German-funded inquiry into DRC atrocities slammed as ‘cover-up’

Photos appear to support the claim that Indigenous villagers were killed in a drive to force them from Kahuzi-Biega Park.

German-funded inquiry into DRC atrocities slammed as ‘cover-up’

ICCN rangers were accused of human rights abuses [File: AFP]

A series of audio recordings, images and leaked documents obtained exclusively by Al Jazeera’s Investigative Unit (I-Unit) appear to show the failures of a German government-funded inquiry into reports of killings at the Kahuzi-Biega National Park in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC).

The Commission of Inquiry, which investigated allegations that park guards and Congolese soldiers killed members of the Batwa Indigenous community in the park between 2019 and 2021, reported on June 1 that no widespread atrocities had taken place.

The inquiry was set up in April after a report published by the London-based human rights organisation Minority Rights Group International (MRG) documented a deadly campaign to expel Indigenous Batwa people from their native land in the park.

The report concluded at least 20 members of the Batwa Indigenous community were killed in the park by “joint contingents” of park guards and Congolese soldiers in three waves of violent attacks.

A researcher and the journalist who authored the MRG report say that since the report was published, they have been forced to go into hiding after receiving a tip-off that armed men had been sent to kill them.

A series of photographs obtained by the journalist, Robert Flummerfelt, and shared exclusively with the I-Unit, appear to show the bodies of villagers in the park after alleged attacks by park guards and Congolese soldiers.

The photographs show several people who appear to have been fatally shot and stabbed in the park after what Flummerfelt says were violent raids between July 2019 and December 2021.

The images, which Al Jazeera was unable to independently verify, also depict a body that appears to have been mutilated with a series of deep machete slashes across its torso.

The journalist, Robert Flummerfelt, says he believes park guards and Congolese soldiers carried out the raids as part of a coordinated campaign to expel Indigenous communities from the park to make the area more attractive for foreign conservationists and foreign tourists. He alleges that at least 20 villagers were killed and Batwa women were gang-raped.

German-funded inquiry into DRC atrocities slammed as ‘cover-up’

Aerial photograph showing some of the destruction [Robert Flummerfelt/Al Jazeera]

The Kahuzi-Biega National Park, which receives the majority of its funding from the German government, is home to the critically endangered eastern lowland gorilla, and it is one of the DRC’s most important tourist attractions.

The controversy over events at the park escalated on June 1, when the German government-funded Commission of Inquiry into the alleged killings dismissed Flummerfelt’s claims and found that park rangers and Congolese soldiers had not committed widespread atrocities.

The commission said park guards had been forced to defend themselves against “armed” Batwa villagers, and that some Batwa had been killed in crossfire when they were used as “human shields” in clashes between park guards and poachers.

The commission’s findings were condemned by Flummerfelt as “a cover-up”. “It can’t be characterised in any other way,” he told Al Jazeera.

“There are circumstances of the direct intimidation of witnesses, the treating of Batwa victims with open contempt, literally laughing about reports that Batwa women were subjected to group rape.”

“I was there with the commission,” said Flummerfelt, who was invited as a participant on the commission. “There were no firsthand, even second-hand accounts of Batwa being used as human shields. And yet this [claim] is used as a sort of flimsy justification for evidence of the fact that Batwa were killed.”

Flummerfelt and his researcher, who wishes to remain anonymous for safety reasons, had gathered accounts of the alleged atrocities for the report commissioned by MRG.

“[We] spoke to eyewitness sources who described park guards opening fire on civilians, killing a number of Batwa, sometimes execution-style,” Flummerfelt said.

“Sometimes members of the community [were forced] to watch while their family members were executed,” he added.

“[Witnesses also described park guards] subjecting Batwa women to group rape at gunpoint.”

Recordings of ‘witness intimidation’

The report compiled by Flummerfelt and his Congolese researcher led to the establishment of the Commission of Inquiry to investigate their claims.

The inquiry was led by a senior official from the Institute for Nature Conservation (ICCN), the Congolese government agency that runs the park.

“In effect, the ICCN was investigating itself, an enormous conflict of interest,” Flummerfelt said.

In audio recordings obtained by the I-Unit, the commission head, George Muzibaziba, can be heard appearing to intimidate witnesses who were giving accounts of violence against Batwa villagers.

In one recording from mid-April, Muzibaziba is heard telling one Batwa leader, Chief Mbuwa Kalimba Bacirembera, that he must “take responsibility” for his community being attacked by militia groups should ICCN guards and Congolese soldiers need to leave the area as a result of the testimony he had provided.

In another interview, conducted in mid-April, Muzibaziba is recorded informing a witness that the information being provided would be “dangerous” for the witness. Another commission member then interrupts Muzibaziba, saying, “George, don’t intimidate him.”

On the recordings, ICCN lawyers can also be heard laughing at the mention of the gang rape and death of a Batwa woman.

German-funded inquiry into DRC atrocities slammed as ‘cover-up’

[Robert Flummerfelt/Al Jazeera]

Due to fears for his safety, the Congolese researcher working with Flummerfelt had not divulged his full name to the Commission of Inquiry. However, the limited personal details he did provide were leaked, providing enough information for him to be identified.

“Within three days, the highly specific information provided to the commission about my colleague’s identity is available to the people in the Congolese government,” Flummerfelt told Al Jazeera.

After being tipped off about credible threats to their lives, Flummerfelt and the researcher fled into hiding.

A witness, who asked not to be identified, told Al Jazeera that ICCN guards “won’t tire until they get [Flummerfelt] and [the Congolese researcher]. To kill someone isn’t a problem for them”.

The head of the Commission of Inquiry, George Muzibaziba, dismissed allegations that ICCN park rangers were targeting Flummerfelt and the researcher, describing the claims as “very wrong”.

Chief Mbuwa Kalimba Bacirembera and another Batwa leader, Chief Gonzalo Malenga Majafa, are also in hiding, believing that their appearances before the inquiry have placed their lives in danger.

“They received credible threats that people who work for the institution in the Congolese government, the ICCN, were hunting them, so as to punish them for communicating to the commission the fact that members of the community were subjected to group rape and killed and attacked and so forth,” Flummerfelt said.

‘Massive human rights violations’

Since the release of the commission’s report, a member of Germany’s parliament described events within the Kahuzi-Biega National Park as “massive human rights violations”.

Deborah Düring, the parliamentary spokeswoman for International Cooperation and Development for The Greens in the German Bundestag, said, “The Batwa have to be heard and their rights have to be respected.”

“I think it’s clear that we’re dealing with structural problems, not isolated incidents,” Düring said.

She said the German government and international donors needed to ensure that “crimes and allegations are fully investigated and those responsible held accountable”.

German-funded inquiry into DRC atrocities slammed as ‘cover-up’

A makeshift grave for a victim of the atrocities [Robert Flummerfelt/Al Jazeera]

‘False claims’

In response to a question about whether park staff were involved in killings, mass rapes and the forced expulsion of Batwa villagers, Muzibaziba suggested that Al Jazeera “refer yourself to the published report”.

Muzibaziba said he believed Flummerfelt had made “false claims” about violence in the park. He described Flummerfelt’s research as “reductionist … evasive and non-thorough”, and said his report alleging atrocities against the Batwa was “highly biased”.

Muzibaziba denied intimidating witnesses who gave evidence to the Commission of Inquiry. He also denied leaking the identity of the Congolese researcher. He described the commission’s work as “fair and objective”.

A spokesman for the German Federal Ministry of Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), which funds the bulk of the costs of running the park, told Al Jazeera that they are “deeply disturbed by accounts of threats and intimidation allegedly levelled against witnesses and sources by members of the Commission”.

Nevertheless, the ministry has “confidence” in the commission’s methodology. In light of the allegations of atrocities committed, the BMZ will “reflect on its continuing support for Kahuzi-Biega”.

Source: Al Jazeera

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Diana Ross reels off the hits during legends slot at Glastonbury

A huge audience gathered to watch the 78-year-old star on the Pyramid Stage. Soul singer Diana Ross fills the Sunday teatime legends slot on the Pyramid Stage during the Glastonbury ... Read more »

UFC Vegas 57: Umar Nurmagomedov hype train continues with victory over Nate Maness

Umar Nurmagomedov showcased his talents as he delivered a stunning performance to beat Nate Maness at UFC Vegas 57. Read more »

Maharashtra reports 6,493 new Covid cases in a day; active count at 24,608

A BMC health worker collects swab sample of a passenger for COVID-19 test, at the CSMT station in Mumbai. (PTI Photo) Maharashtra on Sunday reported 6,493 COVID-19 cases and five ... Read more »

MP cricket team to get grand public welcome for Ranji win, says CM

Madhya Pradesh team taking a bow after winning the Ranji Trophy Final. Photo: @BCCIdomestic The Madhya Pradesh cricket team will be accorded a public welcome for winning the prestigious Ranji ... Read more »

