Gap in research funding leaves global south more vulnerable to climate impacts, studies suggest

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Themba Hadebe/The Associated Press A shepherd stands in the dry riverbed at Colesberg, South Africa, in September. Researchers are warning that without detailed climate impact research, countries in Africa and around the global south may be left unprepared for climate change.

Developing countries suffer from a significant gap in terms of scientific research related to climate change, a new study shows, even though they contain the communities and people most vulnerable to extreme weather, rising sea levels and other serious impacts of climate change. 

“There is a kind of gap in knowledge, specifically in peer-reviewed papers in the large literature databases about those areas,” said Max Callaghan, lead author of the study and a researcher at the Mercator Research Institute on Global Commons and Climate Change in Berlin.

“We know that there are kind of inequalities in this global scientific system in terms of resources.”

The stark divide in availability of scientific research has been on the radar of climate experts, with major barriers facing global south scientists, such as access to prestigious (and expensive) scientific journals, the lack of time and funding to work on research, and even onerous visa requirements that make it difficult for scientists to attend conferences and meetings in the global north.

Experts warn that the gap might leave developing countries without the means to identify where climate mitigation and adaptation efforts should be directed to prepare for future weather disasters. Good climate science is also needed so that aid money from rich countries to help poor countries address climate change is targeted and spent on the right projects.

© Denis Farrell/The Associated Press Demonstrators show their placards during a climate change protest in South Africa in 2019. Even with relatively little funding for climate science, researchers already know that much of Africa is facing climate change impacts.

Machine learning maps climate impacts

The new study, published this week in Nature Climate Change, used machine learning to examine over 100,000 scientific papers worldwide. The study was conceived as a way to see if machine learning could help the work of the UN’s climate science body, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, by making it easier to examine and analyze the thousands of paper scientists currently examine by hand. 

The study authors divided the world into smaller grid cells, and calculated the number of climate studies that studied climate impacts in those areas.

They found far more climate studies had been published on impacts in developed countries than developing countries. 

For example, nearly 30,000 studies looked at areas in North America. Only 10,000 studies looked at Africa, which has more than double the population.

The researchers then used precipitation and temperature data to determine whether a particular area was experiencing climate change caused by human activity. They found that while three quarters of Africans lived in areas experiencing climate change impacts, only 22 percent of those lived in areas with high levels of scientific research on those impacts.

Canada funding research in global south

A Canadian government agency is working to address this research gap. The International Development Research Centre, a federal crown corporation, funds and promotes scientific research in the global south and has offices in countries like Uruguay, Senegal and India. 

In 2019-2020, new projects totalling $166.4 million were funded by the IDRC and its associated donors. The centre puts out calls for proposals for international development research that achieves specific goals, such as climate change adaptation. Researchers and institutions can apply, with the money going to local researchers or collaborations.

Bruce Currie-Alder, the program leader for climate resilience at the IDRC, says while there have been years of conceptual thinking over climate change adaptation, we now need to implement those concepts here in Canada, and everywhere else seeing climate impacts. That’s where local climate science becomes very important, to figure out how exactly a particular region needs to adapt. 

“It’s one thing to say the world is getting warmer. There are certain parts that are drier, there are certain frequency of storms,” he said. 

“What does that mean in a particular district or state? And that knowledge is absolutely essential.”

Barriers facing African researchers

The stark divide in climate science was highlighted by another paper published in September and partly funded by the IDRC that examined funding for research in Africa. It found that a paltry 3.8 per cent of global funding for climate change research is spent on Africa.

Even when it is, the money mostly goes to researchers from the global north. For example, of that small amount of funding for research in Africa, 78 percent went to institutions in Europe and North America. Only 14.5 per cent went to African institutions.

© Nardus Engelbrecht/AP Photo Massive waves break on the Sea Point promenade in Cape Town, South Africa, in 2020. Countries in the global south also contain the communities most vulnerable to extreme weather caused by climate change.

Christopher Trisos, a South African co-author of the paper and senior researcher at the African Climate and Development Initiative in Cape Town, says the solution lies not just in increasing funding to African researchers, but also improving the quality of funding. 

“For example, increasing direct access and direct control of research, design and resources for African partners when working with researchers from places like Canada or the United States, as opposed to research agendas being set externally,” he said.

Trisos also pointed out that African researchers face barriers even trying to access published papers, many of which are in journals behind online paywalls that might be beyond their budgets.

“So publishing more data open access and more scientific publications open access is a big part of the solution there as well,” he said.

The paper said that these funding disparities lead to “unequal power dynamics in how climate change research agendas on Africa are shaped by research institutions in Europe and the USA.” 

One outcome from this is that researchers in developed countries may frame research questions and objectives for a global north audience, rather than provide actionable insights for their local partners to use that research to fight climate change in Africa, the paper warns.

Indigenous knowledge needs to be included

Michele Leone is a senior program specialist at the IDRC’s offices in Dakar, Senegal. He is currently working on an IDRC-funded project that examines migration in the region and how it relates to climate and environmental changes on water sources and agricultural productivity.

Leone welcomed the machine learning study but pointed out that the technological method it used is an example of the resource divide between global north and south scientists. 

“There is the risk of a kind of a new global divide,” he said, “with the rapid, exponentially fast development of artificial intelligence and machine learning tools that have been developed in the north with northern ideas, with northern datasets and northern bias.”

Trisos says that it’s also important to consider who is regarded as an expert. There are multiple barriers to research that intersect with ethnicity and gender, he says, that hold back certain people and certain forms of knowledge.

“Thankfully, within institutions like the IPCC that has begun to change the authorship, teams are becoming more diverse,” Trisos said. 

“There’s also much more appreciation of not just scientific knowledge, but Indigenous knowledge and local knowledge as holding valuable histories on how people in places are being impacted by climate change.”

Even without as much research in the global south, it’s clear climate change is affecting people. 

“I think it’s telling that even with that very small amount of funding and research effort, there are still really strong signals of severe climate change impacts on people’s health, on their food security, on the biodiversity in Africa,” Trisos said. 

“But we would know a lot more if more resources were allocated to the problem.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


WTO postpones major meeting after new COVID-19 variant outbreak

© Subhayan Chakraborty WTO postpones major meeting after new COVID-19 variant outbreak The World Trade Organization (WTO) became the first major diplomatic casualty of the new coronavirus variant on November 26 ... Read more »

Indian Railways: IRCTC Launches Bengaluru, Mysore With Dakshin Darshan Yatra From Mumbai; Check Details

© Provided by News18 Indian Railways: IRCTC Launches Bengaluru, Mysore With Dakshin Darshan Yatra From Mumbai; Check Details The Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation (IRCTC) has come up with ... Read more »

Gove-led cabinet committee makes fresh bid for progress on levelling up

Gove-led cabinet committee makes fresh bid for progress on levelling up Weekly meetings of ministers chaired by Michael Gove expected to lead to new policies on reducing inequality Michael Gove ... Read more »

Best Black Friday camera deals for 2021

There are some great Black Friday camera deals landing this year, with some companies offering the lowest-ever prices on popular models. One of our favorites that we’ve spotted is Fujifilm’s ... Read more »

Shruti and Akshara reunite amid dad Kamal Haasan Covid-19 treatment. See pics, video

(R) Shruti Haasan, Akshara Haasan and Santanu Hazarika reunite as Kamal Haasan gets treated for Covid-19 in Chennai. Kamal Haasan is currently admitted to Sri Ramachandra Medical Centre in Chennai ... Read more »

Philippines cuts target for ambitious three-day vaccination sprint

© Reuters/LISA MARIE DAVID FILE PHOTO: Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak in Manila MANILA (Reuters) – The Philippines has slashed its inoculation target for an ambitious three-day national vaccination push due ... Read more »

Chennai goes under water, red alert issued for several Tamil Nadu districts

© Provided by Zee News Chennai: The Singara or Beautiful Chennai turned into Venice with roads waterlogged and several homes getting inundated owing to the heavy rains that poured throughout ... Read more »

Ravindra Jadeja's batting has improved, but bowling has gone down: Kapil Dev

© Provided by The Times of India KOLKATA: Can Hardik Pandya be called India’s best all-rounder at present? Kapil Dev, without doubt the country’s best all-rounder ever, isn’t sure. “Can ... Read more »

Was Ravana the first man to fly? Sri Lanka to resume study on Pushpak Vimana, wants India to join

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: In 2019, the Sri Lankan government had sanctioned 50 lakh rupees to conduct research into the claims of King Ravana being a skilled ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15: Shamita Shetty tells Nishant Bhat about feeling trapped and being constantly judged by everyone

© Provided by Pinkvilla In the upcoming episode of the reality show Bigg Boss 15, the contestants will be getting new surprises. In the Weekend ka Vaar episode, the contestants ... Read more »

87 TMC ex-councillors get tickets for KMC poll

© Provided by The Statesman 87 TMC ex-councillors get tickets for KMC poll Trinamul Congress today announced its candidates for Kolkata municipal corporation elections late in the evening. TMC MP ... Read more »

Punjab Vs Delhi govt schools, Twitter war between Pargat, & Sisodia escalates

© Provided by The Statesman Punjab Vs Delhi govt schools, Twitter war between Pargat, & Sisodia escalates The ‘Twitter war’ between the Delhi and Punjab education ministers over the condition ... Read more »

Capt denies ‘hand in glove' with PM Modi & BJP as Punjab CM

© Provided by The Statesman Capt denies ‘hand in glove’ with PM Modi & BJP as Punjab CM Former Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh on Friday lashed out at Congress ... Read more »

Delhi air pollution: Only CNG and electric vehicles allowed entry from today

© Provided by DNA With air quality showing no visible improvement, only CNG-run and electric vehicles will be allowed entry into Delhi from today. All petrol and diesel-run transportation will remain banned ... Read more »

'Omicron' Covid variant: Did WHO skip two letters of Greek alphabet to avoid 'Xi'?

Chinese President Xi Jinping (Photo: AP/PTI) When news of the new SARS-CoV-2 variant B.1.1529 first began to emerge, many expected that if it was flagged by the World Health Organisation, ... Read more »

'Gutka khana galat baat hai': Cricket fan from Kanpur Test displays poster after going VIRAL

© Provided by DNA As the first Test between India and New Zealand is underway in Kanpur, one man that grabbed the attention of the cameraman was not any cricketer, ... Read more »

IBPS Clerk Recruitment 2021: Admit cards for prelims exam out at; check direct link here

© Provided by Firstpost IBPS Clerk Recruitment 2021: Admit cards for prelims exam out at; check direct link here The hall tickets for the prelims exam of the Institute ... Read more »

BCCI top brass likely to meet on Saturday, discuss roadmap for South Africa tour amid Covid-19 new variant

The top bras of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) is likely to meet on Saturday to discuss the possibility of going ahead with India’s tour of ... Read more »

Arsenal transfer round-up: Grant Xhaka U-turn as Mikel Arteta makes firm statement

Arsenal‘s overhaul of playing staff has been drastic under Mikel Arteta – and it only looks set to continue at the Emirates. The Gunners have made progress this season after ... Read more »

Friday's Tacoma Mall shooting kindled memories of 2005 shooting that wounded seven

Friday’s shooting at the Tacoma Mall kindled memories of another shooting at that shopping center. It was 16 years ago this month, Nov. 20, 2005, that Dominick Maldonado, then 20, ... Read more »

My Take: Uninformed juries produce incorrect outcomes

Kyle Rittenhouse testifies during his trial at the Kenosha County Courthouse in Kenosha, Wis., on Wednesday, Nov. 10, 2021. I was a troubled teen. I remember the day I was ... Read more »

Fantasy football: Here's where you can find some running back help

The running back position has been a veritable nightmare for most fantasy football managers. Top players like Jonathan Taylor, Dalvin Cook and Najee Harris should have a guaranteed spot in ... Read more »

Global markets fall sharply on new virus variant fears as oil prices battered

More than £65bn was wiped off the UK’s leading share index on Friday, reflecting fears that a new coronavirus variant could wreak further havoc on international business and travel. The ... Read more »

Bobbi-Anne McLeod: Cody Ackland charged with murder over disappearance of 18-year-old in Plymouth

A 24-year-old man has been charged with the murder of Bobbi-Anne McLeod in Plymouth. Cody Ackland, from the Southway area of the city, is due to appear at Plymouth Magistrates’ ... Read more »

Weatherwatch: back-to-back hurricanes to become norm in US

Two storms in same place within fortnight will be twice as likely on US Gulf coast by end of century, study finds Next Tuesday will mark the end of the ... Read more »

Dubai Sevens quarter-finalists confirmed after opening day of play

Australia were on the verge of defeating Olympic champions Fiji until a last-minute try from Iowane Raturaciri saw the powerful Pacific Islanders emerge as 17-12 victors at the Dubai Sevens. ... Read more »

Soziologin: Stille Triage ist ethisch verheerend

© KEYSTONE/AP/Keith Birmingham Überfüllte Intensivstationen wegen Covid-19 führen stillschweigend zu einer Selektion der zu behandelnden Patienten. Diese stille Triage sei ethisch verheerend, sagte Tanja Krones, Mitglied der Nationalen Ethikkommission, in ... Read more »

Steve Wozniak reunited with rare Apple I motherboard in Dubai

© Provided by The National Steve Wozniak with a rare Apple I motherboard in Dubai. Photo: The AAPL Collection Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak was reunited with a piece of history ... Read more »

Allow Maria Ressa to receive Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo

DEPUTY Speaker and Cagayan de Oro City Rep. Rufus Rodriguez has stated Friday Rappler Chief Executive Officer Maria Ressa should be permitted to go to Oslo, Norway, to accept the ... Read more »

Tacoma mall shooting: 1 person shot, sending shoppers scrambling for safety

One person was shot at the Tacoma Mall in Washington state on Friday night, sending shoppers scrambling for safety, officials said. © Google The Tacoma police department said the victim ... Read more »

Long overdue for perpetrators of Mumbai attacks to face justice: US Secretary Blinken

While praising the resiliency of Mumbaikars on the 13th anniversary of the 26/11 terror attacks, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken has emphasised the need for a speedy trial of ... Read more »

Doja Cat says she feels ‘pressured' in the music industry: ‘I'm doing all this s*** that I don't wanna do'

Doja Cat says she feels ‘pressured’ in the music industry: ‘I’m doing all this s*** that I don’t wanna do’ Singer Doja Cat has revealed that she is not happy ... Read more »

Single day rise of 8,318 Covid infections takes India's active cases to 1,07,019, lowest in 541 days

India reported 8,318 fresh COVID-19 cases in the last 24 hours, informed the Health Ministry. As many as 465 people succumbed to the COIVD-19 infection in the country in the ... Read more »

Delhi air in 'very poor' category, expected to improve from Nov 29; minimum temperature 10.2° C

The air quality index (AQI) in Delhi was recorded in the ‘very poor’ category on Saturday morning, according to data issued by the <a href="/tag/central-pollution-control-board”>Central Pollution Control Board. It is ... Read more »

Syarikat penerbangan diarah turun harga tiket domestik

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Malaysia Airlines berkata ia akan menambah penerbangan ke Sarawak bulan depan, sekali gus berupaya mengurangkan kadar tambang ke negeri itu. PETALING JAYA: Kementerian Pengangkuan ... Read more »

JP Nadda likely to attend Inter-Party Conference organised by Russia virtually ahead of Dec 6 summit

BJP President JP Nadda is likely to virtually attend an Inter-Party Conference being organised by the ruling United Russia Party to further boost strategic partnership ahead of the December 6 ... Read more »

‘Segelintir' pendukung MN dibuai kerusi empuk, rasa selesa berkuasa, Tok Mat jawab Hadi

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Wadah kerjasama Muafakat Nasional harus menjangkau politik, menjadi medan segala kepentingan Melayu-Islam dibincangkan, menurut Mohamad Hasan. PETALING JAYA: Segelintir pendukung dalam Muafakat Nasional (MN) ... Read more »

French trawler crews to block ports in row over post-Brexit fishing permits

French trawler crews are planning a series of port and cargo terminal blockades Friday in their push for a political decision over their right to take their trawlers into British ... Read more »

Ex-Trump adviser is out at Newsmax after criticism of vaccine mandates clashed with the right-wing outlet's policy, report says

Rally goers hold signs protesting vaccines at the “World Wide Rally for Freedom”, an anti-mask and anti-vaccine rally, at the State House in Concord, New Hampshire, May 15, 2021.JOSEPH PREZIOSO/AFP ... Read more »

Why the New Coronavirus Variant Triggered Selloffs in Bitcoin and Stocks

After scientists identified a new variant of the virus causing Covid-19, countries restricted travel to and from southern Africa. WSJ’s Anna Hirtenstein explains that investors have turned to bonds and ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic