middle East, and yet arms are sold to these states – and on a large scale.”

In 2020, the Merkel government approved arms exports worth 1.16 billion euros ($1.36bn) to countries involved in conflicts in Yemen or Libya.

The overall value of German military equipment export licences to Saudi Arabia amounted to 3.3 billion euros ($3.87bn) over the past nine years, as Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik (SWP) assessed in 2020 – even as exports to the kingdom halted in 2018 following the killing of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi.

Israel also benefits. Merkel has repeatedly underscored Berlin’s unconditional support for Israel by declaring its security was “Staatsrason”, or raison d’état.

Israel has received military equipment from Berlin, particularly during the Merkel years. To this day, Germany remains the second-biggest exporter of arms to Israel, accounting for 24 percent of Israel’s imports between 2009 and 2020.

© Provided by Al Jazeera Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and German Chancellor Angela Merkel pose photographers between meetings in Jerusalem, Thursday, October 4, 2018 [Oded Balilty/AP/Pool]

These include Dolphin submarines, weapon components and technology used for Israeli tanks, speedboats, and helicopters.

Some of this technology has already been used directly in conflict. Israeli tanks with German engines were used in Gaza, and Saudi Typhoon aircraft were used in Yemen, Wezeman noted.

“In general, countries like Germany that pursue a foreign policy that strives to support peace, development and human rights should carefully and regularly examine whether their arms exports policies are truly embedded in such foreign policies – or extend economic motivations or assumptions about the role of weapons supplies in strengthening relations with and influence in states in the Middle East may have been prioritised,” said Wezeman.

Merkel’s government has never felt the urge to genuinely reconsider its policy, as the topic is not a domestic controversy.

“It is not a major issue in Germany and for the public of minor interest. However, it is a highly political point of contention, a clear right-left schema, with the right supporting the policy for economic and political reasons, and the left opposing it,” Jager said.

However, with the coming vote, a paradigm shift could emerge in the form of a left-wing government.

“It will be exciting to see whether a new left-wing federal government really changes arms export policy. In opposition, they – the Greens, who will almost certainly be part of the new government – certainly talk that way,” Jager said.

During the election campaign, foreign policy issues have been limited to pledges of maintaining Germany’s alliances and commitments in the world.

Moreover, given that the new government will probably consist of a three-party coalition, it is difficult to guess the direction such a coalition will eventually take – with one exception: Israel.

As far as Germany’s Israel policy is concerned, notable changes on its strong support for the state are hugely unlikely, Christian Hacke, emeritus professor at the Institute for Political Science and Sociology at the University of Bonn, told Al Jazeera.

“A solid and close relationship with Israel as a continuum will remain part of Germany’s Staatsrason.”

Neither candidate will alter Germany’s status quo in the conflict between Israel and Palestinians.

Even if one were inclined to do so, the options are rather limited.

“Germany has little influence on the Israel-Palestine conflict, and the struggle itself is not one of the diverging interests in the European context,” Hacke said.

In general, it is fair to assume that the Middle East will not become a focus of German politics even after Merkel.

However, the refugee problem, “created by the West through 20 years of failed humanitarian interventions”, will require more commitment and help, Hacke said.

Here, all three candidates could make a mark as Merkel’s successor, and have indeed already pledged to do so.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Limerick journalist Tom English makes shortlist for William Hill Sports Book of the Year

THIS IS YOUR Everest, co-authored by Limerick journalist Tom English, is one of six books on the shortlist for the 2021 William Hill Sports Book of the Year award. The ... Read more »

SpaceX is launching its 4th astronaut crew to the International Space Station for NASA on Halloween - watch it live

© SpaceX The Crew-3 astronauts, left to right: ESA astronaut Matthias Maurer and NASA astronauts Thomas Marshburn, Raja Chari, and Kayla Barron. SpaceX SpaceX plans to launch its fourth NASA ... Read more »

Apprentice beats the mister: Dionisi downs Allegri as Juventus lose again

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Chris Ricco/Getty Images Before kick-off at Allianz Stadium, Alessio Dionisi posed for photographs with Massimiliano Allegri. There was a faint awkwardness to the scene, ... Read more »

Ireland Baldwin 'threatened' over Rust shooting

© Bang Showbiz Ireland Baldwin Ireland Baldwin has received “threatening comments” in the wake of her dad, Alec Baldwin, being involved in an accidental shooting on the set of ‘Rust’. ... Read more »

Singapore Airlines schedules A380 flights lasting just 60 MINUTES

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Short-haul flights don’t get any fancier than this (unless you’re in a private jet). From Thursday, November 4, Singapore Airlines – voted the ... Read more »