Moment of a lifetime for me: MP captain Shrivastava after winning Ranji

Aditya Shrivastava MP captain with Ranji Trophy winning trophy. Photo: @BCCIdomestic Being the captain of a Madhya Pradesh team winning the 2021/22 Ranji Trophy is a moment of a lifetime, ... Read more »

Is Abortion Illegal in the U.S. Now? Depends Where You Live

(AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File) The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday overturned Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision that had provided a constitutional right to abortion. The ruling is expected to lead to ... Read more »

Afghanistan earthquake: Will this disaster bring the Taliban back to the international table

The Afghanistan authorities estimate at least 1,150 people died in Tuesday's earthquake, while the UN says at least 770 people perished. With severe drought and soaring poverty, the Taliban needs international help more than ever. Read more »

21st century India is leading Industry 4.0 revolution: PM Modi in Germany

File image of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Wikimedia Commons/PMO Munich: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday said that 21st century India is at the forefront of Industry 4.0 and asserted ... Read more »

Humbly accept people's mandate in Sangrur bypoll, will continue to work harder: CM Bhagwant Mann

Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann. ANI Chandigarh: With the ruling AAP suffering a shock defeat in the Sangrur Lok Sabha bypoll on Sunday, Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann said he ... Read more »

Bypoll results show only BSP has ideological and ground force to defeat BJP in UP: Mayawati

BSP chief Mayawati. ANI Lucknow: Bahujan Samaj Party chief Mayawati said on Sunday that the Lok Sabha bypoll results proved that only her BSP has the “ground force” to defeat ... Read more »

Two residents rescued in Port Coquitlam apartment fire; dozens displaced

An apartment fire in Port Coquitlam forced dozens from their home overnight. Just after 10 p.m., officials said firefighters responded to flames coming out of a low-rise apartment building on ... Read more »

‘Largest spiritual Indigenous gathering’ to return to Alberta lake during Pope’s visit

Rev. Garry LaBoucane remembers going to Wakamne — or God’s Lake — during the Lac Ste. Anne pilgrimage as a boy. “It was always a family tradition,” the 74-year-old said ... Read more »

Los Angeles Police Arrest Man For Attempted Murder with Flamethrower During Local Roe V. Wade Protests

Street protests over the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade took a violent turn on Friday into Saturday. Two arrests were made in serious incidents involving police and ... Read more »

Christi Paul Exiting As CNN’s ‘New Day Weekend’ Anchor, Heading To Ohio

CNN Longtime CNN weekend anchor Christi Paul today announced on air that she’s leaving the news network. After almost 20 years with CNN and HLN, New Day Weekend anchor Paul ... Read more »

Alex Ferguson of Ranji Trophy: Cricket fraternity hails Chandrakant Pandit

Chandrakant Pandit won the Ranji Trophy with Madhya Pradesh. Photo: @RaviShastriOfc Chandrakant Pandit was on Sunday hailed as “Sir Alex Ferguson of Ranji Trophy” as accolades poured in for the ... Read more »

Sri Lanka introduces fuel rationing for pvt vehicles amid severe shortage

People wait to buy kerosene oil at a gas station in Kandy, Sri Lanka on June 13. (Photo: Bloomberg) Amid the economic crisis in Sri Lanka, the country's Minister of ... Read more »

'Wow...' - talkSPORT man left stunned on-air at Leeds transfer news he's heard from Elland Road

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Premier League – Leeds United v Manchester City talkSPORT pundit Darren Bent was left stunned after Leeds United agreed a £42m fee with Manchester City ... Read more »

Prince Charles risks alienating younger generations over accepting cash from Qatari politician

A PR expert said the story could affect a ‘generation that really wants to focus on values and authenticity’ Read more »

Youtuber que expôs Klara Castanho volta atrás, pede desculpas e se justifica: “Fake news”

© Bolavip No último sábado (25), a youtuber Dri Paz revelou alguns supostos detalhes sobre a gravidez da Klara Castanho. A atriz fez um desabafo em suas redes sociais e, ... Read more »

Neighbours flee homes after high winds whip up Norbury wildfire

One resident said lack of rain and strong winds caused the grass ‘to go up like tinder’ Close A school playing field was swallowed up by a wildfire that charred ... Read more »

At least 21 teenagers die in mysterious circumstances at South Africa nightclub

At least 21 teenagers, the youngest possibly just 13, died at the weekend after a night out at a township nightclub in South Africa, in a tragedy whose cause remains ... Read more »

Bennedict Mathurin boasts LeBron James has to ‘show me he’s better than me’

Indiana Pacers rookie Bennedict Mathurin should be on notice for his first meeting with the Los Angeles Lakers later this season. LeBron James has never been one to take too ... Read more »

Championship's most valuable team worth £137m including Spurs and West Ham targets

The new Championship season is just under five weeks away. The 2022-23 campaign begins slightly earlier than normal, due to the World Cup in Qatar taking place in winter this ... Read more »

Mum defends decision to take kids to cinema after she's shamed over film choice

Heading to the cinema to see a new film can be an exciting day out for many adults and children alike. But one mum has been left fuming after she ... Read more »

Stacey Solomon mocks photos of Joe Swash talking to girl on stag do

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Maximising returns can harm financial health

Imagine this scenario. It’s the final of a 50-over national level tournament. The host side batting second needs one run to win with three balls and one wicket to spare. ... Read more »

SUVs drive Hyundai Motor India's diesel model sales to three-year high

The share of diesel variants in the overall sales mix at Hyundai rose to 27.4 per cent in the first five months of the current calendar year. A strong demand ... Read more »

Green Day star Billie Joe Armstrong claims he’s ‘renouncing his citizenship’ following Roe vs Wade ruling: ‘There’s just too much stupid in this world’

Green Day frontman Billie Joe Armstrong claimed he was ‘renouncing his US citizenship’ at a concert in London (Picture: Marco Piraccini/Getty) Green Day star Billie Joe Armstrong claimed he was ... Read more »

Man who glassed fellow mourner at funeral in 'unprovoked attack' is jailed

© Provided by Metro Max Prior was found guilty of wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm (Picture: Geograph/Evening Gazette) A mourner who smashed his wine glass into the ... Read more »

Iran launches rocket into space as nuclear talks set to resume

TEHRAN, Iran —  Iranian state television said Sunday that Tehran had launched a solid-fueled rocket into space, drawing a rebuke from Washington ahead of the expected resumption of stalled talks over ... Read more »

NYPD official: SCOTUS gun ruling could turn NY into ‘Wild East’

The Supreme Court ruling striking down a century-old New York gun law will cause the amount of firearms in the hands of “criminals” to skyrocket — turning the Empire State ... Read more »

Boris Johnson looks to shore up vote with ‘red meat’ policies on Brexit and benefits, again

The Prime Minister’s closest aides have been leading outreach to Eurosceptic MPs in order to keep their support Read more »

Bong Go bats for 'comfortable life' for Filipinos

SEN. Christopher Lawrence “Bong” Go has reassured Filipinos that he will continue to support government programs and projects geared toward providing a “more comfortable life” for all Filipinos. The senator ... Read more »

1K farmers to benefit from P5.4-B project

THE P5.4-billion Malitubog-Maridagao irrigation project in North Cotabato is 85 percent completed, Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) Secretary Emil Sadain said over the weekend. Sadain, chief implementer of ... Read more »

LGU recycles cooking oil for biodiesel production

DAVAO CITY: The City Environment and Natural Resources (Cenro) here has renewed its call to all Davaoeños and barangay (village) authorities to collect used cooking oil for biodiesel production through ... Read more »

China takes action against ruinous floods

BEIJING: The Minister of Water Resources Li Guoying on Saturday called for efforts to take precautionary measures for flood control and drought relief work in a bid to safeguard the ... Read more »

3 Pinoy workers injured in steel plant accident

TAGOLOAN, Misamis Oriental: Three Filipino workers were injured in an accident in a Chinese-owned steel plant in the industrial town of Tagoloan, Misamis Oriental, a company official said on Sunday. ... Read more »

X Factor’s Tom Mann holds memorial to remember fiancée after tragic death on wedding day

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

David Beckham’s comments on Cristiano Ronaldo transfer as Man Utd star responds to offer

Cristiano Ronaldo’s future is once more in question. Manchester United star Ronaldo has been linked with a move away from Old Trafford just a year after returning to the club. ... Read more »

Ranji Trophy 2022: Mumbai's Sarfaraz Khan named 'Man of the Tournament'

Mumbai’s Sarfaraz Khan poses with his prize cheque after being named Man Of The Series, at a prize distribution ceremony following Madhya Pradesh’s win in the final Ranji Trophy cricket ... Read more »