Gargling with iodine won't stop you getting COVID

Social media is awash with bogus COVID treatments. First, there was hydroxychloroquine, then bleach, followed hard on the heels by ivermectin – a cattle dewormer. The latest on the scene is povidone-iodine, an antiseptic.

Some people have claimed on social media that gargling with iodine can prevent the spread and severity of a COVID infection, suggesting it as an alternative to getting the vaccine.

Iodine has been used as an antiseptic for almost two centuries, with povidone-iodine being a commonly used modern preparation. Laboratory studies have shown that it is effective against coronavirus, inactivating it in as little as 15 seconds. This caused the researchers who made the discovery to suggest that using povidone-iodine in the nose and mouth could help to reduce the person-to-person spread of coronavirus and limit the severity of the disease in those infected. This presumes that what happens in the test tube will also happen in humans, which is a significant leap of faith.

The idea of halting infection in the mouth has been around for a while. Until the 1970s, the makers of Listerine mouthwash claimed that using it regularly could prevent colds and sore throats, until they were obliged to remove this claim because of lack of evidence. Trials since then that have looked at gargling to reduce colds and flu have shown conflicting results, with little evidence of any worthwhile benefit.

In Japan, daily gargling for hygienic reasons has been a common cultural practice for centuries, using everything from water, to tea, to antiseptics. During a press conference in August 2020, the state governor of Osaka prefecture, responding to a very small research study, suggested that gargling with povidone-iodine would help prevent COVID. When questioned about the strength of the scientific evidence, he side-stepped the question, replying: “It’s worth giving a try.”

Similar advice – based on a hunch – has been offered by oral-health experts in the UK.

A recent review of the evidence attempted to answer the question: does povidone-iodine reduce the transmission of COVID? Much of this research turned out to be laboratory studies, with relatively few trials carried out on patients.

While these patient-based studies suggest that povidone-iodine can inactivate coronavirus in the mouth for a period of time – an unsurprising finding – there is not a single study to date that shows it will stop the transmission of coronavirus or reduce the severity of the disease in those already infected. Using a simple analogy, cleaning down a work surface with antiseptic wipes will only ever provide temporary disinfection.

Questionable argument

The “worth giving a try” argument is questionable. From a practical point of view, povidone-iodine is difficult for many patients to use in the mouth and nose as it tastes and smells disgusting. While side-effects of povidone-iodine are mostly tolerable, irritation of the skin is common and sometimes severe. More rarely, but more seriously, povidone-iodine can cause an underactive thyroid gland, particularly in pregnant women.

The makers of povidone-iodine are clear in advising people that their products are not designed for gargling or putting in the nose to prevent COVID.

Aside from the immediate risks of using povidone-iodine inside the body, is the harmful effect of promoting treatments for a pandemic that are not based on reliable evidence, particularly when there are measurably effective alternatives. Gargling with iodine won’t stop you from getting COVID, but it may distract you from something that will: vaccines.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Roger Tisi does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

‘I wrote better pleadings in law school': Trump lawsuit likely to be rejected by courts, experts say

(Getty Images) The courts are likely to reject the lawsuit former President Donald Trump filed on Monday in hopes of stopping the House of Representatives’ investigation into the 6 January ... Read more »

Shop The Trend: Over-The-Knee Boots That Don't Look Cheap

If you subscribe to the Nancy Sinatra view that boots are made for walking, then we’ve got good news for you. It’s boot season! While boots come in a variety ... Read more »

Best phones in SA - latest arrivals

Creating the best phones in the world has become as much art as it is science and engineering.  © Provided by TechRadar The OnePlus 9 Pro, iPhone 13 Pro and ... Read more »

Why do we focus on Colin Powell's vaccine status and not the unvaccinated person who likely gave him Covid?

© AP2006 Obit Powell – AP2006 Fox News anchor John Roberts tweeted on Monday that former Secretary of State Colin Powell’s death from Covid-19 “raises new concerns about how effective ... Read more »

Apple Music Voice Plan: everything we know (and what we don't)

Apple kicked off its Apple Unleashed Event coverage by letting the world know that a new Apple Music plan was coming – the Voice Plan. Half the price of the ... Read more »

Apple October event: 5 things you might have missed at Unleashed

Apple’s October event was all about computing with a decent amount of audio thrown in for good measure. While the reveals of the new 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pros took ... Read more »

Walmart Black Friday deals are live: shop early sales on TV, toys, laptops and more

Black Friday deals are live at Walmart, and yes, you heard that right! The retailer is kicking off the Black Friday 2021 shopping season with early deals that you can ... Read more »

RICHARD KAY: The BBC should be royally afraid of Earl Spencer in dock

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo For 25 years the BBC’s most senior staff concealed the truth that Princess Diana was tricked into giving her explosive 1995 Panorama interview. Lies ... Read more »

Best online learning platforms of 2021

The best online learning platforms make it simple and easy for educators and trainers to manage course materials online. The best online learning platforms Click the links below to go ... Read more »

GameStop PS5 restock in-store event time on Friday – all locations with stock listed

The next GameStop PS5 restock in-store event in the US will happen in seven cities on Friday, October 22, and if you follow our PS5 and Twitter tracker Matt Swider ... Read more »

Microsoft warned Bill Gates over 'inappropriate' emails to female staffer in 2008, report says

Microsoft executives warned Bill Gates to stop sending flirtatious emails to a female employee in 2008 but dropped the matter after he told them he would stop, The Wall Street ... Read more »

MasterChef at Home: Nick Riewoldt's Dippy Eggs Will Amp up Your Dessert Game

Celebrity MasterChef is ticking along nicely with all kinds of sweet feeds popping up on our screens each week. And lucky for you, we’re following the season closely, sharing any ... Read more »

IT firms cautious about ending work-from-home under 'Living with COVID-19'

Seen above is a night scene of Pangyo Techno Valley at around 9 pm, July 12. Korea Times photo by Lee Hae-rin By Kim Bo-eun With the government preparing to ... Read more »

Can a long-life soup really be good for you? A dietician assesses

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo As more of us buy tinned and long-life soups — sales rose by more than 35 million last year — maybe it’s no ... Read more »

Helmet that zaps brain with infrared light 'could help cure dementia'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A helmet that zaps your brain with infrared light could help cure dementia, a study has found. Researchers from Durham University have developed ... Read more »

Giant space bubble reveals reverse shockwaves from a catastrophic star explosion

© Provided by Space Supernova remnant G344.7-0.1, located 19,600 light years from Earth, is the result of a white dwarf stellar explosion that occurred between 3,000 and 6,000 years ago. ... Read more »

Roger Chaffee: Engineer, aviator and Apollo 1 astronaut

© Provided by Space Roger Chaffee Since childhood, Roger Chaffee dreamt of becoming an astronaut and, when he was selected to be in NASA’s third group of astronauts, that goal ... Read more »

Microsoft Outlook extension finally comes to Google Chrome

Microsoft is making it even easier to access your email in Outlook from Google’s browser with the release of its new Chrome extension. As reported by Windows Central and first ... Read more »

The new MacBook Pro is everything you missed about Apple's best laptop

The rumors leading up to the latest Apple event 2021 offered a ton of hype. Word on the street suggested we were about to get a new MacBook Pro that ... Read more »

macOS Monterey will have the old Safari tab design

Apple debuted a controversial new Safari tab design this summer at WWDC 2021, and since then, it has tweaked that look and even let you turn off many of the ... Read more »

Video Games Are Now More Popular In Australia Than Free-To-Air TV

If it wasn’t already clear from the studies of years past, Australians love video games. That’s only been further affirmed by Bond University’s regular Digital Australia report, which has found ... Read more »

Apple's rumored Beats Fit Pro earbuds could have ear-fitting wingtips

Apple has just announced the next generation of AirPods, but if you’ve been waiting for new Beats earbuds, you may also have something to look forward to there. A report ... Read more »

Colin Powell, who died on Monday from COVID-19, had a blood-cell cancer that likely weakened his immune system

Former Secretary of State Colin Powell. Paul Morigi/Getty Images for Capital Concerts Colin Powell, former US secretary of state, died on Monday from COVID-19 complications. Powell was vaccinated but was ... Read more »

A piece of cloth to clean your Apple devices will cost you $19

If you were ever concerned about safely cleaning your Apple products, now you can use an official $19 piece of cloth made by Apple to do so. Apple released this ... Read more »

Apple's website indicates macOS Monterey will launch without Universal Control

Universal Control, Apple’s upcoming feature that lets you control multiple devices with the same mouse and keyboard, will probably not be launching at the same time as macOS Monterey. While ... Read more »

Want a fully specced-out MacBook Pro? You'll have to pay more than $6,000

© Image: Apple Apple’s most expensive laptop is, well, expensive. Apple announced new M1-equipped MacBook Pros on Monday, and they look like very good upgrades, with powerful chips, adaptive refresh ... Read more »

China's economic growth slumps to just 4.9% amid energy crisis

China’s economic growth slumps to just 4.9% amid energy crisis China’s economy recorded its most sluggish growth in a year for the third quarter of 2021, weighed by an energy ... Read more »

Call for armchair astronomers to help search for new planets

A call has been made for armchair astronomers to help in a search for extrasolar planets. The online citizen project is enlisting the help of the public to examine five ... Read more »

Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz Mourn the Death of Their Dog Frankie: 'My Heart Is Shattered'

Brooklyn Beckham Brooklyn Beckham/instagram Brooklyn Beckham Brooklyn Beckham and Nicola Peltz are mourning the death of their beloved dog, Frankie. The couple, who got engaged last year, announced the sad ... Read more »

Regulators say GameStop rally ‘raises questions of market efficiency'

On Monday, the Securities and Exchange Commission published an official staff report on the GameStop rally earlier this year, calling for more scrutiny of both short-seller activity and broker-dealers like ... Read more »

PLACES+FACES teams with Xbox for limited controller and apparel

© Provided by Windows Central Tees, hoodies, and a custom Xbox controller from the UK label. What you need to know PLACES+FACES has teased an upcoming Xbox-themed capsule collection, including ... Read more »

List of Xbox Series X, Series S games with 120 FPS

© Provided by Windows Central Smoother, faster, cleaner. With a new generation of consoles comes new hardware capabilities. One of the exciting new features of the Xbox Series X and ... Read more »

Alibaba launches fast-fashion shopping site allyLikes for overseas shoppers, taking on shooting star Shein

Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba Group Holding recently launched fast-fashion e-tailer allyLikes targeting the North American and European markets, in an attempt to rival Chinese shopping site Shein, which has taken ... Read more »

MS drug does NOT improve condition of hospitalized COVID-19 patients

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A multiple sclerosis drug combined with the antiviral remdesivir did not improve the conditions of COVID-19 patients, a new federal study reveals. The ... Read more »

Universal Control likely won't be coming with macOS Monterey

Universal Control, Apple’s upcoming feature that lets you control multiple devices with the same mouse and keyboard, will probably not be launching at the same time as macOS Monterey. While ... Read more »

'Smart' cane helps blind avoid obstacles with autonomous car tech

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Researchers at Stanford University have developed a robotic ‘smart’ cane that guides people with visual impairments using technology originated for autonomous vehicles.    Most ... Read more »

Roger Marshall introduces bill to BAN gain-of-function research

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Sen. Roger Marshall, R-Kansas, is leading a group of Republicans who will introduce legislation to halt all federal funding for gain-of-function research after ... Read more »

Doogee V10 rugged smartphone

© Provided by TechRadar Doogee V10 Review Listing Two minute review Doogee introduced a new line of flagship rugged smartphones eschewing the S-prefix for the V one. The first in ... Read more »

The Best Smart Home Hubs to Control All Your Devices

Whether you’ve just screwed in new Wi-Fi controlled light bulbs or installed the latest video doorbell camera, you may have noticed that each smart home device requires its own app ... Read more »

Emergency services at the scene after being called to house explosion in Ayr

Three people have been taken to hospital following an explosion at a housing estate in the Scottish town of Ayr. Residents have been evacuated from the Kincaidston area, near the ... Read more »