Opinion: As Astros' swagger returns, it faces only thing that could stop it: Atlanta's home dominance

HOUSTON — Astros rookie center fielder Jose Siri welcomed All-Star second baseman Jose Altuve to the press conference stage as Siri sat with his sweatsuit unzipped halfway down his chest, ... Read more »

Biden to announce new framework on spending deal: report

President Biden on Thursday will present a new framework for Democrats’ social spending and climate proposal, The Washington Post reported. © UPI Photo President Biden delivers remarks at NJ Transit ... Read more »

Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe: Richard Ratcliffe to meet Foreign Secretary amid hunger strike

© PA Wire Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe detained Richard Ratcliffe is due to meet the Foreign Secretary to discuss further strategy around attempts to free his wife. The meeting with Liz Truss ... Read more »

Bajaj Pulsar 250 India launch highlights: Pulsar F250 and N250 revealed, priced from Rs 1.38 lakh

© Provided by Firstpost Bajaj Pulsar 250 India launch highlights: Pulsar F250 and N250 revealed, priced from Rs 1.38 lakh 14:16 (IST) All-new Bajaj Pulsar F250 and N250 launched in ... Read more »

The whirlwind romance that started with a private flight

Sallie Kuria relocated to Germany from Kenya in 2010, unsure what to expect but ready to embrace a new adventure. © Courtesy Sallie and Klaus Müller © Courtesy Sallie and ... Read more »

Comcast quarterly revenue tops estimates despite slowdown in cable business

By Eva Mathews and Helen Coster © Reuters/Mike Blake FILE PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: The Comcast NBC logo is shown on a building in Los Angeles, California (Reuters) – Comcast Corp’s ... Read more »

Share price special: The LSE stocks that jumped 1,000% in the last decade

© Provided by City AM Ocado, Jet2 and JD Sports are among the big-name companies which have seen their share prices jump over 1,000 per cent in the past 10 ... Read more »

Here's what the letters C and T mean on a rapid test — and why they're used

© Alexandre Silberman/CBC News If your antigen test result reveals a letter C — you’re in the clear. If you’re one of the thousands of New Brunswickers who picked up ... Read more »

Best iPhone apps of 2021

Apps have become a staple in our lives over the past decade. In the wake of the coronavirus pandemic that struck in 2020, many apps saw an install spike as ... Read more »

Nykaa IPO opens: Issue subscribed 1.35 times so far on first day of bidding, retail portion booked 3.29 times

© Sunil Matkar Nykaa IPO opens: Issue subscribed 1.35 times so far on first day of bidding, retail portion booked 3.29 times The public issue of FSN E-Commerce Ventures, backed by ... Read more »

States Struggle With ‘Unfair' School Funding, Report Finds

More than half of states have per-pupil funding levels below the national average – part of an overall bleak picture of U.S. public education painted by a report released Thursday. ... Read more »

Here Are Some Trending Kitchen Floor Designs That Will Elevate The Look Of Your Cooking Space

The most popular part of the home is surely the kitchen. From grandpa to the little one, everyone surely visits the kitchen at least one time in a day. Therefore, ... Read more »

Is this a UFO? Video captured by pilots claims to show ‘pulsating orb' drop out of the sky

A video filmed by pilots claims to show a “pulsating orb” falling from the sky — and experts think it could be a UFO. © NARCAP Is this a UFO? ... Read more »

Yinka Ilori builds colourful Lego launderette in east London for kids to play in

Designer Yinka Ilori has worked with Lego to create the Launderette of Dreams, an installation in London that reimagines the everyday community space as a children’s play zone. © Provided ... Read more »

Zuwanderung 2020 wegen Pandemie um einen Drittel zurückgegangen

© KEYSTONE/PETER SCHNEIDER Die Zuwanderung in die OECD-Länder ist im Jahr 2020 wegen der Corona-Pandemie um rund einen Drittel zurückgegangen. Die dauerhafte Migration war mit rund 3,7 Millionen Menschen auf ... Read more »

Champagne and prosecco to become cheaper but cost of higher-alcohol drinks to rise

© Provided by The Independent Fans of sparkling wine, champagne and prosecco can raise a glass after the Chancellor revealed that he is reducing duties on them, which will see ... Read more »

Activists say millions will not benefit from tax cut for the low paid

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Charities have branded the changes to Universal Credit ‘the tale of two budgets for low income families’ and said they do not go ... Read more »

Rollout of antigen tests to vaccinated close contacts begins

Close contacts of a confirmed Covid-19 case who are fully vaccinated and asymptomatic will now receive a box of antigen tests. © Andrew Milligan The free antigen tests are available ... Read more »

Dubai-based golf prodigy Chiara Noja on taking the sports industry by storm

© Motivate Publishing Chiara Noja At just 15-years-old, Chiara Noja has made remarkable strides in the golfing world and is making her mark around the globe. By balancing both school ... Read more »

Man Creates Video Job Application Grooving to 'I Will Survive', Gets Dozens of Offers

© Provided by News18 Man Creates Video Job Application Grooving to ‘I Will Survive’, Gets Dozens of Offers COVID-19 pandemic has been a tough time not just for the public ... Read more »

Strictly's Nikita's girlfriend admits 'I'm much stronger than I thought' in cryptic post

Strictly Come Dancing star Nikita Kuzmin’s girlfriend Nicole Wirt has admitted she’s ‘much stronger’ as rumours continue to swirl about his close friendship with Tilly Ramsay. Taking to Instagram on ... Read more »

Is Orange the new Black? Shilpa Shetty to Deepika Padukone: 6 Times Celebs decked up head to toe in orange

Celebrities have tried and tested all colours as they continue to experiment over seasons and with upcoming trends. Although bright and colourful shades are always equivalent to summer and spring, ... Read more »

Instagram makes Link stickers available to all users: Here's how you can add them to your story

© Provided by Firstpost Instagram makes Link stickers available to all users: Here’s how you can add them to your story Instagram’s Link Stickers will now be available to all ... Read more »

Cryptocurrency prices today: Meme coins take charge as Dogecoin, Shiba Inu surge

Bitcoin, Ether, Litecoin and Dogecoin price Popular cryptocurrency prices have weakened over the past 24 hours due to heavy profit booking by investors. While popular virtual coin prices bounced back ... Read more »

Brexit impact on economy 'will be worse than the coronavirus pandemic'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Brexit will have a bigger negative impact on the UK’s economy than the coronavirus pandemic in the long term, the chairman of Britain’s ... Read more »

Schock: Tödliche Bananenspinne klettert Autofahrerin auf den Bauch

© mtreasure/iStock Spinne auf Bananen Eine Frau aus Hessen machte ihren Einkauf und kaufte u. a. Bananen. Auf der Autofahrt nach Hause kletterte dann eine tödliche Spinne aus der Einkaufstüte. ... Read more »

Coronavirus: UAE reports 88 new cases and 142 recoveries

© Provided by The National A billboard near the Business Bay Metro station on Sheikh Zayed Road is put up to thank the Covid-19 vaccine volunteers in the UAE. Antonie ... Read more »

EXPLAINER: Why are schools revisiting gifted education?

FILE – In this Thursday Oct. 14, 2021, file photo, protesters at City Hall condemn Mayor Bill de Blasio’s plan to phase out the Gifted and Talented (G&T) public school ... Read more »

New GQ editor Adam Baidawi to give magazine ‘fresh' vision

Adam Baidawi has been named the new editor of GQ (Getty Images) British GQ’s new editor wants to bring “a fresh set of eyes” to the magazine — taking the ... Read more »

Rent crisis: Housing charities warn government's £65m rescue package ‘barely touches sides' of £440m arrears

Housing charities have warned a £65m rescue package of support for private renters who have built up arrears during the pandemic will ‘barely touch the sides’ of the crisis. The ... Read more »

Football Manager 2022 release date, new features and beta early access details

Sports Interactive’s Football Manager 2022 will be released very soon, with a host of new features added to this year’s game. Some of the FM22’s new features include a brand ... Read more »

Barcelona manager situation leaves Everton in strange position

Almost four years to the day since Ronald Koeman was sacked by Everton, the Dutchman was relieved of his duties once more. On the day he left Goodison Park, it’s ... Read more »

Drittes Problem in einem Monat: Bund kann derzeit keine Covid-Zertifikate ausstellen

Der Bund kann nach eigenen Angaben derzeit keine Covid-Zertifikate ausstellen. Die Überprüfung bereits ausgestellter Zertifikate sei nicht betroffen. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Der Bund meldet erneut eine technische Störung beim ... Read more »

Wegen Pandemie: Zuwanderung um einen Drittel zurückgegangen

Die Zuwanderung in die OECD-Länder ist im Jahr 2020 wegen der Corona-Pandemie um rund einen Drittel zurückgegangen. Die dauerhafte Migration war mit rund 3,7 Millionen Menschen auf dem niedrigsten Stand ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic