Future-Reliance deal: Amazon tells SC that Singapore EA award is valid and needs to be executed

Singapore’s Emergency Arbitrator (EA) award, restraining Future Retail Ltd (FRL) from going ahead with its Rs 24,713 crore merger deal with Reliance Retail, is “valid” and needs to be executed, Amazon on Tuesday told the Supreme Court which commenced hearings on its pleas against the amalgamation. A bench comprising justices R F Nariman and B R Gavai started hearing the arguments from senior advocate Gopal Subramanium, appearing for Amazon.com NV Investment Holdings LLC, who apprised the apex court of the facts and legal proceedings so far in the case.
The US-based e-commerce giant said the EA award of Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) was enforceable and the single-judge bench of the Delhi High Court rightly gave an interim order in its favour granting a stay on the ongoing amalgamation.
Subramanium said a division bench of the high court erred in entertaining the Future group’s appeal and granting it relief by paving the way for the deal.
Assailing the order, the senior counsel for Amazon said, “the emergency arbitrator (EA) is not a ‘coram non judice’ (not before a judge)” and hence the award of EA is enforceable and the high court under a provision of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act has to act to execute it and not sit in appeal against the interim award.
The top court would recommence hearing on the pleas either on Thursday or next Tuesday.
On February 22, in its interim order the apex court had asked the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) not to pass the final order on the amalgamation.
The Future group had moved the tribunal seeking regulatory approvals to the Rs 24,713 crore deal with Reliance.
Amazon moved the top court against the order of the Delhi High Court division bench which paved the way for the Reliance-FRL deal.
On February 8, the division bench had stayed the single-judge direction to FRL and various statutory authorities to maintain the status quo on the mega deal.
The interim direction was passed on FRL’s appeal challenging the February 2 order of the single judge.
In August last year, the Future group had reached an agreement to sell its retail, wholesale, logistics, and warehousing units to Reliance.
Subsequently, Amazon took FRL into EA before the SIAC over alleged breach of contract by the Future group.
Amazon had first filed a plea before the high court (single judge) for enforcement of the October 25, 2020, EA award by SIAC restraining FRL from going ahead with the deal with Reliance Retail.
The high court division bench had however said that it was staying the single-judge order as FRL was not a party to the share subscription agreement (SSA) between Amazon and Future Coupons Pvt Ltd (FCPL) and the US e-commerce giant was not a party to the deal for amalgamation between FRL and Reliance Retail.
It had further said it was of the prima facie view that the shareholding agreement (SHA) between FRL and FCPL, the SSA between FCPL and Amazon, and the deal between FRL and Reliance Retail “are different” and “therefore, the group of companies doctrine cannot be invoked”.
Another reason given by the court for its interim order was that there was prima facie no reason to seek a status quo order before the single judge.
The high court had said there were a lot of contentious issues involved in the matter and it was not going to adjudicate on them at this stage.
It had also said that its observations were only prima facie and the single judge ought not to be influenced by them when pronouncing the order on Amazon’s plea for enforcement of the EA award by SIAC restraining FRL from going ahead with the deal.
FRL, in its appeal, had claimed that if the February 2 order was not stayed it “would be an absolute disaster” for it as the proceedings before the NCLT for approving the amalgamation scheme have been put on hold.
It had contended that the single judge’s status quo order will effectively derail the entire scheme which has been approved by statutory authorities in accordance with the law.
In its suit before the single judge for enforcing the EA award, Amazon has sought to restrain FRL from taking any steps to complete the transaction with entities that are a part of the Mukesh Dhirubhai Ambani (MDA) Group.
Amazon has also sought detention of the Biyanis, directors of FCPL and FRL and other related parties in civil prison and attaching of their properties for alleged “wilful disobedience” of the EA order.
After the SIAC’s EA order, Amazon wrote to the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), stock exchanges and CCI, urging them to take into consideration the arbitrator’s interim decision as it is a binding order.
FRL thereafter moved the high court to restrain Amazon from writing to Sebi, CCI, and other regulators about SIAC’s order, saying it amounts to interfering with the agreement with Reliance.
A single judge on December 21 last year had on FRL’s plea passed an interim order allowing Amazon to write to the statutory authorities, but also observed that prima facie it appeared the US e-commerce giant’s attempt to control Future Retail was violative of FEMA and FDI rules.
Against the observation, Amazon moved an appeal before a division bench and during its pendency, it filed the suit for the enforcement of the EA award.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

MLBB to host anniversary gala, month-long giveaway for 5th anniversary

(Photo: Moonton Games) Mobile Legends: Bang Bang (MLBB) developer Moonton Games announced on Tuesday (21 September) that they will be hosting an online gala to celebrate the game's fifth anniversary ... Read more »

What's next for OnePlus? - OxygenOS and ColorOS teams become one

When OnePlus announced its product and R&D teams’ merger with Oppo’s back in June, there was speculation that OnePlus potentially switching from OxygenOS to ColorOS (the Android overlay used by ... Read more »

Post-IPO Robinhood wants to dive into cryptocurrencies

After its IPO in July, trading platform Robinhood is now said to be planning to load up its app with new features like a cryptocurrency wallet. According to a report ... Read more »

Robinhood testing crypto wallet, cryptocurrency transfer features: Report

Robinhood Markets Inc is testing new crypto wallet and cryptocurrency transfer features for its app which would allow customers to send and receive digital currencies such as bitcoin, Bloomberg News ... Read more »

US states rally around proposed laws to rein in Big Tech

A bipartisan group of U.S. state attorneys general sent a letter to lawmakers on Monday urging them to pass a series of bills that tighten antitrust laws aimed at Big ... Read more »

In 2020, Noida saw most cases of cyber frauds in the state

At 1,585, Gautam Budh Nagar has seen the highest number of cybercrimes in the state in 2020, when a majority of people confined to homes because of the lockdown shifted ... Read more »

Ride-hailing giant Didi Chuxing denies executive Jean Liu is leaving amid Beijing's ongoing cybersecurity probe

Chinese ride-hailing giant Didi Chuxing denied a Reuters report that its co-founder and president Jean Liu was on her way out and threatened legal action to fight the “malicious” spreading ... Read more »

Bitcoin, Ethereum slump as market selloff widens

Cryptocurrency prices sank on Monday as concerns over the spillover risk to the global economy from Chinese property group Evergrande’s troubles spread across financial markets. Bitcoin, the world’s biggest and ... Read more »

JP Morgan Chase launches new digital bank brand in the UK

A new digital bank brand offering cashback and money management features has been launched in the UK by JP Morgan Chase. The Chase brand already provides a range of financial ... Read more »

Canada election 2021 live results: Liberals projected to win most seats, will form minority government -- just like last time

Canada's unprecedented COVID-19 pandemic election was never going to be easy. The 36-day whirlwind campaign kicked off with many Canadians asking why they were even heading to the polls during ... Read more »

Best Apple iPhone 13 cases, chargers and cables

Apple recently released the latest set of phones — the iPhone 13-series. Many of you must be planning to upgrade to the latest series and no matter what kind of ... Read more »

Gabby Petito case becomes point of interest for internet sleuths on social media

The extensive reach of social media has become a focal point in the disappearance of travel blogger Gabby Petito. Petito had been traveling cross-country with her boyfriend, Brian Laundrie, in ... Read more »

The Polestar 2 is a Reasonably Priced EV with Panache and Performance

© Paul Barshon / Beadyeye The “guiding light” in the EV space has found the Goldilocks zone with an electric vehicle that offers equal parts torque and opulence. The Takeaway ... Read more »

Xiaomi has a new ‘offline problem' to deal with

The rift between smartphone major Xiaomi and its offline retailers seems to be widening. Some Mi preferred partner store owners across India are unhappy with Xiaomi launching new smartphones online ... Read more »

Haitian journey to Texas border starts in South America

1 / 3Border Haitian DiasporaRobins Exile, of Haiti, eats at a Haitian restaurant, Monday, Sept. 20, 2021, in Tijuana, Mexico. Exile arrived to Tijuana the day before after changing his ... Read more »

Justin Trudeau to remain Canada's prime minister; Liberal Party appears to fall short of majority

Canadians gave Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Liberal Party a victory in Monday’s parliamentary elections, but his gamble to win a majority of seats appeared to have failed. The Liberals were ... Read more »

How Tata is betting big on online healthcare

With the ambition of launching a Super App, the Tata group is betting big on the healthcare segment through Tata Health, which provides teleconsultation services and, in the future, aims ... Read more »

Older sisters better than older brothers for elephants, research suggests

Young elephants benefit from having older sisters more than older brothers, new research suggests. Researchers at universities in Finland, the UK and Myanmar found that Asian elephant siblings influence younger ... Read more »

Kena: Bridge of Spirits Pixar-like charm is lost behind a ton of performance issues

I wasn’t sure what to expect from Kena: Bridge of Spirits. Developer Ember Lab’s adorable adventure caused quite a stir when it was revealed at the PlayStation Future of Gaming ... Read more »

Packers dominate 2nd half, bounce back to beat Lions 35-17

1/9APTOPIX Lions Packers FootballGreen Bay Packers’ Aaron Jones celebrates his touchdown run during the second half of an NFL football game against the Detroit Lions Monday, Sept. 20, 2021, in ... Read more »

NFL Power Rankings: Maybe this is the season someone challenges Chiefs in AFC West

On New Year's Day in 2017 the Kansas City Chiefs won their regular-season finale, with Charcandrick West's two touchdown catches from Alex Smith leading the way over the San Diego ... Read more »

New film finds 'The Wonderful' aboard the space station: director Q&A

© Provided by Space “The Wonderful: Stories from the Space Station” shares the lives of astronauts in space on the biggest human outpost in orbit. Clare Lewins did not think ... Read more »

mSpy parental control software review

MSpy is a hugely powerful phone monitoring app which can report on almost every area of your kid’s online activities (and one or two of the offline ones, too.) Need ... Read more »

Watch an astronaut working out in space aboard the ISS

Thomas Pesquet, an ESA astronaut who is currently aboard the International Space Station (ISS) posted a video of himself on Twitter in which he can be seen doing squats using ... Read more »

Amazon app quiz September 21, 2021: Get answers to these five questions to win Rs 20,000 in Amazon Pay balance

Amazon’s daily app quiz is now live. As part of today’s quiz, the e-tailer is giving the participants a chance to win Rs 20,000 in Amazon Pay balance.The daily app ... Read more »

Best eBay Australia deals: bargains on laptops, monitors and PCs from Dell

Dell’s official eBay store is back with another ripper sale this week, where you can get laptops, monitors and desktop PCs for 20% off their listed price. Some of our ... Read more »

US securities regulator opens probe into Activision Blizzard over employment issues

Activision Blizzard spent the summer grappling with accusations of sexual misconduct and workplace discrimination. WASHINGTON, D.C. (NYTIMES, REUTERS) – Activision Blizzard, the video game maker behind Call Of Duty and ... Read more »

Facebook rebuffs reports on Instagram's negative impact on young people, cites policy trade-offs

Several lawmakers have called on Facebook to scrap plans for an Instagram product aimed at children. MENLO PARK (BLOOMBERG) – Facebook pushed back on reports that the company was aware ... Read more »

Facebook, Google and other Big Tech firms face more fines in Russia as Kremlin curbs access to information online

Russia’s internet regulator is poised to significantly raise the fines it has slapped on US technology companies such as Facebook Inc and Alphabet Inc as the Kremlin escalates its push ... Read more »

Jordyn Woods is a ‘dream girl' in stunning draped crystal dress: ‘All of your dreams shall be furfillleeeeeed'

Jordyn Woods celebrated her 24th birthday early and in style. On Sunday, the 23-year-old influencer shared images from her birthday festivities over the weekend attended by friends and family, including ... Read more »

Australia's New Supercomputer Has Been Unveiled and Its Name Is Adorable

Australian researchers have caught a glimpse of a new mega-powerful computing system described as the fastest public supercomputer in the Southern Hemisphere and named after one of the country’s cutest ... Read more »

Even the Mafia is getting involved in phishing attacks now

Cybercriminals have raked in millions from phishing attacks which is why it’s not a big surprise that the Italian Mafia has adopted similar tactics in recent years. According to a ... Read more »

Halo Infinite: 343i breaks down second beta schedule, Big Team Battle

© Provided by Windows Central We get to play Halo Infinite for two weekends? Rad. What you need to know 343 Industries has broken down details about Halo Infinite’s second ... Read more »

Reliance, Tata, Adani may bid for solar projects under PLI scheme

Reliance Industries, Tata Power , Adani Solar, Acme Solar and Vikram Solar are likely to bid for contracts under the production-linked incentive (PLI) scheme for solar modules. The government is ... Read more »

Best soundbars in Australia 2021: enhance your TV shows, movies, games and music

One of the best soundbars from this list will make a huge difference to the audio within your home. That’s why a top-quality soundbar is an important investment for any ... Read more »

Best Canon RF lenses 2021: the best lenses for Canon's mirrorless EOS R cameras

Looking for the best Canon RF lenses for your new EOS R camera? You’ve come to the right place.  In three years since the launch of Canon’s full-frame mirrorless system ... Read more »

Inside The Lonely But Rewarding World Of Solo Games Development

“You can become someone who spends all day thinking about a world that doesn’t actually exist, that no one else knows about, or understands. Sometimes that can make you feel ... Read more »

China Evergrande fears consume investors awaiting trading

FILE PHOTO: China Evergrande Centre building sign is seen in Hong Kong NEW YORK/BOSTON/HONG KONG (Reuters) – Anxiety over the prospect of China Evergrande Group defaulting on its mountain of ... Read more »

Hailey Bieber shares no makeup bikini pictures while on holiday and it's pure joy

Photo credit: Kevin Mazur/MG21 – Getty Images Now that the world is opening up, my Instagram feed seems to be full of people on holiday. Just look at Hailey Bieber’s ... Read more »